His eyes were red, his face hagggered.

I should have known, he said.

The scout plane reports were delayed.

The Americans appeared exactly when we were most vulnerable.

They knew.

They knew where we were.

They knew what we were doing.

They knew when to strike.

We couldn’t have known they’d broken our codes.

Kusaka said, “I should have assumed it.

” Nagumo said, “I should have assumed the worst.

Instead, I assumed we would surprise them as we always had.

I assumed we would strike first as we always had.

I assumed we would win as we always hate.

He looked down at his half-written report and now four carriers are gone and over 2,000 men are dead and it’s my fault.

Kusaka had no answer for that.

It was Nagumo’s fault in the sense that he had commanded the force.

But it was also Yamamoto’s fault for planning an operation that dispersed Japan’s forces too widely.

And it was the Navy Ministry’s fault for assuming their codes were secure.

And it was the fault of every officer who had believed that Japan’s early victories meant they were invincible.

The blame could be spread wide enough to cover everyone.

But in the end, Nagumo was right.

He had commanded the carriers and he had lost them.

That was the only fact that mattered.

The full scope of the disaster became clear over the following days.

Four fleet carriers lost, 322 aircraft destroyed, 2,200 men killed, including some of Japan’s most experienced pilots and air crew.

The entire elite of Japanese naval aviation, the men who had trained for years, who had perfected their skills over China and Pearl Harbor and the Indian Ocean, gone in a single day.

And for what? The Americans had lost Yorktown, sunk by a Japanese submarine 2 days after the battle.

One carrier, the exchange rate was 4:1 in America’s favor.

And America, with its massive industrial capacity, could replace Yorktown.

Japan could not replace Akagi, Kaga, Soryu, and Hiryu.

Not the ships, and certainly not the trained pilots and crew.

Yamamoto understood this immediately.

Within days of the battle, he was already planning a defensive strategy, something unthinkable before midway.

Japan would consolidate its holdings, build up its defenses, try to make the cost of advancing too high for America to bear.

The offensive was over.

The dream of dominating the Pacific was over.

Now, it was just a matter of holding on, of making America pay for every island, of hoping that eventually the Americans would tire and negotiate a peace.

But Yamamoto knew, even if he wouldn’t say it aloud, that this was fantasy.

America would not tire.

America would not negotiate.

America would build more carriers, train more pilots, and come west with overwhelming force.

Midway had not just stopped Japan’s offensive, it had sealed Japan’s fate.

On June 10th, Nagumo’s force limped back into Hashiima anchorage.

The carriers were gone.

The destroyers and cruisers that returned were battered, low on fuel, their crews exhausted.

Nagumo transferred from Nwaki to a cruiser and prepared to face the Navy Ministry to explain how he had lost four carriers in one day.

He expected to be court marshaled.

He expected to be relieved of command, perhaps forced to commit suicide.

Instead, the Navy Ministry, desperate to hide the scale of the disaster from the public, gave him another command.

They couldn’t admit that their greatest admiral had failed so catastrophically.

They couldn’t admit that the kido bhai had been destroyed.

So they promoted him, gave him new responsibilities, and pretended that Midway had been a minor setback.

But Nagumo knew the truth.

He had stood on a Kagi’s bridge and watched the dive bombers fall from the sky.

He had seen his carriers burn.

He had watched 2,000 men die.

No amount of propaganda could change that.

No amount of pretending could bring back a kagi kaga soryu and hiryu.

Years later, after more defeats, after more disasters, after the war had turned into a grinding nightmare of island battles and kamicazi attacks, Naguma would find himself on Saipan commanding the island’s defense against an American invasion.

When the island fell, when there was no escape and no hope, he would finally do what he had perhaps wanted to do since Midway.

He would take his pistol and end his life.

His last act of final admission that he had failed, that he had lost the carriers, that he had lost the war.

But on June 10th, 1942, standing on the deck of a cruiser in Hashiima anchorage, watching the empty sea where his carriers should have been, Nagumo simply stood in silence.

around him.

His staff officers waited for orders, for guidance, for some sign of what came next.

Nagumo had no answers.

He had commanded the greatest carrier force in the world, and he had lost it in a single day.

What came next was defeat.

What came next was retreat.

What came next was the slow, grinding destruction of everything Japan had built in six months of victories.

But he couldn’t say that, so he said nothing.

He stood on the deck and stared at the empty ocean and remembered the moment when the dive bombers appeared through the clouds.

The moment when he understood that everything was about to change.

The moment when Japan’s war in the Pacific ended before it had really begun.

On Yamato, Yamamoto received the casualty reports and read them methodically.

Over 2,000 men dead, hundreds more wounded, four carriers sunk, the Kido Bhutai destroyed.

He filed the reports carefully, wrote his own assessment for the Navy Ministry, and then sat alone in his cabin, staring at the photograph of the carriers at Pearl Harbor.

Someone asked him later what he had felt in that moment, reading the casualty lists, understanding what Midway meant.

Yamamoto had simply shaken his head.

I told them, he said quietly.

I told them we could run wild for 6 months.

It has been 6 months.

The mathematics was simple.

The outcome was inevitable.

Japan had gambled everything on a quick victory on breaking America’s will before America’s industry could mobilize.

And they had lost the gamble at midway.

lost it in a single morning when four carriers burned and sank and took Japan’s offensive with them to the bottom of the Pacific.

What the Japanese admiral said when American carriers destroyed their fleet at Midway was mostly silence because there was nothing to say.

No words could change what had happened.

No explanations could bring back the ships or the men.

No amount of analysis could alter the fundamental fact that Japan had lost, had lost catastrophically, and that everything that came after would be a long, slow retreat toward inevitable defeat.

They had stood on their bridges and watched their carriers burn.

They had read the casualty reports and understood what they meant.

They had known in that moment that the war was over, even though it would continue for three more years.

They had known that they had lost everything in a single day.

Lost it to an enemy they had underestimated.

Lost it because they had believed their own propaganda about invincibility.

And so they said nothing.

They stood in silence and watched the ocean and understood that they had brought this on themselves, on their men, on their nation, and that there was nothing left to do but continue to fight the losing battle, to watch as everything they had built was slowly destroyed until the end came at last, and they could finally stop pretending that Midway had been anything other than what it was, the day Japan lost the war.

 

« Prev