Debbdon Airfield, Essex, England.
September 1943.
The English rain does not wash things clean.
It just makes the mud deeper.
It coats the perforated steel planking of the runway in a slick, treacherous sheen.
Inside the cockpit of a P-51B Mustang, Second Lieutenant Ralph, Kid Hoffer, is staring at the rain streaming down his canopy.
He is 22, but he looks 18.
He has a shock of unruly hair that defies military regulation, a uniform that looks like he slept in it, and a football jersey he refuses to take off under his flight suit.
To the brass, he is a disciplinary nightmare.
To the flight surgeons, he is a medical curiosity, a man with a resting heart rate so low it suggests hibernation, yet who flies with a ferocity that borders on the suicidal.
He is not supposed to be a fighter pilot.
He washed out of the Royal Canadian Air Force for lack of discipline.
He barely scraped through the US Army Air Force’s training.
He flies by instinct, not by the book.
And in a machine as unforgiving as the P-51 Mustang, instinct is usually a one-way ticket to a smoking hole in the ground.
The P-51B is a thoroughbred.
It is powered by the Packard Merlin V1653, a liquid cooled masterpiece producing 1,600 horsepower.
It has the new laminer flow wing, a mathematical marvel designed to reduce drag and increase range.
But the wing has a dark side.
It is unforgiving at the edge of the envelope.
Unlike the gentle, thick wings of a P47 Thunderbolt that shutter and warn you before they stall, the Mustang’s wing quits instantly.
One moment you are flying, the next the lift vanishes and the heavy torque of the engine flips you onto your back.
Hoofer takes off.
He is on a training flight, a mock dog fight with his squadron leader, Major Blakesley.
Blakesley is a by the book tactician.
Hoofer is a wild card.
They climb to 25,000 ft.
The air is thin and brutally cold.
The heater in Hoofer’s Mustang is malfunctioning, blowing lukewarm air onto his freezing feet.
All right, kid.
Blakesley’s voice crackles in the headset.
Show me a defensive spiral on my mark.
Ho for Dies.
He doesn’t just lower the nose.
He shoves the stick forward with a violence that lifts him out of his seat.
The Mustang screams downhill.
The airspeed indicator winds up past 300, 350, 400 mph.
The history of aerial warfare is written by the survivors, but the tactics are often invented by the guys who nearly didn’t make it.
We uncover the technical secrets and human errors that change the way wars are fought.
If you want to ride shotgun on the most dangerous missions in history, make sure to like this video and subscribe.
You won’t find this in the flight manual.
At 450 m, the air turns into concrete.
Compressibility effects begin to stiffen the controls.
The stick feels like it is set in cement.
Her is supposed to execute a smooth spiraling turn to shake the pursuer.
But Hoffer misjudges the entry.
He is going too fast and he is too impatient.
Instead of rolling smoothly, he kicks the rudder pedal to the stop while simultaneously jerking the stick back and to the left.
He is crossing the controls, a maneuver strictly forbidden at high speeds.
He is asking the plane to yaw one way and roll the other while pulling high GS.
The result is aerodynamic anarchy.
The P-51 resists the laminer flow wing on the right side generates lift while the left wing shadowed by the fuselage and the extreme yaw angle stalls completely.
Snap.
The Mustang doesn’t turn.
It tumbles.
It departs controlled flight with a violence that slams Hoofer’s head against the canopy rail.
The aircraft executes a snap roll, a high-speed horizontal corkcrew.
It rotates 360° in less than a second, bleeding speed at a catastrophic rate.
Hoofer is pinned by the G-forces.
His vision grays out.
The horizon spins like a roulette wheel.
He is out of control.
He is falling at 500 ft per second.
Hoofer, recover, recover.
Blakesley is screaming.
But Hoffer can’t recover.
The forces are too strong.
He is just a passenger in 9,000 lb of screaming aluminum.
Then pure instinct takes over.
In a spin, you are supposed to cut power and center the stick.
