By that date, Minister Al- Muhedi had obtained Rosario Dela Cruz’s personal mobile number, given, as she would later document in the journal she kept at his direct and repeated request, in a context where declining felt, given the layered dynamics of her employment and his institutional position, less like an option than she knew it should have been.

He messaged her for the first time on October 19th, 2020, the day after his mother’s discharge.

The message read simply that he hoped she was well and that her dedication to his mother’s care had not gone unnoticed.

It was the first of what would eventually be several thousand messages.

And it was the beginning of an obsession that grew over the next 18 months in direct proportion to the growth of Rosario’s desire to end it.

Take a moment to consider what the term relationship means when one of its two participants has the structural power to determine whether the other is allowed to go home.

In the months following Shikaura’s discharge, Minister Al- Muhedi pursued Rosario Dela Cruz with a consistency and intensity that she initially received as flattering as the evidence of a serious man’s serious interest and that she eventually came to understand through a process of gradual and painful clarity was not romance but something that functioned more like ownership.

He sent gifts to the hospital, not to the nursing floor collectively, but specifically and personally to Rosario.

Perfume, jewelry, a Kashmir Abbya in deep green that arrived at the nurse’s station in a bag bearing the name of a boutique on the Gulf Road whose price points were approximately three times Rosario’s monthly salary.

She accepted some of these gifts.

She returned others.

The pattern of acceptance and return documented in recovered messages illustrated the internal conflict of a woman who understood increasingly that each accepted gift was a thread in a net being woven around her.

He took her to dinner in the private dining room of the Jamira Messula Beach Hotel, reached in his convoy of SUVs, attended by a discretion that was, she noted in her journal, the discretion of a man who had done this before.

He spoke to her about the future in terms that seemed to promise transformation.

That he would sponsor her family’s immigration status.

That he would ensure a significant financial settlement for her parents.

That he intended once certain domestic arrangements had been concluded to formalize their relationship.

He used the word marriage.

He used the word future.

He used these words with a precision that she wrote in her journal on February 12th, 2021 felt like a map whose coordinates she could not quite verify, but whose destination sounded exactly like what she had been working toward since she had first left Iloilo City.

She entered into a full intimate relationship with him sometime in early 2021.

This is documented in her journal, in recovered messages between herself and a close colleague and confidant, a fellow Filipino nurse named Analyza Santos, who worked on the hospital’s orthopedic floor, and in the DNA evidence that would later become the most important single piece of forensic material in the prosecution’s case.

What she did not know in the early months of 2021 was several critical things.

She did not know that at least two other women, one a Nepalese housekeeping supervisor who had previously worked in Almahedes household compound and one a Sri Lankan medical secretary employed at a clinic in which Al-Mui held an investment share had been incomparable arrangements with the minister in the preceding 5 years.

Both women had left Kuwait.

One of them, the medical secretary, had left abruptly in late 2019 under circumstances that her former colleagues described in testimony later gathered by Philippine embassy investigators as consistent with a sudden and pressure departure.

Her contract canled before its scheduled end date, her exit visa processed with unusual speed.

She did not know that the communication she was having with him were on his side, being managed from a phone registered to the name of a household employee, a prepaid instrument whose existence was entirely separate from any device that could be officially connected to the minister’s identity.

And she did not know that the promises he had made about formalizing their relationship were under Kuwaiti law and his existing domestic arrangements not promises he had any intention of keeping.

They were architecture.

They were the structure within which he was keeping her compliant and present for as long as he chose to need her.

By late 2021, Rosario had begun to understand this.

The messages in her journal from October and November of 2021 reflect a woman in the process of recalibrating.

not yet ready to leave, still hoping that the version of Minister Al- Muhadi she had first encountered was the real one, and the controlling, dismissive, periodically threatening version she was increasingly experiencing was something that could be resolved, but no longer entirely believing her own hope.

He had by this point begun intercepting her communications.

He had asked, and she had initially agreed to share her location via phone at all times.

