That girl in there, she asked me something while I was bandaging her.

She asked if you were trustworthy.

I told her yes.

Don’t make me a liar, Garrett Rollins.

She left him alone with the photograph and his thoughts.

Garrett did not sleep that night.

He sat in his study making lists, forming plans, trying to figure out how a rancher with no authority and no resources was supposed to investigate a potential conspiracy involving the United States Army.

By the time the sun rose, he had filled three pages with notes and crossed out most of them.

The sound of voices in the kitchen drew him out of his chair.

He walked down the hall, found Helen at the stove making coffee, and Tom Fletcher standing by the table looking like he had seen a ghost.

Tom was 58, built like a bull with gray shot through his dark hair and a face that looked like it had been carved from granite with a dull chisel.

He had been Garrett’s sergeant back in the cavalry days, had saved Garrett’s life twice in skirmishes with hostiles, and had followed him into civilian life when Garrett left the service.

Tom was foreman of the ranch now and the closest thing Garrett had to family.

He was also staring at the hallway that led to the spare room where Aasha slept, his expression unreadable.

“Morning, Tom,” Garrett said carefully.

Tom turned that stare on him.

Helen says you brought an Apache into this house.

I did? Why? Garrett poured himself coffee, took a long drink, felt the bitterness scaldled his throat.

Then he told Tom the same story he had told Helen, but this time when he mentioned David Fletcher’s name, Tom’s face went white.

The big man sat down heavily in a chair, his hands shaking.

Tom.

Garrett set his cup down.

What is it? Tom’s voice came out rough, broken.

David Fletcher was my sister’s boy.

My nephew.

The words hung in the air like smoke from a gun barrel.

Garrett felt the floor shift beneath him.

Of course, Fletcher was not an uncommon name in the territory, but now that Tom said it, Garrett remembered.

Tom’s sister had married a man named William Fletcher, had moved to Tucson, had a son.

Garrett had met the boy once years ago.

A serious kid with his father’s height and his mother’s eyes.

David joined the army two years ago.

Tom continued, his voice hollow against his mother’s wishes.

Said he wanted to make a difference.

Last letter we got from him was three months back.

He said he was stationed at Fort Grant.

Said he was doing good work.

Tom looked up at Garrett and there were tears in his eyes.

Now, are you telling me he’s dead? I don’t know, Garrett said honestly.

But that’s what Aayasha claims.

She says Cain killed him.

Says David saw something he shouldn’t have.

Tom’s hands curled into fists on the table.

That Apache girl.

She’s lying.

She has to be lying.

Why would she lie about the name? How would she even know to say David Fletcher if it wasn’t true? I don’t know.

Tom stood abruptly, the chair scraping loud against the floor.

But I know Apaches.

I fought them for 15 years.

They lie.

They steal.

They kill.

That’s what they do.

His voice rose.

And you bring one into this house? Into Sarah’s house.

Tom? Garrett kept his voice level.

I need you to calm down.

Calm down? My nephew is dead, and you’re protecting the people who killed him.

We don’t know who killed him.

That’s what we need to find out.

We Tom laughed bitter and sharp.

There’s no we in this, Garrett.

This is you making a damn fool decision because you feel guilty about Sarah and Daniel.

He jabbed a finger toward the hallway.

That Apache in there, she’s using you.

And when she’s done, she’ll slit your throat and disappear into the desert.

Before Garrett could respond, a voice came from the hallway, quiet, accented, exhausted.

I not kill your nephew.

They both turned.

Aayasha stood in the doorway, leaning heavily against the frame.

She had changed into one of Helen’s spare dresses, too big on her thin frame, and her left arm was in a sling.

Her face was pale, sweat beating on her forehead, but her eyes were clear and steady.

“David Fletcher,” she continued, her English halting, but determined.

“Good man.

He kind to Apache prisoners.

Give us extra water, extra food.

When I try escape, he not shoot.

He let me go.

Her voice broke.

Cain kill him.

Not me.

Not Ashki.

Cain.

Tom stared at her, his jaw working.

You expect me to believe that? I not care what you believe.

Aasha pushed herself upright, swaying but refusing to fall.

But David Fletcher, he die because he good.

Because he tried to stop Cain.

He died protecting truth.

She met Tom’s gaze.

You want hate me? Hate me.

But your nephew, he deserved justice, not hate.

The silence that followed was thick enough to choke on.

