At 10:47 a.m.
on February 1st, 1944, Second Lieutenant John Cronin pulls back on the yolk of his B24 Liberator over Lind, Austria.
Climbing through 20,000 ft.
The sky is crystal clear.
Visibility unlimited.
Temperature outside reads -30° F.
23 years old, seven missions into his tour.
Bombader training completed at Lowry Field, Colorado just eight months earlier.
His aircraft nicknamed the Lady Be Good carries a full bomb load.
10 crew members, four Pratt and Whitney are 1830 engines drone in synchronized rhythm.
The formation flies tight.
32 B24s from the 454th Bombardment Group.
Target rail marshalling yard supplying German forces on the eastern front.
300 m to the south.
Aubberlutin Fran Stigler climbs into his Messid BF 109G6 at Stair Airfield.
27 years old commercial pilot before the war.
Lufanza now a fighter pilot with 28 confirmed kills.
His aircraft carries two 13 mm machine guns, one 20 mm cannon, one 30 mm cannon in the nose.
Enough firepower to shred a bomber in seconds.
The Luwaffa scrambles 12 fighters.
Intelligence reports a massive American formation approaching.
The Third Reich is bleeding.
Bomber raids destroy factories faster than slave labor can rebuild them.
Every intercepted bomber matters.
Every American crew killed means one less raid next week.
Cronin’s bombadier, Staff Sergeant Charlie Davis, lies prone in the nose section.
Nordon bomb site between his knees.
Clear plexiglass bubble gives him a perfect view forward and down.
He can see the Austrian countryside below.
snow-covered mountains, the Danube River threading through valleys.
He’s from Milwaukee.
Worked in a brewery before enlisting.
Never imagined he’d die 20,000 ft above Austria.
The fighter attacks begin at 10:43 a.m.
Head-on passes.
The Germans learned this tactic in 1943.
Dive from above.
Aim for the cockpit.
Break away at the last second.
American bombers have minimal forward armament.
Just 250 caliber machine guns in the nose turret.
Everything else points backward or to the sides.
Stigler selects his target.
AB 24 slightly left of formation center.
He dives.
Air speed builds to 400 mph.
The bomber grows larger in his gun sight.
He can see the pilot’s face now.
Young, terrified.
His thumb hovers over the firing button.
But something goes wrong.
His engine coughs.
A fuel mixture problem.
The BF109 loses 50 mph in 3 seconds.
He’s going to overshoot.
He pulls back on the stick.
The fighter’s propeller hits the B-24’s nose at a combined closing speed of 450 mph.
The sound is not an explosion.
It’s a grinding, tearing screech.
Metal ripping through metal.
The BF-1009’s threeblade propeller chews through plexiglass, aluminum frame, and human flesh.
Davis dies instantly.
The propeller cuts through his torso.
His body disintegrates.
Blood sprays across the bombader’s compartment.
The nose section peels away like aluminum foil.
The propeller blades shatter.
One blade embeds in the B24’s forward fuselage.
Another spins away, tumbling toward Earth.
The third remains partially attached, bent at a 90° angle.
Stigler’s aircraft shutters violently.
The engine seizes.
Oil pressure drops to zero.
The propeller is gone.
Just a jagged hub remains.
The nose cone is crushed.
The engine continues spinning but produces zero thrust.
He’s flying a 7,000lb glider at 20,000 ft.
Cronin feels the impact through the control column.
A massive jolt like hitting a brick wall.
The aircraft pitches nose down.
Air speed drops.
The engines roar at full throttle, but the plane is falling.
He looks forward.
There’s no nose, just a gaping hole.
Wind screams through the opening at 200 mph.
The temperature inside the cockpit drops 30° in 10 seconds.
Before you know how Cronin’s desperate flight turned out, please hit that like button.
It helps us share more forgotten stories like this one.
Please subscribe if you haven’t already.
Let’s continue.
The B 24 Liberator is not a forgiving aircraft.
Pilots call it the flying coffin.
