They Called Her The Ugly Sister in Whispers, The Cowboy Called Her Beautiful Loud Enough For All

…

Inside the house, her mother was indeed waiting, her face already arranged in that particular expression of determined cheerfulness that Catherine had learned to dread.

There you are, dear.

Margaret Vaughn said, “I was just telling Isabelle that we really must get both of you new dresses for the social.

First impressions are so important.

” Isabel looked up from her embroidery, and Catherine felt the familiar twist in her chest that came from loving someone who made you invisible just by existing.

Her sister was not cruel.

She was not unkind.

She simply was, and that was enough.

“I do not need a new dress, Mama.

” Catherine said, “My blue one is perfectly serviceable.

” Serviceable.

Her mother made it sound like a disease.

Catherine, you are 22 years old.

You cannot spend the rest of your life hiding in account books and household management.

I am not hiding.

I am being useful.

You could be useful and married.

Margaret, her father said, his voice carrying a warning note.

Let the girl be.

Catherine escaped to her room before her mother could continue the familiar argument.

She stood at her window, looking out over the ranch she loved more than she could articulate.

This place made sense to her in ways that church socials and courting rituals never had.

The land did not care if you were pretty.

It cared if you were strong, smart, and stubborn enough to survive it.

She was unpinning her hair when she heard the sound of hoof beatats in the yard.

From her window, she could see Owen Nichols dismounting from a sturdy bay horse, his movements economical and sure.

Her father walked out to meet him, and she watched as they shook hands, talked, gestured toward the barn and pastures.

The conversation lasted perhaps 10 minutes before her father clapped Owen on the shoulder in the way he did when he was satisfied with something.

They shook hands again, and Owen led his horse toward the bunk house.

At dinner that night, her father confirmed what Catherine had already guessed.

hired a new hand today,” he announced, passing the potatoes to Isabelle.

“Owen Nichols from Abilene seems to know his business.

We’ll see how he does with the morning chores.

” “Is he young?” Isabel asked, and Catherine saw her mother’s ears practically perk up.

“6, I’d guess.

” “Knows cattle, knows horses.

That’s what matters.

Is he handsome?” this from her mother, who had never learned the art of subtlety.

Her father snorted.

I did not hire him to look at Margaret.

I hired him to work.

But Catherine saw the gleam in her mother’s eye and knew what was coming.

Another eligible man meant another opportunity to parade Isabelle like a prize heer.

and by extension another opportunity for Catherine to blend into the wallpaper while everyone admired her sister’s considerable charms.

She went to bed that night trying not to think about green eyes and a voice like rough velvet, trying not to hope for things she had learned long ago were not meant for girls they called ugly, even in whispers.

The next morning Catherine rose before dawn as she always did.

The ranch did not sleep late, and neither did she.

She dressed in her practical calico, pinned her hair into a simple knot, and went downstairs to help their housekeeper, Mr.s.

Chen, prepare breakfast for the ranch hands, Mr.s.

Chen was a Chinese woman who had come to Kansas with her husband during the railroad boom, only to lose him to fever 3 years later.

The Vans had hired her when most people in town would not give her the time of day, and she had been with them ever since.

She and Catherine worked in comfortable silence, frying eggs and bacon, making biscuits, brewing strong coffee.

The hands came in gradually, dusty and hungry.

Catherine knew them all by name, knew how they liked their coffee, and who could not abide onions, and which ones sent money home to families back east.

She poured and served and listened to their easy banter, comfortable in this space, where her worth was measured in full plates and hot coffee rather than the arrangement of her features.

Owen Nichols came in last, and the conversation died for just a moment as the other men assessed the newcomer.

Catherine kept her eyes on the coffee pot, but she was aware of him in a way that made her hands unsteady.

“Coffee?” she asked, finally looking up.

“Please, madam.

” He held out his cup, and when she poured, their fingers did not touch, but she felt the almost contact like electricity before a lightning strike.

You settling in? All right.

One of the older hands, Charlie asked Owen.

Well enough.

Bunk house is better than some I’ve stayed in.

Where you from originally? Another hand, young Tommy asked through a mouthful of biscuit.

Missouri, born and raised, came west after the war.

Catherine did the arithmetic in her head.

He would have been young during the war, maybe 15 or 16, just old enough to see the worst of it.

Which side? Charlie asked, and the room went quiet.

Owen met his gaze steadily.

Does it matter now? War has been over more than a decade.

Suppose it does not, Charlie said after a moment.

Long as you can rope a steer and mend a fence.

The tension broke and conversation resumed.

Catherine refilled cups and brought out more biscuits and tried to ignore the way her eyes kept drifting toward Owen Nicholls despite her best efforts.

After breakfast, the hands dispersed to their various tasks.

“Catherine was clearing plates when Owen approached with his empty cup and plate.

” “Thank you for breakfast, Miss Vaughn,” he said.

“Best biscuits I have had in months,” she blinked, surprised he knew her name.

“You are welcome, Mr. Nicholls.

Owen, he said, Mr. Nichols was my father and he has been dead 6 years.

Owen.

