December 31, 1942.
The Barren Sea 70° north latitude.
Temperatures below minus30° C.
Sea spray freezing on steel before it can drip.
And closing on convoy JW 51B from two directions.
A German heavy cruiser armed with 8-in guns.
A pocket battleship armed with 11in guns and six destroyers.
Enough firepower to wipe out every merchant ship in the formation.
The convoy’s entire protection consists of five British destroyers, each one carrying 4.7 in guns that fire 50 lb shells.
The German heavy cruisers 8-in guns fire 269 lb shells.
The pocket battleship’s 11in guns fire 661lb shells.
One German broadside outweighs the combined firepower of all five destroyers by more than 10 to one.
By every calculation, this is a death sentence.
Captain Robert Sherbrook on HMS Onslow is about to charge that force headon, bluff a German admiral into retreat on four separate occasions without firing a single torpedo and trigger a chain of events that will destroy the entire German surface fleet as a fighting force.
This is the Battle of the Barren Sea.
By late 1942, the Arctic convoy route from Britain to the Soviet Union had become the most dangerous shipping lane on Earth.
German battleships, heavy cruisers, and destroyers lurked in the Norwegian fjords at Altonfield, ready to pounce on any convoy within range.
The disaster of convoy PQ17 the previous summer, where 35 merchant ships were ordered to scatter and 24 were sunk, hung over every planning meeting at the Admiral Ty.
Convoy JW51B sailed from Loachu, Scotland on December 22 with 14 merchant ships carrying over 2,000 vehicles, 202 tanks, 120 aircraft, and tens of thousands of tons of fuel and supplies desperately needed by the Red Army at Stalingrad.
Losing this cargo was not an option.
The escort was thin.
Captain Sherbrook commanded five destroyers of the 17th flatilla.
His flagship HMS Onslow was an O-class destroyer displacing 1610 tons standard.
She was 345 ft long, powered by 40,000 shaft horsepower on two shafts, capable of 36.75 knots.
Her armament consisted of four single 4.7 in guns, one quadruple torpedo tube mounting, and various anti-aircraft weapons.
Her four sisters, HMS Obedient, Objurat, Orwell, and the older Aclass destroyer, HMS Ashettes, carried similar firepower.
Distant cover came from Rear Admiral Bernett’s Force R, two light cruisers, HMS Sheffield, a Townclass cruiser of 9,100 tons, and HMS Jamaica, a Crown Colony class of 8,631 tons.
each carried 12 6-in guns in four triple turrets and could make 32 knots.
But a navigational error placed Bernette roughly 30 m north of the convoy rather than close a stern.
When the battle began, his cruisers would be too far away to help immediately.
The German plan was operation reanogen, meaning rainbow.
Vice Admiral Oscar Kumitz would attack from the north with the heavy cruiser Admiral Hipper and three destroyers drawing the escort away.
Then Captain Rudolph Stanganger would sweep in from the south with the pocket battleship Lutzo and three more destroyers to slaughter the undefended merchants.
It was a textbook pinser movement with overwhelming force.
Admiral Hipper displaced 16,170 tons standard.
Her 88 in guns could hurl 269lb shells over 36,000 yd.
She carried 12 torpedo tubes, armor plating of up to 150 mm on her conning tower, and a compliment of nearly 1,400 men.
Lutzau, originally commissioned as Deutseland and renamed because Hitler feared the propaganda disaster if a ship bearing Germany’s name was sunk, displaced 12,630 tons.
Her 61in guns could reach targets beyond 36,000 yd.
Each shell weighed approximately 661 lb.
Against this, Sherbrook had five destroyers with no armor whatsoever.
But he had one weapon the Germans feared, torpedoes.
A single 21-in torpedo could sink any ship afloat.
And he had a plan.
Before sailing, Sherbrook had pre-arranged a detailed defensive scheme.
The moment contact was made, Ashhatis would lay smoke between the convoy and the enemy.
The convoy would turn away and his striking force of four Oakclass destroyers would charge directly at whichever enemy ship appeared, presenting the torpedo threat that Comets had been explicitly ordered to avoid.
That order was the key to everything.
After losing the battleship Bismar in May 1941, Hitler had forbidden risking capital ships in aggressive action.
Kumitz received instructions stating, “Use caution even against enemy of equal strength because it is undesirable for the cruisers to take any great risks.” He had the firepower to annihilate the entire convoy in minutes.
He did not have permission to use it.
At 08:30 on December the 31, HMS Objurat reported two unidentified destroyers bearing west.
Sherbrook activated his defensive plan immediately.