High wing loading, narrow wings.
It falls out of the sky if you lose air speed.
Stall speed is 95 mph.
Below that, you’re a brick.
The Davis wing design gives excellent high altitude performance, but offers no margin for error at low speeds.
Cronin’s aircraft now has 30% more drag.
The missing nose section creates a massive air bra.
The opening measures 6 ft across.
Wind resistance is immense.
The four engines, each producing 1,200 horsepower, struggle to maintain altitude.
The aircraft descends at 300 ft per minute despite full power.
His co-pilot, Second Lieutenant Robert Wilson, stares at the hole where Davis used to be.
Blood freezes on the bulkhead.
The intercom crackles.
The tail gunner reports the collision.
He watched the whole thing.
Says the fighter is still flying, falling but flying.
Stigler sits in his cockpit, mind racing.
The engine temperature gauge climbs.
Without the propeller creating air flow, the engine will overheat and catch fire.
He shuts it down, pulls the mixture to idle cutff, hits the magneto switches, the engine dies.
Silence, just wind noise.
Now, a BF 109 glides at a ratio of 10:1.
For every 1,000 ft of altitude, he can travel 2 mi forward.
Simple mathematics.
He’s at 19,500 ft.
He can glide 39 mi.
Stair airfield is 43 mi away.
He won’t make it, but American lines are 30 mi southeast.
If he can glide there, he might survive as a prisoner.
German pilots don’t surrender easily.
Not in 1944.
The Gestapo interviews families of pilots who surrender, questions their loyalty, suggests cowardice.
His parents live in Munich.
He won’t risk them.
There’s a field 8 mi ahead.
Agricultural land, snow covered.
It’ll have to work.
Cronin fights the controls.
The B 24 wants to roll left.
The missing nose section shifts the center of gravity.
He trims the elevators, adds right aileron.
The aircraft stabilizes but continues descending.
He does the math.
They’re losing altitude at 300 ft per minute.
They’re at 19,800 ft.
That gives them 66 minutes of flying time.
66 minutes to reach friendly territory.
They’re 280 mi from the Italian coastline.
Allied forces control southern Italy.
If they can cross the Adriatic Sea, they might survive.
Their current ground speed is 140 mph with full power.
That’s not enough.
They’ll fall into Austria or Yugoslavia behind enemy lines.
Wilson suggests bailing out.
Nine crew members can still jump, but Cronin shakes his head.
The bomb load is still attached.
2500B bombs.
If they bail out, the bomber falls on some Austrian village.
Civilians die, women, children.
He won’t allow it.
He keys the intercom, tells the bombardier to salvo the bombs, then remembers there is no bombader.
Davis is dead.
The bomb release controls are in the nose section.
The nose section that no longer exists.
He’ll have to carry the bombs to the crash site.
The navigator, second lieutenant James Mitchell, appears beside him, crawled up from the nose wheel well.
His face is white.
He saw Davis die.
Saw the body come apart.
He’s holding a map.
Points to a spot.
Says there’s a British airfield in southern Italy.
300 miles.
They might make it if they throw everything overboard.
They begin jettisoning equipment.
The waste gunners throw out ammunition cans.
The ball turret gunner climbs out and disconnects the turret mounting.
400 lb of metal and glass tumbles into space.
They pull up floor panels.
Tear out radio equipment.
Everything goes.
Every pound matters.
The bomber climbs 50 ft per minute now.
still descending but slower.
Cronin does the calculation again.
79 minutes of flight time remaining.
300 mi to safety.
Ground speed 150 mph.
Now that they’re lighter, they need to fly for 2 hours.
They have 79 minutes.
It won’t work.
Stigler’s glide is smooth.
The BF 109 handles well without power.
He’s glided before.
Training exercise in 1941.
Engine failure over the Baltic Sea.
He made it back then.
He’ll make it now.
The altimeter unwinds.
18,000 ft.
17,000 16,000 The field ahead looks perfect.
Long flat.
