He held it in his hands for a moment.

Small, worn at the corners, the cover softened by a year of being pressed against his chest.

He could feel the slight difference in the paper stock of the pages near the front, where Margareti had been in the habit of pressing flowers when she was young, a habit she had told him about once, laughing at herself for it.

He had never verified whether there were flowers in this copy.

He had not opened it in 4 months.

He opened it.

There were no flowers.

What there was on the inside front cover was Margaret’s handwriting.

Not an inscription, just his name, Werner, written simply in the bottom right corner.

the way you write your name in a book you are giving to someone and do not want to make a speech about it.

He looked at his name in her handwriting for a long time.

Then he opened to the middle of the book where the pages fell naturally and read what was there.

A few stanzas of the stunnenbuck, the prayers Rilka had written at the turn of the century.

The ones that addressed God not as an authority but as something being slowly constructed by human attention, something that needed people to look at it in order to exist.

itche mine lean in and walks in and ringan I live my life in widening circles he read it once he set the book on the workbench beside the folded prayer the two pieces of paper sat side by side in the flat light of the storage room’s plain English and Rilka is German a prayer from 1918 and a poem from 1899 both of them saying in their different languages and registers something that Wernern could not yet put into words but could feel pressing against the framework he had been carrying, not breaking it exactly, but widening it.

The way water widens a path.

Harold Biggs was in the fellowship hall when Wernner came back through.

He had arrived at some point during the previous hour.

Wernern had not heard him come in.

He was seated at one of the long tables with a set of papers in front of him, budget figures for the upcoming quarter.

Wernern would later understand the kind of deacons work that happened in whatever space was available.

He looked up when Werner came through the door.

Wernern was carrying the folded prayer.

He had not decided what to do with it.

He knew he would show it to Marsh.

It belonged to the church or to whoever Robert Cole’s people were if any of them remained.

But he had not yet had that conversation and so he was carrying it in his hand as he came through the fellowship hall.

Harold looked at the paper.

He looked at Wernner’s face.

Wernern stopped.

He did not know what Harold saw in his expression.

He had believed for most of his adult life that he was not a man whose face disclosed much.

His students in Leipig had called him precise, which was a students word for unreadable.

His commanding officer had called him reliable, which was a military word for the same thing.

Margareti had called him Maine Stiller Wernner, my quiet Werner, and had meant it with tenderness rather than complaint.

But Harold Biggs was looking at his face with the attention of a man who had spent 60 years reading people and Wernern felt with some discomfort that he was being read.

Harold did not ask what the paper was.

He looked at Werner’s face for a moment longer.

Then he looked back at his budget figures.

Wernern walked through to the yard.

He told Marsh about the prayer that afternoon.

He laid it on the desk in the small office off the main entrance and stood back while Marsh read it.

Marsh read it the way he did most things, thoroughly without rushing, giving it the full attention of someone who understood that attention was a form of respect.

When he finished, he sat for a moment with the paper in his hands.

Robert Cole, he said, Margaret’s father-in-law.

He died in France in 1918.

She never knew him, her husband’s family.

Wernern said nothing.

Marsh looked at the last paragraph of the prayer, the one about the German soldiers.

He read it again to himself, his lips not moving.

Then he set the paper down carefully on the desk.

The way you set down something that is weight.

Where did you find it? In the wall, Wernner said, “Between the stud and the sheathing behind the damaged section.

” Marsh nodded slowly.

He looked at the prayer for another moment.

He put it there before he shipped out.

Marsh said September 1918.

He left in October.

He was killed in November, 3 weeks before the armistice.

The room was quiet.

He never came home, Marsh said.

But this did.

Wernern stood in the office doorway and looked at the prayer on the desk and thought about Robert Cole in September of 1918, crouching over this paper in the fellowship hall before the plaster went on, writing down what he believed and placing it in the wall of his church and walking away from it and shipping out to France and dying 3 weeks before the war ended.

praying for the men on the other side of the line.

Wernern reached into his breast pocket.

The Rilka book was there.

He pressed his hand flat against it for a moment, feeling the shape of it through the fabric.

Then he took his hand away and went back to work.

The last week began quietly.

Warner arrived on Monday morning to find the fellowship hall smelling of fresh plaster.

