March 15, 1943.
The North Atlantic, 40 nautical miles southwest of Iceland.
The seas run gray and cold beneath a March sky that promises snow.
On the bridge of a Vicar’s Wellington bomber, Squadron leader James Thompson watches the surface of the ocean through binoculars, searching for the telltale wake that betrays a submarine running on the surface.
His aircraft has been airborne for 6 hours, patrolling a sector where convoy HX229 lost three merchant ships the previous night.
The yubot responsible is still out there somewhere in these waters.
And Thompson knows he has perhaps 30 seconds between visual contact and the moment when the German captain spots him and orders a crash dive.
30 seconds to close the distance.
30 seconds before the submarine slips beneath the waves and disappears into the murky depths where aircraft cannot follow.
Then his co-pilot calls out, three points off the starboard bow, a dark gray shape cutting through the swells.
Thompson banks the Wellington hard over, throttles pushed forward, and as the distance closes, he can see figures scrambling on the Yubot’s conning tower.
The submarine already beginning its emergency dive.
The bow dips.
Water foams white along the deck.
In 20 seconds, perhaps less, the submarine will be gone.
But Thompson’s aircraft carries something the Germans do not yet understand.
Something that has transformed this encounter from a near miss into a death sentence.
In the bomb bay of his Wellington sits a weapon that renders the traditional 30-second window irrelevant.
A device so revolutionary that it will help turn the tide of the Battle of the Atlantic and save thousands of merchant sailors from drowning in burning oil.
This is the story of the Mark 24 mine, though that designation was itself a deception.
The British called it a mine to confuse German intelligence.
The Americans who later adopted it called it Pho.
But its proper name, the name that described what it actually was, was far more ominous.
The airdropped acoustic homing torpedo.
The problem facing coastal command in 1942 was straightforward in concept, but brutally difficult in execution.
German Ubot were sinking merchant ships faster than Allied shipyards could replace them.
In November 1942 alone, Ubot sent 119 ships to the bottom, totaling over 700,000 tons of shipping.
The mathematics were unsustainable.
Britain imported virtually everything, food, fuel, raw materials for munitions.
If the Atlantic supply line were severed, the war would be lost regardless of what happened on any battlefield.
The Ubot hunted in packs, surfacing at night to attack convoys with deck guns and torpedoes, then diving at first light before aircraft could catch them.
Coastal command aircraft patrolled endlessly, searching thousands of square miles of ocean for targets that appeared as mere specks against the waves.
When a submarine was spotted, the pilot had perhaps 30 seconds, 45 if fortunate, between visual contact and the moment the Yubot completed its crash dive.
A type seven Yubot, the most common German submarine, could fully submerge in approximately 35 seconds from the order to dive.
In that narrow window, the aircraft had to close to weapons release range, line up the attack, and drop conventional depth charges with sufficient accuracy that they would detonate close enough to the submarine to cause fatal damage.
The problem was that depth charges designed for surface ships fell in a ballistic arc.
They had to be released with precise timing and aim, accounting for the aircraft’s speed, altitude, and the submarine’s own movement.
If the pilot released too early, the charges fell harmlessly a stern, too late, and they exploded ahead of the diving submarine.
Even a direct hit was no guarantee.
Depth charges required precise depth settings to explode at the right level beneath the surface, and a submarine diving at emergency speed moved unpredictably, tilting bowdown at steep angles as the captain ordered full ahead and flooded the ballast tanks.
Statistics from 1941 and early 1942 painted a grim picture.
Coastal command aircraft were making contact with Ubot, forcing them to dive, disrupting their patrol patterns, but actual kills were rare.
Estimates suggested that perhaps one in 50 attacks resulted in a confirmed sinking.
The mathematics were brutal.
Coastal Command was flying thousands of sorties, burning through fuel and air crews and aircraft for a handful of kills.
Meanwhile, the Ubot continued their slaughter of merchant shipping.
Something had to change, and it had to change quickly.
The solution emerged not from a single flash of inspiration, but from the convergence of several technologies, some of which had been in development for years.
The critical innovation was acoustic homing, a torpedo that could listen for the sound of a submarine’s propellers and steer itself toward the target without human intervention.
The concept was not entirely new.
German and American engineers were exploring similar ideas.
But it was the British who first made it practical for anti-ubmarine warfare.
The development took place primarily at the Admiral T’s research facilities with substantial input from the telecommunications research establishment.
The basic principle was elegant.
A submarine in motion generates noise, particularly from its propellers and engine.
This noise propagates through water far more efficiently than through air.
A torpedo equipped with a microphone, properly speaking, a hydrophone, could detect that noise and use it to guide itself toward the source.
The engineering challenges were immense.
The torpedo had to be small enough and light enough to be carried by aircraft.
It had to survive the shock of being dropped from altitude into the sea.
Its acoustic sensor had to distinguish submarine noise from the general cacophony of the ocean, from waves and ship engines and the torpedo’s own propulsion system.