Onslow, Obedient, Objurate, and Orwell turned toward the threat.
A Catis began laying her smoke screen.
At 09:15, the unidentified ships opened fire.
The battle was on.
Minutes later, Sherbrook made out the shape he’d been dreading.
A large silhouette in the Arctic twilight, turning to show her full profile.
Admiral Hipper, 16,000 tons against his 1600, 8 in guns against 4.7 in.
Sherbrook’s response was immediate.
He drove on slow straight at Hipper.
His 4.7 in guns could not seriously damage a heavy cruiser, but his torpedoes could sink one.
On four separate occasions over the next hour, Sherbrook turned his destroyers as if to launch torpedo attacks.
Each time Comets pulled Hipper back, unwilling to accept the risk his orders forbade.
Each time the German gave ground, Sherbrook closed in again, pushing Hipper further from the convoy and unknowingly toward Bernett’s approaching cruisers.
Sherbrook never actually fired his torpedoes.
The bluff was the weapon.
If you are finding this deep dive into Royal Navy tactics compelling, a quick subscribe helps the channel and means you will not miss the next one.
At 10:16, the twilight briefly cleared.
Hipper’s gunnery found its mark.
38in shells struck HMS Onslow in rapid succession.
The first shattered the radar antenna and sent thousands of steel splinters raking across the bridge.
A large fragment struck Sherbrook in the face, smashing his cheekbone, his nose, and his forehead.
His left eye was left hanging from its socket.
Two of Onslow’s four guns were destroyed.
17 men were killed and over 20 wounded in moments.
What happened next to find the battle’s legacy? For several seconds, no one on the bridge realized Sherbrook was wounded.
He kept giving orders in an even steady voice.
Another officer found himself covered in blood and thought he himself had been hit before realizing it was the captain’s.
Despite catastrophic injuries and near blindness, Sherbrook refused medical attention until he confirmed that Lieutenant Commander Kinlock on Obedient had taken tactical control.
Even then, he demanded continuous reports until the convoy was safe.
Throughout the morning, HMS Ashetes made herself a target, silhouetted against her own smoke as she screened the merchantmen.
At approximately 11:15, Hipper’s guns found her.
An 8-in shell destroyed her bridge, killing her captain, Lieutenant Commander John’s, and roughly 40 of her crew.
First Lieutenant Loftess Payton Jones, 24 years old, crawled forward through the wreckage and took command.
Despite catastrophic flooding and a worsening list, Aatis continued laying smoke for nearly two more hours.
She died protecting her charges.
The mind sweeper HMS Bramble, just 875 tons with two 4-in guns, had stumbled into Hipper’s path while searching for stragglers.
Commander Rust opened fire on the 16,000 ton cruiser with his two guns.
It was hopeless, but defiant.
Hipper and her escorts destroyed Bramble with all 121 crew.
There were no survivors.
Meanwhile, the German plan had worked perfectly in one respect.
The convoy had turned south directly into Lutz’s path.
Captain Stang had merchant ships visible at ranges between 3 and 7 mi.
His six 11in guns had a maximum range exceeding 15 mi.
No British warship stood between him and the convoy.
He did not press the attack.
He fired 87 11in rounds and 75 6-in rounds without scoring a single hit on any merchant ship.
The combination of Hitler’s restrictive orders, poor visibility, and excessive caution produced one of the war’s most staggering failures.
At approximately 11:30, Bernett’s two cruisers arrived.
HMS Sheffield and HMS Jamaica appeared from the north, completely unseen, and opened fire on Admiral Hipper.
A 6-in shell crashed into Hipper’s number three boiler room, cutting her speed.
Two more hits followed.
At 11:49, Comets ordered a general withdrawal.
In the confusion, German destroyer Z16 Friedrich Eckled mistook Sheffield for her own flagship and closed to point blank range.
Sheffield opened fire with everything she had.
Friedrich Eckled broke in two and sank in under 2 minutes.
All 325 crew were lost.
By 1300, the German force was in full retreat.
HMS Aes finally capsized and sank between 1330 and 1400 after Payton Jones ordered abandoned ship.
The Trollwler Northern Gem rescued 81 survivors.
113 of Ahatti’s crew were dead.
All 14 merchant ships reached Mman safely.
Every tank, every truck, every aircraft arrived intact.
Hitler spent New Year’s Eve waiting for news of a great victory.
Early reports hinted at British ships burning.
Then hours of silence.
No word from Kumitz who maintained radio silence per procedure.
