Why weren’t we seeing flames through the windows yet? His questions felt like they were coming from another lifetime, from a version of myself that no longer existed.

I took a deep breath and told him the truth as simply as I could manage.

I couldn’t go through with it.

Something had happened inside that church that changed everything.

We needed to abort the mission immediately and get away from this place before anyone discovered what we had been planning.

The reaction was exactly what I had feared it would be.

Muhammad’s face twisted with rage and disbelief.

He grabbed me by the shoulders and shook me, demanding to know what had happened to my courage and my faith.

Hassan appeared from the shadows behind the church.

His eyes while with the expectation of seeing Christian property burning when he realized there was no fire.

Fahi began cursing me in Arabic, calling me a coward and a traitor to Islam.

Omar was the most vicious in his response.

He accused me of losing my nerve at the crucial moment of betraying not just our mission but the memory of Ayatah Kame himself.

He said, “I had dishonored my family, my community, and Allah by backing down when it mattered most.

Every word he spoke felt like a physical blow.

Not because I believed him anymore, but because I could see how completely I had disappointed men who had trusted me with their hopes for justice.

Tar tried to grab the matches from my hand, saying he would complete the job himself if I was too weak to do it.

But something had changed in my physical bearing along with everything else.

And I found myself standing firm against his attempts to push past me toward the church entrance.

I I told them that no one was going into that building, that what we had planned was wrong, and that we needed to leave immediately before we made a terrible mistake we could never undo.

The argument that followed was the most intense confrontation I had ever had with fellow Muslims.

These men had been my brothers in faith, my partners in righteous anger, my allies in the struggle against what we saw as Christian oppression.

Now they were looking at me like I had become their enemy.

And in their minds, that’s exactly what had happened.

Ahmed arrived just as the shouting was reaching dangerous levels that might attract neighborhood attention.

He quickly assessed the situation and pulled me aside for a private conversation.

His approach was more calculated than the others as more focused on understanding what had gone wrong rather than simply expressing anger about the failure.

I tried to explain to him about the supernatural encounter I had experienced, about the presence I had felt and the love that had overwhelmed me.

But even as I spoke the words, I could see in his eyes that he thought I was having some kind of nervous breakdown.

He suggested that the stress of the mission and the fumes from the gasoline had caused me to hallucinate or panic.

When gentle persuasion failed to change my mind, Ahmed’s tone became much harder.

He reminded me that I knew all of their identities and could implicate them if I was arrested.

He suggested that my sudden change of heart might be the result of police pressure, that perhaps I had been caught earlier and agreed to cooperate with law enforcement in exchange for leniency.

The accusation stung because it showed how completely my transformation had severed the trust between us.

It was at that moment as I stood in the alley behind St.

Matthew’s Episcopal Church trying to convince four angry Muslims that Jesus Christ had just saved my soul.

That I heard the sound of police sirens growing closer.

Someone in the neighborhood had noticed our suspicious activity and called the authorities.

The very outcome we had planned so carefully to avoid was now approaching rapidly.

And I was the only one who felt relief instead of terror.

As the sirens grew louder, the other men scattered in different directions without another word to me.

They disappeared into the darkness.

I’m leaving me standing alone with the evidence of our failed arson attempt and a heart so full of peace that even the approaching police couldn’t disturb it.

When the police cars pulled up with their flashing lights illuminating the church grounds, I made a decision that surprised even me.

Instead of running like my former brothers had done, I walked directly toward the officers with my hands visible and my heart strangely calm.

The empty gasoline container was still in my hand, and I knew there was no point in trying to hide what we had planned to do.

The lead officer was a middle-aged black man whose name plate read Detective Williams.

He approached me cautiously, his hand resting on his weapon, but not drawn.

I could smell the lingering gasoline fumes on my clothing, and I knew he could, too, before he could ask any questions.

I I told him exactly what had happened.

I had come to this church with the intention of burning it down, but something had stopped me, and I needed to confess everything.