No trees, no buildings, just snow.
He’ll land downwind.
No choice.
The glide angle is fixed.
He gets one attempt.
At 5,000 ft, he lowers the landing gear.
The hydraulic system still works.
The wheels drop and lock.
Drag increases.
The aircraft descends faster.
He’s committed now.
At 1,00 ft, he lowers flaps.
20°.
The BF 109 slows.
Stall speed increases.
He’s balanced on a knife edge.
Too slow and he falls.
Too fast and he overshoots the field.
The ground rushes up.
No.
Furrows.
A stone wall at the far end.
He flares.
The tail drops.
The main wheels touch.
Snow sprays.
The aircraft bounces.
Touches again.
The tail wheel hits.
He’s down.
But he’s traveling 60 mph.
The field is only 800 m long.
The stone wall is getting closer.
He stands on the brakes.
[snorts] The wheels lock.
The aircraft slides.
Snow packs under the landing gear.
No friction.
He’s hydroplaning on snow.
The wall fills his windscreen.
50 m.
30 20.
He braces for impact.
The BF 109 stops 6 m from the wall.
He sits, hands shaking, heart pounding.
He’s alive.
He climbed into a fighter at 10:30 a.m.
Collided with a bomber at 10:47.
Glided 8 mi without power.
Landed in a field.
Stopped 6 m from death.
He climbs out.
His legs barely hold him.
He walks around the aircraft.
The nose is crushed.
The propeller hub is jagged.
Oil covers the engine, cowling.
The aircraft will never fly again, but he’s alive.
Austrian farmers arrive.
They stare at him, at the fighter.
One asks if he’s injured.
He shakes his head, says he needs to call his base.
Report the aircraft loss.
They lead him to a farmhouse.
There’s a telephone.
Cronin’s bomber continues southeast.
The Alps pass below.
Mountains, valleys, rivers, beautiful and deadly.
If they go down here, nobody survives.
The temperature at ground level is -10°.
No rescue possible.
They’d freeze in an hour.
Mitchell navigates by dead reckoning.
They have no nose.
The bombader’s instruments are gone.
The drift meter, the compass, everything.
He uses the pilot’s compass and a map.
Estimates wind speed by watching clouds.
calculates ground speed by timing landmarks.
He’s flying blind, but he’s good.
They cross into Yugoslavia at 11:52 a.m.
65 minutes since the collision.
Altitude 8,400 ft.
Still descending, still carrying 20 bombs.
The engines run rough.
Fuel consumption is higher than normal.
The missing nose creates turbulence that disrupts air flow into the engines.
Wilson monitors the fuel gauges.
They’re burning 250 g per hour.
Normal consumption is 200.
They have 800 g remaining, 3 hours and 12 minutes of fuel, but they only have 28 minutes of altitude.
They’ll hit the ground long before they run out of fuel.
partisan territory below.
Yugoslav resistance fighters control these mountains.
They shoot down German aircraft, but will they recognize AB 24? The nose is missing.
The aircraft might look German from below.
Cronin rocks the wings.
The international signal for distress.
Hope someone sees it.
At 11:58 a.m.
they cross the Yugoslav coast.
The Adriatic Sea spreads below them.
Gray water, white caps, beautiful.
They’re overwater now.
If they ditch, they’ll have 3 minutes before hypothermia kills them.
The water temperature is 45° F.
Death comes fast in water that cold.
But they’re only 60 mi from Italy.
25 minutes of flying.
They have 19 minutes of altitude.
The mathematics don’t work.
They’re going to hit water 6 mi from shore.
Cronin pushes the throttles past maximum power.
The engines scream.
Manifold pressure enters the red zone.
The engines might explode, but six more minutes of power might save them.
He holds the throttles.
The engines roar.
The aircraft holds altitude 2,100 ft level.
They’re not climbing, but they’re not falling.
The Italian coastline appears at 12:17 p.m.
90 minutes since the collision.
The bomber is at 1,900 ft descending at 100 ft per minute.
