Luftwaffe Aces Laughed At The ‘Flying Bathtub’ — Until 3,400 Rounds Per Minute Tore Them Apart
The year is 1945.
The sky over Germany belongs to America.
But let’s get one thing straight before the history books dry.
The Luftwaffer wasn’t buried by strategic bombing.
Not by Patn’s tanks, not by the Normandy landings.
The coffin for German aviation was built 2 years before the surrender.
It was built by 8.5 caliber machine guns mounted on an aircraft the Germans laughed at.
Picture this.
You’re the best pilot in the Luftwaffer.
You have 200 kills.
You’ve been flying since 1939.
You’ve seen Poland, France, Britain, Russia.
You’re the elite.
You’re an expert.
And then in April 1943, you see them approaching barrels, flying milk bottles, fat, clumsy, with engines the size of a small car.
You laugh.
18 months later, you’re dead or captured or hiding in a bunker because going outside during daylight is suicide.
How did an aircraft that couldn’t turn properly destroy 7,000 German planes? How did a flying barrel bury 86,000 railroad cars, 9,000 locomotives, and 68,000 trucks? How did a fighter that American pilots called a flying brick force Field Marshal von Runet to admit? Not a single train can cross the Rine during daylight.
Today, we’re not just looking at an aircraft.
We’re conducting a forensic audit, an investigation into how American industrial logic defeated German tactical mastery, how the mathematics of firepower buried the art of aerial combat.
This is the verdict against the Luftwaffer.
Let’s break it down point by point.
Nail one, the geological jackpot trap.
To understand why the Germans stopped laughing, we need to go back to one number.
2000.
That’s the horsepower of the Pratt and Whitney R2800 double Wasp engine.
18 cylinders.
The most powerful production aircraft engine of its time.
If you skipped physics class, here’s the explain it like I’m five version.
The higher a plane flies, the less air there is.
Less air means less oxygen for the engine.
Less oxygen means less power.
At 26,000 ft, a normal engine gasps like a marathon runner on Everest.
German BF109E and FW190E used mechanical superchargers.
Good technology.
Worked great up to 23,000 ft.
Above that, the aircraft turned into a brick.
The P47 used a turbocharger.
It ran on exhaust gases.
The higher you went, the more efficient it became.
At 30,000 ft, where German fighters could barely maneuver, the Thunderbolt was running at full power.
It’s like a boxer stepping into the ring with an oxygen tank while his opponent is suffocating.
But here’s the trap.
The P47 weighed 10,000 lb empty, fully loaded, up to 17,500 lb.
That’s heavier than some twin engine bombers.
This wasn’t a fighter.
This was a flying tank with wings.
When the first Thunderbolts arrived in England in January 1943, American pilots were horrified.
Fourth Fighter Group pilot Irwin Miller recalled, “The cockpit was so enormous that it felt like if you slipped off the seat, you’d break your leg.” After the cozy Spitfire, “It was like switching from a sports car to a truck.
We were terrified at the thought of going to war in this thing.” British pilots joked, “The best evasive maneuver in a P-47 is to unbuckle and run around the spacious cockpit.” The 56th Fighter Group received these machines first.
During training, 18 pilots died.
41 aircraft crashed.
The P47 killed more Americans in training than the Germans did in the first months of combat.
Here’s the first nail.
The Germans saw the statistics and decided the problem would solve itself.
The Americans would kill themselves flying these monsters.
They were wrong.
Nailed too.
The formula of destruction.
Colonel Hubert Zena, commander of the 56th Group, understood what others didn’t.
Don’t turn with them.
Don’t climb with them at low altitude.
Use your weight.
Use your power.
Use your guns.
Here’s the math the Germans didn’t calculate.
8 M2 Browning machine guns, 425 rounds per barrel, 3,400 rounds total ammunition.
Rate of fire, 800 rounds per minute per barrel.
Combined, 6,400 rounds per minute.
Let me translate that into human terms.
A 2cond burst sent 200 bullets at the target.
Each one armor-piercing incendiary.
Velocity 2,900 ft pers.
Burning temperature 2,900° F.
Enough to instantly ignite aluminum skin.
German ace Hind 220 victories said after the war the P47 could absorb an astounding amount of lead.
You had to handle it very carefully.
Now compare that to German armament.
The BF-109G had one 20 mm cannon with 200 rounds and two 13 mm machine guns with 300 rounds each.
The shells were more powerful individually, but there were fewer of them.
A German could fire for 10 to 15 seconds, an American over 30.
And here’s the key difference.
German shells required precise hits.
You had to be a sniper.
American guns created a cloud of death, a guaranteed kill zone the size of a human torso at 300 yards.
All eight trajectories converged at a single point.
Ace Francis Gabreski, 28 victories.
When our guns hit a target, the plane didn’t just fall, it came apart.
I saw a BF 109 literally cut in half.
In real combat, where adrenaline is pumping, where you have fractions of a second to aim, who wins? A sniper with 15 seconds of fire or a guy with a flamethrower and 30 seconds.
Here’s the second nail.
