30,000 ft over the shimmering frozen patchwork of Belgium.
December 1944, Captain Sila’s slick Vance is fighting two enemies.
The first is the Luftwaffa somewhere out there in the blinding white haze.
The second is his own aircraft.
Vance is strapped into obsession, a P-51D20 N Mustang.
It is the pinnacle of American aeronautical engineering.
It has a laminer flow wing that slices through the air with surgical precision.
It has a Packard Merlin V1657 engine that pumps out 1,720 horsepower when the war emergency wire is snapped.
It is beautiful, deadly, and fast.
But right now, it is also trying to kill him.
Vance is carrying a full load of fuel.
The internal wing tanks are full.
[snorts] But the real problem is the 85galon fuselage tank located directly behind his seat.
The engineers at North American Aviation added it to give the Mustang the range to reach Berlin.
But in doing so, they shifted the aircraft’s center of gravity CG dangerously aft.
When that tank is full, the P-51 is longitudinally unstable.
It doesn’t want to fly straight.
It wants to pitch up.
It wants to tighten turns until it snaps.
Vance has to hold constant forward pressure on the stick just to keep the nose from wandering into the stars.
His right arm burns with the effort.
He is flying a razor blade.
The difference between a design flaw and a secret weapon is often just the pilot holding the stick.
If you want to uncover more true stories of how engineering and instinct collided to change the course of history, make sure to like this video and subscribe.
You won’t find these details in the standard textbooks.
Break right slick 3:00 high.
The warning comes from his wingman.
Vance snaps his head right.
He sees them.
Two Messers BF 109 K4s.
The Kurwist.
These are not the tired 109s of 1940.
These are late war monsters, pressurized, boosted with MW50 watermethanol injection, capable of climbing like rockets.
They are diving on him.
The geometry is bad.
They have the altitude.
They have the speed.
Vance’s instinct is to pull hard into the turn.
Doctrine says, “Turn into the attack.
Ruin their solution.” But Vance knows the math.
With 85 gallons of fuel slloshing behind his spine, if he pulls more than 3GS, the center of gravity will shift further back.
The stick forces will reverse.
The plane will try to swap ends.
It will enter a high-speed snap roll that will tear the wings off or spin him into the ground.
He is trapped.
He can’t outclimb them.
He can’t out turn them.
The lead Messersmid opens fire.
Vance sees the sparkle of the nosemounted 30 MK 108 cannon.
The shells are mining grass mine shells.
One hit will vaporize his tail.
Vance tightens his grip on the stick.
The tracer arc is terrified and close.
He can feel the turbulence of the passing rounds.
In that moment of desperation, Vance stops fighting the instability.
He decides to use it.
He jams the throttle to the wall.
67 in of manifold pressure.
The Merlin screams.
Simultaneously, he stomps on the left rudder and jerks the stick back hard.
He is deliberately inducing the one thing every P-51 pilot is trained to avoid with a full tank.
The accelerated snap stall.
The Mustang reacts violently.
The laminer flow wing, which stalls abruptly without warning, loses lift on one side.
The heavy tail weighed down by the fuel acts like a pendulum.
Wham! The aircraft doesn’t bank.
It departs controlled flight.
It snaps over the top, rolling inverted and pitching down in a corkcrew motion that defies aerodynamics.
It looks like the plane has exploded.
It looks like the pilot has been shot.
To the German pilot in the BF 10009, the target simply ceases to be where it should be.
The German is looking through a Rivy 16B gun site.
It is a reflector site, requiring the pilot to track a smooth path to calculate lead.
But obsession is not following a smooth path.
It is tumbling through the sky in a chaotic, violent gerration.
The German pilot flinches.
He assumes the American is dead or out of control.
He stops firing.
He pulls up to avoid the debris field he expects to materialize.
Inside the cockpit, Vance is being battered against the canopy.
The world is a blur of blue and white.
He is falling at 400 mph, inverted spinning.
But Vance knows something the German doesn’t.
He knows the P-51’s recovery characteristics.
Power back, he grunts, chopping the throttle to idle to kill the torque.
Stick neutral opposite rudder.
The Mustang built with a long fuselage that provides good leverage responds.
The spin stops.
The airflow reattaches to the wings.
Vance gently pulls out of the dive at 15,000 ft.
He checks his six.
The sky is empty.
The Germans are gone.
They saw a plane tumble out of the sky and assumed it was a kill.
They didn’t chase it.
Why waste ammo on a corpse? Vance breathes.
His heart is hammering a frantic rhythm against his ribs.
He is sweating, shaking.
He just survived by intentionally breaking his airplane.
He looks at the fuel gauge for the fuselage tank.
It reads 60 gallons.
He realizes he has discovered something.
