By the end of the Second World War, the men who had commanded Hitler’s armies faced very different fates.

Some were [music] hanged.

Some died alone in prison cells.

Some were driven down quiet roads and never came back.

And some lived long enough to write memoirs, collect pensions, and watch the world forget what they had done.

This is the story of how the most feared generals of the Third Reich met their ends.

Of all the endings in this story, none was more carefully staged or more deliberately concealed than that of field marshal Irvin Raml.

By October 1944, Raml was living under effective house arrest at his family home in Herlingan, a quiet village in the Swabian Alps in southern Germany.

He had been gravely wounded three months earlier on July 17th, 1944 when his staff car was strafed by Allied aircraft near the village of Sant Fua de Montgomery in Normandy.

His skull had been fractured in multiple places.

His left eye was temporarily blinded and he had been thrown from the vehicle.

He had survived barely and had been brought home to recover.

What he could not have fully known as he conileles in Herlingan through August and September was that his name was circulating in the interrogation rooms of the Gestapo.

The July 20th, 1944 bomb plot against Hitler.

The attempt by a group of senior officers and civilians to assassinate the dictator and end the war had failed.

Its aftermath was a wave of arrests, torture, and executions that swept through the German military and civilian establishment.

Thousands were arrested.

Nearly 5,000 were eventually killed.

And among the statements extracted under duress from several plotters, the name Raml kept appearing.

Whether Raml was genuinely a co-conspirator or whether he had simply been aware of the general intent of some plotters without actively joining the plot is a question historians have debated for decades.

What is not disputed is that by late September 1944, Adolf Hitler had been presented with a summary by Martin Borman, his secretary, detailing the evidence against Raml.

Hitler faced a political problem of unusual delicacy.

Raml was not simply a senior general.

He was the most famous military commander in Germany.

The soldier whose face the regime had placed on propaganda posters whose North African campaigns had been celebrated by the German press as the embodiment of military genius and national pride.

A public trial at the hands of Roland Frysler’s People’s Court, the show trial mechanism used to condemn and execute most of the July 20th plotters would have been a propaganda catastrophe.

Hitler made a different decision.

Raml would be given a choice.

On the morning of October 14th, 1944, Raml woke at 7:00 a.

m.

and had breakfast with his 15year-old son, Manfred, who had been brought home from military service at his father’s personal request.

During their morning walk in the garden, Raml counted five trucks full of armed soldiers in civilian clothes positioned around the village.

He told his son that two generals from Berlin were arriving at noon.

He said he had hoped they might be sending him to a new command, perhaps on the Eastern front, but the trucks outside had told him otherwise.

At noon, Generals Bilhelm Burgdorf and Ernst Misel arrived from Hitler’s headquarters.

In a private meeting, Burgdorf laid out the evidence against Raml and informed him of his three [music] options.

He could present himself before Hitler in Berlin to answer the charges, which would be treated as an admission of guilt.

He could face the people’s court, which would result in a near certain death sentence, the public disgrace of his family, and the arrest and execution of members of his staff.

Or he could accept a prepared cyanide capsule, drive a short [music] distance from his house with the two generals and die quietly.

In that case, the regime would announce that he had died of the wounds sustained [music] in Normandy.

He would receive a state funeral with full military honors.

His family would receive pensions.

his staff would be left untouched.

Raml spent approximately 15 minutes with his wife.

He told her what had been offered and what he had decided.

Then he went to his son’s room.

He told Manford that in 15 minutes he would be dead.

He said that to die at the hands of one’s own people was hard, but that the house was surrounded and the choice had been made.

He took his Africa jacket and his field marshals baton.

At 100 p.

m.

he walked out of his house for the last time.

He shook hands with Manfred and with his aid Hermon Aldinger.

The SS driver, Henrik Dose, held the car door open.

Raml got in with Burgdorf and Mazil and the car drove out of Herlingan down a quiet country road through a forest.

The car stopped in a secluded wooded area approximately 15 minutes from the house.

Burgdorf gave Raml the cyanide capsule.

Then Miselle and the driver Deuce stepped out and walked away from the vehicle, leaving Raml alone in the back seat with Burgdorf.

After several minutes, Burgdorf signaled for Deuce to return to the car.

The driver found [music] Raml slumped forward, his cap fallen from his head, his Marshall’s baton on the floor.

The cyanide had worked within minutes.

Deuce opened the door, replaced the cap on Raml’s head, and placed the baton back in his hand.

20 minutes later, the phone rang at the house in Herlingan.

Raml’s aid answered.

The voice on the other end informed him that Field Marshall Raml had died of his wounds.

3 days later, a state funeral was held in M.

Field Marshal Gared von Runstead, who had sat on the military court that had effectively condemned Raml, delivered the eulogy, unaware by his own later account that Raml had been killed by Hitler’s order.

The official death announcement said cardiac failure caused by the injuries sustained in France.

The lie held for months.

The truth only emerged in April 1945 when an Allied intelligence officer interviewed Raml’s widow and received a letter from his son Manfred.

By then, the regime that had killed him had less than a month left to exist.

The manner of Raml’s death, staged, concealed, wrapped in official honors, was uniquely his own.

