This chair is a perfect replica of the rising sun chair used by President Washington during the constitutional convention of 1787.

My father did not commission it, but he facilitated its creation through his role as banker and trustee for the Harrison family, who conceived of this project in 1915.

I was only 7 years old when our family portrait was taken with my father seated in this chair.

I remember how proud he was that day, how carefully he positioned himself, how he insisted the photographer capture the carved sun visible behind his head.

At the time, I did not understand why a piece of furniture mattered so much to him.

Years later, when I was old enough to ask questions, my father explained the chair’s significance to me.

He told me that Jonathan Harrison III had commissioned the replica as an act of faith in America’s future during the dark days of the Great War in Europe.

The original rising sun chair represented the founding of our nation.

The moment when Benjamin Franklin declared he could finally see whether the sun was rising or setting and concluded it was rising.

Harrison wanted a second chair to exist, a private symbol that the sun was still rising even in difficult times.

My father, who handled the financial arrangements and kept the project secret, received the chair as payment for his discretion and his own faith in American ideals.

When my father died, my brothers and I disagreed about what should be done with the chair.

William wanted to display it in our home as father had.

Robert wanted to sell it to a collector, but I believed neither course was appropriate.

This chair represents something larger than our family’s pride or fortune.

It represents the faith of two men, Harrison and my father, in the enduring promise of American democracy.

It deserves to be preserved and protected, not as a private treasure, but as a testament to that faith.

I have donated it to the Philadelphia Historical Society with the condition that it remains sealed for 90 years until 2025.

By then, enough time will have passed that the chair can be studied and appreciated for what it truly is.

Not a fake or a forgery, but a deliberate act of historical preservation created by skilled craftsmen in an era of global crisis.

I hope whoever opens this vault will understand what this chair meant to the men who created it and the family who guarded it.

And I hope you will see as Benjamin Franklin saw that the sun is always rising if we have faith enough to believe it.

Elizabeth Hartley October 15th, 1935.

Elena finished reading aloud, her voice thick with emotion.

James stood silently beside her, visibly moved by the letter’s words.

“She was protecting it,” James said finally.

Not hiding it, protecting it until enough time had passed for people to understand.

Elena nodded, carefully refolding the letter.

And now it’s time.

With Elizabeth Hartley’s letter and the chair now accessible, Elena returned to the earlier mystery.

Who had actually built this masterpiece?

The photograph from 1915 showed the Hartley family, but it revealed nothing about the craftsman who had created the chair.

She returned to Dorothy Callahan with new questions.

Your great-g grandandmother, Catherine, Elizabeth’s mother, did she ever mention who made the chair?

Where it came from?

Dorothy thought for a long moment, her aged fingers tapping against her teacup.

There was something.

Wait here.

She disappeared into her bedroom and returned carrying a small wooden box.

After you visited last time, I kept thinking about other things my grandmother told me.

She gave me this box before she died.

Said it contained letters from her mother.

Inside were dozens of letters arranged chronologically and tied with faded ribbons.

Dorothy handed them to Elena.

I never read them all.

They seemed too personal, but perhaps you’ll find something useful.

Elena spent that evening reading through Catherine Hartley’s correspondence.

Most of the letters were routine, thank you notes, invitations, correspondence with friends.

But then in a letter dated August 1915, Catherine had written to her sister.

William is so pleased with the chair that arrived last month.

He says it represents everything he believes about this country.

The craftsman who made it came to the house yesterday to ensure it had survived the journey from their workshop.

Such interesting men, all immigrants, William said.

One from Ireland, one from Italy, one from Russia.

They barely spoke English, but their pride in their work was evident in every gesture.

The Italian gentleman, Mr. Rossi, I believe, actually wept when he saw it in our parlor, saying it was the finest thing he had ever created.

William paid them handsomely and swore them to secrecy.

He said, “Some things are too precious to announce to the world”.

Elena’s hands trembled as she read.

The same craftsman who had built the chair, Thomas Brennan, Giovani Rossi, Jacob Freriedman, had delivered it personally to the Hartley home.

She had their names now, and with those names, she could trace their stories.

The next week was a blur of research.

Elena contacted immigration records, city directories, and genealogical databases.