Detective Williams looked skeptical as he handcuffed me and read my rights, but I could see curiosity in his eyes as well.

It wasn’t every day that someone voluntarily confessed to attempted arson before being accused of anything.

As he led me to the patrol car, I found myself talking continuously, trying to explain about the supernatural encounter that had changed my heart.

Even though I knew how crazy it must have sounded, the next several hours at the police station were a blur of questioning, paperwork, and phone calls.

I gave them complete details about our plot, including the names of the other men involved and the planning meetings we had held at the mosque.

Detective Williams kept asking me why I was cooperating so fully when I could have claimed I was just an innocent bystander who happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.

How do you explain to a police detective that Jesus Christ had personally intervened to stop you from committing a hate crime? How do you describe the feeling of being completely transformed by divine love in the space of a few minutes? I tried my best to put the experience into words, but I could see that Detective Williams thought I was either mentally unstable or trying to
use a religious conversion story to reduce my legal consequences.

The charges against me were serious attempted arson, conspiracy to commit a hate crime, and several other felonies that could have sent me to prison for decades.

Uh but something remarkable happened during the legal proceedings that followed.

Pastor Margaret from St.

Matthews Episcopal Church, the very building I had tried to destroy, came to court and spoke on my behalf.

She told the judge that she had spent time with me during the weeks after my arrest, visiting me in jail and listening to my story.

She said she believed my conversion was genuine and that throwing me in prison for 20 years would accomplish nothing positive for anyone involved.

Instead, she proposed that I be sentenced to extensive community service, specifically working to repair the damage that religious extremism caused in communities like ours.

The judge was initially skeptical of Pastor Margaret’s recommendation.

Ah, but she had brought letters of support from other religious leaders in Brooklyn who had met with me and vouched for the authenticity of my transformation.

The imam from my former mosque had disowned me completely.

But several Christian pastors, a Jewish rabbi, and even a few moderate Muslim leaders had written statements saying they believed I could be become a force for healing rather than division.

My family’s reaction was devastating, but not unexpected.

My father stripped me of my name and declared that I was no longer his son.

My mother wept for days, convinced that I had been brainwashed by Christian missionaries or government agents.

My siblings stopped speaking to me entirely, and several of my cousins made it clear that I was no longer welcome at family gatherings or community events.

The Muslim community’s rejection was complete and absolute.

Men who had been my closest friends began crossing the street to avoid encountering me.

The mosque where I had taught Sunday school for years banned me from entering the building.

Even Muslims who disagreed with our extremist plot still saw my conversion to Christianity as the ultimate betrayal worse than the attempted arson itself.

But as my old community cast me out, a new one embraced me with open arms.

The congregation at St.

Matthew’s Episcopal Church welcomed me despite knowing exactly what I had planned to do to their sacred space.

They invited me to their Bible studies, their fellowship dinners, their prayer meetings.

They treated me not as a former terrorist who had been reformed, but as a brother who had been lost and was now found.

6 months after that November night, I was baptized in the same sanctuary where I had encountered Jesus Christ.

Pastor Margaret performed the ceremony and Detective Williams actually attended the service along with several other police officers who had been involved in my case.

As I went under the water and came back up, I felt like the last traces of my old life were being washed away forever.

Today I serve as pastor Lukeman at the Brooklyn Interfaith Peace Center, a ministry I founded to help prevent religious extremism and promote understanding between different faith communities.

I speak regularly at churches, mosques, synagogues, and community centers about my experience and the power of divine love to transform even the hardest hearts.

The work isn’t easy and many Christians still view me with suspicion because of my Muslim background.

Many Muslims see me as a traitor who sold out his faith for acceptance by the dominant culture.

But every day I wake up grateful for the night Jesus Christ saved me from committing an act of hatred that would have destroyed multiple lives, including my own.

Ask yourself this question.

What walls is God calling you to tear down in your own heart? What hatred are you carrying that could be transformed into love if you let him work in your life? I came to destroy God’s house that night in November, but instead God built his house in my heart forever.

 

« Prev