Finally, Tom turned to Garrett.

I’m going to Fort Grant today.

I’m going to see the records, the death certificate, the incident report, all of it.

His voice was granted.

And if I find out she’s lying, God help her.

God help both of you.

He stroed out of the house, slamming the door behind him hard enough to rattle the windows.

Garrett watched him go, then looked at Aasha.

You shouldn’t be out of bed.

I hear yelling.

She touched the door frame for support.

He hate me.

He’s grieving and scared and angry.

That’s a dangerous combination.

You not angry? Garrett considered the question.

Was he angry? Yes, but not at her.

at Cain if the story was true, at himself for not seeing it sooner, at the world for taking everything he loved and leaving him with nothing but questions and ghosts.

I’m tired of being angry, he said finally.

Anger doesn’t bring anyone back.

Aayasha studied his face and something in her expression softened.

You good man like David? I’m not good.

I’m just trying to do the right thing for once.

She took a step toward him, winced as the movement pulled at her stitches.

Garrett moved to catch her, but she waved him off.

I walk.

Need to walk.

Make strong.

You need to rest.

Helen’s orders.

Helen, not Apache.

A ghost of a smile crossed Aasha’s face.

Apache women, we strong.

We heal fast.

You were shot yesterday.

Yes.

and today I walk.

She moved past him into the kitchen, her gate unsteady but determined.

Helen appeared from the pantry, took one look at Aasha, and sighed.

Stubborn, just like I thought.

Just, “All right, girl.

You want to walk? You walk.

But you sit down to eat breakfast first, or I’ll tie you to that chair myself.

” Aasha sat.

Helen put a plate of eggs and bread in front of her, and Aisha ate slowly, methodically, like someone who had known too much hunger to waste a single bite.

Garrett watched her, this stranger who had crashed into his carefully ordered life, and wondered if Tom was right.

Was he being a fool? Was he projecting his own need for answers onto a situation that did not involve him? But then he remembered the drawing, the perfect rendering of Virgil Cain’s face, scars and all.

And he remembered the look in Cain’s eyes 12 years ago when he delivered the news about Sarah and Daniel.

Not quite sad enough, not quite surprised enough, like a man who already knew what he was going to find when he rode out to that homestead.

Aayasha, Garrett said quietly.

When Tom gets back from Fort Grant, things are going to get complicated.

He might bring the army.

He might bring the law.

And if he does, I need to know something.

He paused.

Is there anything else you haven’t told me? Anything that could change the story? She set down her fork, met his gaze.

There one thing.

Garrett’s stomach tightened.

What? When I escaped Fort Grant, I not alone at first.

Her voice dropped.

There was other Apache woman older.

She helped me.

She Aasha swallowed hard.

Soldiers shoot her.

She die so I could run.

What was her name? Desba.

Aayasha’s eyes shimmerred with unshed tears.

She was like mother to me.

After my real mother die, she teach me English.

Teach me how to survive.

Her hands clenched into fists on the table.

Cain kill her too.

He give order to shoot.

He laugh when she fall.

The rage that swept through Garrett was cold and precise, the kind of rage he had not felt since the day he buried his wife and son.

It was not the hot chaotic anger of grief.

It was the calculated fury of a man who had found his purpose again after 12 years of drifting.

Then we’re going to make him answer for it, Garrett said.

All of it.

David Fletcher, Desba, and maybe, he hesitated.

Maybe Sarah and Daniel, too.

Aayasha reached across the table, placed her hand over his.

Her skin was warm, her grip surprisingly gentle.

“We find truth,” she said.

“Together.

” And in that moment, sitting in his kitchen with an Apache fugitive and a housekeeper who had seen too much, Garrett Rollins made a choice.

Not the safe choice, not the smart choice, but the only choice he could live with.

He was going to war with Virgil Ca.

And this time he was not going to lose.

Three days passed before Tom Fletcher returned from Fort Grant.

Three days during which Aasha’s wound began to heal.

the fever breaking on the second night, her strength returning in increments that amazed even Helen.

Three days during which Garrett paced his ranch like a caged animal, waiting for news, waiting for answers, waiting for the inevitable confrontation he knew was coming.

On the morning of the fourth day, Tom rode in just after dawn, his horse lthered with sweat, his face carved from stone.

He dismounted in the yard, handed the reinss to Jesse Morgan, the young ranch hand, who had been watching the horizon for him, and walked straight to the house without a word.