Then she took his dishes, acutely aware of Mr.s.

Chen watching from across the kitchen with barely concealed interest.

I hope you find the work here to your liking.

I expect I will.

He settled his hat on his head.

Your father seems a fair man.

He is.

Owen nodded, then did something that made Catherine’s breath catch.

He smiled at her, a real smile that reached his eyes and created creases at the corners.

“I will see you at supper,” then he left before she could formulate a response, and Catherine stood holding his dishes like they might provide answers to questions she did not know how to ask.

“That one looks at you different,” Mr.s.

Chen said quietly.

“He just got here.

He does not know to look at me any particular way yet.

Mr.s.

Chen made a sound that was neither agreement nor disagreement, just acknowledgement.

Time will tell.

The morning passed in its usual rhythms.

Catherine worked through the household accounts, reconciling expenses and income with the meticulous attention to detail that had kept the ranch profitable through drought and depression.

She was good at this, good at seeing patterns in numbers, good at making things balance.

Around midm morning, her mother appeared in the doorway of the small office Catherine used.

Catherine, dear Isabel and I are going into town for fabric.

Would you like to come? It was not really an invitation.

It was a test.

One Catherine failed regularly by preferring ledgers to dress shopping.

I have accounts to finish, she said.

But thank you, mama.

Her mother sighed.

You spend too much time with numbers.

It is not natural for a young woman.

Someone has to do it.

Your father could hire a bookkeeper.

Why, when I do it for free and do it well? Her mother had no answer for that, or at least none she cared to voice.

She swept out in a rustle of skirts, and 15 minutes later, Catherine heard the carriage depart.

She worked until her eyes burned from the close figures, then stood and stretched.

Through the window she could see the hands working in the near pasture, moving cattle from one grazing area to another.

Owen was among them, and even at this distance, she could see the easy competence with which he sat his horse.

On impulse, Catherine left the house and walked toward the pasture.

She told herself she was just checking on the herd, just making sure everything was proceeding smoothly.

She told herself it had nothing to do with wanting a closer look at the new hand.

The cattle were herfords, red and white against the golden grass.

Her father had invested heavily in improving his stock, and it had paid off.

These were prime animals worth good money in Kansas City or Chicago.

They are looking good, Catherine said to Charlie, who sat his horse near the fence line.

Should bring top dollar this year, Charlie agreed.

New hand knows his business.

Got a good eye for cattle.

As if summoned by the mention, Owen rode over, his horse dancing sideways before settling.

“Miss Vaughn,” he said, touching his hat brim.

“Mr. Nicholls, I hear you are impressing the crew.

just doing what your father hired me for.

He looked out over the herd, his expression thoughtful.

You have good stock here, better than a lot of places I have worked.

My father is very particular about breeding.

Shows.

He shifted in his saddle, and his horse took it as a cue to move closer to the fence where Catherine stood.

“You grow up on this ranch, born in that house,” Catherine said, nodding toward the white structure behind them.

Never lived anywhere else.

Must be something having roots like that.

I have been moving since I was 16.

Do you ever want to stop? The question surprised her as much as it seemed to surprise him.

Owen looked at her, really looked at her, and Catherine felt exposed in a way that had nothing to do with the bright sunlight.

I think maybe I am getting tired of moving,” he said slowly.

Starting to see the appeal of staying somewhere long enough to watch the seasons change more than once.

Before Catherine could respond, Tommy shouted something from across the pasture, and Owen wheeled his horse around, “Excuse me, Miss Vaughn, duty calls.

” He canered off and Catherine stood at the fence watching him go, her heart doing things that were probably inadvisable and certainly impractical.

That evening her mother and Isabelle returned from town in high spirits, laden with fabric and ribbons and all the frieries that went into creating the kind of dresses that made young men lose their sense of reason.

We saw the most divine silk.

Isabelle was saying as they came into the parlor where Catherine was reading.

Mama says it will look lovely with my coloring.

I am sure it will, Catherine said and meant it.

Everything looked lovely on Isabelle.

We got fabric for you too, her mother said with the air of someone conferring a great gift.

A nice brown that will be very serviceable.

Brown, of course.

Not that Catherine had expected anything else.

Isabelle got celestial blue silk.

Catherine got serviceable brown.

“Thank you, mama,” she said, because there was nothing else to say.

“Mr.s.

Patterson mentioned that her nephew will be at the social,” her mother continued, settling into her favorite chair.

“He is a lawyer in Witchita, very respectable.

” “How nice for him,” Catherine said, not looking up from her book.

“Catherine.

” Her mother’s voice had taken on that edge of exasperation.

You could at least pretend to be interested in Mr.s.

Patterson’s nephew, whom I have never met in your future.

Catherine closed her book with perhaps more force than necessary.

Mama, we both know that Mr.s.

Patterson’s nephew, like every other man who comes to these socials, will take one look at Isabelle and forget I exist.

Can we please dispense with the pretense? Catherine Vaughn, that is a terrible thing to say about your sister.

I am not saying anything about Isabelle.

I am stating a simple fact.

She is beautiful.

I am not.

Men prefer beautiful.