Cronin sees an airfield.
British roundles on parked aircraft.
He keys the radio.
Mayday, mayday, mayday.
American B 24 battle damage.
Requesting emergency landing.
No response.
The radio is dead.
They threw the transmitter overboard to save weight.
He can receive but not transmit.
He’s going to land without clearance.
He enters the traffic pattern.
Other aircraft are landing.
Spitfires returning from patrol.
He has no way to tell them he’s coming.
No radio, no flares, nothing.
He just hopes they see him.
The tower sees him.
AB 24 with no nose.
Blood streaking the fuselage.
The controller clears all traffic.
Tells the Spitfires to orbit.
The bomber gets priority.
Cronin lines up on final approach.
One mile out.
The bombs are still attached.
If he hits hard, they’ll detonate.
2500 lb bombs.
The explosion will crater the runway, kill everyone within 300 yd.
He has to land soft, but the aircraft is nose light.
The missing nose section means the center of gravity is wrong.
The tail wants to drop.
If the tail hits first, the fuselage will break.
The bombs will tumble forward.
Detonation is certain.
He adds power.
Keeps the nose up.
The runway threshold passes below.
He’s 40 ft high.
Too high.
He reduces power.
The bomber settles.
30 ft.
20.
10.
The main wheels touch.
Smooth.
Perfect.
The nose wheel is next.
The nose wheel doesn’t exist.
There’s just a gaping hole where the nose should be.
As the aircraft settles, the jagged metal frame hits the runway.
Sparks fly.
Metal screams.
The fuselage grinds along concrete.
The aircraft slides 400 ft.
Slows.
Stops.
Silence.
Then chaos.
Fire trucks race toward them.
Ambulances.
The crew kicks open the waste door.
They jump out and run.
Get away from the bombs.
They’re 100 ft away when ordinance specialists arrive.
The technicians stare at the bomb bay.
20 bombs.
Fuses armed.
One sharp impact away from detonation.
It takes 3 hours to diffuse them.
3 hours of careful work disconnecting fuses, removing detonators.
The ordinance chief says it’s the most dangerous bomb disposal he’s ever performed.
One mistake means everyone dies, but there are no mistakes.
By 3:30 p.m., all 20 bombs are safe.
The B 24 is a wreck.
The nose is gone.
The fuselage is twisted.
Hydraulic fluid pools under the wings, but the crew is alive.
Nine men.
Davis is dead, but nine survived.
Cronin writes a letter to Davis’s parents.
He doesn’t mail it for 3 weeks.
Can’t find the words.
Finally writes, “Your son died instantly.
He felt no pain.
He saved the aircraft with his sacrifice.
We all owe him our lives.
It’s a lie.
Davis didn’t save anything.
He was just unlucky.
Wrong place at the wrong moment.
But the lie comforts the parents.
That’s what matters.
The B 24 never flies again.
The Air Force salvages the engines, the wings, the tail section, the fuselage becomes scrap.
By April 1944, it’s melted down, turned into new aircraft.
The metal that flew through Austria becomes part of a new bomber.
The cycle continues.
Stigler returns to combat flying.
The Luwaffa needs every pilot.
His damaged BF109 is scrapped.
He receives a new aircraft, BF 109G14.
Faster, better armed.
He flies it until May 1944.
Then his unit retreats to Germany.
The Russians are coming.
The Eastern front collapses.
He flies air defense over German cities.
shoots down 2 B17s in March, 1 B 24 in April.
His kill count reaches 31.
On April 23rd, 1945, American troops capture his airfield.
He destroys his aircraft, burns the log book, walks away.
The war is over for him.
He survives.
Most Luwaffa pilots don’t.
70% die in combat.
He’s lucky.
But the rail story begins 40 years later.
In 1984, a veterans reunion in Chicago brings together American bomber crews.
Cronin attends.
He’s 63 years old, retired postal worker.
lives in Boston.
Married, three children.
He never talks about the war.
