And did you leave him to die? Jake’s voice was barely a whisper.

I had to choose.

If I stayed, I’d be court marshaled or killed by the Confederates we were chasing.

I thought someone else would help him.

I thought he’d live.

I was wrong.

The cabin was silent.

Takakota stared at him.

Asha stared at him.

Sarah’s hand was on her knife.

“You let him die,” Asha said.

“I tried to save him, but you left.

” “Yes.

” Asha’s hands clenched into fists.

You chose your life over his “I chose wrong,” Jake said.

“I’ve lived with that for 16 years.

You think I don’t see his face every night? Then why didn’t you tell us? Would you have stayed if you knew?” Asha opened her mouth, closed it.

No answer.

Takakota stood up.

She was shaking.

She walked toward Jake.

For a moment, he thought she was going to hit him or spit on him or scream.

Instead, she placed her hand on his chest right over his heart.

You tried to save him, she said quietly.

I saw you.

You were crying while you bandaged him.

You didn’t want to leave.

Jake’s throat tightened.

My husband was not a brave man, Dakota continued.

He ran from fights.

He hid when the soldiers came.

He would have done the same thing you did.

He would have chosen life.

I can’t hate you for making the choice he would have made.

She stepped back.

But I can’t forgive you either, she said.

Not yet.

Then she turned and walked back to the bed, lay down beside Kai, closed her eyes.

Asha was still staring at Jake.

Her face was unreadable.

I need air,” she said.

She walked to the door, pulled on Jake’s coat, and stepped outside into the storm.

Jake followed.

The cold hit him like a wall.

The wind tore at his clothes.

Snow blinded him.

But he could see Asha standing 20 ft away, arms wrapped around herself.

“You don’t get to run from this,” she said without turning around.

“I’m not running.

I’m giving you space.

” She spun to face him.

I don’t want space.

I want answers.

Why did you save Kai? You owe us nothing.

Because I couldn’t save my son, Jake said.

Or your brother-in-law.

But I could save that boy.

Asha’s face crumpled.

She started to cry.

Not soft tears, hardwrenching sobs.

You don’t understand, she said.

Everyone I touch dies or suffers.

What do you mean? She looked at him with red eyes.

Do you want to know why I’m pregnant? Do you want to know who the father is? Jake waited.

Sergeant Lucas Brennan, Fort Apache, 6 months ago, spring of 1882.

I was working as a translator.

He cornered me in the supply room, held a knife to my throat, and he took what he wanted.

Jake felt something break inside him.

I’m carrying his child, Asha continued.

A child I didn’t ask for.

A child I don’t want.

a child my people want to kill because it’s half white.

I ran because if I stayed they’d murder it and me.

Her voice dropped to a whisper.

I hate this baby, she said.

Every time it moves, I feel sick.

Every time I think about it, I want to scream, but I can’t get rid of it, and I can’t love it.

So, what am I supposed to do? Jake stepped forward slowly, carefully, like approaching a wounded animal.

It’s not your fault, he said.

None of this is.

How can you say that? You don’t even know me.

I know enough.

He reached out and pulled her into his arms.

She fought for a second.

Then she collapsed against him and sobbed into his chest.

They stood like that in the storm.

Two broken people holding each other up.

When they finally went back inside, Sarah was waiting by the door.

She looked at Asha’s tear stained face.

Looked at Jake.

If you hurt her, Sarah said quietly, I’ll kill you.

I know, Jake said.

Before dawn, Kai slipped out of bed.

He patted across the floor while everyone else was still sleeping.

He was observant, curious.

He found the old trunk under Jake’s bed.

It wasn’t locked, just latched.

Kai opened it carefully, trying not to make noise.

Inside were folded clothes, a few letters, a worn Bible, and a leather journal.

Kai pulled out the journal, opened it.

The words were in English.

He could read some of it now, but there were also drawings, sketches of places, of people, of battles.

And then he found it.

A drawing of a man, a patchy, lying on the ground, blood on his chest.

Another man kneeling beside him, wrapping bandages around the wound.

The kneeling man’s face was turned away, but Kai could see his hands.

The same hands that had pulled him out of the snow.

Kai looked closer at the wounded man, at the necklace around his neck, a bone carving of a hawk.

Kai knew that necklace.

He’d seen it in the box his mother kept hidden under her blankets.

The box she cried over when she thought no one was watching.

This was his father.

Jake had tried to save him, but Jake had also left him.