It is not complicated.

You could be perfectly pretty if you made an effort,” her mother said, which was perhaps the crulest thing she could have said, because it placed the blame squarely on Catherine’s shoulders, as if she could simply decide to be lovely and make it so.

I will wear the brown dress, Catherine said, standing.

“I will go to the social.

I will be perfectly polite to Mr.s.

Patterson’s nephew, but I will not pretend to believe in fairy tales anymore.

” She left before her mother could respond, taking her book with her.

She passed Isabelle in the hallway and her sister touched her arm gently.

“Kate, I am sorry.

I do not mean to.

I know,” Catherine interrupted because she did know.

“Isabelle could no more help being beautiful than Catherine could help being ordinary.

” “It is not your fault.

” In her room, Catherine stood at the window again, looking out over the darkening ranch.

She could see lamplight in the bunk house, hear the faint sound of someone playing a harmonica.

The melody was sad and sweet, and it matched her mood perfectly.

The days leading up to the social past in a blur of activity.

Her mother and Isabelle were consumed with dress fittings and hair arrangements.

Catherine threw herself into ranch work, helping Mr.s.

Chen with preserving the early summer vegetables, reconciling accounts, even riding out to check on the far pastures with her father.

It was during one of these rides that she encountered Owen again.

“He was alone checking fence line in the northwest section, and he looked surprised when Catherine and her father came over the rise.

” “Problem with the fence?” her father asked.

“Nothing major.

A few posts that need reinforcing before winter.

I was making notes on what we will need.

Good man.

Catherine, did you bring the notebook? She had, of course, she always did.

Catherine dismounted and walked over to where Owen stood, pulling the small leather notebook from her saddle bag.

Tell me what you need, she said, pencil poised.

Owen rattled off a list of supplies, his eyes on the fence rather than on her.

Catherine wrote quickly, her handwriting small and efficient.

Anything else? She asked when he paused.

That should do it.

He glanced at her notebook.

You have good handwriting.

Clear.

It was such a small compliment, such a mundane observation, but it warmed her anyway.

Thank you.

My mother despared of ever teaching me proper embroidery, but she had more success with penmanship.

Penmanship is more useful than embroidery on a ranch, Owen said.

And there was something in his tone that might have been humor.

Try telling her that, Catherine said, surprising herself.

She was not usually so free with comments about her family, especially not to near strangers.

Owen’s mouth quirked up at one corner.

I expect every mother wants their daughter to excel at the ladylike arts.

Some daughters are better suited to other arts.

Some daughters, Owen said looking at her directly now, are good at exactly what they need to be good at.

Her father called her name before Catherine could process that statement, and she had to remount and ride on, but she thought about Owen’s words for the rest of the day, turning them over in her mind like interesting stones, examining them from different angles.

The night of the social arrived with all the inevitability of weather.

Catherine dressed in her brown dress, which her mother’s seamstress had done her best to make flattering.

It was wellmade and fit properly, but no amount of skilled sewing could transform brown surge into celestial blue silk.

Isabelle, of course, looked like a vision.

The blue silk brought out her eyes, and her golden hair was arranged in soft curls that must have taken an hour to create.

“You look lovely,” Belle, Catherine said honestly.

“So do you,” Isabelle replied, which was kind, but not true.

The church hall was already crowded when they arrived.

Lanterns had been strung along the rafters, creating pools of golden light.

A small group of musicians tuned their instruments in one corner, while women arranged food on long tables, and men gathered in clusters to talk about cattle prices and weather.

Catherine found her usual spot among the older women and spinsters, settling in for an evening of watching Isabel dance, but she had barely sat down when Mr.s.

Patterson descended with a young man in tow.

Catherine, dear, I want you to meet my nephew, Albert.

Albert, this is Catherine Vaughn.

Albert Patterson was perhaps 28, with thinning hair and the soft hands of someone who worked primarily with paper.

He gave Catherine a polite nod, his eyes already scanning the room.

Pleased to meet you, Miss Vaughn.

And you, Mr. Patterson.

Albert is a lawyer in Witchita, Mr.s.

Patterson said proudly, doing very well for himself.

How interesting, Catherine said, deploying the bland politeness she had perfected over years of these interactions.

And this, Mr.s.

Patterson said, practically purring, is Catherine’s sister, Isabel.

Catherine watched Albert Patterson’s face transform as he caught sight of Isabelle.

It was always the same.

The polite interest dimming, the real interest sparking to life, the slight shift of body position away from Catherine and toward her sister.

“Miss Isabel,” Albert said, his voice noticeably warmer.

“Would you do me the honor of the first dance?” And that was that.

Catherine settled back into her chair and prepared for a long evening of invisibility.

Except then the door opened and Owen Nichols walked in.

He had clearly made an effort, trading his work clothes for clean trousers and a shirt that looked new, his dark hair still damp from washing.

He stood in the doorway for a moment, his eyes scanning the crowd, and Catherine felt her heart do something complicated and probably inadvisable in her chest.

Several of the younger women noticed him immediately.

Catherine watched them whisper behind their fans, assessing this new possibility.