Garrett met him on the porch.

Behind him, through the open door, Aayasha sat at the kitchen table with Helen, pretending to sip coffee while watching Tom with the weariness of a deer scenting wolves.

Tom stopped at the bottom of the porch steps.

He looked like he had aged 10 years in 3 days.

His eyes were bloodshot, his jaw covered in stubble, his clothes rumpled from sleeping in them.

“Tell me,” Garrett said quietly.

Tom pulled a folded paper from inside his coat, held it out.

His hand shook.

“Death certificate.

Private David Fletcher.

Died October 15th, 1884.

Cause of death, gunshot wound to the back.

” He paused, his voice cracking.

“To the back, Garrett.

My nephew was shot in the back.

Garrett took the paper, scanned it.

The official army seal, the doctor’s signature, the clinical description of wounds that had ended a young man’s life.

But it was the note at the bottom that made his blood run cold.

Witness statement, Sergeant Virgil Kaine.

There was a trial, Tom continued, his voice hollow.

Lasted half a day.

Apache boy named Ashki, 17 years old, accused of murder.

Cain testified he saw the whole thing.

Said the Apache grabbed a rifle, shot David when his back was turned, then tried to run.

Said he had to restrain the boy himself.

Tom’s hands clenched into fists.

Open and shut case.

They convicted him in an hour.

Set execution for November 10th.

That’s 17 days from now.

17 days.

Garrett pulled out his pocket watch, checked the date.

October 24th, November 10th was circled in his mind now.

A deadline written in blood.

17 days to find evidence.

17 days to convince the army.

17 days before an innocent boy died for a crime he didn’t commit.

We’re running out of time, Hayasha whispered, her voice breaking.

17 days is not enough.

It has to be enough, Garrett said, though he wasn’t sure he believed it.

We make it enough.

17 days.

The number hung in the air like a noose.

Did you see the ballistics report? Garrett asked.

Tom’s expression shifted.

Something flickering across his face.

Doubt.

Confusion.

I saw it.

And that’s the thing that doesn’t make sense.

He pulled another paper from his coat.

This one more worn, like it had been read and reread a dozen times.

The doctor who examined David noted the angle of the wound.

Said the bullet entered from behind and below, traveling upward through the chest cavity.

Garrett frowned below as in the shooter was lower than David or kneeling or Tom met his gaze.

Or David was standing and the shooter was a 17-year-old Apache boy who’s 5’6 according to his intake report.

How tall was David? 6’2, just like his father.

Tom’s voice broke.

The angles don’t match, Garrett.

If Ashki shot David face to face and David turned to run, the bullet would have traveled level or downward, not upward.

He crumpled the paper in his fist.

Something’s wrong with Cain’s testimony.

Something’s real wrong.

Behind them, Aasha stood up from the table, moved to the doorway.

Her voice was soft but steady.

I tell you, Cain killed David, not Ashki.

Ashki was holding supplies, his hands full, no gun.

Tom turned to look at her, and for the first time, there was no hatred in his eyes, just exhaustion and grief and a terrible, dawning understanding.

There’s more, Tom said.

I went through David’s personal effects.

The army had them boxed up, waiting to be sent to his mother.

I told them I’d take them.

He reached into his coat again, pulled out a small leather journal.

David kept a diary.

Last entry was 2 days before he died.

He opened it to a marked page, handed it to Garrett.

The handwriting was neat, careful.

The words of a young man trying to make sense of the world around him.

October 13th, 1884.

Saw Sergeant Cain at the trading post today with men I didn’t recognize.

Rough types, banditol looking.

He was loading crates into their wagon.

Crates with US Army stamps, rifles, at least 20 Winchesterers.

When I asked what he was doing, Cain told me to mind my own business.

Told me if I knew what was good for me, I’d forget what I saw.

But I can’t forget.

Those are army weapons, our weapons, going to God knows who.

October 14th, 1884.

Confronted Cain this morning at the fort.

told him I was going to report what I saw unless he could explain it.

He laughed in my face.

Said no one would believe a green private over a decorated sergeant.

Said accidents happen to soldiers who don’t know when to keep their mouth shut.

I’m writing to Mr.

Garrett Rollins tonight.

Uncle Tom says he’s a good man.

If something happens to me, someone needs to know the truth.

The entry ended there.

No entry for October 15th.

That was the day David Fletcher died.

