In Iran, Ali Khamenei Ally and Islamic Scholar Goes Viral as He Abandons Islam for Jesus

…

But I could not stop.

It was as if something inside me had awakened and refused to go back to sleep.

I began to notice other problems.

I studied the different Quranic manuscripts and learned that there were variations, that verses had been lost, that some companions of Muhammad had questioned the compilation.

This contradicted what I had always taught, that the Quran was perfectly preserved.

I studied the scientific claims in the Quran that we scholars often cited as proof of its divine origin.

When I looked honestly, many of them were not as clear as I had claimed.

Some reflected the scientific understanding of 7th century Arabia, not timeless divine knowledge.

I studied the prophecies of Muhammad.

When I examined them critically, they were vague or written after the events they supposedly predicted.

Everything I had built my life upon was shaking.

I felt sick.

I felt terrified.

I felt guilty for even doing this research.

But I also felt something else.

A desperate need for truth, whatever the cost.

One evening, I was sitting in my study and surrounded by Islamic texts I had spent my life mastering.

My wife had gone to bed.

The house was quiet.

I had just finished reading a troubling hadith about violence against apostates and I felt a weight on my chest so heavy I could barely breathe.

I put my head in my hands and for the first time in my life I prayed a prayer that would have shocked anyone who knew me.

I prayed, “God, if you are real, show me the truth.

Even if it destroys me, even if it costs me everything, I want truth and not comfort.

I did not know it then.

But that prayer changed everything.

” Because when you genuinely ask God for truth, he answers.

Not always in the way you expect, not always quickly, but he answers.

In the weeks after that prayer, my internal crisis deepened.

I continued teaching, continued leading prayers, continued writing, but I felt like a fraud.

How could I teach others with authority when I was drowning in doubt? I began to have dreams, strange and vivid dreams.

In one dream, I I was walking in darkness, stumbling, unable to find my way.

Then a light appeared in the distance.

I walked toward it, and as I got closer, I saw it was a person clothed in brilliant light.

I could not see his face clearly, but I felt overwhelming love radiating from him.

He reached out his hand to me.

I woke up before I could take it, my heart pounding.

I tried to dismiss the dream, just my stressed mind playing tricks.

But the dream came again and again, always the same figure of light, always the same feeling of love and invitation.

I did not yet understand what these dreams meant.

Or perhaps I was too afraid to admit what I suspected.

My scholarly work suffered.

I could not write with conviction anymore.

How could I write defending Islam when I no longer knew if I believed it myself? I started avoiding my colleagues, afraid they would sense my doubt.

My wife noticed something was wrong.

She asked me if I was ill, if something had happened.

I told her I was tired, just tired.

She accepted this.

But I could see worry in her eyes.

I felt utterly alone.

In Islam, there is no room for doubt.

You believe or you do not.

There is no space for wrestling, for questioning, for seeking.

Doubt is weakness, perhaps even apostasy.

So I kept my questions locked inside where they grew and multiplied like shadows in a dark room.

I had been taught that Islam meant submission and I had submitted fully for my entire life.

I had submitted my mind, my will, my heart.

And but now something in me was rebelling against that submission.

Something in me was crying out, “What if submission to Muhammad is not the same as submission to God?” That question terrified me more than any other because if I followed that question to its conclusion, I did not know where I would end up.

I did not know what I would become.

I did not know if I would lose everything, my family, my community, my identity, even my life.

But I also knew I could not continue living a lie.

And I could not keep teaching something I no longer believed.

I could not keep pretending everything was fine when inside I was falling apart.

I was standing at a crossroads, though I did not fully realize it yet.

Behind me was everything I had known and loved.

Islam, my family, my reputation, my sense of self.

Ahead of me was darkness and uncertainty, but also a distant light I could not explain.

I had spent 43 years walking one path with absolute confidence.

And at now I was beginning to suspect that path led nowhere good.