Owen seemed oblivious to the attention, moving instead toward where her father stood talking to some other ranchers.

The music started and Isabelle took the floor with Albert Patterson.

They made a handsome couple, Catherine had to admit, the kind of couple people expected to see together.

She was so focused on not watching them that she did not notice Owen approaching until he was standing directly in front of her.

“Miss Vaughn,” he said, “would you care to dance?” Catherine’s first instinct was to look around, certain he must be addressing someone else.

But his green eyes were fixed on her, patient and steady.

I She started, then stopped.

You do not have to do that.

Do what? Ask me to dance out of pity.

Something flickered across Owen’s face.

Not anger exactly, but close to it.

I do not do things out of pity, Miss Vaughn.

I asked because I wanted to dance with you.

If you do not want to dance with me, just say so and I will go away.

But do not tell me why I did something when you do not know.

It was the most words she had heard him strug together at once, and they hit her like cold water, bracing and clarifying.

Catherine stood, her chin coming up.

I would be happy to dance with you, Mr. Nichols.

His expression softened.

Owen, Catherine.

He offered his arm and she took it, aware of every eye in the room tracking their movement to the dance floor.

The music was a simple waltz, and Owen danced the way he did everything else with quiet competence and no wasted movement.

“You dance well,” Catherine said after they had completed one turn around the floor.

My mother insisted.

She said no son of hers would grow up unable to dance properly.

She sounds formidable.

She was.

Owen’s hand tightened fractionally on Catherine’s waist.

She died of chalera when I was 17, right before I went off to war.

I am sorry.

It was a long time ago.

They turned again and Owen steered them expertly around another couple.

Your sister is very beautiful.

Catherine felt something in her chest close up like a fist.

Of course.

Of course.

He had noticed Isabelle.

Everyone noticed Isabelle.

“Yes, she is,” Catherine said, keeping her voice level.

“You do not look much alike.

” “No.

” Owen was quiet for a moment, and Catherine prepared herself for the inevitable comparison, the gentle suggestion that perhaps he might be introduced to Isabelle, the slow fade of his interest now that he had seen the prettier sister.

“Good,” Owen said.

Catherine missed a step and would have stumbled if Owen had not been holding her securely.

What? I said good.

That you do not look alike.

His eyes met hers and there was something fierce in them, something that made her breath catch.

Because you are beautiful in a completely different way, and it would be a shame if people could not see that.

I Catherine started, but her voice failed.

She tried again.

People do not generally call me beautiful, Owen.

Then people are generally fools.

He said it matterof factly the way he might comment on the weather or the quality of the herd.

You have good bones, strong features, eyes that actually pay attention to things, and when you smile, which you do not do nearly enough, you light up like sunrise.

Catherine felt heat flooding her face, felt something unfamiliar and fragile unfurling in her chest.

You should not say things like that.

Why not? It is true.

Because she stopped, unsure how to articulate the danger in believing him in hoping.

Because words are easy, and I have learned not to trust easy things.

The music ended and they stopped moving, standing in the middle of the dance floor while other couples dispersed around them.

Owen looked at her for a long moment, his expression serious.

“Then I will just have to prove it, won’t I?” he said quietly with more than words.

He escorted her back to her seat, thanked her for the dance, and walked away, leaving Catherine feeling like the ground had shifted beneath her feet, and she was still waiting to find her balance.

The rest of the evening passed in a blur.

Catherine danced twice more, once with Charlie from the ranch who took pity on her, and once with a merchant from town who spent the entire dance talking about the price of flour.

But her mind was elsewhere, circling back again and again to Owen’s words, to the way he had looked at her like she was something worth seeing.

On the ride home, her mother was in high spirits.

Did you see how taken Albert Patterson was with Isabelle? He danced with her three times.

Three times.

That is practically a declaration.

He seemed nice enough, Isabelle said, but she sounded less enthusiastic than their mother.

Nice enough.

He is a lawyer, Isabelle.

A professional man.

You could do far worse.

I suppose, Isabelle said, and caught Catherine’s eye in the darkness of the carriage.

Something passed between them, a understanding that had nothing to do with words.

Isabelle did not love Albert Patterson, would probably never love Albert Patterson.

But their mother would push and maneuver until Isabelle found herself engaged to him anyway because that was what mothers did with beautiful daughters.

They married them off to the best prospect available.

Catherine was spared such minations by virtue of being unmarable which had always seemed like a curse but in that moment felt almost like freedom.

The next morning Catherine was up early as usual helping Mr.s.

Chen with breakfast.

The hands filed in gradually and Catherine poured coffee and served eggs with automatic efficiency until Owen came in and their eyes met across the kitchen.

Something in his expression made her heart skip.

He did not say anything, just gave her a small nod, but Catherine felt it anyway.

That recognition, that promise of something more than words.

After breakfast, she returned to the account books, but found herself unable to concentrate.

The numbers swam before her eyes, meaningless.

Finally, she gave up and went outside, drawn by an impulse she did not fully understand.

She found Owen in the barn repairing a saddle.

He looked up when she entered, his hand stilling on the leather.

