The telephone call came through to the White House at a half nine on the evening of May 15th, 1940.

President Franklin Roosevelt sat at his desk in the Oval study.

The windows opened to the spring air when the operator connected him to London.

The voice on the other end belonged to Winston Churchill, Britain’s new prime minister, for exactly 5 days, and what he said made Roosevelt reach for a cigarette with fingers that trembled slightly.

German panzers had broken through the French lines at Sedan.

They were racing toward the English Channel, cutting the Allied armies in two.

Churchill’s voice, usually so resonant and confident, carried an edge Roosevelt had never heard before.

The French were collapsing.

The British Expeditionary Force was being surrounded.

Churchill needed help immediately, and he needed Roosevelt to understand something that would define the next 18 months of both their lives.

Britain would not surrender.

No matter what happened to France, no matter how dark things became, Britain would fight on alone if necessary.

Roosevelt set down the telephone, and sat very still.

Through the open window he could hear the distant sounds of Washington at night, traffic on Pennsylvania Avenue, the ordinary rhythm of a nation at peace.

But in his mind, he was calculating what Churchill’s words actually meant.

The president had been watching Europe’s descent into war with growing alarm.

But this was different.

This was the moment when the abstract threat became terrifyingly concrete.

If France fell, if Britain stood alone against Hitler’s war machine, then only 3,000 mi of ocean would separate Nazi Germany from American shores.

The fall of France unfolded with a speed that stunned even Hitler’s generals.

The German offensive had begun on May 10th, the same day Churchill replaced Neville Chamberlain as prime minister.

Within 5 days, Panza divisions commanded by Hines Gderion had crossed the Moose River and were driving toward the coast.

The French army, which most military experts had considered the finest in Europe, was disintegrating.

British and French troops were being pushed into an evershrinking pocket around the coastal town of Dunkirk.

Roosevelt convened his cabinet on May 20th.

The men who gathered in the cabinet room that morning represented the full spectrum of American political opinion on the European War.

Secretary of State Cordell Hull, cautious and legalistic, worried constantly about violating the neutrality acts that Congress had passed to keep America out of foreign conflicts.

Secretary of the Treasury Henry Morganthaw and Secretary of the Interior Harold Dickers, both more hawkish, pushed for immediate aid to Britain and France.

Secretary of War Harry Woodring, ironically, was an isolationist who believed America should stay out of Europe’s problems entirely.

Roosevelt listened to them argue, his face revealing nothing.

Then he spoke, and his words were careful, measured, but underneath them was a current of deep concern.

The United States, he said, must do everything possible to help the Allies short of actually entering the war.

He emphasized those last six words short of actually entering the war.

Because the American people, Roosevelt knew with absolute certainty, would not support direct military intervention.

Not yet, possibly not ever.

The polls told a clear story.

More than 80% of Americans wanted Britain and France to win, but only 13% wanted America to send troops to help them.

The country was still haunted by the First World War, by the 53,000 American boys who had died in France, by the sense that European quarrels were not worth American blood.

Roosevelt understood this sentiment, even as he feared where it might lead.

On May 28th, Belgium surrendered.

King Leopold ordered his army to lay down its weapons, opening a gap in the Allied lines that made the situation at Dunkirk even more desperate.

That same day in London, Churchill’s war cabinet met to discuss whether Britain should explore the possibility of a negotiated peace with Hitler.

Lord Halifax, the foreign secretary, made the case.

France was finished.

The British Expeditionary Force was trapped.

If Britain fought on alone, Halifax argued, the country would be bombed, invaded, and conquered.

Better to explore what terms Hitler might offer while Britain still had some bargaining power while the Royal Navy and the promise of a long war might make Hitler willing to compromise.

Churchill listened to Halifax make this argument.

Then he stood and paced the cabinet room.

His hands were clasped behind his back, his shoulders hunched forward in that characteristic posture that would become so familiar to millions over the next 5 years.

When he spoke, his words were blunt.