The repair compound he had mixed and applied on Friday had cured over the weekend, and the wall was ready for sanding.

He ran his hand across the surface.

It had set evenly without cracking, which meant the mix had been correct and the application consistent.

Small satisfactions, the kind that did not announce themselves.

Thomas was there already, sweeping the plaster dust from Friday off the pine floor, moving the broom in the long, careful strokes of someone who had been taught to sweep properly.

He looked up when Wernner came in and nodded once and went back to sweeping.

Wernern set his toolbox on the workt and looked at the wall.

For weeks ago, it had been a water stained surface with a failed roof above it and a framework of assumptions behind it.

Now the roof was sound and the wall was smooth in the assumptions.

Wernern did not finish the thought.

He picked up the sanding block and began.

Jimmy Sutton came in at 8 with the coffee, set Wernern’s cup on the workt without interrupting the work, and took his usual position near the door with the particular relaxed vigilance that Werner had stopped noticing weeks ago.

The way you stop noticing a reliable thing.

Jimmy had not changed in 4 weeks.

He was the same man he had been on the first Tuesday.

Unhurried, consistent, present without pressing.

Wernern had come to understand that this was not a performance of ease, but the actual thing.

the genuine temperament of a man who had made his peace with his circumstances and lived inside that piece without drama.

Wernner sanded the wall came smooth under the block in the slow circular motion his grandfather had taught him.

Never linear, always circular because linear sanding leaves lines and lines show under paint.

The motion required full attention at first and then became its own rhythm.

The hand knowing what to do while the mind moved elsewhere.

It moved to Robert Cole’s prayer.

Marsh had placed it in a small wooden box in his office alongside the church’s founding documents.

The deed, the original congregation list from 1887, a photograph of the building under construction.

He had shown Wernner the box on Friday before the work ended.

Opening it with the same care he brought to everything, setting the folded prayer inside with the deliberateness of someone placing something in the correct location after a long time in the wrong one.

It belongs here, Marsh had said.

Not to Wernner specifically, simply as a statement of fact addressed to the room.

Wernern had looked at the prayer in the box, Robert Cole’s neat handwriting, the eight names, the last paragraph, and had felt again the thing he had felt when he first unfolded it in the open wall.

Not sentiment, not the soft, dissolving feeling that sentiment produced, something harder and more structural than that.

The feeling of a loadbearing element being identified, something that had been present in the structure all along, holding weight you had not accounted for, and the faint vertigo of realizing the building was larger than your blueprint of it.

He had not said anything to Marsh.

He had looked at the prayer in the box for a moment, and then he had gone back to work.

Now he sanded the wall and thought about the prayer and thought about the regime that had told him what America was and what Americans were and what the war was for and what the world required.

the regime that had handed him a blueprint and told him it was complete.

He had been a school teacher.

He had taught Latin and German literature.

He had taught boys to read texts carefully, to look for what the text actually said rather than what they expected it to say, to distrust the interpretation that arrived too easily.

He had believed in that discipline.

He had applied it in his classroom for 6 years.

He had not, he understood now, applied it to the blueprint.

He had accepted the blueprint the way his students accepted bad translations.

Not because it was accurate, but because it was authoritative, and authority had a way of substituting for accuracy when you were not paying the right kind of attention.

Warner sanded the wall in careful circles and did not make a speech about this, even internally.

He simply held it the way you hold a measurement that changes the scope of the work.

not with drama, but with the quiet acknowledgement of a man who intends to proceed accurately from this point forward.

Margaret Cole came to the fellowship hall on Wednesday.

She came most Wednesdays.

Wernern had learned this was her regular volunteer day, the day she cleaned the kitchen and prepared the fellowship hall for whatever the week required.

She moved through the space with the efficiency of long familiarity, knowing where everything was, doing what needed doing without consultation.

She stopped when she saw the wall.

The sanding was complete, and Wernern had applied the first coat of paint that morning, a clean white, slightly warmer than the original, the closest match Marsh had been able to find at the hardware store.

It had dried through the afternoon, and Warner was now assessing it for the second coat, standing back from the wall with the painters squint of someone reading a surface for what it still needs.

Margaret stood beside him and looked at the wall.

“It’s good,” she said.

It needs a second coat, Wernern said along the upper edge.