He had contacted the hospital’s nursing director, not with threats, but with a casual exercise of institutional leverage, to request that Rosario not be assigned to overnight shifts that required her to be unreachable for extended periods.

He had arrived at her apartment building, a staff residential compound in Salmia, on two occasions without notice or invitation, at hours that her flatmates, two other Filipino nurses, found alarming.

When she raised these behaviors with him, his responses followed a consistent pattern.

Initial denial, then brief acknowledgement framed as concern rather than control.

Then a pivot to the promises, the land in Iloilo, the family sponsorship, the future he was building for her.

She had not yet reached the point of documenting her concerns formally because she still believed in a part of herself that the investigation would later illuminate as both profoundly human and profoundly dangerous, that she could resolve this within the relationship rather than by ending it.

This belief did not survive January of 2022.

On January 19th, 2022, Rosario Dela Cruz purchased a pregnancy test from a pharmacy on Tuna Street in Salmia.

She took it in the staff bathroom of the Alnor Medical Complex on the morning of January 20th at approximately 6:15 a.

m.

before the beginning of her day shift.

Her colleague and confidant, Analyza Santos, was with her.

She was pregnant.

She was in a foreign country on a work visa.

She was in a secret relationship with a married man whose cultural and legal context made the existence of that relationship, if publicly disclosed, catastrophic for her in ways that ranged from the professional to the criminal.

She was a Catholic woman from a provincial Filipino family who had built through years of sacrifice and discipline a professional reputation that was the single most durable asset she possessed.

And the father of the child she was carrying was a man who had in recent months made it increasingly clear that his promises about the future were instruments of management rather than genuine commitments and who had the institutional power to end her visa, cancel her contract, and have her removed from Kuwait on a timeline that would allow no appeal and generate no accountability.

She did not panic.

This is one of the most striking dimensions of what the evidence documents about Rosario Dela Cruz in the weeks between January 20th and her death in March of 2022.

She did not make impulsive decisions.

She did not immediately confront the minister.

She did not immediately contact the Philippine embassy.

She did not tell her mother.

What she did was begin with a methodical discipline that her nursing training had cultivated and that her situation now demanded absolutely to document everything.

She printed copies of her messages with the minister, all of them as far back as October of 2020 from the prepaid phone she had maintained for their communications.

She wrote a detailed account of the relationship’s full history in a letter addressed to her sister Jacqueline Dela Cruz in Iloilo City, which she sent by Cer on February 2nd, 2022.

Not a digital message, but a physical letter with printed photographs attached.

Sent by registered mail through a crier service to her sister’s address.

She gave a second copy of this letter in a sealed envelope to Analyza Santos with instructions that it be opened only if something happened to her.

She told Analyza Santos what she was planning.

She was going to inform Minister Alma Haiti of the pregnancy.

She was going to tell him that she intended to resign her position, return to the Philippines, and give birth to her child in Iloilo.

She was going to make clear that she expected no financial arrangements, no promises, no future, only his facilitation of her departure and his non-interference with her contract release and exit visa.

and she was going to make clear that she had documented everything, that copies of that documentation were in safe hands outside Kuwait, and that if any obstacle was placed in the path of her departure, those documents would be transmitted to the Philippine embassy, to the Kuwaiti public prosecutor’s office, and to two specific journalists, one at a Kuwaiti newspaper and one at a Manila based investigative publication, whose contact information she had already obtained and written down.

Analyza Santos would later testify that she had begged Rosario to go to the Philippine embassy first rather than to the minister.

Rosario had responded, according to Analyza’s testimony, that she had considered this, but that she owed the minister the directness of a conversation before she went anywhere else.

That this was, in her own phrase, the right order of things.

She sent Minister Al- Muhadi a message on February 28th, 2022 asking to meet him.

She told him she needed to discuss something important, that it could not be done by message, and that she preferred to meet somewhere private and within the hospital building, somewhere they were both known to have legitimate reasons to be.

