And I’m deeply sorry that I was the instrument of that humiliation to prepare the way for a testimony more powerful than any theological argument.

That Carlo is alive spiritually.

That he can appear in dreams.

That he corrects pride with mercy rather than anger.

Your inability to answer my arguments that day wasn’t weakness.

It was the necessary condition for Carlo to demonstrate that his intercession is real.

His prayers are heard and his influence continues beyond death.

If you had defeated me intellectually, I would have walked away respecting your intelligence but unchanged.

But because you couldn’t defeat me and yet Carlo reached me anyway through my dream.

I now know something my intellect alone could never have taught me.

That there are forms of truth that transcend logic and argument.

Today, 15 months after the initial confrontation and 12 months after Ysef’s return visit, I understand what God was teaching me through that painful experience.

a lesson I desperately didn’t want to learn but needed to learn.

For 18 years as Carlo’s mother accompanying pilgrims, I had become comfortable in that role.

I had developed reliable responses to most questions, created a kind of script for sharing Carlo’s story, and built up confidence that I knew how to represent my son well.

But that comfort had also created a subtle pride, not overt arrogance, but a quiet assumption that my role was to defend Carlo, to explain him, to make him accessible through my words and my witness.

The confrontation with Ysef shattered that assumption.

It exposed brutally that my intellectual defenses were inadequate, my theological knowledge insufficient, my arguments incapable of withstanding aggressive challenge.

And in that moment of humiliation when I stood defenseless and inadequate.

God taught me Carlo doesn’t need you to defend him.

He can defend himself.

My role isn’t to win arguments or defeat objectors.

My role is simply to love Carlo authentically, to share his story with genuine maternal affection, and to trust that when someone like Yousef attacks with arguments I can’t counter, Carlo himself will intervene, not through my words, but through his continuing spiritual presence that reaches even into the dreams of those who come to mock.

Ysef and I have maintained occasional contact since November 2024.

He emails me every few months updating me on his spiritual journey, sometimes asking questions about Catholic practice, sometimes sharing insights from Islamic spirituality.

In March 2025, he wrote that he had given a Friday sermon at his mosque about recognizing righteousness beyond religious boundaries.

He didn’t mention Carlo explicitly.

That would have been too provocative for his conservative congregation.

But he spoke about how Allah can work through people of different faiths.

How Muslims should respect genuine devotion to God even when expressed through theological frameworks we don’t accept.

The response was mixed.

Yousef wrote, “Some appreciated the message of respect and dialogue.

Others accused me of compromising Islamic distinctiveness.

But I felt I had to speak truth as I’ve come to understand it through my experience.

In July 2025, Ysef made his third visit to Aisi.

This time bringing his teenage son.

I want Ahmed to meet you.

He wrote beforehand, I want him to understand that Muslims and Christians can disagree about theology while respecting each other’s sincere devotion to God.

When they arrived, I welcomed them both warmly.

Ahmed was 15, the same age Carlo was when he died, and I was struck by how Ysef introduced me.

Ahmed, this is Senora Antonia Salzano, mother of Carlo Akutis.

Her son was a young person who loved God deeply, and his example has taught me important lessons about humility and respect.

We spent an hour together and I shared Carlo’s story with Akmed much as I share it with any young person.

His love for the Eucharist, his computer skills, his care for the poor, his joyful acceptance of suffering, his final offering of his illness for the Pope and the church.

Ahmed listened intently, then asked, “If Carlo loved God so much, why didn’t he become Muslim? Islam is the true religion.

Before I could respond, Ysef gently corrected his son.

Ahmed Carlo expressed his love for Allah through Christianity because that’s the tradition he was born into and the way he understood God’s revelation.

We believe Islam is the complete and final revelation.

But that doesn’t mean people in other traditions can’t genuinely love Allah and serve him faithfully.

I was moved by how Ysef framed this, maintaining his Islamic convictions while also making space for recognizing Carlo’s authentic devotion.

The story of my humiliation by Ysef Almansour and his subsequent transformation has become one of the most powerful testimonies in Carlo’s cause for canonization.

Church officials investigating miracles attributed to Carlo’s intercession have included Ysef’s dream and conversion of heart as an example of Carlo’s continuing influence beyond Catholic boundaries.

Some Catholics are uncomfortable with this.

They want clear conversions to Catholicism rather than Muslims remaining Muslim while recognizing Carlos holiness within their own framework.

But I’ve come to see Yousef’s position as its own kind of miracle, a bridge between traditions, a recognition that God’s work doesn’t always fit our neat categories.

For me personally, the experience taught me the hardest lesson of motherhood, letting go.

For 18 years, I tried to defend Carlo, explain Carlo, make Carlo accessible through my efforts.

But Carlo doesn’t need my defense.

He operates from heaven with freedom I can’t control.

Reaching people in ways I can’t facilitate, building bridges I can’t construct.

My job is simply to love him, to share his story authentically, and to trust that when my words are inadequate, as they will often be, Carlo himself will step in to accomplish what I cannot.

And if this channel has been an answer for you, consider leaving a super thanks.

This financial help, however small it may seem, sustains this mission and allows us to continue bringing deep and transformative content to more lives that need this word.

My name is Antonia Salzano.

I am 59 years old.

I am the mother of Carlo Acutis who died at age 15 on October 12th, 2006 and was beatified on October 10th, 2020.

On August 3rd, 2024, I was publicly humiliated by a Muslim imam who attacked Catholic faith with arguments I couldn’t refute, who called Carlos memory idolatry, and who exposed my intellectual inadequacy in front of 40 witnesses.

I felt devastated, inadequate, abandoned by God.

I cried from rage and helplessness, questioning whether I should continue accompanying pilgrims if I couldn’t defend the faith properly.

3 weeks later, that same imam sent an email begging forgiveness because Carlo had appeared in his dream, correcting his arrogance, not with anger, but with mercy, speaking truth he couldn’t dismiss.

God allowed my humiliation precisely so that Carlo’s subsequent intervention would be more powerful testimony than any argument I could have offered.

My weakness became the canvas on which Carlo painted his continuing intercession.

A Muslim imam remains Muslim but now recognizes a Catholic teenager as a friend of Allah.

That bridge between our traditions was built not through theological debate, but through my failure to debate effectively, followed by Carlo’s supernatural intervention.

I learned the hardest lesson.

Carlo doesn’t need me to defend him.

He defends himself.

And sometimes God allows us to be humiliated precisely.

So the glory of what he does afterward belongs entirely to him.

This is my testimony.

This is my wound that became grace.

This is the day I was defeated.

And how that defeat became victory I never could have achieved through my own strength.

« Prev