“I manage two words, polite and absolute.

I’m heading that direction anyway.

This was a lie.

” He’d been heading toward the livery stable, which was entirely the wrong direction.

Wouldn’t be any trouble.

For just a moment, something flickered in those smoke-colored eyes.

Not gratitude, something harder and more complicated.

She knew exactly what he was doing, and she knew exactly what it would cost her to accept.

In Broken Creek, Montana, in the summer of 1882, there were two kinds of women.

Decent women who lived in houses with white picket fences and belonged to the church auxiliary, and the other kind who worked the saloons and cribs down by the railroad tracks.

Evelyn Hart occupied a third category that didn’t officially exist.

A woman alone without family or protection or prospects, surviving on her labor, and trying desperately not to slip from the first category into the second.

Accepting help from a man in the street, even something as simple as carrying a basket was a crack in the wall, and walls once cracked had a tendency to crumble.

Thank you, Mr.

Harlo.

Her words were correct.

Her tone was proper, but her eyes said, “I see exactly what you’re doing, and I don’t trust it.

” She handed him the basket.

It was heavier than it looked, at least 30 lb of potatoes, flour, and tinned goods.

She’d been carrying this weight for six blocks in the blistering heat without letting it show.

Colt felt something uncomfortable shift in his chest.

They walked in silence, their boots kicking up small clouds of dust with each step.

The town moved around them with its usual chaotic energy.

A freight wagon rattled past.

The blacksmith’s hammer rang against his anvil.

Somewhere, a dog barked with persistent enthusiasm at absolutely nothing.

Normal life, indifferent to the small drama of a man carrying a woman’s groceries home.

“You work for Widow Pritchard,” Colt said, because the silence was starting to feel heavier than the basket.

“Yes, hard woman to work for, I hear.

She’s fair enough.

Evelyn’s tone suggested the topic was closed.

Colt tried another angle.

You’re not from Montana.

No.

East.

Yes.

It was like trying to have a conversation with a fence post except the fence post was deliberately shutting him out and doing it with impeccable manners.

Colt found himself oddly amused.

In a town where most people would talk your ear off about nothing at all, Evelyn Hart’s militant silence was almost refreshing.

They turned the corner onto Birch Street, where the boarding houses and modest homes clustered together like animals seeking shelter from the wind.

Widow Pritchard’s establishment sat at the end of the block, a sagging two-story structure that had been white once, but had faded to the color of old newspaper.

Laundry hung in the backyard, snapping in the hot breeze.

Evelyn stopped at the back gate.

You can set it there.

Thank you for your help.

Dismissal clear and final.

Colt set the basket down carefully, then straightened.

He should leave.

He’d done his good deed for the day, and she clearly wanted nothing more to do with him, but something made him hesitate.

Miss Hart, he heard himself say, “Would you mind if I asked you a question?” She went very still.

“That depends on the question.

Why do you only have one dress?” The words hung in the air between them like a gunshot.

He’d meant it kindly, or at least he’d meant it as something other than cruel.

But watching her face drain of color, seeing her take one small involuntary step backward, Colt realized with sinking horror that he’d just touch something raw and bleeding.

I Evelyn’s voice came out rough, and she stopped, swallowed, tried again.

That’s none of your concern.

I didn’t mean Thank you for carrying my basket, Mr.

Harlo.

Good day.

She snatched up the basket, 30 lb of supplies that she shouldn’t be able to lift easily, but somehow did and disappeared through the back gate so fast she was almost running.

Colt stood there in the dust, feeling like he’d just kicked a dog that was already down.

Somewhere in the distance, another gunshot rang out.

Broken Creek going about its business, casual and violent and indifferent.

But Colt couldn’t shake the look on Evelyn Hart’s face.

that flash of pure unguarded pain before she’d locked everything down again.

He’d seen that look before in the mirror back when he’d been sleeping in livery stables and working cattle drives for pennies because it was that or starve.

He knew what it meant to have nothing.

He knew what it meant to wear that nothing like armor, to refuse Charity because Charity acknowledged the terrible truth you were trying desperately to hide.

And he just ripped that armor right off her back.

Smooth, Harlo, he muttered to himself.

real smooth.

The thing about Broken Creek that nobody talked about but everyone knew was this.

