Girl Vanished in 1991—Hunter Finds Her Living in a Burrow 28 Years Later.

…

They brought in a cadaavver dog from Lexington.

They talked to every resident within 10 miles.

Dennis Combmes didn’t leave the search area for the first 6 days.

A photograph of him ran in the Hazard Herald standing at the edge of the creek in a red hunting jacket.

And that photograph is one of the bleakest things I have ever seen.

The way a man looks when the world has removed something from him that he will spend the rest of his life trying to locate.

Melissa Anne Combmes was officially declared dead on October 3rd of 2001, exactly 10 years after she disappeared.

Dennis Combmes died of a heart attack in 2008.

Janet Comolmes, who had remarried and moved to Lexington, died of ovarian cancer in 2014.

Kevin Combmes was killed in a car accident on US68 in 2016.

Rhonda, the youngest, the six-year-old who had been sleeping beside Melissa when she vanished, was, as far as I knew, in November of 2019, living somewhere in Ohio.

I did not know any of this on the morning I found the burrow.

I didn’t put the pieces together for another 3 weeks.

What I knew when I set out that morning was that it was a Thursday.

It was 19° at dawn and I had the whole week off between my last survey job and Thanksgiving.

I had a deer tag that I hadn’t filled.

I had a thermos of coffee and a turkey sandwich in my dayack.

I had my rifle, a Remington 730 6 that I have carried on every deer season since 1992 when my father handed it to me and told me not to shoot until I could see the whites of their eyes.

And I had a general intention to work the backside of Sawmill Ridge, which I had not hunted in three seasons because I’d been focused on a different drainage that had been producing better sign.

I parked on a logging road off Stinit Branch Road at 5:45 in the morning and hiked in by headlamp.

The logging road petered out after about a mile and became a deer trail that I’d been using since I was a teenager.

a faint track through second growth hardwood that climbed the east face of Sawmill Ridge before dropping into the hollow on the far side.

The ground was frozen, which I was grateful for because it made for quiet walking once I got off the leaves and onto the mineral soil near the ridge crest.

There was no wind.

The sky was clear and full of stars in that particular way that Kentucky skies get in November.

hard and sharp, like the cold had sharpened the light the way it sharpens everything else.

I reached the ridge line at about 7:00, just as the first gray light was coming up in the east, and I worked my way north along the crest toward a saddle I’d always thought held potential.

A low spot between two knobs where deer tend to cross when they’re moving between bedding areas.

The ridge was familiar to me, same as always.

Same broken church underfoot.

Same scrubby cedars along the exposed spine of the hill.

Same view of the valley below when the canopy opened up.

I had walked this exact ground maybe a hundred times in my life.

But the backside of the ridge, the west-facing slope that dropped down into a narrow hollow before climbing again toward the next ridge over.

I hadn’t been on that slope in three seasons.

And what I noticed as I began working down it was that the deer sign was remarkably heavy.

Fresh rubs on saplings, a scrape under a cedar tree that was maybe 2 days old, tracks in the frozen mud along a seep where a spring was barely trickling.

Something was using this slope regularly.

I moved slowly, glassing the timber ahead of me, taking my time, letting the light build.

I had been on the slope for about 40 minutes, moving maybe a 100 yard below the crest when I smelled it.

The smell stopped me the way a physical obstacle would have.

I stood completely still with my rifle across my chest and my nostrils working, trying to identify what I was breathing.

It was organic, musky, dense, layered, the way a pile of wet hide smells.

But underneath that, there was something sweeter, almost herbaceious, like crushed plant matter mixed into the animal smell.

It reminded me of the den smell you get when you find a bear bed.

That closed, humid hibernation odor, except stronger.

And under all of it, faint but unmistakable wood smoke.

I’ve been in these woods my whole life.

I have smelled bear dens and coyote dens and bobcat scrapes.

I have smelled dead deer and dead cattle.

And once a dead man who had been in a hollow for 2 weeks before anyone found him.

The smell coming from somewhere below me and to my left did not match any of those things.

It matched nothing in my catalog.

I stood there for probably 5 minutes without moving.

The light was fully up by then, thin and flat through the bare hardwood canopy, and I could see 50 or 60 yards in most directions through the timber.

There was nothing moving, no sound except the distant tap of a woodpecker on a dead snag somewhere up the ridge.

Whatever I was smelling, it was close, within a 100 yard, maybe closer.

I worked downhill toward it, moving slowly and deliberately the way I move when I’m closing on a deer.

Setting each foot carefully, testing the ground before putting my weight down, keeping the wind in my face.

The slope steepened as I descended, and the timber changed from hardwood to a thick stand of hemlocks that created a darker, denser section of forest where the light barely reached.

The smell was stronger now.

underneath the hemlock boughs on the north-facing side of the slope.