“Catherine,” he said, and her name in his mouth sounded like something precious.

I wanted to thank you, she said, moving closer, for last night for the dance.

No thanks necessary.

I enjoyed it.

Most men do not enjoy dancing with me.

They endure it out of politeness.

Owen sat down the saddle and stood, closing the distance between them, until he was close enough that she could see the flex of gold in his green eyes.

I am not most men.

No, Catherine agreed softly.

You are not.

He reached up slowly, giving her time to step back if she wanted to, and tucked a loose strand of hair behind her ear.

His fingers lingered against her cheek, calloused and warm.

“I meant what I said last night,” Owen said, about you being beautiful, about proving it with more than words.

“How the question came out barely above a whisper? by looking at you the way you deserve to be looked at.

By saying it loud enough that other people hear and maybe start to wonder if they have been seeing things wrong all along.

His thumb traced the line of her jaw feather light.

By courting you if you will let me, Catherine’s breath caught.

You want to court me? Yes.

But Isabelle is your sister and I am sure she is a lovely person but I have no interest in courting her.

Owen’s voice was firm.

I want to court you, Catherine.

Just you, if you are willing.

She should say no.

She should protect herself against the inevitable disappointment, against the whispers that would intensify when people saw them together, against the moment when Owen realized his mistake and moved on to someone prettier, someone easier to be seen with.

But looking into his eyes, Catherine found she did not want to say no.

She wanted quite desperately to say yes.

I am willing, she said.

Owen’s smile was slow and devastating.

Good.

Then I should probably do this properly and ask your father’s permission.

He will think you are insane.

I expect a lot of people will think that.

Do you care? Catherine thought about it.

Really thought about it.

Did she care what people thought? the people who had spent her whole life whispering about her plainness, who had never looked past her face to see what lay beneath.

“No,” she said, and felt something like power in the word.

“I do not care at all.

” Owen’s smile widened.

“That is my girl.

” He kissed her, then soft and sweet and careful, his hands coming up to frame her face like she was something precious.

Catherine had never been kissed before, but she kissed him back with an instinct older than thought, her hands gripping the front of his shirt to keep herself steady.

When they finally pulled apart, both breathing hard, Owen rested his forehead against hers.

“I will talk to your father tonight,” he said.

“He will say yes,” Catherine said, surprising herself with the certainty.

He wants me happy, even if he does not always know how to make that happen.

Then I will make it my job to keep you happy,” Owen said, and kissed her again.

True to his word, Owen approached her father that evening after supper.

Catherine was in the parlor with her mother and Isabelle when she heard raised voices from her father’s study.

Not angry exactly, but intense.

Her mother looked up from her needle work.

What on earth? The study door opened and Catherine’s father emerged, followed by Owen.

Her father looked stunned.

Owen looked determined and Catherine felt her heart hammering against her ribs.

“Margaret,” her father said slowly.

“Owen here has asked permission to court Catherine.

” The parlor went utterly silent, her mother’s mouth opened and closed without sound.

Isabelle looked between Catherine and Owen, her expression shifting from surprise to something that might have been delight.

Catherine, her mother finally managed.

Not Isabelle.

Catherine, Owen confirmed, and his voice carried through the room like a bell.

If she will have me.

All eyes turned to Catherine.

She stood, her legs not entirely steady, and crossed to where Owen stood.

Yes, she said clearly.

I will have you.

her father let out a breath.

Well then, I suppose that is settled.

You have my permission, Owen, though I think you are taking on more than you know.

I doubt that, sir, Owen said, and the look he gave Catherine made her feel like she might catch fire from the inside out.

Her mother seemed to be struggling with the reality of the situation.

But Catherine, are you certain, Owen? No offense, but have you met Isabelle? Mama, Isabelle said sharply, standing.

That is enough.

It was perhaps the first time Catherine had ever heard her sister use that tone with their mother.

Isabelle crossed to Catherine and took her hands.

I think it is wonderful, Isabelle said firmly.

Owen clearly has excellent taste.

Catherine felt tears prick her eyes.

Belle, you deserve this, Kate.

You deserve someone who sees you.

Isabelle squeezed her hands, then turned to Owen.

You hurt her, and I will have words with you.

Noted, Owen said seriously, but I do not plan to hurt her.

The next few weeks were unlike anything Catherine had ever experienced.

Owen courted her with a single-minded determination that left her breathless.

He brought her wild flowers from the prairie, the simple blooms more precious than roses.

He sought her out during the day, stealing moments to talk or simply walk together.

He sat beside her at supper and made conversation that actually included her rather than just being polite noise, and he was loud about it.

Owen had no interest in discretion or propriety.

When they went to town together for supplies, he held her hand on the main street where everyone could see.

When people whispered, he ignored them.

When Mr.s.

Patterson made a snide comment about surprising choices, Owen looked her in the eye and said, “The only surprising thing is that someone did not snap Catherine up years ago.

Makes me grateful for other men’s blindness.

” Mr.s.

Patterson had no response to that.

The following Sunday at church, Owen sat with the Vaughn family and held Catherine’s hand during the sermon.