Germans built fighters for aces.
America built fighters for armies in Total War.
That’s the decisive difference.
Nail three.
The day nothing could kill it.
June 26th, 1943.
The date that changed everything.
Lieutenant Robert Johnson was returning from escorting bombers over France.
16 Fauler Wolf FW190’s attacked from above.
In the first seconds, his aircraft took 21 hits from 20 mm shells.
The canopy shattered.
Hydraulics leaked out.
Shrapnel hit his leg.
A bullet grazed his nose.
The engine caught fire.
Johnson tried to bail out.
The canopy was jammed.
A shell had exploded in the rails, welding it shut.
He was trapped at 26,000 ft in a burning aircraft.
No chance.
Somehow he leveled the plane and headed for the English Channel.
Then it got worse.
A lone FW190 found the The German came in from behind and emptied his entire ammunition load from four 20 mm cannons.
The Thunderbolt kept flying.
The German repositioned and emptied his machine gun ammunition.
The P47 kept flying.
The German pilot flew up close.
Johnson could see his face, young, blonde.
His expression changed from confidence to confusion and finally to something like fear.
The German waggled his wings, an informal salute, and left.
He was out of ammunition.
Johnson’s P47 made it back to base.
Mechanics started counting bullet holes and gave up after 200 without even covering half the aircraft.
Any other fighter Spitfire BF-1009 FW190 Yak would have fallen apart after the first attack.
When the report reached German intelligence, they refused to believe it, but testimony from several JG26 pilots confirmed the impossible.
Johnson returned to duty 5 days later.
By war’s end, he had 27 victories.
Here’s the third nail.
The P47 didn’t just fly.
It refused to die and that broke the psychology of German pilots.
Nail four death of the experts.
October 8th 1943.
Breman Obus Litnant Hans Phillip commanded JG1.
Behind him 206 victories over 500 combat missions.
One of Germany’s best aces.
At 28,000 ft.
His FW190 became sluggish.
The engine was gasping in the thin air.
P47s from the 56th group dove from 33,000 ft.
According to German radio intercepts, Philillip’s last words were, “Reinhardt, attack.” That evening, the squadron learned their commander was dead.
His parachute didn’t open.
Think about that.
206 victories, 500 missions, six years of war, and he couldn’t survive against a flying barrel.
Philip’s death shook the Luftwaffer.
If one of the best couldn’t survive, what chance did the rest have? Answer: none.
Here’s the fourth nail.
Germany spent years training elite pilots.
America spent months training ordinary guys and gave them aircraft that compensated for lack of experience with firepower and survivability.
When an expert dies, you lose 500 missions of experience.
When an American pilot dies, you lose 100 hours of training.
Guess who replaces losses faster? Nail five, the industrial juggernaut.
Now to the numbers that finally buried the Luftwaffer.
15,683.
That’s how many P47s America produced.
More than any other American fighter, two factories, Farmingdale on Long Island and Evansville, Indiana.
At peak, 28 aircraft per day.
Every hour, a new Thunderbolt rolled off the line.
Each P47 required 36,000 parts, 25,000 rivets, 2,400 engine components, 8 miles of electrical wiring.
And all of this was assembled by people, many of whom had never seen an aircraft before Pearl Harbor.
Nearly half the workers in Evansville were women.
They called them radarcts.
They learned to rivet in evening classes and months later were building the most complex combat machines of their time.
On September 20th, 1944, the 10th,000th Thunderbolt rolled off the line.
At the ceremony, Jquel and Cochran smashed champagne on the propeller hub.
I christen thee 10 grand.
Now compare.
Germany produced about 36,000 fighters of all types during the entire war.
America produced over 15,000 of just one model.
January 1st, 1945, Operation Bowden Platter.
The Luftwaffer threw 900 fighters at a surprise attack on Allied airfields.
At base Y34 near Mets, they burned 22 P47s.
A captured German pilot asked with a smirk in perfect English, “So, how do you like that?” Major George Brooking pointed to the field where crews were clearing space for new aircraft.
Tomorrow we’ll have 40.
How long will it take you to replace your pilots? The smirk disappeared.
Within 48 hours, factory fresh P47s arrived.
The Luftwaffer lost 280 aircraft and over 200 pilots in Bowden Platter, including veteran instructors.
Those losses they never replaced.
Here’s the fifth nail.
You can win a battle.
You cannot win a war against a country that produces fighters faster than you produce bullets.
Nail six.
Angels of death at treetop level.
After D-Day, the P47 found its true calling.
On June 6th, 1944, over 500 thunderbolts flew above the Normandy beaches.
An impenetrable umbrella from sea level to 30,000 ft.
Obeloidant Wolfgang Fischer of JG2, one of only three Germans to break through to the beaches that day.
The sky belonged to the Americans.
We tried to break through at dawn.
12 fighters.
I came back alone.
Their guns turned our aircraft into aluminum rain, but air combat became only part of the job.
The P47D carried two 1,000 lb bombs under the wings and a 500 pounder under the fuselage.
Later, 10 5-in rockets, each one like a 105 mm howitzer shell from D-Day to surrender.