The lie constructed around it was elaborate and for a time effective.

The official announcement described cardiac failure brought on by the wounds sustained in Normandy.

An official day of national mourning was declared.

The state funeral in M was attended by senior military and political figures.

Hitler sent a wreath.

Fon Runstead delivering the eulogy spoke of Raml as a soldier who had died in the service of the fatherland.

Behind the scenes, the Gestapo that had surrounded the village of Herlingan quietly withdrew.

Raml’s family received the pension payments that had been promised.

His staff were left alone.

The bargain Hitler had offered was honored in full.

The public fiction of a hero’s death in exchange for a private unagnowledged execution.

What no one in Berlin had anticipated was Manfred Raml, the 15-year-old who had breakfasted with his father that morning, walked in the garden, counted the trucks, and heard those final words, was keeping a record.

He wrote it down, and when Allied forces reached the area in 1945, the full account reached Allied intelligence officers within days of Germany’s surrender.

But what happened to the generals who remained loyal to the end was in some ways more revealing of what the regime had actually been.

If Raml’s end was tragedy, the end of Field Marshall Vilhelm Kaidle was something closer to accounting.

Kaidle had served as chief of the Ober commando de Vermacht, the supreme command of all German armed forces since 1938.

He had remained in that position for the entire duration of the war through every campaign, every atrocity, every criminal order that passed from Hitler’s hands into the military chain of command.

He had signed the commasar order which authorized the summary execution on site of Soviet political officers, a direct violation of international law.

He had signed the night and fog decree which ordered that civilians arrested for resistance activities in occupied western Europe be transported to Germany and made to disappear without record or notification of their families.

He had approved the use of Soviet prisoners of war as forced labor under conditions that killed hundreds of thousands of them.

He had functioned in the assessment of the Nuremberg tribunal not as a military commander exercising professional judgment but as a transmission belt for Hitler’s will.

faithfully conveying the most criminal orders downward without objection.

His fellow generals despised him for it.

Among themselves they called him Leatel, a contemptuous play on his name, combining it with the German word for lackey.

He was not, in the eyes of the professional officer corps, a general in any meaningful sense.

He was an administrator of obedience.

On May 8th, 1945, in a school room in Berlin, Carl’s host, Keel signed the unconditional surrender of Nazi Germany’s armed forces on behalf of the German military command.

He arrived in full dress uniform, complete with field marshals baton and decorations.

He signed the documents with the stiff, precise bearing he had maintained throughout his career.

It was, by the testimony of those present, a surreal scene.

a man who had just signed the total defeat of his nation, performing the ceremony of surrender as though it were a routine military procedure.

He was arrested by Allied forces shortly afterward and transferred to Nuremberg to face trial before the International Military Tribunal.

At trial, Kaidle’s defense was that he had only followed orders, that a soldier’s duty was obedience, and that the criminal nature of some of those orders had not been his responsibility to question.

The tribunal rejected this argument.

The principle being established at Nuremberg that professional soldiers bore personal responsibility for the crimes they facilitated regardless of who issued the orders was applied directly to Kaidel and with particular emphasis.

He was the most senior military commander on trial.

He was convicted on all four counts, conspiracy, crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity.

His request to be executed by firing squad on the grounds that shooting was the customary military form of execution and that hanging was the method for common criminals was denied.

The allies had specifically [music] considered this request and rejected it precisely because they wanted to make clear that Kadel’s crimes were not military in any honorable sense.

He would be treated as a criminal because he was one.

On the morning of October 16th, 1946, Kitle was led into the gymnasium of Nerburgg prison.

Nine other condemned men had already been executed or would follow him that morning.

He walked to the gallows with what witnesses uniformly described as a military bearing, erect, controlled, his head held high.

When asked his name for the record, he responded loudly.

On the scaffold, he delivered his final words.

He called on God to have mercy on the German people.

declared that more than two million German soldiers had gone to their deaths before him and said he now followed his sons, all for Germany.

It was the statement of a man who at the very end understood himself as a soldier rather than a criminal.

The trap was opened shortly after 1:20 a.

m.

According to the eyewitness account of journalist Kingsbury Smith, who was present in the gymnasium that night, Kadel was pronounced dead at 1:44 a.

m.

The duration reflected a grim reality about the Nuremberg executions that the US Army tried for years to suppress.

The hangings had been botched.

Executioner Master Sergeant John C.

Woods used a standard short drop rather than the long drop method calibrated to break the neck cleanly.

As a result, several condemned men that night died not quickly, but from prolonged strangulation.

Multiple post-war investigations and witness accounts documented what happened beneath the scaffold’s black canvas curtain.

Kaidel’s death, by several accounts, was among the most prolonged of the night.

His body, along with those of the other executed men, was transported to Munich and cremated.

The ashes were scattered in a tributary of the Isar River, a deliberate act to prevent the graves from becoming pilgrimage sites for future admirers of the regime.

Kaidle went to the gallows as he had served in uniform to attention facing forward.

Whether he understood in those final moments what his compliance had actually made possible, that is a question no one can answer for him.

Not all of the most feared generals of the Third Reich faced the scaffold or the pistol.