Nations that went down fighting rose again.

Nations that surrendered tamely were finished.

If Britain entered negotiations with Hitler, it would be forced to accept terms that would turn the country into a German dependency.

The Royal Navy would be handed over.

The British Empire would be dismantled.

Hitler’s word, Churchill said with contempt, was worth nothing.

Any agreement would simply be a prelude to complete subjugation.

Britain would fight on.

If necessary, Britain would fight on alone.

The evacuation from Dunkerk began on May 27th and continued for 9 days.

The Royal Navy sent destroyers and cruisers into the shallow waters off the French coast, braving German artillery and dive bombers to lift soldiers from the beaches.

Civilian vessels joined them, hundreds of small boats crossing the channel to ferry exhausted men from the shore to the larger ships waiting offshore.

By June 4th, more than 330,000 British and French troops had been rescued.

It was a military disaster disguised as a miracle.

The British army had abandoned nearly all its heavy equipment in France.

Thousands of vehicles, hundreds of tanks and artillery pieces, mountains of supplies.

Britain’s army had been saved, but it had been stripped of the weapons it would need to defend the home islands if Germany invaded.

Churchill addressed Parliament on June 4th, the day the last ships returned from Dunkirk.

His speech was broadcast on the BBC that evening, and Roosevelt listened to it in the White House, hearing Churchill’s voice crackle through the static of the transatlantic connection.

“We shall fight on the beaches,” Churchill said, his voice rising with each phrase.

“We shall fight on the landing grounds.

We shall fight in the fields and in the streets.

We shall fight in the hills.

We shall never surrender.

” Roosevelt heard those words and felt something shift in his thinking.

This was not political rhetoric.

This was a statement of intent, a promise that Britain would resist no matter what the cost.

And if Britain resisted, if it held out long enough, then perhaps Hitler could be stopped without American troops crossing the Atlantic.

But only if Britain survived.

France formally surrendered on June 22nd, signing an armistice in the same railway car where Germany had surrendered in 1918.

Hitler insisted on this symbolic humiliation and he danced a little jig when the French delegates arrived.

German troops occupied Paris.

The French government now led by the elderly Marshall Philip Peta established itself in the spar town of Vishi and began collaborating with the Nazi regime.

Britain stood alone.

Roosevelt’s problem was both simple and maddeningly complex.

He wanted to help Britain.

He believed privately that American security depended on Britain’s survival.

But the neutrality acts passed by Congress in the late 1930s severely restricted what aid he could provide to nations at war.

He could not sell weapons to belligerent powers.

He could not loan them money.

American ships could not carry war materials into combat zones.

These laws had been designed to prevent the kind of gradual entanglement that had drawn America into the First World War.

Now they threatened to prevent America from helping the one nation standing between Hitler and complete domination of Europe.

Roosevelt began looking for loopholes.

The first opportunity came with a request from Churchill for destroyers.

The Royal Navy had lost a dozen destroyers during the Norway campaign and the Dunkirk evacuation.

Britain needed escort vessels to protect the convoys, bringing food and supplies across the Atlantic and to defend against a German invasion.

The US Navy had dozens of destroyers left over from the First World War, sitting idle in harbors.

Could Roosevelt transfer some of these ships to Britain? The answer legally was no.

The neutrality acts forbade it.

But Roosevelt’s attorney general, Robert Jackson, found a way around the law.

If Britain gave the United States something of equal value in return, then it would not be a sale to a belligerent power.

It would be a trade between friendly nations.

What did Britain have that America wanted? Naval bases.

Britain controlled islands throughout the Atlantic and Caribbean, strategic locations where the US Navy could establish bases to protect the approaches to the American mainland.

If Britain leased these bases to the United States for 99 years, and if the value of those leases happened to equal the value of 50 old destroyers, then perhaps a deal could be made.

Churchill hated the arrangement.

It felt like selling pieces of the British Empire to pay for survival, but he had no choice.

Britain needed those destroyers desperately, and Roosevelt was offering the only help available.