He responded that he would arrange a meeting.

He told her he had a particular location in mind, the VIP rooftop terrace on the 29th floor, a restricted access area that was used for private functions associated with the hospital’s donor community, and that outside of scheduled events, was accessible only by credential.

He had access.

He told her he would provide her with a single-use access code for the door from the service stairwell.

He told her to come on the night of March 8th, 2022.

At 11:30 p.

m.

she went.

The Alnor Medical Complex’s VIP rooftop terrace was not by the standards of comparable facilities in Kuwait City an extraordinary space.

It was a paved platform approximately 40 m by 20 m bordered on three sides by a glass and steel railing system whose design specification, as a structural engineer would later testify in court, met the minimum safety standard for a non-public access area and nothing beyond it.

On the fourth side, the side facing northeast toward the Gulf, the railing transitioned into a lower parapet wall approximately 90 cm in height beyond which the rooftops he helipad occupied a raised platform itself railed but separated from the terrace by a step transition that placed it approximately 30 cm higher than the main terrace surface.

Below the helellipad’s northeast edge, the building’s service access platform, a concrete ledge approximately 3 meters wide, serving the mechanical systems housed at the building’s upper exterior, extended out from the building’s face before dropping vertically to the street below.

Rosario Dela Cruz, who had worked in this building for 4 years, had been on the VIP rooftop terrace once before during a hospital donor reception in December of 2021.

She knew what it looked like.

She knew its dimensions.

She knew where the edges were.

She arrived at the service stairwell door on the 28th floor at 11:26 p.

m.

on March 8th, 2022 and used the access code the minister had sent.

The door was logged as accessed at 11:26 and 33 seconds p.

m.

by the building’s access management system.

She climbed the single flight of service stairs to the rooftop level.

The rooftop access door was logged as opened at 11:27 and 11 seconds p.

m.

Minister Al- Muhadi was already there.

He had arrived via the main VIP elevator whose interior camera designated Alnor ELV VIP01 captured him at 11:19 and 42 seconds.

Dressed in a dark th and carrying nothing, he had used his own ministerial credential to access the rooftop terrace through the main access door.

At 11:20 and 7 seconds p.

m.

He was alone.

The rooftop terrace had three surveillance cameras.

Alnor roof 01 covering the main entrance and the eastern half of the terrace.

Elnor roof02 covering the helellipad approach and the northern parapet.

and Elnor roof03 covering the western side and the service stairwell door.

All three cameras were operational on the night of March 8th, 2022.

Minister Al- Muhadi knew the cameras were there.

He had, as a member of the hospital’s donor advisory board, attended at least three briefings in which the hospital security infrastructure had been discussed.

He had access through his institutional position at the hospital to information about the camera coverage configuration.

He had been on that rooftop before.

What happened next? What the cameras recorded over the 41 minutes between Rosario’s arrival at 11:27 p.

m.

and the moment her body was found on the service platform below at 12:14 a.

m.

constitutes the evidentiary core of this case and the factual record that the defense was never able to satisfactorily explain.

Camera Elnor Roof 03 covering the service stairwell entrance captured Rosario Dela Cruz emerging onto the rooftop terrace at 11:27 and 14 seconds a.

m.

She was wearing her nursing uniform, light blue scrubs with the hospital’s crest embroidered on the left chest.

And she was carrying a small crossbody bag, the same bag the investigation would confirm, in which she was carrying a printed copy of her documentation of the relationship and the message thread regarding the rooftop meeting.

Minister Al- Muhadi crossed the terrace toward her at 11:27 and 28 seconds.

As captured by camera Elnor Roof 01, the two of them stood in the center of the terrace, visible across two camera angles simultaneously for the first 4 minutes and 17 seconds of her time on the rooftop.

Then they moved they moved toward the northern edge toward the parapit section that bordered the helellipad approach toward the area where the railing was lowest and the drop beyond it was most accessible.

Camera Elnor roof 02 picked them up at 11:33 and 41 seconds PM standing near the northeast parapet.