And it had to do all of this reliably in the freezing waters of the North Atlantic in a package simple enough to be mass- prodduced.
The weapon that emerged was a masterpiece of compact engineering.
The Mark 24 measured just under 2 m in length and weighed approximately 310 kg, roughly the weight of four DAL men.
Its diameter was 19 in, which made it compatible with standard torpedo tubes should surface ships wish to use it, though its primary deployment was always intended to be from aircraft.
The warhead carried 42 kg of Torpex, an explosive compound more powerful than TNT, sufficient to crack a pressure hull if detonated within a few meters.
The propulsion system was electric, powered by batteries, which solved one of the critical problems.
An electric motor ran nearly silent, unlike the compressed air or combustion engines used in conventional torpedoes.
This was essential because the acoustic sensor had to hear the target, not the torpedo’s own propulsion.
The sensor itself was a marvel of miniaturization.
Mounted in the nose, it consisted of four hydrophones arranged to provide directional information.
When the torpedo entered the water and activated, the hydrophones began listening for propeller noise in specific frequency ranges known to be generated by submarines.
The electronics compared the signal strength from each hydrophone and adjusted the torpedo’s rudder to steer toward the loudest source.
The system was simple, which made it reliable, but it worked.
The torpedo ran in a circular search pattern if it did not immediately detect a target spiraling outward to cover a larger area.
Once it acquired a sound source matching its target profile, it straightened its course and homeed in, accelerating to approximately 12 knots.
This was slow compared to conventional torpedoes, which could exceed 40 knots, but speed was not the priority.
Stealth was.
A submarine captain who saw a fast torpedo track approaching could attempt evasive maneuvers.
An acoustic homing torpedo gave no visual warning.
It simply appeared from the depths, drawn inexorably toward the noise of the submarine’s own propellers.
Manufacturing took place at several facilities with final assembly concentrated at Green in Scotland.
Production numbers remain partially classified even today, but estimates suggest that approximately 4,000 Mark 24 torpedoes were produced during the war with the majority delivered in 1943 and 1944.
Each weapon cost roughly £3,000, a significant sum, but far less than the cost of a merchant ship and its cargo.
The first operational use of the Mark 24 came in May 1943 during the period that would later be called the turning point of the Battle of the Atlantic.
Coastal Command, Wellingtons, and Liberators began carrying the new weapon, though strict secrecy surrounded its deployment.
Air crews were briefed that the weapon was a mine, not a torpedo, and they were instructed to report attacks as mine drops in their logs.
The deception was deliberate.
If a Hubot survived an attack and reported being struck by what appeared to be a mine, German naval intelligence would draw the wrong conclusions about British weapons development.
The first confirmed kill occurred on May 12th, 1943 when a Wellington of 172 Squadron attacked U456 in the North Atlantic.
The submarine had been caught on the surface and was in the process of diving when the aircraft arrived.
The pilot dropped a Mark 24 from low altitude.
The torpedo entered the water, activated its sensor, detected the submarine’s propellers, and homeed in.
Witnesses aboard the aircraft reported seeing a column of water and debris erupt from the ocean surface approximately 40 seconds after the drop.
U456 did not resurface.
All hands were lost.
Over the following months, the weapon proved its worth repeatedly.
Ubot caught diving were particular vulnerable because the crash dive maneuver required the submarine to run its electric motors at maximum power, generating significant noise.
The faster the submarine tried to escape, the louder it became and the easier it was for the Mark 24 to track.
Some captains, realizing they had been spotted, would shut down their engines and attempt to glide silently to depth, but this tactic rarely worked.
The momentum from a surface run was insufficient to carry the boat deep enough quickly enough.
Records from coastal command cross referenced with German naval archives after the war suggest that the Mark 24 was responsible for sinking or severely damaging at least 37 new boats.
The true number may be higher as some losses attributed to other causes might have involved Mark 24 attacks where the aircraft crew did not observe the results.
The psychological impact on yubot crews was substantial.
Submariners knew that a crash dive offered escape from conventional depth charges.
They knew the mathematics of time and distance.
They knew that if they could get below 50 m before the aircraft released its weapons, they had a good chance of survival.
The Mark 24 changed that calculation entirely.
Now diving was no longer guaranteed safety.
The very act of running the motors to dive made the submarine more vulnerable.
Some Yuboat captains began reporting mysterious explosions during or shortly after crash dives.
Explosions that seemed to come from nowhere with no warning of bombs falling or depth charges detonating overhead.
German naval intelligence initially dismissed these reports as confused accounts of near misses with conventional weapons, but gradually a pattern emerged.
Something new was in the water.
If you’re finding this interesting, a quick subscribe helps more than you know.
The Germans did eventually develop their own acoustic torpedoes designated T5 Zancunig or Ren.
These weapons entered service in late 1943 and were designed for submarine to ship attacks, homing in on the propeller noise of escort destroyers.
The T5 was larger and faster than the Mark 24 with a speed of approximately 24 knots and a warhead of 274 kg.