The frost hadn’t melted, and the ground was pale and white, and my boots crunched softly with each step.

The rock shelf appeared through the hemlocks gradually.

The way large things in the forest reveal themselves when you’re moving through timber.

First as a change in the light, then as a shape, then as a specific thing.

It was a sandstone outcrop, maybe 15 ft high and 30 feet wide, that jutted from the hillside at a slight downward angle, creating a natural overhang at its base.

The overhang was deep, maybe 8 ft from the drip line to the back wall, and the floor of it was dry, packed earth, shielded from the weather by the rock above.

I’ve seen hundreds of outcroppings like it in these mountains.

Animals use them routinely.

I found bear beds and fox dens and raccoon latrines under outcroppings like this one.

What was different about this one was the opening at the base of the back wall where the rock met the earth.

Someone had dug, not an animal.

[clears throat] A person or something with the capacity for deliberate excavation.

The opening was roughly oval, maybe 2 and 1/2 ft high and 3 ft wide, and the earth that had been removed from it had been piled to one side in a way that suggested intention, not the random digging of an animal going after a grub or a root.

The edges of the opening had been reinforced, if that’s the right word, with flat stones set into the sides to keep the walls from collapsing.

Cedar boughs had been pushed into the entrance and arranged in a way that created a screen, not blocking the opening completely, but obscuring it so that from more than 30 ft away, it would have read as shadow rather than entrance.

There were other things under the overhang.

A fire ring, small and carefully made, the kind of fire ring you build when you want heat without much light.

Stones tightly fitted together.

The ash inside gray and old.

Next to the fire ring, a stack of firewood.

Oak splits about 12 in long.

The top pieces dry and fresh.

The bottom pieces mossy with age, which told me this was not a recent camp.

That someone had been tending this fire ring for years along the back wall just outside the entrance to the burrow.

A row of objects that I can only describe by listing them one by one because their combination was what undid me.

A plastic grocery bag, the kind from a Walmart or a Dollar General, knotted at the top.

A child’s sneaker, a girl sneaker, pink and white, size three, its laces long gone, but its soul still intact.

A bundle of dried plants tied with a strip of bark.

The kind of thing a person does when they understand the medicinal or practical properties of those plants.

Three flat riverstones arranged in a precise triangle.

Each one painted with red ochre in a pattern I didn’t recognize.

And a bone.

A long bone.

A deer femur by the look of it with notches cut into it at regular intervals in a series that might have been a tally or might have been something else entirely.

I stood at the edge of that overhang for a long time before I did anything else.

I am not an impulsive man.

One of the things 22 years underground teaches you is to assess before you act.

Because in a coal mine, the wrong movement at the wrong moment can end your life and the lives of the men beside you.

I stood there and I looked at everything I could see.

And I tried to build a picture of what I was dealing with.

My first instinct was a hermit.

There are men and women in these mountains who have chosen to live entirely off the grid.

Sometimes for reasons of mental illness, sometimes for reasons of legal trouble.

Sometimes simply because the world offers them nothing they want.

It’s not common, but it’s not unheard of.

The construction of that burrow was sophisticated enough to suggest a human mind.

The fire ring suggested a human need for warmth.

The organized objects along the back wall suggested a human tendency toward order and meaning.

But the sneaker, a child’s sneaker, pink and white, size three, sitting on the ground in front of a burrow entrance in a hollow that no casual hiker had ever found or would ever find.

That sneaker was what kept me from backing away.

I eased forward until I was at the edge of the overhang, maybe [clears throat] 10 ft from the burrow entrance.

I could hear something inside, very faint, a sound that resolved itself as my ears adjusted to the silence, into breathing.

Slow and steady and deep, the rhythm of sleep.

Whatever was inside that burrow was asleep.

I crouched down and looked at the entrance more carefully.

The cedar bow screen had a small gap at one corner and through that gap I could see a quality of darkness that was different from the darkness of the rock behind it.

A darkness that had warmth in it that moved slightly with each breath I was hearing and something else.

The faintest smell layered into the musk and the wood smoke that I recognized from somewhere I couldn’t immediately place.

Something human.

Something that belonged to a different register than the rest of the smells.

Clean and warm and milk sweet in the way of infants.

That last recognition went through me like cold water.

I stepped back from the entrance and I stood at the edge of the overhang and I thought about what to do for what felt like a long time.

The rational options were straightforward.

Leave, walk back up the ridge and drive to the Leslie County Sheriff’s Office and report what I’d found and let somebody else figure it out.

That was the sensible choice.

That was the choice that kept me out of whatever was about to happen.

I didn’t make the sensible choice.

I set my rifle against the rock wall of the overhang, well away from the burrow entrance, muzzle pointed up the slope.

I unslung my daypack and set it on the ground.