Kai closed the journal carefully.

He looked at Jake asleep in the chair, looked at his mother curled up near Asha, looked at the journal in his hands.

He didn’t know what to feel, so he hid the journal under his blanket.

He’d think about it later.

But as he lay there pretending to sleep, one thought kept circling in his mind.

If Jake tried to save his father, why did his father die? And if Jake felt so guilty, why did it take 16 years for him to try to make it right? Kai didn’t have answers, but he was starting to have questions.

Outside, the storm began to ease.

The wind died down.

The snow stopped falling.

By noon, the sun broke through the clouds for the first time in a week.

The world was white and silent and new.

Asha stood by the window looking out.

“The storm’s over,” she said.

Jake nodded.

“It is, so we should go.

” “You could.

” “But Jake met her eyes.

” “But I think you should stay.

” “Why?” “Because leaving now won’t solve anything.

Garrett’s still out there.

Brennan’s still out there.

And winter’s just getting started.

You need a place to heal, to rest, to figure out what comes next.

” Asha looked at Takakota, at Kai, at Sarah.

What do you think? She asked them.

Sarah shrugged.

I think he’s right, but I don’t have to like it.

Takakota spoke softly.

I think my son is safe here for now.

Kai said nothing.

He just watched Jake with those dark, thoughtful eyes.

Asha turned back to Jake.

If we stay, we pull our weight.

We’re not charity.

Fair enough.

And if trouble comes, you let us fight.

I wouldn’t dream of stopping you.

Asha held out her hand.

Jake shook it.

Then we stay, she said.

Until spring, Jake nodded.

Until spring.

But both of them knew it was a lie.

Spring was a long way off, and a lot could happen before then.

Three more days passed.

The snow kept falling.

Not the violent blizzard that had trapped them before, but steady and relentless.

The kind of snow that buried everything slowly that made the world smaller that forced people to live in close quarters whether they wanted to or not.

Inside the cabin they found a rhythm.

Jake woke first always before dawn.

He’d build up the fire, put coffee on to boil, and step outside to check on Flint and break the ice in the water trough.

The cold didn’t bother him anymore.

He’d learned to live with it the same way he’d learned to live with guilt.

as a constant companion.

By the time he came back inside, Asha would be up.

She’d take over the cooking without a word.

She was efficient, careful.

She made meals stretch further than Jake thought possible.

A handful of beans became soup for five.

Stale bread became something almost worth eating.

Sarah helped with the heavy work, hauling wood, pumping water.

She still didn’t talk much, but she’d stopped watching Jake like he was about to attack.

That was progress.

Takakota spent most of her time with Kai, teaching him things in Apache, braiding grass into small figures, humming songs that had no words.

But she also watched Jake, not with suspicion, with something else.

Curiosity maybe or recognition.

and Kai.

Kai was everywhere asking questions in increasingly fluent English, picking up tools and trying to figure out how they worked, following Jake around like a shadow.

One afternoon, Jake was repairing a broken chair leg.

Kai sat on the floor beside him, watching.

“Why you fix?” Kai asked.

Jake looked at him.

The youth’s English was getting better every day.

“Because it’s broken,” Jake said.

“Why not new chair? Can’t afford a new chair.

And this one’s still good.

Just needs some work.

Kai thought about that.

Like people.

Jake stopped working, met the boy’s eyes.

Yeah, like people.

Kai nodded.

He picked up a small piece of wood and turned it over in his hands.

You fix people.

I try.

You fix me.

You weren’t broken.

You were just cold.

My mother broken.

Jake set down his tools.

Your mother’s been through a lot, but she’s strong.

She’s not broken, just hurt.

Can you fix hurt? Jake didn’t have an answer for that.

That evening, after supper, Asha pulled one of Jake’s books from the shelf, the same one she’d read from before.

She sat at the table and opened it.

“Do you mind?” she asked.

“No.

” She read aloud.

Her voice filled the cabin.

The words were about exile, about trying to find purpose after everything you knew was gone, about whether redemption was even possible.

Jake listened.

So did Takakota.

Even Sarah stopped mending and paid attention.

When Asha finished the passage, she closed the book.

“Your wife had good taste,” she said.

“She did.

” “Did she like living out here?” Jake shook his head.

She hated it.

The isolation, the cold, the constant work, but she did it anyway.

Why? Because I asked her to.

Asha looked at him for a long moment.

That must have been hard for her.