She could feel eyes on them, could practically hear the whispers, but Owen’s hand was warm and steady in hers, and for the first time in her life, Catherine did not care what people said.

After the service, as people milled about outside, Albert Patterson approached with Isabelle on his arm.

He had been courting her with increasing seriousness, much to their mother’s delight.

Nicholls, Albert said with a nod.

I hear congratulations are in order.

You and Miss Catherine are courting.

We are, Owen said easily, his arm coming around Catherine’s waist.

Albert glanced at Isabelle, then back at Owen, and Catherine could see the confusion in his expression.

He was trying to figure out why any man would choose her over Isabelle and coming up empty.

“Well,” Albert said finally, “Best of luck to you both.

” After he and Isabelle had moved on, Owen leaned down to murmur in Catherine’s ear.

“He is an idiot.

He is going to marry my sister.

” Then she is too good for him, but that is her choice to make.

They walked together to where the Vaughn carriage waited, and Catherine felt something shift inside her.

For so long, she had been defined by what she was not.

Not beautiful like Isabelle, not charming like the other girls, not worth looking at twice.

But Owen looked at her like she was the only woman in the world.

And slowly Catherine was beginning to believe that maybe, just maybe, there was more to worth than the arrangement of features on a face.

Summer deepened into July, the heat pressing down on the Kansas prairie like a heavy hand.

The cattle grew lazy in the heat, and the hands worked early mornings and late evenings to avoid the worst of the sun.

Catherine and Owen fell into a rhythm.

She would rise early to help with breakfast, and Owen would linger after the other hands left, stealing a few minutes alone with her in the kitchen, while Mr.s.

Chen pretended not to notice.

During the day, Catherine would work on her accounts or help her mother with the household.

But in the evenings after supper, Owen would walk with her around the ranch, talking about everything and nothing.

He told her about his childhood in Missouri, about a father who drank too much and a mother who held things together through sheer force of will.

He told her about the war, though not in detail, just enough for her to understand that he had seen things no 16-year-old should see.

He told her about the years after, drifting from ranch to ranch, never quite finding a place that felt like home.

“Until now,” he said one evening as they stood watching the sun set over the prairie.

“This feels like it could be home.

The ranch,” Catherine asked.

“You,” Owen corrected, turning to face her.

“Wherever you are, that is where home is.

” He kissed her as the sky turned orange and purple and gold.

and Catherine felt like she was falling and flying at the same time, but not everyone was happy about their courtship.

In town, the whispers intensified.

Catherine heard fragments when she went to the general store or the post office.

How had plain Catherine Vaughn caught such a handsome man? What did he see in her? how long before he came to his senses and turned his attention to Isabelle, who was still available despite Albert Patterson’s best efforts.

The words stung, even though Catherine tried not to let them.

Owen seemed oblivious, or perhaps he just did not care.

He continued to court her publicly and enthusiastically, and if anything, the whispers seemed to make him more demonstrative, not less.

It came to a head on a Saturday in late July.

Catherine had gone to town alone to pick up supplies, and Owen had ridden in later to meet her.

She was in the general store when she heard two women talking in the next aisle, their voices carrying clearly.

“It is embarrassing, really.

” One of them was saying, “That poor man saddled with the ugly sister when everyone knows Isabelle is the real prize.

Do you think he knows he could do better? He must.

Maybe he is after the family money.

[snorts] The Vans are the richest ranch in the county.

Catherine stood frozen, the bolt of fabric in her hands forgotten.

The words were not new, but they still had the power to cut.

Then she heard the bell over the door chime, and Owen’s voice, loud and clear, and carrying through the entire store.

Excuse me, ladies, but I could not help overhearing your conversation, and I feel obligated to correct some misconceptions.

The store went dead silent.

Catherine moved quietly to where she could see the main area without being seen.

Owen stood in the center of the store, his hat in his hands, addressing the two women directly, but his voice was pitched to Carrie, and Catherine knew everyone in the store was listening.

First, Owen said, his tone conversational, but his eyes hard.

I am not saddled with anyone.

I am courting Catherine Vaughn because she is the most remarkable woman I have ever met.

She is smart, capable, kind, and yes, beautiful.

If you cannot see that, the failure is in your vision, not in her face.

One of the women opened her mouth, but Owen continued.

Second, I am not after money.

I work for my living and I am proud of it.

What I am after is a life with a woman who has substance and character which Catherine has in abundance.

He turned slowly, his gaze sweeping the store, making eye contact with everyone present.

Third, and most importantly, the next person I hear call Catherine vaugh ugly in whispers or otherwise will be hearing from me directly, and I promise you that conversation will not be pleasant.

” He settled his hat back on his head.

“Catherine, I know you are here.

Are you ready to go?” Catherine stepped out from behind the shelf, her heart pounding so hard she could feel it in her throat.

Every eye in the store was on her, but for once she did not care.

She walked straight to Owen, who took her hand and laced his fingers through hers.

“I am ready,” she said.

They walked out together, heads high and did not look back in the wagon on the way back to the ranch.

Catherine finally found her voice.

“You did not have to do that.