Slowly, the lives of the three master craftsmen emerged from the historical shadows.

Thomas Brennan had come from County Cork, Ireland in 1889, fleeing poverty and limited opportunities.

He had learned carpentry from his father and established a successful workshop in Philadelphia by 1900.

Giovani Rosi had fled economic hardship in southern Italy in 1895, bringing with him centuries old woodarving techniques passed down through his family.

Jacob Freriedman had escaped religious persecution in Russia in 1902, arriving in Philadelphia with nothing but his tools and his skills as a furniture maker.

These three men, along with others whose names had been lost to time, had pulled their diverse talents to create something extraordinary.

They had studied the original rising sun chair in Independence Hall, taking precise measurements and detailed notes.

They had selected the finest mahogany, carved each detail with painstaking accuracy, and assembled a chair that was identical to the original in every way.

and they had done it all in secret, sworn to silence, knowing their masterpiece would be hidden in a wealthy family’s parlor rather than displayed in a museum.

Elena found herself moved by their story, the story of immigrants who had found opportunity in America and expressed their gratitude through their craft.

3 months later, on a cold January morning in 2025, the Philadelphia Museum of American History prepared for one of the most significant exhibitions in its history.

Elena had worked tirelessly to bring all the pieces together.

The replica chair itself borrowed from the historical society, the 1915 family photograph, Katherine Hartley’s letters, Elizabeth Hartley’s 1935 letter, documents from the Harrison family archives, and immigration records for the craftsman who had built the chair.

The exhibition was titled Two Sons Rising: The Secret History of America’s Most Symbolic Chair.

Media attention had been intense since the museum announced the discovery.

National news outlets had covered the story.

Historians had debated its significance.

And thousands of people had requested tickets to the opening day.

Marcus Williams stood beside Elena in the gallery an hour before the doors opened.

Both of them exhausted but exhilarated.

The exhibition space had been designed to tell the story chronologically.

Visitors would enter through a recreation of the 1787 Constitutional Convention, seeing images of the original rising sun chair and reading Benjamin Franklin’s famous quote about not knowing whether the sun was rising or setting.

Then they would move into the 1915 section where the replica chair sat in a specially designed case with lighting that mimicked the conditions in the Hartley family parlor.

The family photograph was displayed prominently, enlarged, so that every detail was visible, including the proud expression on William Hartley’s face as he sat in his treasured chair.

The walls around the chair displayed the story of its creation, the Harrison family’s commission, William Hartley’s role as financier and guardian, the craftsman who had built it, and Elizabeth Hartley’s decision to preserve it for future generations.

The final section of the exhibition was devoted to the chair’s legacy.

What it meant that private citizens in 1915 had cared enough about American symbols to create and protect this replica, and what it meant that Elizabeth Hartley had sealed it away for 90 years, trusting that future generations would understand its significance.

Dorothy Callahan arrived early, accompanied by several members of her extended family.

At 92, she moved slowly, but her eyes were bright with excitement.

Elena escorted her personally through the exhibition, watching as Dorothy stopped before the enlarged photograph of her great-grandparents and their children.

“I wish grandmother Elizabeth could see this,” Dorothy said softly.

“She would be so pleased to know the story is finally being told.

She made it possible,” Elena replied.

“Without her foresight, the chair might have been lost or destroyed decades ago”.

The museum doors opened at 10:00 and the crowd streamed in.

Elena watched from a corner as people moved through the exhibition, reading the wall texts, examining the documents, and finally stopping before the chair itself.

She saw expressions of wonder, heard whispered conversations, watched parents explaining the significance to their children.

One moment stood out.

An elderly man, perhaps in his 80s, stood before the chair for a long time, tears streaming down his face.

Finally, he approached Elena, who was standing nearby, answering visitors questions.

My grandfather was Giovani Rossi, he said, his voice breaking.

I never knew he had worked on something like this.

Our family always knew he was a master carver, but we had no idea he had created something so important.

“Thank you for finding this story.

Thank you for honoring him”.

Elellanena felt her own eyes fill with tears as she embraced the man.

This was why the story mattered, not just for the historical record, but for the families whose ancestors had poured their hearts into creating something beautiful and meaningful.