The destroyers for bases deal was announced in September 1940.

Roosevelt presented it to the American people as a shrewd bargain that strengthened US defenses while helping Britain.

Isolationists in Congress howled that it was a violation of neutrality.

A step toward war.

Roosevelt ignored them.

He had found his loophole and he intended to exploit it.

But 50 destroyers would not be enough.

Britain needed aircraft, weapons, ammunition, food, fuel.

The country was spending every dollar it had liquidating investments, selling off assets, borrowing against the future.

By December 1940, Churchill had to send Roosevelt a message that was both a plea and a warning.

Britain was running out of money.

Churchill’s letter arrived at the White House on December 9th.

Roosevelt was aboard the USS Tuscaloosa taking a Caribbean cruise to rest and think.

He read Churchill’s letter slowly, then read it again.

The prime minister laid out Britain’s financial situation with brutal honesty.

Britain had orders placed with American factories for weapons and supplies worth billions of dollars.

But Britain could not pay for them.

The country was broke.

If the flow of American supplies stopped, Britain would have to reduce its war effort, perhaps drastically, perhaps to the point where continued resistance became impossible.

Roosevelt spent two days thinking about this problem.

He paced the deck of the Tuscaloosa.

He sat in his cabin staring at maps.

He discussed it with his aid, Harry Hopkins.

The question was not whether to help Britain.

Roosevelt had already decided that Britain’s survival was essential to American security.

The question was how to help Britain when Congress would never approve a loan.

when the American people would never accept a gift of billions of dollars to a foreign country, when the neutrality acts blocked every obvious path.

On the evening of December 11th, Roosevelt called his staff together and told them he had an idea.

The press conference on December the 17th, 1940 was one of Roosevelt’s masterpieces of political communication.

Reporters packed into the Oval Office, notebooks ready, expecting the president to announce some new policy regarding Britain’s financial crisis.

Instead, Roosevelt told them a story.

Suppose, he said, that your neighbor’s house caught fire, and suppose your neighbor needed a garden hose to fight the fire, but he did not have one.

Would you refuse to lend him your hose because he could not pay for it? Of course not.

You would lend him the hose, let him put out the fire, and then he would return the hose when the fire was out.

Britain was the neighbor.

The fire was Hitler.

The hose was American weapons and supplies.

Roosevelt proposed a new system he called lend lease.

America would lend or lease weapons and supplies to any nation whose defense was vital to American security.

Britain would not have to pay cash.

After the war, Britain would return what it could and pay for what had been destroyed or used up, but on terms to be determined later.

In the meantime, American factories would supply Britain with everything it needed to keep fighting.

The isolationists understood immediately what Roosevelt was doing.

Senator Burton Wheeler of Montana called Lend Lease the New Deal’s AAA foreign policy, a reference to the Agricultural Adjustment Act that had paid farmers to plow under crops.

It will plow under every fourth American boy, Wheeler said.

Roosevelt was furious.

At his next press conference, he called Wheeler’s statement the most untruthful, the most dastardly, unpatriotic thing that has ever been said.

His anger was genuine, but it was also calculated.

By attacking Wheeler so forcefully, Roosevelt was framing the debate, “Support lend lease,” or side with someone the president had just called unpatriotic.

The land lease bill was introduced in Congress as HR1 1776, a deliberate reference to the year of American independence.

Roosevelt was positioning aid to Britain as a continuation of the fight for freedom that had begun with the American Revolution.

Britain was fighting America’s fight.

He suggested the least America could do was provide the weapons.

The debate in Congress lasted two months.

Isolationists warned that Len lease would drag America into war.

Interventionists argued that helping Britain was the best way to stay out of war.

By ensuring that Hitler was defeated before he could threaten the Western Hemisphere, Roosevelt worked behind the scenes, calling in favors, making promises, using every tool of presidential persuasion to line up votes.

On March 11th, 1941, Congress passed the Len Lease Act.