But leaving it meant entering a wilderness with no map, no guide, no guarantee of safety.

All I had was that desperate prayer.

God, show me the truth.

I did not know it yet, but he was already answering.

The light I had seen in my dreams was not just a symbol.

It was a person.

And that person was about to shatter and rebuild everything I thought I knew about God, about truth, about life itself.

But I am getting ahead of myself.

And I was not ready for that revelation yet.

First, I had to go deeper into my questions.

I had to let everything fall apart.

I had to reach the end of myself because only when you are broken can you be remade.

Only when you admit you are lost can you be found.

The months that followed my prayer for truth were the darkest of my life.

I felt like a man trapped between two worlds, belonging fully to neither.

During the day, I performed my duties as a scholar and teacher.

At night, I wrestled with questions that had no easy answers.

I need you to understand something about leaving Islam, especially for someone like me.

It is not like changing your opinion about politics or deciding you prefer one philosophy over another.

Islam was not just my religion.

It was my identity, my culture, my community, my livelihood, my family structure, my entire understanding of reality.

Questioning Islam meant questioning everything about who I was.

And in Iran, questioning Islam meant risking death.

The penalty for apostasy in Islamic law is clear.

death.

This is not extremism or misinterpretation.

This is mainstream Islamic juristprudence across all major schools of thought.

I had taught this myself.

I had explained to students why this law was just and necessary.

A person who leaves Islam is seen as a traitor worse than someone who was never Muslim because they have known truth and rejected it.

So my questions were not academic exercises.

They were dangerous.

I began my investigation in secret late at night when everyone slept.

I would lock my study door and pull out books I had never examined critically before.

I started with Islamic sources only because I did not trust outside sources.

If Islam was going to fall apart, it would have to fall apart from within by its own contradictions.

I studied the different Quranic manuscripts and the history of how the Quran was compiled.

How I had always taught that the Quran was perfectly preserved, that not a single letter had changed since it was revealed to Muhammad.

But when I actually researched the historical evidence, I found a more complex and troubling picture.

I learned about the different readings of the Quran, the variant manuscripts, the verses that early Muslims reported but that are not in our Quran today.

I learned that the Quran was compiled after Muhammad’s death uh and that there were disagreements about what should be included.

I learned that Khalif Uman had burned other versions of the Quran to enforce standardization.

Why burn other versions if they all said the same thing? The question haunted me.

I studied the hadith collections, particularly those about Muhammad’s life.

I had read these hadiths many times before, but I had always read them through the lens of faith, finding explanations for anything troubling.

Now I read them honestly and I was disturbed by what I saw.

I read about the massacre of the Banu Kurisa, a Jewish tribe in Medina.

After they surrendered, Muhammad ordered that all the men and boys who had reached puberty be executed and the women and children be taken as slaves.

The men were beheaded, between 600 and 900 of them, their bodies thrown into trenches.

This was in sahi hadiths, authentic according to Islamic standards.

I sat with that story for a long time.

Like I tried to find ways to justify it, to explain it, to make it fit with the image of Muhammad as the perfect example for all humanity.

But I could not.

This was not self-defense.

This was mass execution after surrender.

How was this the example I was supposed to follow? I read about the night raids Muhammad ordered where Muslim fighters would attack enemies at night.

When companions asked whether it was permissible to kill women and children in these night raids, you know, Muhammad said it was acceptable because they were from the polytheists.

The casualness of that statement shook me.

I read about Safia, a Jewish woman whose husband was tortured and killed by Muslims who was then taken as a war captive and became Muhammad’s wife that same night.

How was that not trauma and coercion? How was she supposed to genuinely love the man who had destroyed her life? I read about Aisha who was 6 years old when Muhammad married her nine when the marriage was consummated.

I had always defended this by appealing to cultural norms of the time.

But Muhammad was supposed to be the eternal example for all times and places.

If his example cannot be followed today without being considered abuse, what does that say about his claim to be the perfect model? These were not attacks from enemies of Islam.