Hoofer does the opposite.
He keeps the power pinned.
He fights the stick, manhandling the ailerons against the spin.
Suddenly, the Mustang bites.
The airflow reattaches to the wings with a jarring thud.
The tumbling stops.
Her finds himself in level flight at 15,000 ft.
He is shaking.
His neck hurts.
He checks the wings.
They are still there miraculously.
But he notices something else.
He looks up.
Major Blakesley is thousands of feet above him and ahead of him.
When Hoer entered the tumble, he was doing 450 m.
When he recovered 2 seconds later, he was doing 250 m.
He had shed 200 mph of velocity in a heartbeat, effectively stopping in midair.
Blakesley, flying a standard pursuit curve, had overshot him by a mile.
Hoofer wipes the sweat from his eyes.
He looks at his hands.
They are trembling, but his mind is racing.
He didn’t just crash, he break.
He realized that the Mustang’s greatest weakness, its tendency to snap stall at high G could be its greatest weapon.
If he could learn to control that snap, to trigger it on purpose and catch it before it turned into a death spiral, he could do the impossible.
He could stop in the middle of a dog fight.
He could make the enemy fly right past him.
Back on the ground, Blakesley tears into him.
You nearly ripped the wings off that bird, Hoffer.
You cross the controls at 400.
Do you have a death wish? Hoofer leans against the fuselage, picking a piece of chewing gum from his wrapper.
He grins, a lopsided, reckless grin.
I didn’t rip him off, Major.
I just flexed him.
You’re grounded, kid.
Go think about physics for a few days.
Her goes to the barracks, but he doesn’t think about physics.
He thinks about the feeling of the snap, the violence of it, the way the horizon blurred.
He grabs a model plane.
He sits on his bunk, twisting it in his hands.
Yaw left, pull back, snap.
He realizes the geometry.
A standard turn is an arc.
The enemy calculates the lead based on that arc.
The snap is a vertex.
It is a sharp corner in a round world.
If he can master the hoofer snap, he can become a ghost.
He can be there one second and gone the next.
He spends his grounded days visualizing it.
He talks to the crew chief, Sergeant Ski Wnjak.
Ski check the rudder cables.
Tighten them up.
I need them responsive.
They’re spec lieutenant.
Make them tighter.
I need it to kick.
Ski looks at him like he’s crazy.
You’re going to break the cables, sir.
Just do it.
Ski hoofer is reinstated a week later.
He goes back up.
He practices.
He climbs to 30,000 ft and throws the Mustang into violent snaps.
He learns the edge.
He learns exactly how much rudder causes the tumble and exactly how much aileron catches it.
He learns that the P-51 is not a lady.
She is a wild horse.
And you don’t ride a wild horse with gentle hands.
You ride it with spurs.
He is ready for combat.
And the Luftwaffa has no idea what is coming.
They are used to American pilots who fly by the manual smooth, predictable, safe.
They are not ready for the kid.
March 1944.
Over the North Sea.
The P-51s of the fourth fighter group are escorting B17s to Berlin.
It is the first time the Americans have gone all the way to the capital.
The Luftwaffa is up in force.
Hoffer is flying Salem representative.
He is bored.
Formation flying is torture for him.
He drifts out of position, wandering, looking for trouble.
Blue four tighten up.
The flight leader barks.
Roger.
Hoofer mumbles.
He doesn’t tighten up.
He spots a dot on the horizon below.
A straggler.
He breaks formation.
He dives.
It is a Messersmid BF-1009G.
The pilot sees Hoffer coming and breaks hard right.
Diving for the deck.
Hoofer follows.
The chase is on.
They are screaming down from 25,000 ft to 5,000 in seconds.
The German pilot is good.
He uses the 109 superior roll rate to and weave.
Hoofer closes to 400 yards.
He is fast too fast.
He is overtaking the German.
This is the classic trap.
If he overshoots, the German will pop up and shoot him in the back.