I took my hunting knife from its sheath on my belt and set that on top of the pack.

Then I crouched down about 6 ft from the entrance with nothing in my hands and I waited.

I waited for a long time, maybe 40 minutes.

The temperature dropped as the sun went behind clouds somewhere above the hemlock canopy, and the cold settled into the back of my knees where I was crouching and worked its way up my thighs.

I shifted my weight carefully to keep from making noise, and I watched the burrow entrance, and I listened to the slow breathing inside it.

At some point, the breathing changed.

It deepened first, then quickened slightly, and then there was a sound, low and quiet, that was not a word in any language, but that was unmistakably the sound a person makes when they first come awake.

That specific universal sound of consciousness returning to a body that hasn’t yet decided whether it’s safe to open its eyes.

Then silence.

Then a sound from inside the burrow that was different in quality, smaller, thinner, that resolved itself after a moment into the sound of a baby.

Not a crying baby, a waking baby making the soft exploratory sounds that infants make before they’ve decided whether they need anything.

That particular sound that is the most recognizable thing in the world if you’ve ever been around a newborn.

My youngest daughter made those sounds in the mornings when she was 3 months old.

I know that sound.

The cedar boughs at the entrance shifted.

She came out slowly, blinking in the thin November light.

She emerged head first on her hands and knees and then straightened up once she was clear of the entrance, unfolding herself to her full height, which I estimated at 5’3 or 5’4.

She was wearing what I can only describe as constructed clothing, not sewn in any conventional sense, but assembled from materials she had gathered and worked.

There were deer hides, tanned to softness, layered and wrapped and secured with strips of senue or twisted plant fiber.

There were sections of woven plant material, a coarse, effective weave integrated into the hides at the seams.

The whole of it was practical rather than decorative, built for warmth and coverage by someone who understood both the materials and the purpose.

Her hair was dark brown and hung loose to her waist, clean by the smell of it, but uncut since a time I couldn’t guess.

Her feet were covered in moccasins, hand constructed from hide with thick rawhide souls.

She was thin in the way of people who work hard and eat what the land provides.

not skeletal but lean.

All the softness stripped away, senue and bone and necessary muscle.

Her face was the face of a white woman, a Scots-Irish mountain face like half the faces in this county with dark eyes that were scanning the space in front of her with the particular attention of someone who has survived by being alert.

Every muscle in her face and body engaged in the act of reading her environment.

She saw me.

She stopped.

I did not move.

I did not speak.

I stayed where I was, crouched down, hands visible, no sudden motion.

She looked at me for a very long time.

I am going to try to describe that look accurately because I have thought about it every day for 5 years and I believe it is the most important thing I witnessed in that hollow.

There was no fear in her eyes.

Not the fear I expected.

the flight response, the animal terror of a human being who has lived wild encountering another person unexpectedly.

What was in her eyes was something more complicated and more controlled.

It was assessment, the same kind of careful, unemotional measurement that I use when I’m looking at a piece of timber and trying to figure out what it will do.

She was reading me with an expertise that came from a long history of reading the things that shared her world, deciding whether I was a threat or a neutral presence or something else.

While she was reading me, she pulled the bundle she had been carrying closer to her chest.

I had not fully registered the bundle when she emerged, but now I could see it clearly.

It was wrapped in hide, swaddled and secured in a way that was efficient and certain, the work of someone who had done it many times.

And inside it, moving slightly with the small seahorse flexing of a very young infant, was a baby.

She held it the way mothers hold babies that are so new they haven’t yet decided whether the world is safe.

One hand supporting the weight from below, the other curved around the back in a cradle.

And even from 8 ft away, even in the flat gray light of that November morning, I could see that the infant was not like any baby I had seen before.

It was large.

Not grotesqually, not alarmingly, but meaningfully large, the way a pup from a big working breed is noticeably different from a pup of a small one.

A structural difference.

A density of frame that registered even through the wrapping.

Its head, visible above the hide swaddling, was larger than I expected.

The brow heavy, the features broad and settled in a way that reminded me of something I couldn’t place in the first moment, and that placed itself in my memory with a cold, slow certainty in the moment after.

The infant’s hands, one of which was free and curled against the side of its face, were large knuckled, wide palmed, the fingers thick in a way that was not the soft baby thickness of a normal newborn, but the structural thickness of something built for different work than human hands are built for.

And its eyes, which were open, were a color that I have tried to describe to myself a dozen times since, and always settled on the same word, gold.

Not brown, not hazel, gold in the way of certain raptor eyes.

A warm layered functional gold that looked at the gray November sky above the overhang with an expression of total attention, as if it was already cataloging the world.

The woman and I looked at each other for what I believe was about 3 minutes without either of us making a sound.

The baby made the small sounds that babies make.

A crow called somewhere up the ridge.

The hemlock boughs shifted in a breath of wind.