Thunderbolt pilots destroyed.
86,000 railroad cars, 9,000 locomotives, 68,000 trucks, 6,000 tanks, 60,000 horsedrawn vehicles, 132,000 tons of bombs, 135 million rounds of ammunition.
Field Marshal Gerd Fon Runstead, commander of all German forces in the west, admitted after capture, air attacks made it impossible to move a single train across the Rine in daylight.
German soldiers developed a term Jabo fever, fighter bomber fever.
Physical symptoms of stress at the mere mention of P47 Esther Stalingrad veterans started trembling when they heard that distinctive sound.
That sound was unique.
The blades of the massive propeller at high RPM reached supersonic speeds.
The Germans called it donnlag thunderclap.
When you heard that sound, you had seconds to find cover or die.
Here’s the sixth nail.
The P47 paralyzed German logistics.
You can’t fight a war if your tanks have no fuel.
Your soldiers have no ammunition.
And any movement in daylight means death from the sky.
Nail seven.
The transformation of opinion.
Let’s look at the timeline of German assessments.
April 1943 from captured documents.
Large unmaneuverable fighter.
Inferior to German types.
Assessment.
Minimal threat.
December 1943.
Exceptional high altitude characteristics.
Extreme durability.
Assessment.
Significant threat above 25,000 ft.
June 1944.
Dominant fighter bomber.
Firepower is devastating.
Assessment.
Critical threat.
March 1945.
Best fighter bomber of the war.
Assessment.
We don’t survive direct confrontation.
Major Joseph Priller, commander of JG26, who in 1943 called P47’s pregnant cows, said after the war.
We laughed at them in 1943.
By 1945, there was no one left to laugh.
It was the perfect fighter bomber.
The guns never jammed, never overheated.
It exceeded all our expectations.
And if this video helps you understand how war really worked, hit that like button.
It’s free, unlike the 135 million rounds the P47s fired at Germany.
The algorithm loves likes.
I love subscribers.
Everyone’s happy.
Nail 8.
The mathematics of defeat.
Final balance sheet.
Production.
P47.
15,683 all German fighters approximately 36,000 P-47 combat sorties 546,000 losses 0.7% per sorty one of the best rates of the war kill ratio 4.6:1 6 to 1 destroyed in the air 3,752 German aircraft destroyed on the ground 3,315 total over 7,000 enemy aircraft 56th fighter group Wolfpack 992.5 victories most in the eighth air force the only group that refused to transition to the P-51 Mustang stayed with the P-47 until wars end by choice when command offered the transition ition to superior Mustangs in 1944.
The veterans refused.
They knew in real combat the P47 wasn’t just an aircraft.
It was an insurance policy.
353rd Group pilot Harrison Toroff.
When I flew the P-47, I felt invincible.
Pilots brought back tree branches and telephone pole tops in their wings.
Some returned with cylinders shot off.
You could barely land it in a forest.
Pilots appreciated that kind of toughness.
Here’s the eighth nail.
Germans built engineering masterpieces for virtuosos.
America built tools for workers.
In industrial warfare, the assembly line beats the workshop.
The verdict.
So, the verdict is in.
The Luftwaffer wasn’t destroyed by political decisions, not by Hitler’s strategic mistakes, not by fuel shortages, though that helped.
The Luftwaffer was destroyed by mathematics.
The mathematics of firepower, eight machine guns versus three.
The mathematics of production, 28 aircraft per day versus struggling to make ends meet.
The mathematics of survivability, aircraft returning with damage that would have destroyed any other fighter.
The mathematics of training, 400 hours versus 100.
Were German pilots better individually perhaps in the beginning.
But war isn’t a duel.
War is a system.
And the American system was built for a war of attrition.
When you lose 10 aircraft, they send you 20.
When Germans lose one, it’s gone forever.
When your pilot returns with 200 bullet holes, he’s flying again in 5 days.
When a German ace dies, his 206 victories won’t replace 500 hours of experience.
At the US Air Force Museum in Dayton stands a restored P47D.
Next to it, a display case with shell casings and gun camera footage.
An FW190 coming apart under fire.
Below the display, a quote from the interrogation of an unnamed German pilot, 1945.
We laughed when we first saw them.
Fat, ugly American fighters that couldn’t turn, couldn’t climb.
We stopped laughing when we realized they didn’t need to turn or climb.
They just pointed those guns and you ceased to exist.
The laughter died with our comrades.
The P-47 Thunderbolt entered combat as an object of ridicule.
It ended the war as a machine of destruction.
Between those points, 15,683 aircraft, 546,000 combat sorties, and eight synchronized Browning machine guns that rewrote the rules of aerial warfare.
Germans laughed at the clumsy American fighter in April 1943.
By May 1945, there was no one left to laugh.
The thunder had rolled.
The sky belonged to America.
If this forensic audit was useful, subscribe.
Coming up, more breakdowns of how industrial logic defeated tactical mastery on every front of World War I’s.
See you in the comments.
And remember, war isn’t about heroism.
War is about mathematics.