It sorted people.

The strong survived.

The weak got ground under.

And the unlucky, well, the unlucky ended up in places that were better than dying, but not by much.

Colt Harllo had arrived in Montana territory 5 years ago with $17, a decent horse, and a burning determination never to be poor again.

He’d grown up in Kansas, if you could call it, growing up, watching his father drink away three different farms and his mother’s hope along with them.

By the time Colt turned 15, he’d learned that the only person you could count on was yourself.

And even that was questionable.

So he’d left, worked cattle drives, hired out his ranch hand, saved every penny he didn’t absolutely have to spend.

He slept rough, ate less, and kept his eyes fixed on a single unwavering goal, land.

His own land.

acres that couldn’t be drunk away or gambled off or taken from him.

At 28 years old, Colt was almost there.

He had money saved, not enough yet, but close.

He had a reputation as a reliable worker, the kind of man who showed up when he said he would and did the job right.

He had a future that was finally, finally within reach.

He did not have time for complications, and Evelyn Hart was definitely a complication.

But 3 days after the basket incident, Colt found himself standing outside Murphy’s general store again, watching the boarding house alley, waiting for a woman who’d made it abundantly clear she wanted nothing to do with him.

You got a reason for loitering, or are you just admiring the architecture? Colt turned to find Sheriff Tom Brennan leaning against the storefront, a knowing smirk on his weathered face.

Brennan was one of the few men in Broken Creek that Colt genuinely respected.

Honest without being naive, tough without being cruel, and possessed of an uncomfortable ability to see straight through “Just take the air,” Colt said mildly.

“Uh-huh.

And the air just happens to be best appreciated while staring at Widow Pritchard’s back alley.

” “I like that particular alley.

You planning to court that girl?” Colt felt heat rise to his face.

“I don’t know what you’re talking about.

Evelyn Hart.

Brennan said it casually, but his eyes were sharp.

You’ve been watching her for weeks.

Either you’re interested or you’re planning to rob her.

And since she’s got nothing worth stealing, I’m guessing it’s the first one.

She seems alone.

She is alone.

Been working for the widow about 3 months now.

Came in on the eastbound stage with one carpet bag and 40 cents.

Nobody knows much about her except she works like a horse and keeps to herself.

Brennan paused, his expression sobering.

“You got intentions toward that girl, Harlo.

You better be serious about them.

She’s not the kind who can afford to be trifled with.

” “I wasn’t planning to trifle.

” “Then what were you planning?” Colt didn’t have an answer for that.

He wasn’t entirely sure himself.

The sheriff studied him for a long moment, then nodded slowly.

“She’s a good woman.

quiet, proud, works herself half to death trying to maintain some kind of dignity in a town that doesn’t give a damn about dignity.

But she’s also scared.

And you need to understand why.

Why? Because she’s one mistake away from disaster.

And she knows it.

Brennan pushed off from the wall.

Women like Evelyn Hart, decent women with no money and no family, they’re walking a tightroppe every single day.

Fall off on one side, you end up married to some bastard who will work you to death.

fall off on the other side, you end up in Diamond Lil’s establishment down by the tracks.

There’s no safety net, Harlo.

So, yeah, she’s scared, and she should be.

The word settled in Colt’s gut like lead.

I just wanted to help, he said quietly.

I know, but help can be dangerous, too, especially when it comes from a man and she doesn’t know what he wants in return.

Nothing in this world is free, Harlo.

She’s learned that lesson hard.

I’d wager.

You want her to trust you, you’re going to have to earn it.

Brennan tipped his hat and walked off, leaving Colt alone with his thoughts and the burning Montana sun.

Um, Sunday came, dragging its respectability behind it like a train.

In Broken Creek, Sunday meant the saloons closed until noon officially.

Anyway, there was a back room at the Lucky Star that never really closed.

Families dressed in their bestworn clothing and everyone who wanted to maintain their standing in the community made an appearance at First Methodist.

Colt wasn’t much for church.

His relationship with the Almighty was complicated at best, downright hostile at worst.

But he went anyway because not going marked you as a certain kind of man, and he was trying not to be that kind of man anymore.

He sat in the back pew, half listening to Reverend Michael’s drone on about righteousness and redemption, and tried not to stare at the woman sitting five rows ahead.