Then she spoke.

Her voice when it came was rough with disuse, like a machine that hasn’t been run in a long time.

The mechanism still functional, but the surfaces needing wear before they smooth out again.

What she said was not a sentence.

It was two words and they were not spoken with confidence but with the careful enunciation of someone reaching for a language from a distance.

She said quiet and then she said please.

I have a daughter.

Her name is Leanne and she is 31 years old and lives in Corbin, Kentucky with her husband and my two grandchildren.

I have watched Leanne nurse both of those grandchildren.

I know the posture a woman takes when she is about to feed a child.

The particular adjustment of the arms and the shoulders, the way the body opens to the task.

The woman in front of me made that adjustment, shifting the baby in her arms, turning slightly away from me without turning enough to lose sight of me.

And I understood what she was about to do.

and I understood what she was asking me for when she said please.

I looked away.

I looked at the tree line above the overhang and I studied it with great attention while the sounds behind me told me that the baby had found what it needed and the woman was settled against the rock wall and the morning was continuing around us with the complete indifference of the natural world.

A pair of chickades worked the hemlock boughs above me.

The frozen leaves on the slope above crunched once as something small moved through them.

A mouse or a shrew.

The creek somewhere in the hollow below ran quietly over its stones.

I sat down on the cold ground.

I put my back against the rock wall of the overhang at a respectful distance from her and I stayed.

I need to talk about what that silence was like because it was not the silence I expected.

I had imagined in the fragmented way you imagine things when they’re happening faster than your mind can organize them that the situation would escalate.

That she would bolt or I would panic or something would interrupt the strange equilibrium we had somehow achieved.

What actually happened was the opposite.

The silence between us settled into something that felt gradually like a kind of peace.

Not the peace of two strangers who have nothing to say to each other.

The peace of two people who have both survived things that required them to learn how to be still.

After about 20 minutes, I reached into my daypack without making any sudden movement and took out my turkey sandwich.

I unwrapped half of it slowly, held it up where she could see it, and set it on the ground between us.

Then I ate the other half deliberately and without urgency.

She watched me for a long time.

Then she reached out with one hand and took the half I’d left.

She ate it in three bites efficiently with the concentration of someone who does not waste food.

When it was gone, she licked each finger once and then looked at me and said the word thank.

Not thank you, just thank.

as if the full phrase was in there somewhere, but she’d had to excavate it from a long way down and only got part of it to the surface.

I said, “You’re welcome.

” Her eyes moved over my face in a way that was almost a physical thing, reading each feature with the same systematic attention she’d used when she first emerged.

Then she looked at the thermos that was visible in the top of my pack, and she said a single syllable that was not quite a word.

an interrogative sound rising at the end.

I poured coffee into the thermos cap and set it on the ground between us.

She reached for it and wrapped both hands around it and brought it to her face and breathed the steam before she drank.

And the expression that crossed her face when she did that was the most human thing I had seen since I came down that slope.

a reflex of pleasure so involuntary and so familiar that it closed the distance between us in a way that nothing else had.

She drank the coffee in small sips slowly with great deliberate attention.

When she finished, she set the cap back down and looked at me.

I said, “My name is Earl.

” She didn’t respond immediately.

Her mouth worked slightly, as if she were turning the word over behind her teeth.

Then she said, “Liss.

” I said, “Liss.

” She said it again, clearer this time.

“Liss.

” A sound that could have been a name or the remnant of one.

The beginning of something longer worn down by years of disuse.

I didn’t push.

I sat with her for another 20 minutes.

The baby had gone to sleep again, and she held it with the absent unconscious security of a mother for whom that weight is as natural as breathing.

Before I left, I reached into my pack and took out the granola bar and the apple I had brought for the afternoon, and I set both of them on the ground beside the fire ring.

She watched me do this.

I stood up slowly and I picked up my rifle and I slung my pack and I looked at her one more time.

She was watching me with those dark assessing eyes.

The baby was a warm bundle against her chest.

The cold was settling in under the hemlock canopy and the light was beginning to thin toward midday gray.

I said, “I’m going to come back.

Is that all right?” She looked at me for a long time.

Then she nodded once.

The deliberate economical nod of someone who does not move without reason.

I walked back up the slope to the ridge line.

I stopped once about a 100 yards up and turned to look back down through the hemlocks.

The overhang was invisible from up here.

Just the gray face of the sandstone shelf merging with the shadows of the trees.

If you didn’t know what was under it, you would walk right past.

You would have walked past it for decades without knowing.

I drove home in silence.

I did not call anyone.

I sat in my truck in my driveway for a long time after the engine was off, looking at my hands on the steering wheel.

And then I went inside and I made a pot of coffee and I sat at my kitchen table and I tried to put together what I had seen.

The baby was not fully human.