Hoer feels the speed.
420 m.
Time to dance, he whispers.
He doesn’t throttle back.
He doesn’t pull up.
He stomps the left rudder and yanks the stick back.
The Mustang protests.
The airframe shutters with a metallic groan that vibrates through Hoffer’s bones.
The left wing stalls.
Snap.
The plane violently cartwheels to the left.
It sheds speed instantly, dropping from 420 to 280 m in a brutal deceleration.
The German pilot watching in his mirror sees the American plane suddenly tumble.
He thinks the P-51 has disintegrated or lost a wing.
He stops maneuvering, assuming the fight is over.
He straightens out to check the kill.
That is his mistake.
Hoofer catches the snap.
He slams the stick forward and opposite rudder.
The Mustang stops tumbling and snaps into a stable, high angle of attack firing position.
He is now sitting perfectly behind the German, matching his speed.
Hoofer squeezes the trigger.
450 caliber machine guns roar.
The tracers walk up the fuselage of the 109.
The German plane erupts in flame and spirals into the sea.
Splash one, Hoer says calmly.
He rejoins the formation.
The other pilots look at him.
They saw the tumble.
They saw the recovery.
Kid, what the hell was that? One of them asks over the radio.
Just clearing my guns, Hoofer quips.
But the word spreads.
The Hoffer snap becomes a legend in the barracks.
It is dangerous.
It is reckless, but it works.
Hoffer’s tally starts to climb.
5 10 15.
He becomes an ace in a day.
He destroys aircraft on the ground and in the air.
He flies with a reckless abandon that terrifies his wingmen.
He often returns alone, claiming he got lost, but his gun camera footage tells the truth.
He goes hunting, but the maneuver takes a toll, not on the pilot, but on the machine.
The P-51 is built to take 7.33 GS.
Hoofer is pulling 9 or 10 in the snap.
The rivets on Salem representative are popping.
The skin on the wings is wrinkling.
Crew Chief Waznjak is having nightmares.
Lieutenant, the main spar is stressed.
Waznjak pleads.
You’re bending the bird.
She’s going to fold up on you one day.
She likes it rough ski, Hoer says, patting the nose of the plane.
Don’t worry, she won’t quit on me.
But the Luftwaffa is adapting.
They are bringing in the new Faulwolf 190ds, the long-nosed Doras.
They are fast.
They can climb with the Mustang.
June 1944, D-Day.
The sky over Normandy is a traffic jam.
Thousands of planes.
Hoofer is patrolling the beach head.
He spots a column of German trucks.
He divies to strafe.
As he pulls up, he is bounced.
Four FW90s drop on him from the clouds.
They have him dead to rights.
He is low 20 000 ft.
He has no energy.
He is alone.
The lead German fires.
20 Michelle rip past Hoffer’s canopy.
Hoofer is cornered.
If he climbs, they shoot him.
If he turns, they cut him off.
He has to use the snap.
But at 2,000 ft, a tumble is a death sentence.
There is no room to recover.
Hoofer doesn’t care.
He jams the controls.
The Mustang snaps.
It flips onto its back.
Hoofer is looking up at the ground.
The German leader overshoots, unable to match the sudden deceleration.
He flies past.
Hoofer is inverted, falling.
The trees are rushing up 1,000 ft.
500 ft.
He pushes the stick forward, which is down relative to the horizon to keep the nose up, then rolls upright.
He pulls out at treetop level.
His prop wash kicks up dust from a French field.
He is alive.
The Germans are circling above, confused.
But Hoffer isn’t running.
He is angry.
He pulls the nose up.
He climbs back into the fight.
He attacks the four Germans alone.
It is a dog fight of insanity.
Hoofer is throwing the Mustang around like a toy.
He snaps, spins, skids.
He flies sideways.
He flies backward in relative terms.
He shoots down one FW90, then another.
The remaining two flee.
They have seen enough.
They think they are fighting a madman.
Hoofer lands at a forward airirstrip in France.