The camera’s angle and resolution standard definition fixed position installed at a height of approximately 3 m captured their general movements without the facial detail resolution that the lower floor cameras installed in the renewed security infrastructure provided.

but it captured the relative positions of two people’s bodies, the distance between them, and the sequence of events that followed.

At 11:34 and 22 seconds p.

m.

, the camera recorded a sudden change in the relative position of both figures.

A sharp movement characterized by the NBI forensic video analyst as consistent with a physical confrontation.

At 11:34 and 29 seconds p.

m.

, one figure moved quickly toward the other.

At 11:34 and 31 seconds PM, the camera recorded a single fast sequence, arms extended, contact, a second figure’s body moving backward and over the parapet in a motion whose analysis the video forensics expert described in testimony with controlled and deliberate precision as a propulsion event involving applied external force rather than a voluntary movement.

Rosario Dela Cruz went over the parapet at 11:34 and 31 seconds.

Her body struck the service access platform below the building’s northeast face at 11:34 and 33 seconds p.

m.

2 seconds later, the fall, as calculated by the structural engineers testimony, was 22 m from the parapet to the service platform.

On the rooftop, camera roof 01 recorded Minister Al- Muhadi at 11:34 and 38 seconds.

7 seconds after the camera, Elnor roof02 recorded the parapet event.

He was standing near the northern edge.

He stood there without moving for 43 seconds.

The camera recorded him breathing, not running, not moving, not reaching for a phone, standing.

At 11:35 and 24 seconds p.

m.

, he walked back toward the main rooftop entrance, the VIP elevator access door, at a pace the forensic analysts described as controlled.

Camera Elnor roof 01 captured him exiting through that door at 11:35 and 41 seconds.

Camera Elnor ELV VIP01.

The VIP elevator interior captured him at 11:36 and 2 seconds PM.

Descending, he exited the building through the ground floor VIP lobby at 11:37 and 19 seconds.

As captured by camera Elnor, EXT VIP 02, he did not call emergency services.

He did not alert hospital security.

He did not attempt any communication related to the event until investigators would later establish 11:58 p.

m.

24 minutes after Rosario’s body had landed on the service platform when he sent a single message from his secondary prepaid phone to an unregistered number.

The content of that message was later recovered from the devices cloud backup.

It read, “Done.

Don’t contact me.

” He drove away from the Elnor Medical Complex at 11:38 p.

m.

Security camera Elnor EXT Park 04 captured his convoy of two black SUVs exiting the underground parking structure.

Rosario Dela Cruz’s body was discovered on the service access platform by a building maintenance technician, Domingo Fernandez, a Filipino OFW from Cebu, who had been dispatched to check an HVAC alarm on the building’s upper mechanical level at 12:09 a.

m.

He found her at 12:14 a.

m.

He called the hospital security emergency line immediately.

He stayed with her on that concrete ledge 22 m above the street until the security team arrived at 12:22 a.

m.

He later told the Philippine Embassy’s labor attach that he had held her hand.

The initial police report filed by the Alnor Medical Complex security chief at 107 a.

m.

on March 9th, 2022 recorded the incident as a suspected suicide.

a hospital employee found on an exterior service platform cause of death pending medical legal examination.

This classification was not unusual in the context of a foreign national found outside a building in the early hours of the morning.

It was however in this specific case catastrophically wrong and investigators with the criminal investigation directorate of the Kuwait Ministry of Interior would begin to understand this within hours.

The first indication came from the rooftop cameras.

The Alnor Medical Complex’s Security Operations Center had by protocol begun reviewing its overnight footage at 6:00 a.

m.

on March 9th as part of a standard morning audit.

The security operations supervisor, a Kuwaiti national named Taric Al- Shamari, who had held this role for 7 years and who, by his own account to investigators, had been prepared for a routine review, reached the rooftop camera footage at 6:47 a.

m.

and immediately stopped the review.

Continue reading….
« Prev Next »