I knew this in the way you know things that your rational mind resists but your animal recognition accepts without debate.

The size, the bone structure, the quality of the hands, the color of the eyes.

These were not the features of a human infant.

They were something else.

Something that bore a human overlay, the shape of a face, the proportions of a body, but built on a different foundation.

A foundation that was larger and denser and older than what I was used to.

The woman was human.

Of that, I was absolutely certain.

The language she reached for was English.

The face she wore was a mountain woman’s face.

The way she held that baby was the way every mother I had ever known held their babies.

I sat at my kitchen table and I thought about the child’s sneaker.

Pink and white, size three, and the date and the drainage and the name that was somewhere inside the word list if you let yourself hear it.

Melissa.

I didn’t sleep that night.

Over the following week, I did three things.

I went back to the overhang twice, each time bringing food and coffee, each time sitting with her for an hour or more in a silence that was becoming less cautious and more companionable.

I went to the Leslie County Public Library and I spent an afternoon in their newspaper archive looking at the Hazard Herald from October of 1991.

And I called my cousin Daryl, who had spent 24 years as a Kentucky state trooper before his retirement in 2017, and who I trust with my life and have trusted with my life since we were boys running these same ridges together.

The newspaper archive confirmed what I already feared.

Front page of the Hazard Herald, October 7th, 1991.

a photograph of a small girl with dark hair and dark eyes and a gaptothed smile wearing a purple fleece pullover.

The headline read, “Search continues for missing Perry County girl.

” The girl’s name was Melissa Anne Combmes.

The campsite had been on the Cutchin Creek drainage, less than 3 mi from the hollow where I had found the burrow.

She had been 9 years old in 1991.

She would be 37 years old in 2019.

The woman under the rock shelf with the hand constructed clothes and the remnant English and the infant that was not fully human was, I was now almost certain, a person who had been missing for 28 years.

A person the state of Kentucky had officially declared dead 18 years ago.

A person whose entire family, as I would discover in the weeks that followed, was gone.

Daryl came up from his house in Harlem on a Wednesday morning, 9 days after I found the burrow.

I had not told him on the phone anything more than that I had found something in the woods that required his eyes and his judgment.

Daryl knows me well enough to know that I do not use the word require lightly.

We drove as far as the logging road would take us and walked in from there.

Me in front with my pack and my rifle.

Daryl behind me in his hunting clothes, his face carrying the particular expression of a man who has seen a lot of unusual things in a long career and is prepared to see one more.

He is 59 years old and has bad hips and a mind like a steel trap.

And there is no one on this earth I trust more.

I told him everything as we walked.

The smell, the overhang, the objects along the wall, the woman, the baby.

I told him about the sneaker.

I told him about the newspaper archive.

I told him what I believed about the infant.

He walked behind me and listened without interrupting, which is one of the things I value most about him.

When I finished talking, there was a silence of about 100 yards of walking.

Then he said, “If this is what you think it is, Earl, we handle it exactly the way you’ve been handling it.

Slow and careful.

” I said, “That’s what I thought, too.

” He said, “And if she doesn’t want to be found, she doesn’t get found.

” I said, “That’s what I thought, too.

” We came down the slope through the hemlocks in the thin December light.

The temperature was in the mid20s, and the ground was iron hard underfoot, and our breath came out in clouds that dissolved into the cold air above us.

The smell hit Daryl about 50 yard from the outcrop, the same place it had hit me on the first morning.

I watched him stop and work it with his nose and say nothing and keep walking.

She was outside when we got there.

She was crouched by the fire ring, feeding a small, careful fire from the stack of oak splits along the wall.

She looked up when we emerged from the hemlock stand, and her body went still for a moment, the way a deer goes still with absolute stillness.

Not flight, but complete freeze while the assessment happened.

Then she saw me and something in her shoulders released by a degree.

I said, “This is Daryl.

He’s with me.

He’s safe.

” She looked at Daryl for a long time.

He stood where he was, hands in plain sight, no sudden movement, meeting her eyes with the calm, neutral expression of a man who has spent his career approaching frightened people in desperate situations.

Whatever she saw in his face, she accepted it.

She turned back to her fire.

The baby was inside the burrow, judging by the small sounds filtering through the cedar bow screen.

That first visit with Daryl lasted 2 hours.

During those two hours, she spoke more than she had in all my previous visits combined.

The language came in pieces, fragments that had been buried under 28 years of a different kind of communication and were now surfacing with the uneven startling quality of things that have been frozen and are thawing out.

single words first cold fire far then pairs of words come back stay here not afraid then toward the end the first complete sentence she spoke in my presence directed at Daryl who had asked her in a quiet voice if she was all right she said I am right I am where I am supposed to be the language kept coming back.

Not all at once and not without effort, but steadily over the weeks and months that followed.