Finally, a message arrived, not from his own navy, but copied from a British Reuters news flash announcing that the Royal Navy had fought off a superior German force.
Hitler’s fury was volcanic.
He declared the surface fleet utterly useless, a breeding ground for revolution, and ordered every capital ship scrapped and the crews sent to the front.
On January 6, 1943, Grand Admiral Eric Rder reported to the Wolf’s Lair.
Hitler delivered a tirade lasting 90 minutes condemning the German Navy’s entire history since 1866.
Raider submitted a 5,000word memorandum defending the fleet.
It changed nothing.
On January 30, Raider resigned.
Admiral Carl Donitz, the Yubot commander, replaced him as head of the Creeks Marine.
Donit saved most of the ships by arguing they served as a fleet in being tying down Royal Navy resources even while sitting idle.
But the damage was done.
The surface fleet was effectively finished as an offensive force.
Only one more major sorty occurred.
The Battle of the North Cape on December 26th, 1943 when Shanho attacked Convoy JW55B and was sunk by HMS Duke of York.
In a fitting echo, that convoy was escorted by HMS On Enslow, Orwell, Sheffield, and Jamaica.
The same ships that had humiliated the Creeks Marine one year earlier.
Captain Sherbrook received the Victoria Cross.
He lost the sight in his left eye permanently.
He continued serving in the Royal Navy and retired as a Rear Admiral in 1957.
He always maintained the medal was awarded in honor of the whole crew of Onslow.
The Battle of the Barren Sea was not decided by tonnage or gun caliber.
Five destroyers totaling roughly 8,000 tons held off warships totaling over 40,000 tons.
Not because the British had superior weapons, but because one side was willing to die, and the other was forbidden to risk losing.
Sherbrook’s four torpedo faints, never firing a single torpedo, may be the most cost-effective bluff in naval history.
The specifications favored Germany.
The combat doctrine favored Britain.
The results confirmed what the Royal Navy had always understood.
Aggressiveness in the face of impossible odds is not suicidal.
It is how destroyer captains win battles.
And on the last day of 1942, in 4 hours of Arctic twilight, five British destroyers proved that lesson so completely that Hitler dismantled his own fleet in rage.
British naval excellence was not built on caution.
It was built on the willingness to charge.
News
A Single Dad Helped a Deaf Woman at the Airport — He Had No Idea Her Daughter Was a CEO!..
I was standing in the middle of one of the busiest airports in the country, surrounded by hundreds of people rushing to their gates, dragging suitcases, staring at their phones, completely absorbed in their own little worlds. And in the middle of all that chaos, there was this older woman, elegantly dressed, silver hair pinned […]
“They Made Us Line Up.” What Cowboys Did Next Left Japanese Comfort Girls POWs Shocked
They were told they would be stripped, punished, paraded. Instead, they were told to line up and handed dresses. The boots of the guards thudded softly against dry Texas soil as the sun climbed higher. A line of exhausted Japanese women stood barefoot in the dust, their eyes hollow, their uniforms torn. They had once […]
“They Made Us Line Up.” What Cowboys Did Next Left Japanese Comfort Girls POWs Shocked – Part 2
Another girl flinched when a medic approached her with a stethoscope. She covered her chest with both arms. Trembling, the medic froze, then slowly knelt down and placed the stethoscope against his own heart, tapping it twice, and smiled. She didn’t smile back, but she let him listen. One girl had a bruised wrist, deep […]
“They Made Us Line Up.” What Cowboys Did Next Left Japanese Comfort Girls POWs Shocked – Part 3
The field where they had learned to laugh again, the post where someone always left tea, the porch where banjos had played. And the men, the cowboys, the medics, the guards, they stood watching, hats in hand. Not victors, not jailers, just men changed, too. Because the truth was the war had ended long ago. […]
He Found Germany’s Invisible Weapon — At Age 28, With a $20 Radio
June 21st, 1940. 10 Downing Street, the cabinet room. Reginald Victor Jones arrives 30 minutes late to a meeting already in progress. He’s 28 years old, the youngest person in the room by decades. Winston Churchill sits at the head of the table, 65, prime minister for 6 weeks. Around him, Air Chief Marshall Hugh […]
He Found Germany’s Invisible Weapon — At Age 28, With a $20 Radio – Part 2
She memorizes them near photographic memory. Her September 1943 WTEL report identifies Colonel Max Waktell, gives precise operational details, maps planned launch locations from Britney to the Netherlands. When Jones inquires about the source, he’s told only one of the most remarkable young women of her generation. Rouso is arrested in April 1944. Survives three […]
End of content
No more pages to load