” “Yes, I did.

” Owen’s jaw was tight.

“I will not have people talking about you like that.

Not now, not ever.

People have been talking about me like that my whole life.

Well, they can stop now.

He pulled the wagon over to the side of the road and turned to face her fully.

Catherine, I need you to understand something.

I do not care what they think.

I do not care what they say.

All I care about is you and how you feel.

Do you believe me when I say you are beautiful? Catherine looked at him at the fierce intensity in his eyes, at the way he held her hand like she was something precious.

I am starting to, she admitted.

Good.

Because I plan to keep saying it until you believe it completely.

I will say it every day for the rest of our lives if I have to.

The rest of our lives.

Catherine’s voice came out barely above a whisper.

Owen reached into his pocket and pulled out a small box.

I was going to wait, do this properly with flowers and moonlight and all the romantic nonsense, but sitting here on a dusty road feels more honest somehow.

He opened the box.

Inside was a simple gold band with a single small stone.

Nothing fancy or elaborate.

Catherine Vaughn, will you marry me? Will you let me spend the rest of my life proving to you and everyone else how extraordinary you are? Catherine looked at the ring, at Owen, at the future spreading out before her like the Kansas prairie, wide and open and full of possibility.

She thought about the whispers, about the years of being second best, about all the reasons she should say no.

Then she thought about the way Owen looked at her, the way he made her feel seen and valued and loved, and all those reasons evaporated like morning dew.

Yes, she said.

Yes, I will marry you.

Owen’s whoop of joy startled the horses, but he did not care.

He pulled Catherine into his arms and kissed her right there on the side of the road, and Catherine kissed him back with her whole heart.

When they finally pulled apart, Owen slipped the ring onto her finger.

It fit perfectly like it had been made for her.

“I love you,” Owen said.

“In case that was not clear.

I love you too, Catherine said, and felt the truth of it settle into her bones, solid and sure.

They drove back to the ranch, hand in hand, and Catherine kept looking at the ring on her finger, marveling at how quickly life could change.

A month ago, she had been resigned to spinsterhood, to a life of managing accounts and being the ugly sister.

Now she was engaged to a man who loved her, who saw her, who was not afraid to tell the whole world how he felt.

Her father was predictably pleased when they announced their engagement.

Her mother was less so, still struggling with the reality that Owen had chosen Catherine over Isabel.

But even she could not deny the obvious affection between them.

Isabelle was genuinely happy for her sister.

And that night she came to Catherine’s room and sat on the bed looking at the ring with a wistful expression.

I am glad you found someone who loves you like that.

Isabel said.

Someone who chooses you and keeps choosing you.

Albert does not choose you.

Catherine asked carefully.

Isabel shrugged.

Albert chooses what I represent.

A pretty wife, a good family connection.

I do not think he knows who I actually am and I do not think he cares to find out.

Then do not marry him.

Mama wants me to.

Belle, you are the one who has to live with him, not Mama.

Isabelle was quiet for a long moment.

You are braver than I am.

Kate, you always have been.

I am not brave.

I am just tired of being invisible.

With Owen, you could never be invisible.

Isabelle stood.

I am happy for you truly.

After she left, Catherine lay in bed turning the ring on her finger, thinking about her sister’s words.

Brave.

She did not feel brave.

She felt terrified and exhilarated and hopeful all at once.

The next few weeks were consumed with wedding preparations.

Catherine wanted something simple, but her mother had other ideas.

They compromised on a ceremony at the ranch with a reception afterward.

big enough to satisfy her mother’s need for propriety, but intimate enough that Catherine would not feel like she was on display.

Owen was patient through all the planning, though Catherine could tell he would have been happy to ride to the nearest preacher and be done with it, but he understood that this was important, that after a lifetime of being overlooked, Catherine deserved a day where she was celebrated.

The wedding was set for the first Saturday in September when the worst of the summer heat would have broken, but the autumn cold had not yet set in.

Owen continued working on the ranch, but he also began making plans for their future.

He and Catherine’s father had several long conversations about Owen’s role on the ranch, eventually agreeing that Owen would take over as foreman with the possibility of buying a stake in the operation down the line.

“Your father is being generous,” Owen told Catherine one evening as they sat on the porch watching fireflies dance in the dusk.

“More generous than I deserve.

You deserve it.

You are a good worker and he trusts you.

” He trusts me with his ranch and his daughter.

That is a heavy responsibility.

Catherine leaned her head on his shoulder.

You are equal to it.

August passed in a blur of activity.

The ranch hands threw together a barn raising for a structure that had been needed for years, and Owen worked alongside them, his shirt off in the heat, muscles moving under sunown skin.

Catherine brought water and lemonade and tried not to stare too obviously at her fianceé.

Charlie caught her looking and grinned.

“You picked a good one, Miss Catherine.

” “I know,” she said, and could not keep the smile off her face.

The wedding dress was finished two weeks before the ceremony.

It was ivory silk, simple in design, but beautifully made.

Nothing like the brown serviceable dresses Catherine usually wore.

When she tried it on for the final fitting, even her mother teared up.