Evelyn Hart sat alone, as she always did, in the same faded green dress she wore everyday because it was the only dress she owned.

Her back was straight, her hands folded in her lap, her attention fixed on the Reverend with an intensity that suggested she was either deeply spiritual or deeply committed to appearing so.

Colt suspected the latter.

After the service, people spilled out into the sunshine, gathering in small clusters to exchange gossip and make plans for Sunday dinner.

Colt watched as Evelyn slipped through the crowd like smoke, heading toward the edge of town where the boarding houses clustered.

He followed, not subtly.

Colt had never been particularly good at subtle, but with the kind of determined purpose that suggested he had every right to be walking in this direction, even though they both knew he didn’t.

Miss Hart.

She stopped, her shoulders tensing almost imperceptibly.

When she turned, her face held that same carefully neutral expression from before.

Mr.

Harlo, I owe you an apology.

That surprised her.

He saw it flicker across her face before she locked it down again.

For what? Her voice was cool, polite, utterly uninterested.

For the other day, the question I asked, it was inappropriate, and I’m sorry.

Evelyn studied him for a long moment, those smokeced eyes searching his face for something.

Sincerity, mockery, hidden motives.

Colt wasn’t sure.

Whatever she found must have satisfied her at least partially because some of the rigidity left her posture.

Apology accepted, she said quietly.

They stood there in awkward silence, the Sunday morning crowd flowing around them like water around stones.

Would you? Colt cleared his throat, suddenly feeling like a school boy asking his first girl to dance.

Would you like to take a walk? There’s a nice path along the creek.

It’s shaded.

He watched her calculate the offer, weighing risks and benefits with the precision of a banker assessing a loan.

A walk with a man was courting behavior, and courting had expectations attached to it.

But refusing might offend him, and offending a man, any man, could have consequences for a woman in her position.

The fact that she had to make this calculation at all, made Colt’s chest tight with anger, not at her, but at the world that put her in this position.

Just a walk, he added quickly.

No expectations.

I give you my word.

Something shifted in her expression.

Your word? Yes, ma’am.

And what is Colt Harlo’s word worth? It was a fair question, if brutally direct.

Colt met her eyes steadily.

I’ve never broken it yet.

Another long moment of assessment.

Then, almost imperceptibly, she nodded.

All right, Mr.

Harlo.

a walk.

The path along Willow Creek wound through a stand of cottonwoods that provided blessed relief from the sun.

The water ran shallow this time of year, trickling over smooth stones and creating a sound that was almost musical.

It was, Colt realized, probably the most peaceful spot in the entire territory.

They walked in silence for a while, Evelyn keeping a careful distance between them, her eyes fixed on the path ahead.

Colt found himself acutely aware of every sound.

The rustle of her dress, the soft scuff of her boots on the dirt, his own breathing, which suddenly seemed too loud.

“You’re from Kansas,” Evelyn said abruptly.

Colt glanced at her in surprise.

“How’d you know?” “You said ma’am three times in 2 minutes.

And you have a very slight accent, the way you flatten your vowels on certain words.

My father was from Kansas.

Topeka was Her expression shuddered.

He died 4 years ago.

I’m sorry.

Are you? Most people say that, but they don’t really mean it.

They just say it because it’s expected.

Colt considered this.

You’re right.

I didn’t know your father, so I can’t honestly be sorry he’s dead.

But I am sorry that you lost him because that clearly still hurts you.

Evelyn stopped walking.

She turned to look at him fully, and for the first time since he’d met her, something genuine flickered in her expression.

“Surprise maybe, or recognition.

” “That’s honest, at least,” she said softly.

“I try to be.

” They started walking again, and this time when Evelyn spoke, her voice had lost some of its careful guardedness.

“My father was a banker.

We had a good life.

A house in Philadelphia, nice things, security.

My mother died when I was young, so it was just the two of us.

He made sure I had an education, piano lessons, everything a young woman was supposed to have.

She paused, her fingers tracing the worn fabric of her dress.

Then he made some bad investments.

Very bad.

When he died, there were debts, significant debts.

Everything had to be sold to pay them.

Everything.

Everything.

The house, the furniture, my mother’s jewelry, my father’s books.

even the piano.