The instability isn’t a bug.
If you have the nerve to ride the chaos, it’s a cloaking device.
It makes you disappear from the math of the enemy’s gun site.
He rejoins his squadron 10 minutes later.
His flight leader, Major Papy Doyle, comes over the radio.
Slick, we thought you were a goner.
We saw you spin in.
I recovered, Papy, Vance says, his voice surprisingly steady.
You spun a Mustang with a full tank and lived.
Doyle asks incredulous.
“I didn’t just spin it,” Vance whispers to himself, padding the instrument panel.
“I vanished.” “The debriefing room at Leon Airfield is filled with cigarette smoke and the smell of wet wool.” Vance sits in the corner, staring at a diagram of the P-51’s laminer flow wing on the wall.
The wing is a masterpiece of mathematics.
Unlike earlier air foils, the thickest part of the Mustang’s wing is further back at 50% cord.
This reduces drag and allows the plane to fly faster and further than anything else.
But there is a cost.
When a standard wing stalls, the airflow separates gradually.
The pilot feels a buffet, a shutter warning him to ease off.
The Mustang’s wing doesn’t shutter.
It quits.
One second.
it is flying.
The next the lift is gone.
Combine that with the rear center of gravity from the fuselage tank and you have a recipe for a snap roll that happens faster than human reaction time.
Vance takes a piece of chalk and walks to the blackboard.
He draws a standard dogfight curve.
It is a smooth arc.
This Vance says to the room of pilots is what the German gun site expects.
The gyro site computes a curve.
It predicts where you will be in two seconds based on where you are now.
He draws a jagged erratic line that breaks off the curve at a 90° angle.
This is what happens when you snap the plane.
The other pilots look at him like he’s crazy.
You’re telling us to stall on purpose? asks Lieutenant Miller.
In combat with a bandit on our tail.
I’m telling you that a stall is only fatal if you don’t expect it.
Vance says if you initiate it, you control the recovery.
The bandit doesn’t know it’s coming.
His brain can’t process the vector change.
He loses the solution.
Target lost.
The squadron commander, Colonel Blakesley, crosses his arms.
And what happens if you don’t recover, Vance? What happens if you flat spin into the channel? Then I die,” Vance says flatly.
“But if I stay on that smooth curve with a K4 on my tail, I die anyway.
At least this way, I get to choose the terms.” Vance spends the next week refining the move.
He goes up alone.
He pushes the limits of the CG envelope.
He learns that the snap is more violent to the left because of the engine torque.
He learns that if he drops 10° of flaps just before the snap, the lift differential is even sharper.
He calls it the jutdder break.
He learns the sound of it.
The airframe groans, a low-frequency moaning of aluminum under torture.
The stick goes light in his hand as the stability fails.
He learns to trust the recovery.
Stick forward.
Rudder against the spin.
Wait for the air to bite.
It is terrifying every single time.
It feels like suicide.
January 14, 1945.
Escort mission to the oil refineries at Magnabberg.
The Luftwaffa is up in force.
Vance is leading a flight of four.
They are at 28,000 ft.
The contrails are thick, creating a false ceiling of ice crystals.
Bandits 12:00 level.
It’s a head-on merge.
the worst kind.
Closure speeds of 800 miles per hour.
Vance fires a burst, flies through the debris of a foxwolf 190 and pulls up into a vertical climb.
He checks his tail clear.
But as he levels off, he spots a lone fighter below him.
It has long slender wings, a radial engine with an annular radiator that makes it look like a long nose.
It is a Foxwolf TA 152.
The ultimate piston fighter of the war.
It is faster than the Mustang.
It turns tighter.
It is flown by the experts.
The expert who have survived 5 years of war.
The TA 152 spots Vance.
The German pilot pulls up.
He climbs with an impossible energy.
He is gaining on Vance.
Vance pushes the throttle.
The Mustang responds, but the TA 152 is relentless.
It cuts the corner.
It is closing the distance.
Vance tries a standard defensive spiral.
The German matches him effortless.
The TA 152’s long wings give it tremendous lift at high altitude.
It is eating Vance’s turn radius alive.
Vance looks at his fuel gauge.
The fuselage tank is half full.
The CG is still afted.
He can feel the German pilot’s confidence.
The enemy is taking his time refining the aim.
He knows the Mustang can’t get away.
Okay, Vance whispers.
Let’s see how good your math is.
Vance levels the wings for a split second, baiting the shot.
The German fires.
Vance yanks the stick back and kicks the rudder.
He doesn’t just snap the plane, he forces it into a tumble.
The Mustang flips end over end.
It looks like a leaf caught in a hurricane.
It is ugly.
It is chaotic.
It is aerodynamically offensive.