It was.

Do you regret it? Jake was quiet.

Every day.

Asha nodded.

She understood regret.

The fourth night brought the nightmare.

It was past midnight.

Everyone was asleep except Jake, who sat in his chair by the fire.

He couldn’t sleep.

Hadn’t been able to for years.

So he just sat and watched the flames and tried not to think too much.

Then Takakota screamed.

The sound ripped through the cabin like a blade.

Jake was on his feet instantly.

He crossed the room and dropped to his knees beside the bed.

Takakota was sitting up, eyes wide, mouth open, screaming like her soul was being torn out.

Her hands clawed at the blankets.

Her whole body shook.

Kai woke up.

Asha grabbed him and held him close.

Sarah was against the wall knife already in her hand.

Jake reached out slowly.

Takakota, it’s all right.

You’re safe.

She didn’t hear him.

She screamed again.

Jake touched her shoulder gently.

You’re in the cabin.

You’re with Kai.

You’re safe.

Takakota’s eyes focused.

She saw Jake.

Saw the cabin.

Saw Kai in Asha’s arms.

And then she spoke.

Her voice was rough, unused, like something rusty finally breaking free.

“Maka,” she whispered.

Asha’s eyes went wide.

“Sister, you spoke.

” Takakota’s face crumpled.

Tears poured down her cheeks.

“I saw him die.

I see it every night.

Over and over.

” Asha sat Kai down and moved to the bed.

She took Dakota’s hands.

You haven’t spoken since it happened.

I couldn’t.

Takakota’s voice broke.

Every time I tried, the words got stuck.

All I could see was the blood, the soldiers, his face.

But you can speak now, Takakota looked at Jake.

Her eyes were raw.

Because he’s here.

Jake felt his stomach drop.

What do you mean? Asha asked.

Takakota’s hands trembled.

Canyon Delli, 1866.

I was hiding in the rocks with the other women and children.

The soldiers came through chasing the warriors.

There was shooting, screaming.

Maka was hit.

He went down.

Her voice steadied like she’d been waiting 16 years to tell this story.

I watched a soldier run to him, a young man.

He pulled Macau behind a boulder, started wrapping his wound.

He was crying while he did it.

I remember that he was crying.

Jake closed his eyes.

Then the other soldiers started pulling back.

Takakota continued.

An officer was yelling, ordering everyone to retreat.

The young soldier looked at Maka, looked at the others leaving.

He didn’t want to go.

I could see it on his face.

“What happened?” Asha asked quietly.

The officer yelled his name.

“Morrison,” he said.

“Morrison, we’re pulling out.

If you don’t come now, you stay forever.

” Jake’s real name, the one he’d left behind when he came west.

The soldier looked at Maka one more time.

Takakota said.

Then he ran.

He left my husband there bleeding alone.

Maka died an hour later.

I held him while he went.

The cabin was silent except for the fire crackling.

Asha turned to Jake.

Her face was pale.

Morrison.

That’s you.

It wasn’t a question.

Jake nodded.

You were at Canyon Delli.

Yes.

You tried to save her husband.

Yes.

And you left him to die.

Jake’s voice came out horsearo.

I didn’t have a choice.

“Everyone has a choice,” Sarah said from the wall.

Jake looked at her.

“You’re right.

I chose to live.

I chose to follow orders.

I chose wrong.

” Asha stood up, her fists clenched.

“You’ve been here all this time.

You saved Kai.

You let us stay.

And you never said anything.

Would you have stayed if you knew?” “That’s not the point.

” “Yes, it is.

” Jake’s voice rose.

If id told you you would have left, Kai would have died in the cold.

Takakota would still be silent.

You’d all be dead or hunted.

So yes, I kept quiet because keeping you alive mattered more than clearing my conscience.

Asha’s eyes blazed.

You don’t get to decide that.

Someone had to.

Why didn’t you stay with him? The question came from Takakota.

Her voice was soft but steady.

Jake turned to her.

Because I was young and scared.

Because my commanding officer was a bastard who would have left me behind without a second thought.

Because I thought someone else would help him.

Because I didn’t want to die.

All of those are true, Takakota said.

But which one is the real reason? Jake swallowed hard.

The last one.

I didn’t want to die.

Takakota stood up.

She walked toward him slowly.

Sarah tensed hand on her knife, but Takakota just stopped in front of Jake and looked up at his face.

She was shorter than he was, thinner.