“You look lovely, Catherine,” she said, and it might have been the first time she had ever said those words to her daughter.

Catherine looked at herself in the mirror and saw a woman transformed not by silk and lace, but by love, by being seen and chosen and valued.

Owen had done that.

Owen had looked past the whispers and the comparisons and seen her.

The night before the wedding, Isabelle came to Catherine’s room again.

She was quiet, subdued in a way that made Catherine worry.

“What is wrong?” Catherine asked.

I broke it off with Albert, Isabelle said quietly.

Mama is furious.

What happened? He proposed properly with a ring and everything.

And when he did, I realized I could not do it.

I could not marry a man who loves the idea of me but does not actually know me.

Isabelle twisted her hands together.

You inspired me.

Watching you with Owen, watching how he loves you for who you actually are.

I want that, too.

Catherine pulled her sister into a hug.

You deserve that.

You deserve someone who sees you, not just your pretty face.

Mama says I am being foolish.

That I am 20 and if I do not marry Albert, I might not get another chance.

Mama is wrong.

You have time.

Do not settle, Belle.

They stayed up late talking, sisters in a way they had not been since childhood.

And when Catherine finally fell asleep, it was with a sense of peace she had never felt before.

The wedding day dawned clear and beautiful, the September sky a brilliant blue unmarred by clouds.

Catherine woke early, nerves and excitement churning in her stomach.

Mr.s.

Chen brought her breakfast, but she could barely eat.

Isabelle and her mother helped her dress, pinning her hair and arranging the simple veil.

When Catherine looked in the mirror, she saw a bride radiant with joy.

The ceremony was held in the ranch yard under a bower of prairie wild flowers that Owen and the ranch hands had constructed.

Chairs were arranged in neat rows, and it seemed like half the county had turned out to witness the wedding.

Catherine walked down the makeshift aisle on her father’s arm, but she only had eyes for Owen.

He stood at the front in a new suit, his dark hair neatly combed, his green eyes bright with emotion.

When he saw her, his whole face transformed with a smile so pure and joyful that Catherine felt tears spring to her eyes.

The preacher spoke about love and commitment, about the sacred bond of marriage, but Catherine barely heard him.

She was too focused on Owen, on the way he held her hands like she was the most precious thing in the world.

When it came time for the vows, Owen spoke clearly, his voice carrying to everyone present.

I, Owen Nichols, take you, Catherine Vaughn, to be my wife.

I promise to love you, honor you, and cherish you for all the days of my life.

I promise to see you, really see you, and to make sure you know every single day how extraordinary you are.

Catherine’s voice shook when she spoke her vows, but she meant every word.

I, Catherine Vaughn, take you, Owen Nichols, to be my husband.

I promise to love you, honor you, and cherish you for all the days of my life.

I promise to build a life with you that is full of joy and laughter and all the things that make a house a home.

The preacher pronounced them husband and wife.

And when Owen kissed her, Catherine heard cheers and applause, but it all seemed distant, muffled.

The only thing that mattered was Owen.

The way he held her, the way he looked at her like she was everything.

The reception was a joyful affair.

Ms.

Chen had outdone herself with the food, and the ranch hands had set up tables and chairs in the barn, which had been cleaned and decorated for the occasion.

There was music and dancing and laughter, and Catherine felt like she might burst from happiness.

When it came time for the first dance, Owen led her to the center of the barn floor.

The musician struck up a waltz, and he pulled her close.

“How does it feel to be Mr.s.

nickels,” he murmured in her ear.

Like coming home, Catherine said, “They danced, and Catherine was aware of people watching, but for once the scrutiny did not bother her.

Let them look.

Let them see how Owen loved her, how he held her like she was precious, how he smiled at her like she was the son.

” Later, as the evening wore on and the dancing continued, Catherine overheard two women talking near the refreshment table.

She recognized them as the same women who had been gossiping in the general store weeks earlier.

I must admit, I did not think it would last, one of them was saying.

But you can see how he looks at her.

Really looks at her.

She does seem different somehow.

Happier, more confident.

Love does that, I suppose, changes people.

Catherine smiled to herself and moved on.

They were wrong.

Love had not changed her.

It had just allowed her to become more fully herself, to step out of the shadows she had been hiding in for so long.

As the party wound down, Owen and Catherine said their goodbyes and retreated to the small house on the ranch property that her father had given them as a wedding gift.

It was not large, just a bedroom, a kitchen, and a sitting room, but it was theirs.

Owen carried her over the threshold, both of them laughing, and set her down gently in the middle of the sitting room.

“Alone at last,” he said, pulling her close.

“Was it too much, the wedding? It was perfect.

” “You were perfect.

” Owen cuped her face in his hands.

“I am the luckiest man alive, Catherine Nichols.

” She kissed him, pouring all her love and joy and gratitude into it.

They had the rest of their lives to build together, and Catherine could not wait to start.

That night, in the darkness of their new bedroom, Owen held her and whispered all the things he loved about her.

her strength, her intelligence, her competence, her kindness, the way she saw the world clearly and dealt with it honestly.

Continue reading….
Next »