Like a muscle that had atrophied, recovering its strength through use, Daryl and I fell into a pattern of visiting every 10 days or so through that first winter.

Always together, always bringing food, always staying for 2 hours or more, and letting the silence do as much work as the words.

She was never waiting for us, but she was never alarmed when we appeared.

She had a quality of acceptance about our visits that I eventually came to understand was not passivity, but accommodation.

She had decided we were safe, and she made room for us in the way she made room for everything else in her world, practically and without sentiment.

Her name was Melissa.

She confirmed this in late December, about 6 weeks after I first found her.

She said it the way you might say a word in a foreign language that you’ve recognized from its written form, but never heard spoken aloud with a slight uncertainty about the sounds, testing them against something internal.

“Melissa,” she said.

That was my name.

The past tense was deliberate and considered.

She was not denying the name.

She was placing it accurately in time.

She told me about the night she disappeared in pieces over the course of that first winter.

And I’m going to tell you what she told me.

But I want to be honest that what she gave me was not a narrative.

It was fragments.

Some of which connected clearly, others which existed in isolation, impressions more than memories.

The way very early childhood experiences live in adults, not as stories, but as sensations and images that carry emotional weight without complete context.

She remembered the sound that woke her.

She was clear about this, clear and specific in a way that suggested it had replayed in her mind for years.

A sound that came through the tent wall in the dark of that October night.

A rhythmic sound, she said.

not right, not like anything she had heard before.

She used the phrase not right repeatedly when she was trying to describe the sounds of those early encounters, which I took to mean a recognition that she was hearing something outside her prior category of experience.

A sound that was too large and too regular for any animal she knew and too patient for any animal she knew.

Something that was not in a hurry.

something that had decided to wait.

She remembered getting up.

She was specific about the fact that she was not afraid in the way she would have expected to be afraid, that the sound was not threatening in quality, that it was more like a pull than a push, the way certain music pulls you toward it without your deciding to move.

She unzipped the tent and went outside.

The fire had burned down to coals and the creek was a white noise in the dark and the stars were very bright.

She stood outside the tent in her bare feet on the cold gravel bar.

She remembered something large at the treeine, standing still at the edge of the dark where the forest began.

She could not see it clearly, only the shape of it, large and still and patient.

She remembered that it smelled of the woods, of deep woods, of the rich layer of decomposition and growth that accumulates under the canopy of old forest over many decades.

She remembered that it made a sound that was not the sound that had woken her, a lower sound, quieter, something that she would struggle for words to describe and that she eventually described as soft asking.

She said it was not frightening.

I believe her not because it makes me comfortable to believe her, but because the specific character of her description, the absence of fear, the sense of being drawn rather than compelled is consistent in every account she gave me of that night.

Whatever happened on that gravel bar in the dark of October 3rd, 1991, the 9-year-old girl who walked away from it walked freely.

She remembered the woods.

She remembered walking into the trees, following the shape ahead of her through timber that should have been impossible to navigate in darkness, but that the shape ahead of her moved through with a certainty that she followed instinctively, like following a current.

She remembered cold.

She remembered stumbling once on a route and being caught.

a hand that was much larger than a human hand closing around her forearm, steadying her without gripping, setting her back on her feet and releasing.

She remembered the smell again, very close then, overwhelming and somehow reassuring in its density, like being wrapped in something.

After that, the memories became less sequential.

There was warmth.

There was darkness that was not frightening.

There was the smell of the burrow, which was the smell she had been breathing in for 28 years, and which she could no longer separate from the smell of safety.

There was food, meat, berries, things she didn’t have names for, but that kept her alive through the first weeks.

While the cold deepened around her, and the world she had come from searched for her three miles away without finding her, there was the one who had brought her.

She called her mama.

She used this word without any apparent awareness that it needed context.

When she first said it, I thought she was talking about Janet Comolmes.

And then I understood that she was not.

And the understanding went through me with the particular chill of a revelation that confirms a fear you’d already halfformed.

I asked her to describe Mama.

She did so with the patient, detailed attention she gave to every concrete thing in her world.

Tall, she said, very tall, bigger than any person she had seen.

Hair that was dark and thick all over.

Hands that could carry things that would take three men to move.

A face that was broad and heavy.

And that Melissa had over time learned to read the way she read the faces of people, the way certain muscles around the eyes and mouth moved, the expressions they made, what those expressions meant.

She said the face was not frightening once you knew how to read it.

She said the eyes were dark, very dark, and that they were always watching with a quality of attention that she had never felt from any human and that had taken her years to understand was not surveillance, but care.

A particular form of concentrated, undemanding care.

I asked her if mama had ever heard her.

She looked at me as if I had asked whether water was wet.

No, she said.

Mama kept her safe.

Mama kept her warm.

