So, we didn’t even consider them Jewish anymore.

They were apostates.

But as the evening went on and David spoke, something bothered me.

He wasn’t ignorant.

He wasn’t some uneducated person who had been tricked into believing a false gospel.

He knew Torah.

He knew Talmud.

He knew the rabbitical commentaries.

When he quoted scripture, he quoted it in Hebrew.

And he knew the context and the traditional interpretations.

After the formal discussion ended, I found myself talking with him privately.

I don’t know why I did it.

Maybe I was looking for someone to prove my growing doubts wrong.

Maybe I wanted him to say something foolish so I could dismiss everything I had been thinking about.

Maybe I was just desperate to talk to someone, anyone, about the questions that were tearing me apart.

Should I asked him how he could believe in Jesus and still call himself a Jew? He smiled, not in a mocking way, but sadly, like he had heard this question many times before, and it still hurt.

He told me his story.

He had been raised Orthodox just like me.

He had studied at Yeshiva.

He had been on track to become a rabbi, but then he started reading the Messianic prophecies in the Tanakh, and he couldn’t reconcile them with what he had been taught.

So he did something that terrified him.

He read the New Testament.

I interrupted him there.

I told him that the New Testament was a Christian book, a foreign book, nothing to do with Judaism.

He looked at me carefully and said something I will never forget.

He said, “Rabbi, have you ever actually read it?” I hadn’t.

Of course I hadn’t.

Why would I? It was a Christian book.

It was about a false messiah or a rabbi who led people astray, who was rejected by our people, and rightly so.

I knew what it said without reading it.

Or at least I thought I did.

David reached into his bag and pulled out a book.

It was a Jewish New Testament, he explained, translated in a way that showed its Jewish context.

He handed it to me and told me that if I really wanted to understand why he believed what he believed, I should read it.

Not with the intent to convert, he said.

Just read it and see if it sounds as foreign as you think it does.

I took the book.

I don’t know why.

Maybe because part of me was curious.

Maybe because the questions that had been building in my mind for the past two months were becoming unbearable and I needed answers from somewhere anywhere.

I drove home with that book sitting on the passenger seat of my car like a live bomb.

I felt guilty just having it.

When I got home, I hid it in my study in the back of a drawer where no one would find it.

For three days, it sat there and I didn’t touch it.

I knew that if I opened that book, if I read it, I was crossing a line.

I was doing something that every Orthodox Jew knew was forbidden.

We don’t read missionary materials.

We don’t expose ourselves to Christian teachings.

These things are dangerous.

They can lead you astray.

But on the fourth night, after everyone had gone to bed, I took the book out of the drawer.

My hands were shaking as I opened it to the first page.

The Gospel of Matthew, it was called the Genealogy of Yeshua, Jesus, son of David, son of Abraham.

I started reading and I couldn’t stop.

Matthew was written by a Jew to Jews about Jewish things.

It started with a genealogy proving that Jesus was descended from King David.

It talked about Torah, about the prophets, about the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.

It quoted from the Tanakh constantly, showing how Jesus fulfilled prophecy after prophecy.

He was born in Bethlehem, just like Micah 5:2 said the Messiah would be.

He was called out of Egypt just like Hosea 11:1 said.

He spoke in parables just like Psalm 78:2 said the Messiah would do.

I read about his teachings, the sermon on the mount.

And I was shocked to discover that it sounded like like the rabbis, like Jewish ethical teaching.

Blessed are the meek.

Blessed are those who hunger for righteousness.

Don’t murder and don’t even hate in your heart.

Don’t commit adultery and don’t even lust in your heart.

This was taking the Torah and showing its deepest meaning, its heart.

This wasn’t foreign.

This wasn’t pagan.

This was deeply, thoroughly Jewish.

I read how Jesus celebrated Passover with his disciples, how he taught in the temple, how he quoted Moses and the prophets, how he said he hadn’t come to abolish the Torah but to fulfill it.

And I read how he was rejected by the religious leaders.

How he was arrested.

How he was crucified.

I read how before he died, he cried out, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” The opening words of Psalm 22.

The psalm about the suffering servant with pierced hands and feet.