The German pilot, expecting a desperate turn or a dive, is baffled.
The target has effectively exploded into a cloud of tumbling aluminum.
The German breaks off his attack run, pulling up to avoid a collision with what he thinks is a destroying aircraft.
Vance hangs in his straps upside down, blood rushing to his head.
He counts to three.
Recovering, he neutralizes the controls.
He eases the power back in.
The Mustang, screaming in protest, snaps back to straight and level flight.
Vance looks up.
The TA 152 is above him, circling the pilot likely scanning for a parachute.
Vance is now below and behind.
He has lost energy, but he has gained position.
He pulls the nose up.
He has 1 second before the German realizes the dead plane is still flying.
Vance doesn’t fire.
He just watches the German fly away.
He has proven the theory.
He has defeated a superior aircraft, not with speed, but with instability.
But as he turns for home, he notices a vibration in the stick, a subtle rhythmic thrming.
He looks out at his right wing.
The aluminum skin is wrinkled.
The stress of the snap roll has warped the main spar.
He has survived the enemy, but he has wounded his own bird.
The jutdder break has a price, and the price is structural integrity.
The engineers at North American Aviation designed the P-51 for 7.33GS.
They did not design it to tumble and do in like a baton.
Obsession is grounded.
The crew chief, Sergeant Kowalsski, points out the popped rivets along the tail boom.
“You’re bending the airframe, Captain,” Kowalsski says, wiping grease from his hands.
“The vertical stabilizer is loose.
If you do whatever you’re doing one more time, the tail is going to rip off.” Vance gets a new ship, Obsession III.
It’s a brand new D25 model.
It has the tail warning radar, which is useless half the time, and the K14 gyro gun site, which is a marvel of computing.
But Vance knows the gun site is only as good as the target’s predictability.
February 1945.
The war is closing in on Berlin.
The missions are long, grinding affairs.
The Luftwaffa is dying, but it is thrashing violently in its death throws.
Vance is leading a fighter sweep near the Elba River.
They are hunting jets.
The MI262s.
Slick.
I’ve got a bogey.
3:00 low.
Moving fast.
Vance looks down.
It’s not a jet.
It’s a propeller plane, but it’s moving like a banshee.
It’s painted black.
No markings.
It’s a Dornne.
Do 335 fail.
Arrow.
A pushpull fighter with an engine in the front and an engine in the back.
It is the fastest piston engine aircraft Germany has.
I’m going down.
Vance radios.
He dives.
The Mustang builds speed 450 500.
The airframe stiffens as compressibility sets in.
The Dornier pilot sees him.
The German plane accelerates.
It pulls away from the Mustang in a straight line.
It is incredibly fast.
Vance knows he can’t catch it in a drag race.
He has to cut it off.
He pulls lead trying to intercept the Germans flight path.
The German pilot is good.
He pulls the huge heavy fighter into a vertical climb.
The two engines give him massive thrust.
Vance follows.
He is in the zoom climb now, trading his dive speed for altitude.
They are vertical.
Two silver needles stitching the sky.
The Dornier stalls first.
It’s heavy.
It flops over the top.
Vance is hanging on his prop.
He is slow.
120 knots.
He pushes the rudder to hammerhead over.
As he comes down the backside of the loop, the German reverses.
The Dornne is now on Vance’s tail.
The hunter has become the hunted.
The DU 335 has a massive nose cannon, a 30 MK 103.
It fires with a heavy slow thump thump thump.
Vance feels the rounds passing.
He is in trouble.
He is slow, low on energy, and he has a monster on his six.
He checks the fuel.
Fuselage tank is empty.
The CG is normal.
The plane is stable.
Damn.
Advance thinks I need the instability.
Without the aft CG, the Mustang is too polite.
It won’t snap as violently.
It will just stall mushily.
That won’t fool the German gunsite.
Vance has to improvise.
He needs to create instability manually.
He reaches down to the trim wheels.
He cranks the elevator trim all the way back, nose up.
Then he pushes the stick forward with all his strength to counter it.
He is fighting the plane’s aerodynamics, creating a massive tension in the control surfaces.
The plane wants to loop.
He is forcing it to fly straight.
He has loaded the spring.
The German closes to 300 yd.
The firing solution is perfect.
Now Vance screams.
He lets go of the stick.
The Mustang released from the forward pressure reacts to the full noseup trim instantly.
It doesn’t just pitch up.
It violently bunts upward putting 10 GS on the airframe in a fraction of a second.
Simultaneously, Vance kicks full left rudder.
The combination of the violent pitchup and the yaw creates a gyroscopic procession stall.
The gyroscopic force of the massive propeller spinning at 3,000 RPM translates the yaw force into a pitch force.
The Mustang tumbles.