Yes, she said, but it’s good.

She looked at it for another moment.

Wernern had told Marsh about Robert Cole’s prayer being Margaret’s father-in-law, and Marsh had spoken to her.

Wernern did not know what had been said, only that Margaret had been quieter than usual on Thursday, and that she had taken a long time in Marsha’s office before emerging and returning to the kitchen with her face composed and her movements slightly more deliberate than their normal efficiency.

Now, she stood beside Wernern and looked at the wall that covered the place where her father-in-law’s prayer had been for 26 years.

Caleb told me where you found it, she said.

In the wall? Yes.

He would have put it there before the plaster went on.

She said he was on the building crew.

1918 before he shipped out.

She paused.

My husband never knew his father.

He was born in 1919.

After Wernner looked at the wall.

He prayed for them.

Margaret said the Germans.

Robert did.

Caleb showed me.

I know.

Wernern said.

I read it.

Margaret was quiet for a moment.

Then she said without accusation or sentiment in the same informational tone she used for everything.

I’m glad it was you that found it.

She went back to the kitchen.

Wernern stood in front of the wall for a long moment.

Then he picked up the brush and began the second coat.

Harold Biggs came on Thursday afternoon.

Wernern was on the exterior making a final inspection of the shingle work, going over each section from the ground with the methodical attention of someone signing their name to something.

He wanted to be certain before he left.

Not for Marsh, not for the congregation, for the work itself, which was its own standard, and did not negotiate.

Harold came around the side of the building and stopped in the yard.

He looked at the roof.

He stood with his hands in his pockets and looked at it the way he had looked at it on that first Thursday.

the same posture, the same unhurried assessment, the same quality of attention from a man who had built this fellowship hall with his hands 15 years ago and knew what he was looking at.

Wernern continued the inspection.

He moved along the yard, changing his angle, checking the line of the gutter, the profile of the flashing at the steeple junction, the edge alignment of the new shingles against the old.

He was aware of Harold in the yard behind him and did not adjust his movement for the awareness.

After several minutes, Harold spoke.

He did not look at Werner.

He kept his eyes on the roof.

It’s good work, he said.

For words, the same four words Wernern had anticipated since the moment Thomas had told him Harold had built this hall.

Not an apology, not a reclassification of Wernern from enemy to friend.

Simply the honest assessment of a man who knew good work when he saw it and had after 4 weeks decided that accuracy required him to say so.

Wernern looked at the roof.

Thank you, he said.

Harold nodded once.

He looked at the roof for another moment.

Then he walked back toward the main entrance without turning around.

Wernern watched him go.

He stood in the yard in the Thursday afternoon light and looked at the repaired roof, the new shingles running straight and tight, the gutter level, the flashing sealed, the steeple junction sound, and felt the particular completion of work done correctly.

Not pride, something quieter than pride, the satisfaction of a thing that would hold.

Friday was the last day.

Warner arrived at 7 and spent the morning on final details, touching up the paint along the upper edge of the fellowship hall wall, checking the interior trim he had reset around the repaired section, going over the storage room where he had staged his tools, and leaving it cleaner than he had found it.

His grandfather had been insistent on this.

You leave a place better than you found it, where you have not understood the work.

Thomas helped him carry the tools to the truck at midday.

They made two trips.

neither of them speaking much, the silence between them, the comfortable kind that had developed over four weeks of working alongside each other without requiring conversation to fill every space.

On the second trip, Thomas set his end of the toolbox in the truck bed and stood for a moment with his hand on the side of the truck.

“My father comes home in the spring,” he said.

“They think good,” Wernern said.

“He<il know did it.

” Wernern looked at the truck bed.

That is all right, he said.

The roof knows.

Thomas looked at him with the expression of someone filing a thing away.

Then he nodded and went back inside.

Reverend Marsh came out at 2:00 for the final inspection.

He walked the yard slowly, looking up at the roof from several angles, the same thoroughess he brought to everything.

He went inside and looked at the fellowship hall wall, standing back from it with his arms crossed, reading the surface.

He checked the trim.

He went into the storage room and looked around it.

He came back to the yard where Wernern was waiting.

“It’s exactly right,” Marsh said.

Wernern said nothing.

There was nothing to add to exactly right.