Some survived, were processed through Allied legal systems, and walked away.

Of those, few embodied the strange postwar existence of the former German military commander more completely than Hines Gderion.

Gderion was, in the technical sense, the man who had made the Blitz Creek possible.

As a theorist and commander through the 1930s, he had transformed the tank from a support weapon for infantry into the central instrument of a new kind of warfare, rapid, deep, decisive, that could collapse entire fronts before the enemy had time to respond.

His armored core had torn through Poland in September 1939, through France and Belgium in May and June 1940, and deep into Soviet territory after June 1941.

His men had reached further and faster than any army had moved since Napoleon.

In the operational history of the Second World War, Gudderion was a figure of genuine military significance.

He was also a figure who had authorized the criminal commasar order in the units under his command, who had actively served a regime conducting a war of extermination on the Eastern Front and who had been appointed by Hitler as a member of the Court of Military Honor in the immediate aftermath of the July 20th plot.

The body that reviewed the cases of officers suspected of involvement and recommended them for trial at the People’s Court, where execution was essentially guaranteed.

The court processed hundreds of cases.

Officers who appeared before it were stripped of their military rank and handed to civilian justice, which in Fryler’s courtroom meant death.

Gdderian signed off on those recommendations.

He had also in October 1944 delivered a speech to senior Vermach commanders in which he explicitly demanded that every officer demonstrate unconditional loyalty to Hitler.

A speech delivered knowing full well the context in which it came.

mass executions of his own colleagues in the weeks following the failed bomb plot.

The speech was preserved in the record.

It was the speech of a man choosing consciously and publicly to bind himself and the officer corps [music] to the regime at the precise moment the regime was murdering its own generals.

Hitler dismissed Gderrion from his position as chief of the army general staff on March 28th, 1945 after a violent argument over the conduct of operations on the Eastern Front.

Specifically, a failed attempt to break through to German units encircled at Kustran, which Hitler blamed on Gderian subordinates, and Gderrion blamed on Hitler’s interference.

The argument by the accounts of those present was one of the most heated of the entire war with both men shouting at each other in the presence of senior staff.

Gderrion was placed on sick leave.

He was replaced by General Hans Krebs who would himself be dead within 7 weeks.

On May 10th, 1945, 2 days after Germany’s unconditional surrender, Gderion turned himself into American forces.

He was interned at various prisoner of war facilities for the next 3 years.

Despite persistent requests from the Soviet Union and Poland that he be charged with war crimes, the Western Allied authorities declined to prosecute him.

He was released in June 1948.

In the years that followed, Gdderian lived in southern Bavaria writing his memoirs Panzer Leader, which was published in German in 1950 and translated into English in 1952.

The book became an international bestseller.

It was read by military professionals across NATO as a masterclass in armored warfare.

It was also, as historians would conclude in later decades, a deeply misleading document, one that attributed the German military’s failures entirely to Hitler’s interference, portrayed the Vermacht as a professional force largely separate from the crimes of the Nazi regime, and carefully omitted Gderian’s own role in the execution of criminal orders.

He continued to write and correspond with former colleagues and military professionals in his remaining years.

By 1954, his heart disease, which had required regular medical treatment since at least 1944, had progressed significantly.

On May 14th, 1954, Gderian died of congestive heart failure at Schwanga in southern Bavaria.

He was 65 years old.

He was buried in Golar.

He was never tried.

He never faced a judicial accounting for the orders issued under his command or for his role in the Court of Military Honor that sent men to their deaths after July 20th.

He died in his bed in peace time Bavaria, having published a successful book and having spent his final years as a respected figure in the circles of Western military thought.

His post-war reputation illustrated something that would take decades to fully confront.

That the end of a war does not automatically produce accountability and that a sufficiently useful expertise can outlast almost any legal or moral reckoning.

Eric von Mannstein was by the consensus of military historians on both sides of the conflict the most operationally gifted German commander of the Second World War.

his plan for the invasion of France in 1940.

The concentrated armored thrust through the Ardan that cut off the Allied armies in Belgium and forced the evacuation at Dunkirk had been one of the most audacious and successful military operations of the modern era.

His defense on the Eastern Front through 1942 and 1943 had prevented the collapse that Soviet numerical superiority might otherwise have produced years earlier than it did.

He was also a commander who had received detailed reports on the operations of the Inets groupin, the mobile SS killing units that followed the Vermacht into Soviet territory and murdered Jewish communities, Soviet officials, and others deemed enemies of the occupation and had done nothing to interfere with them.

He had issued orders implementing the criminal treatment of Soviet civilians in his operational zone.

He had in short commanded in a theater where some of the worst crimes of the entire war were committed in circumstances where his authority might have limited them.

In 1949, Monstein was brought before a British military court in Hamburgg to answer 17 charges of war crimes.

He was found guilty on nine of them, including failing to protect civilian lives in his sphere of operations and using scorched earth tactics that denied food to civilian populations.

He was sentenced to 18 years imprisonment.

The sentence was reduced to 12 years in 1950 and he was released in May 1953 for medical reasons, specifically deteriorating eyesight, having served slightly over 4 years in total.

Continue reading….
Next »