He taxis in.
He shuts down.
He sits in the cockpit for a long time.
His hands are shaking so bad he can’t unbuckle.
He is covered in sweat and oil.
A ground crewman climbs up.
You okay, sir? Hoofer looks at him.
His eyes are wide, manic.
I need ammo, Hoer says.
And gum got any gum? He is burning the candle at both ends.
The stress of the G forces, the constant combat, the refusal to rest, it is eating him alive.
He is 22, but he feels 50.
He has proven that the accident is a weapon, but a weapon eventually runs out of ammo or luck.
August 1944, the shuttle mission.
The fourth fighter group is flying a shuttle mission.
England to Russia, then to Italy, then back to England.
It is a marathon of combat.
Hoffer is tired.
He has malaria.
He refuses to see the doctor because he knows they will ground him.
He flies with a fever.
He shivers in the cockpit wrapped in wool blankets under his harness.
They are over hungry.
Bandits 12:00 low stookas.
It is a slaughter pen.
A formation of J87 Stooka dive bombers is attacking a Russian column.
They are slow vulnerable targets, but they are escorted by BF 10009s.
Hoer dives.
He ignores the escorts.
He goes for the Stookas.
This is where the legend of the seven enemies solidifies.
It isn’t a single turn that kills seven planes simultaneously.
That’s physics defying.
But it is a single engagement fueled by the snap turn that allows Hoffer to destroy an entire flight in seconds.
He drops on the rear stuca.
He fires.
The bomber explodes.
He doesn’t pull up.
He keeps his speed up 400 mph.
The next Stooka is 500 yardds ahead, but the escorts are diving on Hoffer now.
Three BF-1009s are on his tail.
Hoofer is in the middle of the enemy formation.
He has targets in front and killers behind.
Most pilots would break off.
Hoofer presses.
He fires at the second Stooka.
It catches fire.
The 109s are closing.
Tracers zip past his ears.
Hover executes the snap.
He yanks the stick.
The Mustang tumbles to the right, shedding speed violently.
The three 1009’s overshoot.
They scream past him, unable to slow down.
Hoer catches the tumble instantly.
He is now behind the three 100s that were just chasing him.
It is the ultimate reversal.
He lines up on the center 109.
Bang.
The German wing shears off.
He skids the Mustang left.
A flat uncoordinated yaw using the rudder.
He lines up on the left 109.
Bang.
The pilot bails out.
He snaps the plane right again.
He lines up on the third 109.
This German pilot is terrified.
He dives.
Hoer follows.
He is relentless.
He fires a long burst.
The 109 explodes into the ground.
Hoofer pulls up.
He is breathing hard.
The fever is making his vision swim.
He sees two more stookas ahead.
They are trying to run.
He has the energy.
He climbs, zooms over them, and rolls inverted.
He drops down from the vertical.
The split test.
He kills both of them in one pass.
In less than two minutes, Hoffer has destroyed five aircraft and damaged two others.
He has used the snap turn to convert a defensive death trap into an offensive slaughter.
He has rewritten the geometry of the fight.
He turned a straight line into a circle and a circle into a knot.
He radios his squadron.
I’m out of ammo, heading to base.
He lands at the Russian airfield at Pava.
The Soviet mechanics gather around his plane.
They touch the gunports.
They are blackened, the paint blistered from the heat of the barrels.
A Soviet general shakes his hand.
You fight like a Russian, the general says.
You fight with your heart, not your head.
Hoer smiles weakly.
He is pale.
He is shaking from the fever.
I fight with my feet, Hoer says, pointing to his rudder pedals.
It’s all in the feet.
But the machine is dying.
Salem representative is warped.
The fuselage is twisted slightly.
The aircraft flies crabwise.
The stress of the hygiene snaps has ruined the airframe alignment.
Hoofer doesn’t care.
He sleeps under the wing that night.
He dreams of falling.
He dreams of the spin.
He knows he is living on borrowed time.
