By 1892, the Morgan ranch was a prosperous, well-managed operation that was known in Colfax County as one of the solid, reputable places in the region.

Elias was 12 and Clara Ruth was 10 and the house had been added to a second time and the bunkhouse had good permanent hands in it and there was a small, genuinely good vegetable garden behind the house that Susanna kept with the same systematic care she gave to everything.

And there were chickens and a milk cow and a pair of dogs that had earned their positions through genuine usefulness and charm.

Hector Reyes, by this point, had bought a small piece of land adjoining the Morgan property and built himself a modest house on it and he remained the most reliable person in Frederick’s professional orbit, the person whose judgment Frederick trusted absolutely on land and cattle questions and whose steady, quiet presence had been part of the Morgan ranch for going on 18 years.

He was a man the community respected deeply, a fact that had not always been guaranteed given the era and the territory’s complicated relationship with Mexican-born residents, but that had been established through consistent demonstration of character and competence.

And Frederick had been openly vocal in his support of Hector’s standing in the county ranching cooperative, which was the kind of advocacy that mattered.

On a September evening in 1892, Susanna and Frederick sat on the porch in the early darkness with their coffee, the children having gone inside an hour earlier.

The valley was settling into fall, the aspens on the upper slopes visible from the ranch in their gold turning and there was wood smoke on the air from someone’s chimney and the smell of the dry grass and the river, which was their particular mixture, the smell that Susanna had come to know as the smell of home.

“I was thinking today,” she said, “about that moment on the porch in Cimarron, the November night.

” “I think about it regularly,” he said.

This was not surprising, she knew he did.

“What do you think about when you think about it?” she asked.

He was quiet for a moment, but the quiet was not the closed, uncertain quiet of the early days.

It was a thinking quiet, a composing quiet.

“I think about what it cost to wait so long,” he said, “and what it cost to finally say it and how those costs were completely different.

The waiting cost more.

” “Yes,” she said.

“And I think about how I said it twice,” he said, “and there was something in the way he said this, something that had in it both memory and a kind of irreversible gratitude.

I said it twice and both times it was true and both times saying it added to the truth of it rather than diminishing it.

I had believed for a long time that saying it would be the smaller version of feeling it.

I was wrong.

” “You were wrong,” she agreed warmly.

“It happens occasionally,” he said, which made her smile.

He reached over and took her hand and she leaned her head briefly against his shoulder before straightening to look at the valley, which was theirs and yet larger than theirs, this wide piece of the American West in the last decade of a century that had been the most dramatic and complicated and consequential century this land had ever known.

There was still so much that was unresolved in the territory and in the country, still injustices being done and questions being fought over and the hard, slow work of building something just and lasting still very much in progress.

But here in this valley on this evening, there was the irreducible fact of two people who had found each other and stayed, who had built something real together out of the materials available, out of courage eventually applied and honesty maintained and a feeling that had grown from something tentative and uncertain into something as substantial and durable as the red rock that rimmed their valley.

Susanna Fletcher Morgan held her husband’s hand in the autumn dark and felt the full, certain weight of her life, which was good, not simple, not without cost, not easy in all its parts, but good, deeply and genuinely good in the way that things are good when they are built rather than inherited, when they are chosen fully and lived in honestly, and when the word that makes everything possible, the word that had once been locked away behind 32 years of cautious silence, had finally, at the best necessary moment, been said out loud, twice, and many thousands of times after that in every season of the years that followed, in every quiet morning and long evening and difficult passage and moment of uncomplicated joy that made up the whole of the life they built together in that valley in the territory of New Mexico in the last vivid decades of the American West that was becoming something else, something that would remember what it had been even as it changed, the way people do, the way everything worth loving does.

He said it.

He had said it twice on that first night and he said it every day after and she said it back and between them it was the truest currency they had, the thing that bought everything worth having.

« Prev