These were our own most authentic sources.

I could not dismiss them.

When I began comparing the life of Muhammad with the life of Jesus as described in the Quran and in history, the contrast was stark and troubling.

Jesus performed miracles of compassion, healing the sick, feeding the hungry, raising the dead.

Muhammad’s miracles were mostly claimed visions, and splitting the moon, which no other civilization recorded.

Jesus spoke of loving enemies and praying for those who persecute you.

Muhammad led armies against enemies and ordered their execution.

Jesus had no political power and did not seek it.

Muhammad became a political and military leader.

Jesus taught forgiveness.

Muhammad taught retaliation.

Even according to the Quran, Jesus was sinless.

The Quran never claims Muhammad was sinless.

In fact, the Quran tells Muhammad to ask forgiveness for his sins multiple times.

I kept asking myself, if I did not know either of these men and just looked at their lives and teachings objectively, which one seemed more like the character of God? The answer troubled me deeply.

I studied the nature of Allah as described in the Quran.

Allah is described as the best of deceivers.

He is merciful but also the one who leads astray whomever he wills.

He loves believers but not unbelievers.

His mercy is conditional.

I tried to pray to this Allah as I always had but I felt nothing.

The prayers felt hollow like speaking into an empty room.

I would prostrate on my prayer mat and feel only the floor beneath my forehead cold and indifferent.

I began to realize something that frightened me.

I had never known Allah personally.

I had known about Allah.

I had memorized his 99 names.

I had followed the rules.

But I had never had a relationship with him.

How could you have a relationship with someone who was utterly transcendent, completely other, unknowable? Islam taught that Allah was not like us in any way.

That anthropomorphizing him was sherk, the unforgivable sin.

But this meant that Allah was fundamentally unknowable, distant, separate.

You could submit to him, obey him, fear him, but you could not know him.

The Christian claim that God became man, that you could actually know God personally, had always seemed like blasphemy to me.

But now I began to wonder, what if that is exactly what humans need? What if we need a God who comes close, who enters our suffering, who makes himself knowable? I tried to push these thoughts away, but they persisted.

Then I started having more dreams.

Not every night, but several times each week.

Always the same figure in light.

Always extending his hand toward me.

In one dream he spoke.

I heard him say two words clearly.

Follow me.

I woke up trembling.

I knew who this was supposed to be.

My mind knew.

But my heart was resisting with everything it had.

I tried to convince myself these dreams meant nothing, just my subconscious processing my doubts, but they felt different from normal dreams.

They felt real, more real than waking life sometimes, like I became withdrawn.

My wife knew something was seriously wrong now.

She kept asking, kept pressing.

One evening she confronted me directly, asking if I had done something shameful if I was involved in sin.

The irony struck me.

She was worried I might be committing moral sins when the reality was far worse in her eyes.

I was doubting the faith entirely.

I told her I was going through a spiritual trial, that I was struggling with some difficult theological questions.

Uh she seemed relieved it was nothing worse and encouraged me to speak with the senior Ayatollah to seek guidance.

But I knew I could not speak to anyone in the religious community.

If I expressed even a fraction of my doubts, I would be marked as deviant, possibly dangerous.

I felt utterly isolated.

I could not speak to my wife, my colleagues, my friends.

They all assumed I was a devoted believer.

They all saw me as a pillar of the community.

If they knew what was happening inside my mind, they would reject me immediately.

In my desperation, I did something I had never done before.

I decided to read the Bible.

This was a major step.

In Islam, we are taught that the Bible has been corrupted, that it is unreliable, that it has been changed by Jews and Christians to hide prophecies about Muhammad.

I had taught this myself without ever actually reading the Bible to verify it.

But now I wanted to know for myself.

I wanted to read the actual words attributed to Jesus.

In getting a Bible in Iran was not easy, especially for someone in my position.

I could not simply walk into a bookstore and buy one.