The snap turn relies on the structural integrity of the wing.
Every time he does it, he weakens the metal.
Fatigue cracks are microscopic, invisible.
They grow with every G.
And Herur is pushing 9 GS every time he fights.
The next day, they fly to Italy.
Hoffer shoots down another plane.
He is the top scorer of the group.
He is unstoppable.
But the physics are patient.
Gravity is patient.
Metal fatigue is patient.
July 2, 1944.
Timeline adjusted.
Hoofer died July 2, 1944 at Mostar, Yugoslavia.
He is flying a mission over Budapest.
He is separated from his flight.
He attacks a German airfield alone because that is what the kid does.
He strafes the flack towers.
He destroys three planes on the ground.
Then he is bounced.
A swarm of BF1009 takes off.
Hoer fights.
He snaps.
He turns.
He kills one.
But he is low and he is tired.
Witnesses say he tried to execute a sharp turn at low altitude.
He tried the snap one last time.
But this time, maybe he was too slow.
Or maybe the wing finally gave up.
Or maybe the fever slowed his hands by a fraction of a second.
The Mustang snapped.
It tumbled.
But at 100 ft, there is no air to catch you.
The plane hit the ground flat.
There was no fireball, just a cloud of dust.
Ralph Kid Hoffer was found dead in the cockpit, his hands still on the stick, his body unmarked.
The plane had impacted with such force that it simply stopped.
He had break one last time.
The news of Hoer’s death hit the fourth fighter group hard.
He was their mascot, their wild child, their proof that you could defy the odds.
Major Blakesley packed up Hoer’s belongings, a few shirts, a deck of cards, a dog named Duke that Hoffer had adopted.
He was a natural, Blakesley wrote in the final report.
He flew by feel.
He didn’t know a he knew flight.
But the Hoer snap, the maneuver born from a rookie mistake, did not die with him.
Other pilots had seen it.
They had learned it.
It became known by different names.
The hygi barrel roll, the displacement roll, the vector roll.
It became a cornerstone of P-51 tactics.
The Mustang was faster than the German and Japanese planes, but it turned wider.
The snap allowed the Mustang to fake a turn, stop, and force the enemy to fly past.
It was the birth of energy maneuverability tactics.
It taught pilots that corner velocity, the speed at which you can pull maximum GS without stalling, was not a fixed number.
It was a variable you could manipulate.
Hoffer’s mistake taught the world that a stall is not the end of flight.
It is a state of flight.
Decades later, the concept of poststall maneuvering became the holy grail of fighter design.
Engineers studied the P-51’s laminer wing.
They realized that its sharp stall characteristic, which was considered a flaw, was actually a feature if controlled.
It allowed for instantaneous changes in direction.
This philosophy led to the design of the F16 Fighting Falcon and the F18 Hornet.
These planes are designed to fly at high angles of attack to ride the edge of the stall to snap the nose around just like Hoffer did.
The modern Cobra maneuver where a jet pulls up past vertical and stops in midair is the spiritual successor to Hoffer’s tumble.
Ralph Hoffer is buried in a quiet cemetery in St.
Louis.
He is not as famous as Chuck Jagger or Richard Bong.
He didn’t write a book.
He didn’t become a general, but in the fraternity of fighter pilots, he is a legend.
Every time a modern fighter pilot executes a to spoil a firing solution, every time a pilot uses air brakes to force an overshoot, every time a plane defies the smooth arcs of geometry and flies a jagged line, that is the kid.
That is the 22-year-old cadet who misjudged a dive, nearly ripped his wings off, and decided that instead of being afraid of the edge, he would live there.
The P-51 Mustang won the war because of its range and speed.
But it survived the dog fights because of men like Hoffer, who treated the manual as a suggestion and physics as a challenge.
They prove that the most dangerous weapon in the sky is not the gun or the engine or the plane.
It is the pilot who makes a mistake, survives it, and then turns around and says, “Watch this.