I sat in my study with tears streaming down my face reading about the resurrection.

About how on the third day, according to the scriptures, Jesus rose from the dead.

About how he appeared to his disciples.

Even about how he showed them his wounds.

about how he opened their minds to understand the scriptures.

Beginning with Moses and all the prophets, he explained to them what was said in all the scriptures concerning himself.

I closed the book and put my head in my hands.

The sun was starting to come up.

I had been reading all night, and I was terrified because everything I had just read, it made sense.

It fit together.

The prophecies, the timeline, the suffering servant, the pierced one, the son of David who would reign forever.

It all pointed to one person, Yeshua.

Jesus.

No.

No.

This couldn’t be right.

This was Christian propaganda.

This was deception.

I was a rabbi.

I knew Judaism.

I knew the truth.

Jesus was a false Messiah.

He had to be.

But then why did the prophecies fit him so perfectly? Why did Isaiah 53 describe his death so accurately? Why did Daniel’s timeline point exactly to his time? Why did Psalm 22 describe crucifixion in such detail written hundreds of years before crucifixion was invented? I put the New Testament back in the drawer and locked it.

I didn’t sleep that day.

I went through my duties in a days.

I taught a class and barely remember what I said.

I met with the synagogue board and nodded at the right times.

I came home and had dinner with my family and pretended everything was normal.

But nothing was normal.

My entire world was tilting on its axis and I felt like I was going to fall off.

Over the next few months, I became obsessed.

Late at night, when everyone was asleep, I would take out that New Testament and read more.

I read the Gospel of Luke, a written by a careful historian who interviewed eyewitnesses.

I read the Gospel of John with its profound theological teachings.

I read the Acts of the Apostles about how the early believers, all Jews, spread the message of Yeshua throughout the known world.

And I read the letter to the Hebrews.

This was the one that broke me.

The letter to the Hebrews was written to Jews who believed in Yeshua, explaining how he fulfilled the entire sacrificial system of the Torah.

It talked about how the law was a shadow of the good things to come, not the reality itself.

How the blood of bulls and goats could never take away sins.

How we needed a better sacrifice, a perfect sacrifice.

And then I read Hebrews 9 22.

Without the shedding of blood, there is no forgiveness.

I sat there staring at that verse for a long time because I knew it was true.

The Torah itself says it.

Leviticus 17 11.

It is the blood that makes atonement for one’s life.

But there was a problem, a massive fundamental problem that I had never really thought about before.

We don’t have the temple anymore.

The Romans destroyed it in the year 70.

For almost 2,000 years, we haven’t had a temple.

And without a temple, we can’t offer sacrifices.

And without sacrifices, without the shedding of blood, how can we have atonement for our sins? I thought about Yom Kipur, the day of atonement, our holiest day.

In ancient times, the high priest would enter the Holy of Holies once a year and sprinkle blood on the mercy seat to atone for the sins of the nation.

But we don’t do that anymore.

We can’t.

So what do we do instead? We fast.

We pray.

We ask God for forgiveness based on our repentance and good deeds.

But the Torah says we need blood.

The Torah says, “Without blood, there is no forgiveness.

” For 2,000 years, we’ve been trying to atone for our sins without the blood that God said was necessary.

Unless Unless there was a sacrifice that happened 2,000 years ago, a final sacrifice, a perfect sacrifice, one that was so complete, so effective that it covered all sins for all time.

A lamb without blemish, slain so that we could be forgiven.

I thought about the Passover lamb.

How in Egypt God commanded each family to take a perfect lamb, kill it, and put its blood on their doorposts.

When the angel of death came through Egypt, the blood would be a sign, and the angel would pass over that house.

The lamb died so the firstborn could live.

and the lamb died so others could live.

By his wounds we are healed.

I started weeping again sitting there in my study in the middle of the night because I was starting to understand the whole Torah, the whole sacrificial system, the whole structure of atonement.

It had been pointing to something, to someone, the reality that cast the shadow.

Yeshua, the lamb of God, the final perfect sacrifice.

I wanted to talk to someone.

I wanted to share what I was discovering, to ask questions, to have someone help me make sense of this.