Her voice remained steady, but Colt could hear the weight behind the words.

I was 19 years old with no family, no money, and an education that was completely useless for actually surviving in the world.

So, I came west.

People said there were opportunities out here.

They didn’t mention that most of those opportunities involved marrying whatever man would have you or working in establishments that, well, she didn’t finish the sentence.

She didn’t have to.

How’d you end up in Broken Creek? Ran out of money for the stage fair.

This is just where I stopped.

A bitter smile touched her lips.

Sometimes I wonder if I’d had another $5.

Would I have made it somewhere better? Or is every Frontier Town just a different flavor of the same struggle? Probably the same struggle, Colt said honestly.

But some struggles are worth fighting, and some aren’t.

Evelyn stopped at a large flat rock near the creek’s edge and sat down, arranging her skirts with practiced precision.

“Why are you being kind to me, Mr.

Harlo?” The question was direct, almost confrontational.

Colt lowered himself onto the rock beside her, careful to maintain a respectful distance.

“Why does there have to be a reason?” Because there’s always a reason.

Men don’t do things for free, especially not for women like me.

Women like you, poor, alone, vulnerable.

She said the words without self-pity, just cold assessment.

I’m not stupid, Mr.

Harlo.

I know what I look like to men in this town.

I’m either a charity case or an opportunity, and I don’t like being either one.

Colt was quiet for a moment, watching the creek flow past.

My father was a drunk, he said finally.

Mean drunk, too.

Beat my mother until she couldn’t stand anymore, then beat me when I tried to stop him.

drank away every farm we ever had, every chance we ever got.

By the time I was old enough to leave, I hated him so much I could taste it.

He could feel Evelyn’s eyes on him, but he kept staring at the water.

I swore I’d never be like him, never be weak, never be poor, never be at someone else’s mercy.

So I worked, saved every penny, slept in barns, went hungry more times than I can count.

All of it pointed toward one thing.

Getting my own land.

Being my own man.

Never having to depend on anyone or have anyone depend on me.

That sounds lonely, Evelyn said quietly.

It is, but it’s safe.

Colt turned to look at her.

You asked why I’m being kind to you.

Honest answer? I don’t know.

Maybe because you remind me of myself 5 years ago.

proud, scared, fighting like hell to maintain some dignity in a world that wants to strip it away.

Maybe because I know what it’s like to be invisible.

Or maybe he hesitated, then pushed forward.

Maybe because kindness doesn’t need a reason to exist.

Evelyn was quiet for a long time.

When she finally spoke, her voice was barely above a whisper.

I have three dresses, Mr.

Harlo.

Not one.

Three.

Colt’s breath caught.

One I wear everyday because it’s the most practical.

One is too fine for daily work.

It was my mother’s, and I can’t bear to wear it out with hard labor.

And one is, she swallowed hard.

One is torn beyond repair.

I keep trying to fix it, but the fabric is so worn that every time I mend one spot, another rips.

I wash the green dress every night and wear it every morning because the alternative is admitting that I’m one torn seam away from having nothing decent left.

Her voice cracked on the last word.

The church ladies look at me and think I’m lazy or too poor to care about my appearance.

The men think I’m loose or desperate.

The truth is I’m just trying to hold on to the last shreds of respectability I have because once those are gone, I don’t know what happens next.

and that terrifies me more than anything else in this world.

Colt’s hand moved before he could think about it, reaching out to cover hers where it rested on the rock between them.

She flinched but didn’t pull away.

You’re not going to lose your respectability, he said firmly.

And you’re not alone anymore.

Not if you don’t want to be.

Evelyn looked up at him and for the [clears throat] first time he saw tears in those smokeced eyes.

Don’t make promises you can’t keep, Mr.

Harlo.

I told you I never break my word.

Then you’re either the best man I’ve ever met or the best liar.

I guess you’ll have to stick around long enough to find out which one.

And there on a rock beside Willow Creek on a Sunday afternoon in the hard summer of 1882, Evelyn Hart did something Colt Harlo had never seen her do before.

She smiled.

It was small, tentative, like something that had forgotten how to exist and was just now remembering, but it was real.

and it transformed her entire face.

Continue reading….
« Prev Next »