Marsh looked at him for a moment with the direct, unhurried attention that Wernern had come to understand was simply how this man looked at things he was taking seriously.

“I’d like to pray before you go,” Marsh said.

“If you’re willing.

” Wernern had not been inside the main church in 4 weeks.

He had worked beside it, heard it, smelled it, listened to its piano and its congregation through open windows.

He had not been inside it.

He looked at Marsh.

Yes, he said.

They went in through the side entrance.

The main church was empty at 2 in the afternoon, the pews in their long rows, the light coming through the stained glass in the way Wernner had seen from the roof on the first day, the colored pattern moving slowly on the floor as the light shifted.

The building smelled of candle wax and old wood and something else that Werner could not name.

The accumulated presence of years of people in the same space for the same purpose.

They stood at the front of the church, not at the altar, just inside the chancel rail, standing rather than kneeling.

Marsh bowed his head.

He prayed in the plain direct language Wernner had come to expect from him.

Not lurggical, not performed, simply a man speaking to something he trusted was listening.

He prayed for the work and for the building.

He prayed for Thomas’s father in France.

He prayed for Harold Biggs and for Robert Cole who had died in 1918 and for Margaret Cole’s husband who had never known his father.

Then he prayed for Werner, not for his captivity to end, not for Germany’s defeat or surrender.

He prayed for Wernern’s wife and for his daughter Latte, who was almost 3 years old and was asking where her father was.

He prayed that they were safe in Leipig and that Wernern would see them again.

He prayed for this in the same tone and with the same conviction as everything that preceded it, without qualification, without the careful diplomatic distance of a man praying for an enemy because protocol required it.

He prayed for them because he meant it.

Warner stood in the colored light of the empty church with his hands at his sides and his eyes open and listened to an American pastor pray for Margaretti and Latte by name in a Tennessee church on a Friday afternoon in August 1944.

He did not move.

He was thinking about the framework.

The blueprint that had told him what this country was, what these people were, what the war required, the blueprint that the regime had handed him, and that he had carried without examining it with the same rigor he had required of his students.

He reached into his breast pocket.

He took out the Rilka book.

He held it in his hands while Marsh finished the prayer, feeling the worn corners, the softened cover, the slight difference in the paper stock near the front where Margaretti had once pressed flowers when she was young.

When Marsh said, “Amen.

” Wernern opened the book not to read.

He turned to the inside front cover and looked at his name in Margaret’s handwriting.

Wernern in the bottom right corner written simply without speech.

He looked at it for a long moment.

Then he took the folded paper from his jacket pocket.

He had been carrying Robert Cole’s prayer since Marsh had shown him the wooden box, had asked to carry it for the final week, and Marsh had understood why without being told, and he placed it inside the front cover of the Rilka book beside his name in his wife’s handwriting.

two men who had gone to war, two pieces of paper, one framework that had told him the enemy had no soul, and one prayer written in 1918 by a man who had prayed for the souls on the other side of the line before walking into a war that would kill him.

Wernern closed the book.

He pressed it flat against his chest and held it there with his hand for a moment.

The way Margaret had held his hands on the platform in Leipig in September 1941 before his name was called.

Then he put it back in his breast pocket and walked out of the church into the Tennessee afternoon.

Jimmy Sutton was waiting by the truck with the engine running, his arm resting on the open window, looking at nothing in particular with the easy patience of a man at home in his own skin.

He glanced at Wernern as he came down the church steps and read something in his face that he did not comment on.

Because Jimmy Sutton understood, in the instinctive way of a decent man, when something had happened that was not his to name, he simply put the truck in gear.

Wernern climbed in and closed the door.

The truck pulled out of the yard and onto the main road heading north, past the diner and the hardware store and the post office and the water tower at the end of the street.

Wernern looked at the church once in the side mirror as they pulled away, the white clabbered, the simple steeple, the repaired roof catching the afternoon light.

Then the road curved and the church was gone.

He sat with his back against the slat wall and his hand pressed flat against his breast pocket and watched the tobacco fields go by in the late August light and did not look away from them because looking at them clearly without the blueprint telling him what they should mean was the first accurate thing he had done in a very long time.

The truck drove north through Tennessee.

Warner Hos looked at the fields and saw

« Prev