Garrett closed the journal, felt something cold and hard settle in his chest.

Gun running just like Aasha said.

There’s one more thing.

Tom’s voice had gone quiet, almost a whisper.

I found this tucked in the back of the journal.

David must have written it, but never had a chance to send it.

He handed Garrett a folded letter.

The address line read Lieutenant Garrett Rollins, but it had been crossed out and rewritten.

Mr.

Garrett Rollins, Rollins Ranch.

Garrett’s hands shook as he unfolded it.

Mr.

Rollins, you don’t know me, but I know of you.

My uncle Tom Fletcher served under you in the cavalry.

He speaks highly of you.

Says you’re a man who values truth and justice.

I’m writing because I’ve discovered something at Fort Grant that I believe you should know about.

It concerns Sergeant Virgil Kaine and an incident from 12 years ago.

The raid on your homestead, sir.

I think Cain knew about it beforehand.

I found a report in the old files, a scouts warning about Apache war parties moving south.

The report was dated 2 days before your family was killed.

Cain was the duty officer that day.

He should have sent writers to warn the homesteads.

He didn’t.

I don’t know why he would do such a thing, but I think you deserve to know.

I’m going to confront him tomorrow if anything happens to me.

The letter ended there, unfinished, unscent.

Garrett read it twice, then a third time, the words blurring as his vision tunnneled.

Cain had known.

Two days in advance, Cain had known that Apache war parties were riding south toward the scattered homesteads where families lived unprotected, and he had done nothing.

He had let them die.

He had let Sarah die.

Let Daniel die.

Not through incompetence, through choice.

Why? The word came out of Garrett like broken glass.

Why would he do that? Tom’s face was grim.

I asked around at the fort, quiet.

found an old clerk who’s been there since before your time.

He said, “The year your family died, there was a big increase in army funding for the territory.

Congress authorized double the budget because of the Apache threat.

More money meant more supplies, more weapons, more everything.

” He paused.

“More opportunities for men like Cain to skim off the top, to build their little empires.

He let my family die for money.

” Garrett’s voice was eerily calm, the kind of calm that comes before a storm breaks.

He let Sarah and Daniel burn so he could pat his pockets.

“We don’t know that for certain,” Tom said.

“But there was no conviction in his words.

” “Yes, we do.

” Garrett looked at Aasha saw the understanding in her eyes, the shared weight of knowing what evil men were capable of when they thought no one was watching.

And David figured it out.

So Cain killed him and framed Ashki to cover his tracks.

“If we take this to the army, they’ll investigate,” Tom said.

“They’ll have to.

” “And how long will that take?” Garrett asked.

“Weeks? Months? Ashki hangs in 17 days, Tom.

By the time army bureaucracy gets around to questioning Cain’s testimony, that boy will be in the ground.

” “So what do you suggest?” Garrett walked to the edge of the porch, looked out at the land he had built his new life on, the land that had been supposed to help him forget.

The morning sun painted everything gold, beautiful, and indifferent to human suffering.

“We get proof,” he said.

“Real proof, not just suspicions and coincidences.

We find evidence of Cain’s gun running operation.

We get someone to testify against him.

And then we make sure Ashki lives long enough for the truth to matter.

” How? We go to Kane’s trading post.

We see what’s really in those crates.

Tom was quiet for a long moment.

That’s breaking and entering.

Maybe theft.

Definitely illegal.

I know.

If we get caught, we’ll be arrested.

Could lose everything.

I know that, too.

Tom looked at him.

Really looked at him like he was seeing Garrett clearly for the first time in 12 years.

This isn’t just about saving that Apache boy, is it? No, Garrett admitted.

It’s not.

You want revenge.

I want justice.

There’s a difference, is there? Tom’s gaze was unflinching.

Because from where I’m standing, they look an awful lot alike.

Garrett turned to face him.

Tom, you don’t have to come with me.

This is my fight.

My ghosts to lay to rest.

You have the ranch to think about your own life.

I won’t ask you to risk that.

Tom was silent for so long that Garrett thought he might walk away.

Then the older man sighed long and heavy.

David was my nephew, my sister’s only child.

And if what we think is true, then Cain took him from her the same way he took Sarah and Daniel from you.

He met Garrett’s eyes.

I’m coming with you, not for revenge, for David.

So his mother knows her boy didn’t die for nothing.

Continue reading….
« Prev Next »