Her hair was graying at the temples, but her eyes were clear and sharp.

“My husband was not a brave man,” she said.

“He ran from fights.

He hid when danger came.

The other warriors mocked him, called him weak, but he was kind.

He was gentle.

And when he died, I think he understood.

” Jake’s throat tightened.

“He would have done the same thing you did,” Takakota continued.

If the positions were reversed, if he’d been the one with the choice, he would have chosen to live.

I know this because I knew him.

She reached up and placed her hand on Jake’s chest over his heart.

You carry his death like a stone, she said.

I can feel it.

It’s been crushing you for 16 years, but he wouldn’t want that.

He’d want you to let go.

I can’t.

You have to because my son needs a father and my sister needs someone who isn’t broken by the past.

She stepped back.

I forgive you, she said.

Not because you deserve it, but because holding on to hate will kill me the same way it’s killing you.

Jake couldn’t speak.

Takakota walked back to the bed, lay down beside Kai, closed her eyes.

Asha was still standing, still staring at Jake.

Her face was unreadable.

I need air,” she said.

She grabbed Jake’s coat and walked out into the snow.

Jake followed without thinking.

The cold hit him like a fist.

The snow was falling harder now.

The wind cut through his shirt.

But he could see Asha standing 20 ft from the cabin arms wrapped around herself.

“You don’t get to run from this,” she said without turning around.

“I’m not running.

” “Then what are you doing giving you space to be angry?” Asha spun around.

Her eyes were wet.

I don’t want space.

I want to know why you saved Kai, why you let us stay, why you’ve done any of this.

Jake took a step closer because I couldn’t save my son or your brother-in-law.

But I could save that boy.

And maybe if I did, it would mean something.

Maybe it would balance the scales somehow.

That’s not how it works.

I know, but it’s all I have.

Asha’s face crumpled.

She started to cry, not quietly.

Hard-wrenching sobs that shook her whole body.

“You don’t understand,” she choked out.

“Everyone I touch dies or suffers.

My parents, my sister’s husband, my people turned on me.

And now I’m carrying a child I never wanted from a man who destroyed me.

” She looked at Jake with desperate eyes.

“Do you want to know the truth?” she asked.

“Do you want to know why I’m really out here?” Jake waited.

“Sergeant Lucas Brennan,” she said.

Fort Apache 1881.

I was translating a meeting between the Apache leaders in the army.

Afterwards, I stayed to clean up.

Brennan stayed, too.

He locked the door, put a knife to my throat, and he took what he wanted.

Jake felt rage flood through him, hot and sharp.

I tried to fight, Asha continued, but he was stronger.

When it was over, he told me if I said anything, he’d make sure my whole family was arrested for treason.

So I said nothing.

I went home.

I tried to forget.

Her hand moved to her stomach.

Three months later, I realized I was pregnant when my people found out they wanted to kill the baby.

Said it was tainted blood.

So I ran.

I took Takakota and Kai and Sarah.

We’ve been running ever since.

Tears streamed down her face.

I hate this child, she whispered.

I feel it move inside me and I want to scream.

I look at my belly and I see his face, his hands.

I know it’s wrong.

I know the baby didn’t choose this, but I can’t stop feeling it.

Jake stepped forward slowly, like approaching something fragile.

It’s not your fault, he said.

How can you say that you don’t know me? I know enough.

I know you’re strong enough to keep running when most people would have given up.

I know you love your sister and that boy enough to risk your life for them.

I know you read Milton in a language that isn’t yours and still understand every word.

He was close enough now to see the tears on her cheeks, the exhaustion in her eyes, the pain she’d been carrying alone.

I know you’re scared, he said softly.

And I know you’re hurting.

And I know none of this is fair, but you’re not alone anymore.

And that child, whatever you feel about it now, it’s not responsible for what happened to you.

Asha’s voice broke.

How am I supposed to love it? You don’t have to.

Not right now.

You just have to let it live.

The love might come later or it might not.

But that’s a problem for another day.

Asha collapsed against him.

Jake caught her and held on.

She sobbed into his chest while the snow fell around them.

Her whole body shook.

Jake just held her.

He didn’t say anything else.

Didn’t make promises he couldn’t keep.

just stood there in the cold and let her break.

When the tears finally slowed, Asha pulled back.

Her face was red and swollen, but her eyes were clearer.

“Thank you,” she whispered.

“For what? For not looking away.

Continue reading….
« Prev Next »