Mama fed her and taught her where to find food and how to read the weather and how to move through the woods without sound.

Mama had a language, not English, nothing like English.

a system of sounds and gestures and postures that Melissa had absorbed the way a child absorbs language through immersion and repetition and context until it became as natural as the English that was slowly becoming less natural.

I asked her if she had understood at some point that she could leave that there were people who had been looking for her.

She was quiet for a long time.

Then she said, “I knew.

” She paused.

I knew there were people.

She paused again.

But people were there and mama was here.

I didn’t push further.

There are some answers that are complete in themselves.

The infant’s father was not something she volunteered and not something I asked about directly.

Not in the first months.

What she did tell me in the natural course of those winter conversations was that she was not alone in the hollow.

that there were others, that Mama was one of a family, a small family, fewer than she could count on one hand, that ranged through the ridges and hollows of a territory that she understood to be large, that she had walked with them through most of it over the years, that she knew it as well as she knew herself.

She said there was a male.

She described him as younger than Mama and very different in character, more cautious, less certain of human beings, but not aggressive.

She used the word shy, which she followed immediately with a small sound that I recognized after a moment as a laugh.

A quiet, rusty, seldom used laugh, but unmistakably a laugh.

“He’s shy,” she said.

And then she made the sound again.

I thought about what that meant.

I thought about the infant with the gold eyes and the broad hands sleeping in the burrow behind her.

I thought about Shai.

I said, “Does mama know we come here?” She said, “Yes.

” I said, “Does she mind?” Melissa thought about this for a moment in the careful, unhurried way she thought about everything.

Then she said she watched you the first time.

Both times she sat on the ridge and she watched.

I looked up at the ridge above the hemlock stand.

I thought about the hours I had spent under that overhang.

I thought about how thoroughly I had scanned that slope for deer sign and for any movement that might represent a thread.

I had seen nothing.

Whatever had been on that ridge watching me had been as invisible to me as the burrow entrance had been until I was standing in front of it.

I said, “What did she decide?” Melissa said, “She decided you were like my father.

” She paused.

She said it like she was translating something, reaching for the closest English approximation of a concept that didn’t translate exactly.

She said it the way you translate a word from another language that doesn’t have a direct equivalent with a slight apology for the gap between the original and the rendering.

Like my father, she said again, not afraid of what he doesn’t understand.

Dennis Combmes, the man in the red hunting jacket standing at the edge of the creek, the bleakest photograph I had ever seen.

I thought about that for the rest of that visit and for many days afterward.

By February of 2020, I had worked out most of what I believe to be the shape of the thing.

[clears throat] I want to be precise about what I mean by believe and shape because I am not a man who claims certainty about things he cannot verify.

And there are aspects of this story that I cannot verify and that I am relying on the testimony of a woman who spent 28 years in conditions that would have broken most people in a month.

But her account was consistent across multiple conversations.

It had the texture of lived experience rather than invention.

And it was internally coherent in ways that I think would be very difficult to manufacture.

What I believe happened is this.

A family of creatures that this country has been arguing about the existence of for a 100red years has been living in the deep hollows of the hill system that runs through the eastern end of Leslie County for at least as long as anyone in the county can remember, which is to say several generations.

They are not numerous, they are careful.

They have survived by being invisible in terrain that makes invisibility possible for something with the right instincts and the right knowledge of the land.

The hills of eastern Kentucky and specifically the country around the headarters of Kutchen Creek and its tributaries are as remote and as little traveled as any country east of the Mississippi.

There are hollows back in there that no human foot has entered in living memory.

There are ridges that are on no trail and no maintained road and that would require a full day’s hard travel to reach from the nearest point of vehicle access.

In country like that, invisibility is not a magic trick.

It is a discipline and one that can be maintained indefinitely by something that has been practicing it for a very long time.

The creature Melissa called Mama had lost an infant.

Melissa did not know the details of this and could not give them to me.

But she knew the fact of it.

Knew it from the quality of Mama’s attention toward her in those early weeks.

A griefshaped tenderness, she said when she was reaching for words for it.

The infant she lost had been recent.

Recent enough that the physical fact of the loss was still present when she found Melissa on that gravel bar.

I do not think the finding was accidental.

I think something that has lived in those mountains for its entire life.

Something that can move through timber in absolute darkness without making a sound.

Something that can sit on a ridge for hours without being detected by a reasonably skilled hunter sitting directly below.

Can find a 9-year-old girl on a gravel bar beside a creek.

I think the finding was deliberate.

I think Melissa is right that she was not frightened.

And I think she is right about why.

I think what came to the edge of those trees that night came with a gentleness that was specific and intentional.

Because whatever she was, she knew what a child was, and she knew what she needed one to do.

She kept her.

She raised her.

She taught her everything she knew about living in the deep country of those mountains, which turns out to be a great deal.