However, it was designed for an entirely different tactical situation.
The T5 was fired from a submerged submarine at surface ships where its higher speed allowed it to catch fastm moving destroyers.
The Mark 24, by contrast, was optimized for the specific scenario of an aircraft attacking a diving submarine.
Its slower speed and electric propulsion made it nearly undetectable, whilst its compact size allowed aircraft to carry multiple weapons.
The Americans adopted the Mark 24 enthusiastically after being briefed on its capabilities in mid 1943.
They designated it the Mark 24 mine using the same deceptive nomenclature, though American air crews nicknamed it Pho after the faithful dog that would not let go once it had ascent.
American production supplemented British manufacturing, and US Navy patrol aircraft operating in the Atlantic and Pacific began achieving similar success rates.
The German Navy never developed a direct equivalent to the Mark 24 for anti-ubmarine use, partly because Germany lacked the extensive air coverage over convoy routes that would have made such a weapon tactically useful, and partly because their submarine force was the hunter, not the hunted.
until relatively late in the war.
By the time German engineers might have prioritized such a weapon, resources were being diverted to other desperate measures.
The Japanese Navy experimented with acoustic torpedoes late in the war, but never fielded an operational equivalent to the Mark 24.
The British weapon remained unique in its specific application.
An airdropped acoustic homing torpedo optimized for attacking submarines caught on the surface.
The strategic impact of the Mark 24 extended beyond the raw numbers of Yubot sunk.
Every submarine that went to the bottom took with it 50 odd trained submariners, men who represented years of training and experience.
But more importantly, the weapon changed yubot tactics in ways that reduced their effectiveness.
Captains became more cautious about surfacing during daylight, even in areas where air patrols were sparse.
The need to recharge batteries and refresh air supplies meant they could not remain submerged indefinitely.
But the risk calculation had shifted.
A hubot that spent more time submerged was a yubot that covered less distance, found fewer targets, and expended more of its limited battery capacity on evasion rather than pursuit.
The increased caution translated directly into reduced sinkings of merchant ships.
The Mark 24 was one element among many in the complex matrix of technologies and tactics that eventually won the battle of the Atlantic.
long range patrol aircraft, improved radar, better convoy tactics, the breaking of German naval codes, escort carriers, and sheer industrial production all played critical roles.
But the acoustic homing torpedo represented something qualitatively different.
A weapon that exploited the enemy’s own evasive maneuvers against him.
The faster a yubot tried to escape, the more noise it made and [clears throat] the more vulnerable it became.
After the war, surviving Mark 24 torpedoes were carefully preserved, and examples can be seen today at the Imperial War Museum Duxford and the Fleet AirArm Museum in Yovilton.
Stripped of their explosives and batteries, they appear almost innocuous, dull gray cylinders with small fins at the tail.
But these unassuming devices helped ensure that thousands of merchant sailors reached port safely, that fuel and food and munitions continued flowing across the Atlantic, and that Britain remained in the war.
The technology pioneered in the Mark 24 influenced all subsequent acoustic torpedo development.
Modern anti-ubmarine torpedoes, whether dropped from helicopters or fired from submarines, employ far more sophisticated sensors and guidance systems, but the fundamental principle remains the same.
Use the target’s own noise against it.
Guide the weapon to its prey with minimal human intervention.
March 15th, 1943.
The North Atlantic.
Squadron leader Thompson watches the column of water subside where U,456 went down.
His crew is silent, understanding what they have just witnessed.
A Yubot crew of 50 men has just died, drowned or crushed by pressure as their hull collapsed.
There is no satisfaction in this, only grim necessity.
The submarine they have just sunk will not attack convoy HX229 tonight.
It will not send merchant sailors to die in burning oil.
It will not fire torpedoes into ships carrying food for Britain’s cities or ammunition for Britain’s armies.
The Wellington turns for home, its bomb bay empty, its fuel running low.
In the water below, the Mark 24 that killed U456 has already sunk into the depths.
Its battery exhausted, its propeller still.
The ocean keeps its secrets.
The weapon that changed the battle of the Atlantic did so quietly, without fanfare, without the drama of battleship duels or fighter combat.
It was a cylinder of metal and electronics and explosive dropped from an aircraft into the cold Atlantic where it listened for the sound of an enemy trying to escape and followed that sound to its conclusion.
The Hubot learned to fear it.
They called it different things, inventing explanations for the mysterious explosions that plagued their crash dives.
But the men who died never understood what killed them, never saw the weapon approaching, never had the chance to evade or fight back.
They heard only the sound of their own propellers driving them deeper, driving them to safety.
And then they heard nothing at all.
The Mark 24 mine that was not a mine.
The secret weapon that hunted submarines with their own noise, the torpedo that helped ensure Britain would not starve, would not surrender, would survive to see victory.
In the cold mathematics of war, it was brutally effective.
In the history of anti-ubmarine warfare, it was revolutionary.
And in the dark waters of the Atlantic, it was absolutely lethal.