But who could I tell? If I told another rabbi, they would think I was going insane.

If I told my wife, she would be devastated.

If I told my congregation, they would remove me immediately.

So, I kept it to myself, and the secret ate away at me like acid.

I lost more weight.

I wasn’t sleeping.

I was snapping at my children for no reason.

Rachel knew something was wrong, but every time she asked, I told her I was fine.

I was lying to my wife.

I was lying to everyone.

And I was becoming more and more convinced that Yeshua was exactly who he claimed to be, the Messiah, the son of God, the savior of the world.

And if he was, if he really was, then what was I going to do about it? The breaking point came on Yomkipur, the day of atonement, the holiest day of the Jewish year when we fast and pray and ask God to forgive our sins and write our names in the book of life for another year.

I had led Yom Kipur services for 23 years as a rabbi.

I knew the liturgy by heart.

I knew the traditions, the prayers, the ancient rituals that connected us to our fathers.

Going back to Moses, it was always the most meaningful day of the year for me.

The day when I felt closest to God.

But this Yom Kipur was different.

This Yom Kipur, I stood before my congregation knowing things I hadn’t known before.

And those things made everything feel hollow.

The service started at sunset.

The cold nidra prayer, the haunting melody that releases us from vows we made to God that we couldn’t keep.

I sang the words I had sung every year.

But this time I was thinking, what about the covenant itself? What about the promises God made to Abraham, to Moses, to David? Didn’t God promise that the Messiah would come? And if he came and we rejected him, what then? We spent the
next 24 hours in prayer, no food, no water, asking God to forgive us.

I stood before the ark containing our Torah scrolls, and I led the prayers for forgiveness.

We confessed our sins.

We have been guilty.

We have betrayed.

We have robbed.

We have spoken slander.

going through the entire alphabet of wrongdoing.

But as I prayed, as I beat my chest in repentance, a question kept echoing in my mind.

Where is the sacrifice? Where is the blood? In the ancient temple on Yum Kipur, the high priest would take two goats.

One goat would be sacrificed, its blood sprinkled on the mercy seat to atone for sins.

The other goat, the scapegoat, would have all the sins of the people symbolically placed on its head.

And then it would be driven out into the wilderness, carrying those sins away.

But we don’t do that anymore.

We haven’t done it in 2,000 years.

We just pray and hope that God accepts our prayers instead of the blood sacrifice that his own Torah says is necessary.

See, I thought about what I had read in the letter to the Hebrews.

How on Yum Kipur in the ancient temple, the high priest would enter the Holy of Holies with blood.

But Yeshua entered the true Holy of Holies, heaven itself, with his own blood, obtaining eternal redemption for us.

Not the blood of goats and bulls, which can never take away sins, but his own blood, which can cleanse us completely.

The service went on for hours.

We prayed for forgiveness.

We asked God to seal our fate for good in the coming year.

And I stood there leading these prayers while my heart was breaking because I knew something my congregation didn’t know.

There was a sacrifice.

God had provided a sacrifice.

A perfect lamb without blemish who took away the sins of the world.

And we had rejected him.

My people had rejected him 2,000 years ago.

And we were still rejecting him now.

When the service finally ended at nightfall the next day, when the chauffear was blown to signal the end of the fast, everyone around me was relieved and joyful.

We had made it through another yom kipur.

God had heard our prayers.

We were forgiven for another year.

I went through the motions of shaking hands, accepting good wishes for a good year.

But inside I was screaming.

After everyone had left, after I had locked up the synagogue, I went back inside and sat in the sanctuary alone in the dark.

And I wept, deep, wrenching sobs that came from a place I didn’t even know existed inside me because I finally understood what had been bothering me all these months.

I had been trying to make atonement without the atonement God provided.

All these years of service, all this effort to be good enough, I to be righteous enough to earn God’s favor through my prayers and my works and my observance of the law.

And it was all insufficient.

Not because I wasn’t trying hard enough, but because that’s not how God designed it to work.

The law was never meant to save us.

It was meant to show us that we needed saving.

The sacrifices were never meant to permanently remove our sins.

They were meant to point us toward the one sacrifice that could.