Melissa can build a fire in wet conditions in under 3 minutes.

She can identify and prepare every edible plant in Eastern Kentucky.

She can track and take deer without a firearm, using methods that I will not describe in detail, but that rely on patience and knowledge of terrain that most hunters spend their whole lives trying to develop and few fully achieve.

She can read weather from cloud formation, wind direction, bark growth patterns, and animal behavior with an accuracy that is better than most forecasting services.

She is in the practical terms of surviving in a harsh landscape one of the most capable people I have ever encountered.

She is also and I say this because I want to be honest about all of it.

A person who spent the years between 9 and 37 without a written language, without sustained contact with other human beings, without the social structures and the accumulated knowledge and the identity documents and the continuous experience that we use to construct what we call a self.

The language is coming back.

It has been coming back steadily for 5 years.

And she uses it now with increasing fluency and ease.

But there are concepts in human life that do not have equivalence in the world she built under those hemlocks.

And when she encounters them, she looks at me with a particular expression that I have come to recognize as the expression of a person who understands that a gap exists without being able to see across it.

The baby’s name is Reed.

She named him in January, about 6 weeks after I found the burrow.

And she told me the name without explanation.

Matter of factly, the way you tell someone a fact that is simply true.

Read.

I asked her how she chose it and she said it was his grandmother’s name.

She said grandmother in the way she says certain words with a slight searching quality, reaching for the human word for a concept she already has in the other language.

His grandmother.

Mama.

Reed is by every measurement I can apply without medical equipment.

Growing faster than a human infant of his age, he was alert in ways that I have never seen in an infant this young.

He tracked my movement from the time he was 6 weeks old.

following my face with those gold eyes with the deliberate attention of something considerably older.

His grip, which Melissa tested with her own finger and then offered to me when Reed was about 8 weeks old, sitting in my palm with my finger extended, closed around it with a force that I would describe as uncomfortable.

Not painful, not yet, but firm in a way that no 8-week old human baby is firm.

He does not cry the way a human infant cries.

He makes sounds, communicative sounds, sounds that Melissa responds to with the automatic fluency of a parent who knows every register of her child’s voice.

But the distress cry that is the defining sound of human infancy.

That particular escalating cry that is designed to be impossible to ignore, Reed does not make.

He makes lower sounds, deeper sounds.

Sounds that when he makes them in the burrow and they carry out through the cedar boughs and across the still air of the hollow, remind me of something I heard once at the edge of a deep hollow in the dark of a September night 20 years ago.

A sound I attributed at the time to an animal I couldn’t identify and then forgot about.

The way you forget things that don’t have a category.

Mama died in the spring of 2020.

April, Melissa said she knew it was April because she counts the months on the notched bone I had seen on my first visit, which she has been marking since she was old enough to understand the year as a unit.

She did not describe the death to me, and I did not ask.

What she said was that she had been sick for a long time, over a year, and that she died in a place she had chosen, a place Melissa knew and had visited, a deep crack in the limestone face of a ridge about 2 mi from the burrow.

She said it the way you say a thing that is simply true and that has been accepted.

She is gone, she said.

She is in the rock.

I sat with that for a while.

The silence in the hollow was complete.

Even Reed was quiet in his swaddling.

I said, “I’m sorry.

” Melissa said she lived a long time.

She said she saw many things.

She paused.

She saw me grow up.

She said this with a quality that was not sadness exactly, but of fullness, the way a vessel sounds when it is full of something rather than empty.

The others, the male and the one other that Melissa described as younger and female, and who she said kept away from the burrow more than the male did, were still out there.

She was clear about this.

They were still in the territory.

She saw the male regularly, she said, in the way of family members who live close but separately, a passing in the trees, a sound at the edge of the hollow in the evening, the clear communication that someone she knew was nearby.

He had accepted Reed in the way that Melissa had described Mama’s acceptance of her practically and without elaboration.

and he came sometimes in the evenings to the edge of the hemlock stand and she would go out to him and they would sit together for a time and then he would go back into the dark of the timber.

I thought about what it meant that Reed existed.

I thought about it carefully the way I think about timber assessment methodically from the evidence outward.

A human woman and something that was not human had produced a child.

That child was alive and healthy and growing at a rate that suggested vigor rather than weakness.

A combination of two inheritances that had apparently not canceled each other out, but added to each other.

The way hybrid plants sometimes display what biologists call heterosis, exceeding both parent strains.

Reed was going to be large.

Reed was going to be strong.

Reed had those gold eyes that watched the world with the focused, unblinking attention of something that was going to spend its life navigating a space between categories.

In the summer of 2020, during a visit in which the heat had broken into something manageable, and we sat outside the overhang in the shade with our backs against the rock, Melissa asked me about the world.

Continue reading….
Next »