That would raise questions.

Finally, I found a way to obtain a Persian translation through a contact who asked no questions.

When the Bible arrived, I hid it in my study, buried under other books.

I felt like I was hiding something evil, even though part of me knew that was absurd.

If Islam was truth, it should not be threatened by me reading another religious text.

Odd.

The first time I opened the Bible, my hands were shaking.

I had no idea where to start.

I decided to read the Gospel of Matthew first to read about Jesus directly.

What I read astonished me.

This was not what I had expected at all.

The Jesus I encountered in the Gospels was nothing like the distant prophet figure described briefly in the Quran.

This Jesus spoke with authority.

He healed the sick not with Allah’s permission as the Quran claimed, but with his own power.

He forgave sins and something only God could do.

He claimed to be one with the father.

He said he was the way, the truth, and the life and that no one could come to the father except through him.

These were not the words of a mere prophet.

These were the claims of someone who believed he was God himself.

I read the sermon on the mount and I wept.

I do not know why exactly.

Something about the words pierced through all my defenses.

Blessed are the poor in spirit.

Blessed are those who mourn.

Blessed are the meek.

Love your enemies.

Do good to those who hate you.

Pray for those who persecute you.

This was a completely different ethic from what I knew.

Islam taught to fight those who fight you.

To not take Jews and Christians as close friends, to be harsh against disbelievers.

But Jesus taught something entirely different.

He taught radical love even for enemies.

I read about the crucifixion.

The account was detailed, brutal, and heartbreaking.

Jesus knew it was coming.

He prayed in agony in the garden.

Yet he was betrayed, arrested, mocked, beaten, crucified.

And on the cross, he prayed for those killing him.

Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do.

I had never encountered anything like this.

What kind of person prays for his executioners while dying? The resurrection accounts followed the empty tomb, the appearances to disciples, their transformation from terrified, scattered followers into bold proclaimers willing to die for their testimony.

I spent weeks reading and rereading the gospels.

Each time I was struck by the same things, the character of Jesus, his compassion, his authority, his claims, his sacrifice.

I began to compare the Quranic Jesus with the gospel Jesus.

The Quran gave a few brief stories, but no extended teachings from Jesus.

It denied the crucifixion outright.

It denied Jesus was the son of God.

It reduced him to a prophet who announced the coming of Muhammad.

But the Gospels presented Jesus as the centerpiece of all history, the fulfillment of prophecy, God’s ultimate revelation of himself.

The Gospels were written by people who claimed to be eyewitnesses or who had interviewed eyewitnesses.

They were written within decades of Jesus’s life, not six centuries later, like the Quran.

From a historical standpoint, which source about Jesus was more reliable? The answer seemed obvious.

I studied the crucifixion from historical sources outside the Bible.

In Roman historians like Tacitus confirmed it, Jewish historians like Josephus mentioned it.

There was no credible historical doubt that Jesus was crucified under Ponteus Pilate.

So the Quran was simply wrong about this historical fact.

And if it was wrong about something so central to Christianity, how could it be divine revelation? I studied the resurrection.

I looked at the evidence, the empty tomb, the transformation of the disciples, the early Christian testimony in the fact that Christianity spread despite intense persecution.

Could this all be explained away as legend or hallucination? The more I studied, the more compelling the resurrection evidence became.

People do not die for what they know is a lie.

The disciples were willing to be tortured and killed rather than deny they had seen the risen Jesus.

Would they do this for something they made up? I wrestled with the concept of the Trinity, and this had always been my main objection to Christianity.

How can God be one and three? It seemed like obvious mathematical impossibility, a corruption of pure monotheism.

But as I studied, I realized I’d been attacking a straw man.

Christians do not believe in three gods.

They believe in one God who exists eternally in three persons.

It is mysterious, yes, but not illogical.

And it actually makes sense of many things.

How God can be love eternally without needing to create beings to love.

Continue reading….
Next »