I drove home that night feeling like I was coming apart.

When I walked in the door, Rachel was waiting up for me.

She took one look at my face and knew something was terribly wrong.

She asked me what happened.

I told her I couldn’t talk about it.

She asked if I was sick.

I said no.

She asked if something happened at the synagogue.

I said no.

Then she did something that broke my heart.

She put her arms around me and held me while I cried.

She didn’t know what was wrong, but she held me anyway.

And I knew that I was about to destroy everything, our marriage, our family, our life together, because I couldn’t keep living this lie.

A few weeks later, Rachel found the New Testament.

I had been careless.

I had left it out on my desk, thinking I would put it away before anyone saw it.

But I got called away to deal with an emergency.

A family in the congregation had a death.

And when I came back hours later, Rachel was sitting in my study holding the book.

Her face was white.

She looked at me like she didn’t recognize me.

She asked me what this was.

I tried to explain.

I tried to tell her about the journey I had been on, about the prophecies I had been studying, about the questions I couldn’t answer.

But she wasn’t listening.

She was crying and asking me if I was converting to Christianity.

She asked if I was abandoning our faith.

She asked if I was abandoning her.

I told her I wasn’t abandoning anything.

I told her I had found the truth.

And the truth was that Yeshua was the Messiah we had been waiting for all along.

She stood up and backed away from me like I had struck her.

She said I was destroying our family.

She said I was throwing away everything we had built.

She said our children would be devastated.

She begged me to stop this, to burn that book, to forget everything I had been thinking about and just come back to normal life.

I told her I couldn’t.

I told her that once you see the truth, you can’t unsee it.

I told her that I loved her with all my heart, but I couldn’t deny what God had shown me.

She left the study crying, and that night she slept in the guest room.

The next morning, she was cold and distant.

The warmth that had defined our marriage for over 20 years was gone, frozen by my betrayal.

Our children knew something was wrong.

Sarah, who was 17, asked me if mom was okay.

I told her that mom and I were having some disagreements, but that we loved her and everything would be fine.

I was lying again.

Everything was not going to be fine.

Within a week, word started spreading through our Orthodox community.

I don’t know how it happened.

Maybe Rachel told her parents.

Maybe someone saw me meeting with David Rosenberg, the Messianic Jew.

Maybe it was just the way news travels in a tight-knit community where everyone knows everyone.

I started getting phone calls from other rabbis.

At first, they were gentle, concerned, wanting to help me through what they saw as a crisis of faith or possibly a mental breakdown.

They invited me to lunch, to coffee, to their homes.

They wanted to talk to understand what was happening to me.

I tried to explain.

I showed them the prophecies.

I walked them through Isaiah 53, through Psalm 22, through Daniel 9.

I showed them how the timeline pointed to Yeshua.

I explained about the sacrifice, about the blood atonement we no longer had, about how Yeshua fulfilled the entire sacrificial system.

They listened and then they explained to me why I was wrong.

Isaiah 53 was about Israel.

The suffering was metaphorical.

Daniel’s numbers were symbolic.

Psalm 22 was just David being dramatic.

And the idea that God would have a son, that God would become human, sought that the Messiah would need to die.

These were pagan ideas, Greek ideas, not Jewish ideas.

I asked them about the blood atonement.

Without the temple, without sacrifices, how are we forgiven? They told me that God accepts prayer and repentance instead.

I asked them where in Torah it says that.

They said the rabbis had explained it.

The oral tradition says that after the temple was destroyed, God accepted our prayers as a substitute for sacrifice.

But I kept thinking, that’s not what the Torah says.

The Torah says we need blood.

And you’re telling me that God changed his mind? That what he said was absolutely necessary is now no longer necessary.

The conversations went nowhere.

We were speaking different languages.

They were speaking from tradition, from what the rabbis had always taught.

I was speaking from scripture, from what the text actually said.

After a few weeks, the gentle concerns turned to warnings.

A group of senior rabbis from the area came to meet with me.

There were five of them, respected men I had known for years.

They sat in my living room and told me that I was in danger of being labeled a heretic.

Continue reading….
« Prev Next »