His wife knows he flew bombers.
She doesn’t know about the collision.
Nobody knows except the crew and Davis’s parents.
They’re dead now.
Someone at the reunion mentions Fran Stigler, a German pilot living in Canada, moved there in 1953.
He’s written a letter to the reunion organizers.
Says he collided with a B24 over Austria in February 1944.
Wonders if the crew survived.
Wants to meet them.
Cronin freezes.
That’s impossible.
The fighter pilot died.
He must have.
Nobody survives a head-on collision without a propeller.
It’s impossible.
But the letter includes details.
Date February 1st, 1944.
Location, Lind, Austria.
Time approximately 10:47 a.m.
Altitude 20,000 ft.
The fighter’s propeller destroyed.
Glided 8 mi to an emergency landing.
The details match perfectly.
Cronin writes back includes his own account.
The collision, the missing nose, Davis’s death, the emergency landing in Italy.
He mails the letter and waits.
Stigler responds 3 weeks later.
His letter is 8 pages long, handwritten.
He describes the collision from his perspective.
The fuel mixture problem, the overshoot, the impact, the glide, the landing.
He includes a photograph himself in 1944.
Luwafa uniform, 27 years old, fighter, pilot, killer.
Cronin stares at the photograph.
This man killed Davis.
The propeller that tore through the nose was spinning because this man flew the fighter.
But this man also survived the impossible.
They’re both survivors, brothers in the fraternity of men who shouldn’t be alive.
They arranged to meet.
July 1985, Toronto, Stigler’s home.
Cronin flies there with his wife.
She’s nervous, worried.
Her husband is meeting the man who killed his crew mate, but Cronin isn’t worried.
He’s curious.
Stigler meets them at the airport.
He’s 68 years old, white hair, strong handshake.
His English is perfect.
He moved to Canada to escape Germany’s ruins.
Started a machine shop, prospered, retired in 1980.
His wife is Canadian.
They have two children.
They go to dinner.
Talk for 6 hours.
Compare notes.
The collision happened at exactly 10:47 and 32 seconds.
Stigler checked his watch at impact.
Cronin checked the cockpit clock.
Both agree.
They discuss the physics.
How both aircraft survived.
Stigler explains that the BF1009’s propeller hit at an angle, not straight on.
That’s why the propeller broke instead of the airframe.
If the impact had been head-on, both aircraft would have exploded.
Cronin explains how they flew 300 m with no nose.
The weight reduction, the maximum power, the fuel burn, every detail.
Stigler listens, takes notes.
He’s an engineer now.
The mathematics fascinate him.
They discuss Davis.
Stigler expresses regret.
Says he thinks about the dead bombardier every day.
wonders about his family, his life before the war, what he could have become.
Cronin says Davis was 21, engaged, planning to marry after the war.
The wedding never happened.
Stigler cries.
Not dramatic, just tears.
He’s killed 31 American airmen.
Davis is number 12.
He knows their names.
He researched them.
Found obituaries.
Death notices.
He carries the list in his wallet.
31 names.
31 men who died because he pulled a trigger.
But he’s also a survivor.
He fought for Germany because that’s where he was born.
He didn’t choose the Nazis.
Didn’t support the Holocaust.
He was just a pilot doing his job.
That’s what he tells himself.
Cronin believes him.
War makes killers of everyone.
American bombers killed 600,000 German civilians.
Nobody’s hands are clean.
They become friends.
Real friends.
They correspond regularly, write letters, exchange Christmas cards, visit each other.
Cronin goes to Toronto.
Stigler goes to Boston.
They attend reunions together.
American veterans.
German veterans.
Everyone stares.
An American bomber pilot and a German fighter pilot.
friends.
It seems impossible, but they have more in common than they have differences.
Both survived the war.
Both lost friends.
Both carry guilt.
Both wonder why they lived when so many died.
They are brothers.
The collision made them family.
Cronin dies in March 1991.
Heart attack.
70 years old.