Roosevelt signed it the same day.

The vote was not even close.

60-31 in the Senate, 317-71 in the House.

America had committed itself to supporting Britain’s war effort with the full productive capacity of American industry.

Churchill received the news in London and felt something close to overwhelming relief.

Britain could keep fighting.

The supplies would keep coming.

Hitler had not won.

Roosevelt’s statement to the press after signing lend lease was characteristically understated.

He said that the act gave him the tools he needed to help defend democracy.

He did not say that he had just committed the United States to a policy that made war with Germany almost inevitable.

He did not say that he had maneuvered around congressional isolationists and public opinion to provide Britain with what amounted to a blank check.

He did not say that he had in effect made America a non-belligerent ally of Britain months before Pearl Harbor made the alliance official.

What Roosevelt said both publicly and privately was simpler and more direct.

He said that Britain’s fight was America’s fight.

That if Britain fell, America would face Hitler alone.

That the defense of Britain was the defense of America.

and he said in a cable to Churchill after the Lend Lease Act passed, something that revealed his true feelings about Britain’s decision to fight on alone.

“We are going to win this war,” Roosevelt wrote and the peace that follows.

“Not you are going to win.

” Bulman Roosevelt had heard Britain’s declaration that it would fight on alone, and his response was to ensure that Britain would never have to fight alone again.

It took him 9 months to maneuver around the political obstacles, to find the legal loopholes, to build public support, to overcome congressional resistance.

But from the moment Churchill told him that Britain would never surrender, Roosevelt had been working toward this outcome.

The president understood what many Americans did not yet grasp, that the Atlantic Ocean was not wide enough to protect America if Hitler controlled all of Europe.

that American security depended on Britain’s survival.

That Britain’s fight was America’s fight, whether America admitted it yet or not.

When Roosevelt heard that Britain would fight on alone, he made a decision that would shape the rest of his presidency and the rest of the war.

He decided that Britain would not fight alone.

He would find a way to help within the constraints of American law and public opinion, but he would help.

The destroyers for bases deal was the first step.

Lend lease was the second.

Each one pushed the boundaries of neutrality a little further.

Committed America a little more deeply to Britain’s cause.

By the time Japanese bombs fell on Pearl Harbor in December 1941, America was already fighting an undeclared naval war against German yubot in the Atlantic.

already supplying Britain and the Soviet Union with billions of dollars in weapons and supplies already committed to the defeat of Nazi Germany.

Roosevelt never gave a single dramatic speech announcing this policy.

He never asked Congress for a declaration of war against Germany.

He moved incrementally, step by careful step, always staying just ahead of public opinion, but never so far ahead that he lost congressional support.

He was patient, calculating, willing to accept criticism and opposition because he knew where he was going.

He was going to war, but he was going to arrive there with the American people behind him, or at least not actively opposed.

And he was going to ensure that when America entered the war, Britain would still be standing, still fighting, still holding the line against Hitler.

That was what Roosevelt said through his actions and his policies.

When he heard that Britain would fight on alone, he said quietly but firmly that Britain would not be alone, that America would help in every way possible short of war and eventually in war itself if necessary.

Churchill understood this.

In his memoirs written after the war, he described Roosevelt’s support during those dark months as the difference between British defeat and British survival.

Without American supplies, without the hope that America would eventually enter the war, Britain might have been forced to accept a negotiated peace.

With American support, Britain could hold on, could build up its strength, could wait for the moment when the tide would turn.

Roosevelt’s reaction to Britain’s decision to fight on alone was not a single statement or a dramatic gesture.

It was a sustained campaign of support that lasted 18 months from the fall of France in June 1940 to Pearl Harbor in December 1941.

It was a masterclass in political leadership in finding ways to do what needed to be done despite legal obstacles and public opposition.

And it was a commitment that Roosevelt honored fully.

When America finally entered the war, it did so with a clear priority.

Germany first.

The Pacific War against Japan would have to wait.

Continue reading….
Next »