6 months after the exhibition opened, Elena stood in Independence Hall in the very room where the Constitutional Convention had taken place in 1787.

She had been invited to give a presentation to the National Park Service rangers who guided tours through this sacred space.

The original rising sun chair sat where it had always been, behind a protective barrier, its carved sun catching the afternoon light streaming through the tall windows.

Elena had stood in this room dozens of times, but today felt different.

She saw the chair not just as a historical artifact, but as part of a larger story about faith, preservation, and the enduring power of symbols.

The discovery of the replica chair has given us new insight into how Americans in later generations related to the founding era.

Elena told the Assembled Rangers, “In 1915, as World War I raged in Europe and the future seemed uncertain, private citizens decided that the symbol of the rising sun needed to be preserved and duplicated.

They weren’t government officials or museum directors.

They were a banker, a philanthropist, and immigrant craftsman.

But they understood that this symbol mattered.

She showed them the 1915 photograph, now famous, of the Hartley family posed so formally around the chair.

William Hartley commissioned this portrait specifically to document the chair’s existence.

He positioned himself to make sure the carved sun was visible.

This wasn’t vanity.

It was testimony.

He was creating a record that said, “We believe.

We believe in what this symbol represents.

We believe the sun is still rising”.

After her presentation, Elena walked slowly around Independence Hall, thinking about the journey that had brought her to this moment.

It had started with a photograph in a cardboard box and an elderly woman’s decision not to throw away a family heirloom.

It had led through archives and letters, through the stories of immigrants and wealthy families, through 90 years of hidden history.

The replica chair now resided permanently in the Philadelphia Museum of American History, where it continued to draw crowds.

But more importantly, the story behind it had sparked conversations about American identity, about immigration and craftsmanship, about how private citizens preserve what they value most.

Elena had received letters from descendants of all three craftsmen, Thomas Brennan, Giovani Rosi, and Jacob Freriedman.

Each family had been moved to discover their ancestors role in creating something so significant.

Several had donated their own family artifacts to the museum, adding depth to the exhibition.

The Harrison family had also come forward sharing additional documents that showed Jonathan Harrison III’s motivation for commissioning the replica.

He had written in his private diary, “The original chair belongs to history, to the people.

But perhaps we as individual citizens need our own symbols to remind us of our responsibilities to this nation.

The replica is not a copy.

It is a commitment”.

As Elena left Independence Hall that evening, she thought about Benjamin Franklin’s famous question, “Was the sun rising or setting”?

The beauty of the question, she realized, was that every generation had to answer it for themselves.

In 1787, Franklin had seen it rising.

In 1915, Jonathan Harrison and William Hartley had chosen to see it rising.

In 1935, Elizabeth Hartley had preserved that choice for the future.

And now, in 2025, visitors to the museum could stand before both the photograph and the chair and ask themselves the same question.

The answer wasn’t carved into the wood, though the symbol remained constant.

The answer lived in the choices people made.

To create, to preserve, to honor, to believe.

Elena pulled out her phone and looked once more at the photograph that had started everything.

Five people frozen in time.

A banker, his wife, their three children gathered around a chair that represented more than fine craftsmanship.

It represented hope.

It represented the decision to believe that despite wars and economic crises and all the uncertainties of history, the sun was still rising.

She thought about the craftsmen who had created the chair, pouring their skills and their faith in their adopted country into every carved detail.

She thought about Elizabeth Hartley, wise enough at 24 to know that some things needed time before they could be properly understood.

She thought about Dorothy Callahan, who had trusted her instinct not to throw away an old photograph.

All of them had played their part in preserving this story.

And now the story would continue, told and retold to new generations who would stand before the replica chair and see in its carved sun a reminder that every generation must choose, rising or setting.

Elena walked through the streets of Philadelphia as evening fell, past Independence Hall, and toward the museum where the replica chair waited in its carefully lit case.

The real sun was setting behind the city skyline, painting the sky in shades of orange and gold.

But tomorrow, it would rise again, and the chair, both chairs, the original and the replica, would continue to ask their quiet, essential question of everyone who saw them.

The answer, Elena thought, was always the same.

It had to be.

The sun was rising.

It would always be rising as long as people believed it and work to make it

« Prev