It departs controlled flight completely.
It spins flat, rotating like a Frisbee.
The German pilot in the Dornne is looking through his sight.
One second the Mustang is there.
The next it has effectively stopped and rotated 90° flat.
The Dornne shoots past.
The German pilot cannot correct.
His heavy plane has too much momentum.
Vance is spinning.
The world is a green and blue blur.
He is low 800 feet.
He has to recover.
Stick forward opposite rudder.
The controls are slush.
The plane is locked in a flat spin.
The air is not flowing over the tail.
Come on, baby.
Fly.
Vance jams the throttle to full power.
The blast of air from the prop hits the tail.
The rudder bites.
The nose drops.
The spin breaks.
Vance pulls out at 2,000 ft.
The trees are terrifyingly close.
He levels off, his hands shaking so hard he can barely throttle back.
He looks up.
The Dornier is gone.
The pilot likely saw the flat spin and assumed the American crashed.
No one recovers from a flat spin at that altitude.
Except Vance just did.
He limps back to base.
When he lands, he can feel the plane dog tracking.
It’s flying sideways.
Kowalsski meets him at the revetment.
He looks at the plane.
The fuselage is twisted.
The metal skin behind the cockpit is wrinkled like tissue paper.
The plane is a total rideoff.
Captain Kowalsski says his voice low.
You broke her back.
She scrap metal.
Vance climbs out.
He pats the twisted aluminum.
Better her than me, chief.
Vance says better her than me.
Vance is grounded, not by the enemy, but by the flight surgeon.
Combat fatigue, the thousandy stare.
You can only snap roll a high performance fighter into the abyss so many times before your own internal gyro starts to fail.
He spends the last month of the war in the officer’s club drinking warm beer and teaching the new kids.
The Mustang is a lady, Vance tells a group of wideeyed second lieutenants.
But she’s a lady with a temper.
If you treat her gentle, she flies gentle.
But if the wolf is at the door, you have to make her crazy.
You have to be willing to throw away the manual.
He draws the diagram again, the smooth curve, the jagged break.
The German sites are machines, Vance says, tapping the chalk.
Machines love predictability.
They love calculus.
They hate chaos.
Be chaos.
The war ends in May 1945.
Vance goes home to Ohio.
He never flies a plane again.
He becomes a structural engineer designing bridges.
He spends the rest of his life calculating load limits, safety margins, ensuring that things don’t fall down.
But the legacy of the target lost move lives on.
In 1952, over the Yalu River in Korea, American pilots in F86 Sabers find themselves outturned by the lighter Mig 15s.
A veteran pilot remembers a story from the big war.
He remembers Vance’s theory of instability.
He teaches his wingman to execute a high G barrel roll that forces the attacker to overshoot.
It’s the same principle.
Disrupt the tracking solution.
In the 1960s, the concept evolves.
It becomes part of the energy maneuverability theory developed by John Boyd.
Boyd realizes that the ability to transition quickly between energy states to go from fast to slow, from stable to unstable, is more important than raw speed.
Vance’s jutdder break was the grandfather of the cobra maneuver that Sukcoy pilots would perform decades later, a maneuver where the plane pitches up past vertical, stalling instantly, effectively stopping in midair to force an overshoot.
Vance watches the news in 1989.
He sees a Russian jet perform the Cobra at the Paris Air Show.
The crowd gasps.
The announcers call it impossible aerodynamics.
Vance smiles.
He is an old man now.
He sits in his armchair, his hands gripping the armrests.
He remembers the smell of ozone.
He remembers the vibration of the laminer wing letting go.
He remembers the terror of the spin.
It’s not impossible, he whispers to the television.
You just have to trust the recovery.
One afternoon, Vance receives a letter.
It is from Germany.
It is from a man named Hans.
He was a Luftwaffa pilot.
He flew a TA 152.
Dear Captain Vance, the letter reads, I have spent 40 years wondering what happened to the Mustang I fought over Magnabberg.
I saw you explode.
I saw you tumble.
I wrote in my log book that you were destroyed by structural failure.
But then I saw your name in a history of the 357th Fighter Group.
You lived.
You survived.
I realized then that you defeated me not with your guns but with your mind.
You understood that I was looking for a plane and you became a falling leaf.
It was the finest piece of flying I never saw.
Vance folds the letter.
He looks out the window at the peaceful Ohio corn fields.
The P-51 Mustang is remembered as the Cadillac of the sky.
It is remembered for its range, its speed, its beauty.
But for Cela’s Vance, it was a weapon of deception.
He proved that in the cold mathematical equation of aerial combat, the only variable that truly matters is the pilot’s willingness to embrace the fall.
He proved that sometimes to survive the untouchable, you have to become unflyable.