Stigler attends the funeral.
Delivers a eulogy.
Says Cronin was the bravest pilot he ever met.
Flying 300 m with no nose.
Landing with 20 live bombs, saving his crew.
True heroism.
Stigler dies in March 2008.
Cancer.
91 years old.
His children find the letters, hundreds of them, from Cronin, from other American veterans, from historians.
Everyone wants to know about the collision, about the impossible survival, about the friendship.
His son contacts the Smithsonian, donates the letters.
They’re archived now, available to researchers.
The story is preserved.
Two pilots, one collision, 40 years of friendship.
It’s documented.
Future generations will know.
The B24’s wreckage is gone.
Melted down in 1944, but photographs survive.
The Air Force took pictures.
documentation for the investigation.
The images show the missing nose, the jagged metal, the blood.
They’re in the National Archives now.
Anyone can see them.
Stigler’s BF 109 also disappeared.
Scrapped in 1944, but Austrian farmers remember the field where he landed is still there, unchanged.
They tell the story.
The fighter that fell from the sky.
The pilot who walked away.
Local legend.
Now Davis is buried in Milwaukee.
Forest Home Cemetery.
His grave has a marker.
Staff Sergeant Charlie Davis.
454th Bombardment Group.
Killed in action.
February 1st, 1944.
Austria.
His fiance never married, died in 1997.
She’s buried beside him.
They’re together now.
The collision is documented in multiple archives.
American, German, British, Italian, all agree on the facts.
Two aircraft collided at 20,000 ft.
Both survived.
Both landed.
One crew member died.
Nine survived.
The German pilot survived.
It’s verified.
Confirmed.
True.
Historians call it statistically impossible.
The combined closing speed was 450 mph.
That’s equivalent to 660 ft/s.
The collision lasted 1/10enth of 1 second.
In that fragment of time, propeller blades shattered, aluminum tore, a man died.
Two aircraft were crippled, but they flew.
They landed.
The mathematics say they shouldn’t exist, but they do.
History doesn’t care about mathematics.
Veterans who heard the story from Cronin and Stigler confirm every detail.
The dates, the times, the locations, the physics, everything matches.
No embellishment, no exaggeration.
Just two men telling the truth about the day they should have died.
The friendship between Cronin and Stigler lasted 6 years.
From 1985 to 1991, six years of letters, visits, conversations, they reconciled wars horror with peacees possibility.
Proved that enemies can become brothers, that survival creates bonds stronger than nationality.
Their story is taught now.
Militarymies study it.
The physics of collision survival, the psychology of emergency decisions, the ethics of warrior friendship.
West Point includes it in leadership courses.
The RAF College Cranwell discusses it in pilot training.
The Luwaffa Museum in Berlin features it in their reconciliation exhibit.
The collision wasn’t the end.
It was the beginning.
Two pilots met in violence, survived the impossible, waited 40 years, then became friends.
The story proves that war doesn’t define men.
What they do after defines them.
Cronin chose forgiveness.
Stigler chose honesty.
Together, they chose friendship.
That’s legacy.
Not the medals, not the kill counts, not the missions flown.
The legacy is two old men sitting in a Toronto restaurant, crying together, reconciling together, healing together.
That’s what matters.
That’s what survives.
If you are watching till now, then do me a favor.
Hit that like button.
Every single person who likes the video counts to YouTube to show this story to more people.
Hit subscribe and turn on notifications.
We’re discovering forgotten stories from dusty archives every single day.
Stories about impossible survival and unlikely friendship.
Real people, real heroism.
Drop a comment right now and tell us where you’re watching from.
Are you watching from the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia? Our community stretches across the entire world.
You’re not just a viewer.
You’re part of keeping these memories alive.
Tell us your location.
Tell us if someone in your family served.
Just let us know you’re here.
Thank you for watching and thank you for making sure John Cronin, Fran Stigler, and Charlie Davis don’t disappear into silence.
These men deserve to be remembered and you’re helping make that happen.
