It was simply the feeling of a crack.

The first thin crack in a wall that had taken years to build.

The first moment in which the absolute certainty I had lived inside began to show a fissure and through that fissure came the cold draft of a question I had not allowed myself to ask.

What did I just do? Not what did the group just do? Not what did we accomplish.

What did I just do? I sat down on the ground against that wall in court adu and I put my face in my still shaking hands and I tried to think but thinking was not possible yet.

The images kept coming unbidden and unstoppable.

The singing rising above the smoke.

The congregation walking out together upright.

The old woman’s face turned up toward the sky.

The fire that burned but not the way it was supposed to.

The people who were afraid because they were.

I know that.

I know they were frightened.

I know what it is to be in a burning building.

And I know that even the most faithful person is still a human being in a body that registers danger.

but who were not destroyed by the fear, who had something in them that was stronger than what we had brought against them.

I stayed there for a long time.

I did not know it then, but I was already changed.

Not saved, not even close to saved, not yet capable of naming what had happened or where it was going.

The road from that morning to the man I am today was long and painful and full of its own fire.

A different kind of fire, the internal kind that burns away the things you cannot afford to keep carrying.

But the process had begun.

Something had been set in motion in front of that whitewash church with the iron cross on its roof.

And it was not the process we had planned.

and prepared for.

It was something else entirely, something none of us had prepared for, and none of us could have stopped.

I went home that afternoon to the house where I had grown up.

I went home to the sound of my mother in the kitchen, and the smell of food cooking, and the ordinary, unchanged texture of everything that had always been there.

I sat down to eat and I could not taste the food.

I answered questions without knowing what I was saying.

I smiled when it was expected of me.

I performed the surface of normaly while something underneath the surface was shifting, grinding, resettling.

I went to my room when the evening came and I lay on my mat and I stared at the ceiling.

The ceiling I had stared at a thousand times.

Cracks I had memorized without meaning to.

The particular gray of the plaster, the single dark mark near the corner that had been there as long as I could remember.

All of it unchanged.

All of it exactly as it had always been.

And for the first time in as long as I could remember, I did not pray.

Not because I had decided not to, but because I could not find the words, because every formula I had ever used to speak to God suddenly felt hollow and insufficient and slightly false, like a script I had been reading without understanding the play, because something had happened that morning that my prayers had no container for, that sat outside the edges of everything I thought I knew and demanded that I look at it and I could not look at it and pray in the old way at the same time because looking at it honestly meant admitting that I did not
understand it.

And admitting I did not understand it meant admitting that the world was not arranged the way I had been so completely certain it was.

So I lay there in silence, and the silence was enormous.

It had weight and texture.

It pressed down slightly from above and rose slightly from below and surrounded me like something thick.

And somewhere in that silence, without my permission, without my understanding, without my knowledge of what it meant or where it would lead, something that felt like a question began to form.

Not a question I could put into words.

Yet just the shape of one, just the sensation of an opening where before there had been only wall, just the beginning of a wondering and that was enough.

That was enough for what came next.

There is a particular kind of silence that follows a terrible thing, not peace.

Do not confuse the two.

Silence is not always peace.

Sometimes silence is just the absence of all the noise you were using to avoid thinking.

And when that noise stops, you are left alone with what is actually inside you.

And what is inside you is not always something you are prepared to face.

That is the kind of silence that followed me in the days after that Sunday morning.

It followed me the way a shadow follows a man in afternoon light.

Always just behind, always slightly larger than you, impossible to outrun, disappearing only when you turn toward the sun.

But I was not yet turning toward anything.

I was only running.

The nightmare started within the first week.

I have never been someone who places great significance in dreams as messages or prophecy.

I want to be careful about that.

But I will tell you what kept happening because it was a real part of those weeks and it is part of the honors telling.

I kept seeing the church not always in the same version but always with the same essential elements.

The smoke rising in that windless sky.

The singing that refused to stop.

The congregation walking out with their arms around each other.

And specifically always the old woman’s face turned upward toward the sky and the small boy in the doorway with his lips moving quietly.

And in the dreams I was always standing exactly where I had stood that morning at a distance watching, unable to move, unable to look away, unable to do anything except witness what I had set in motion and could not undo.

Sometimes the fire would turn in the dream and begin moving toward me.

Not violently, not like something attacking.

slowly the way water rises in a flood, finding the low places filling them patient.

And I would wake from those dreams with my heart hammering in the darkness of my room and lie there listening to my own breathing and feel the walls of everything I had built pressing in on me from all sides.

I need to take you back into that morning more carefully before I take you forward.

I rushed through parts of it in the first telling and there are things I did not fully describe that I need to describe now.

Things I have spent years trying to find the right words for.

Not because they are impossible to describe, but because they are the kind of things that when you describe them plainly and without exaggeration, without decoration, just as they were, they can sound like something constructed, something designed to achieve an effect.

And I am not constructing anything.

I have no reason to.

The truth of what I saw that morning is strange enough on its own that it does not need my help.

I told you the fire was real.

I want to come back to that and be more specific because the specificity is important.

It is the specificity that cannot be argued away.

General claims are arguable.

Specific ones are harder to dismiss.

The wooden storage structures connected to the rear and side of the church building were old.

When I say old, I mean the kind of old that Punjab sun produces over decades.

The kind of old where the wood has been slowly giving back its moisture to the air for so many summers that it has become something closer to tinder than timber.

There was no earthly reason those sections should have done anything except catch immediately and burn completely and fast.

We knew this.

The man who had planned it knew this.

He had done similar things before.

He had chosen the target partly for this reason.

The physics of what we set in motion was not in question.

The wooden sections did catch.

I will not tell you they didn’t.

They caught and they burned and the smoke went up and the heat came outward in that wall I described.

I’m not going to tell you the fire simply stopped because God blew on it because that is not what happened and that would not be the truth and the truth is the only thing I am here to offer you.

What happened was more subtle and more unsettling than an obvious miracle.

And I have come to think that is exactly how it was supposed to be because something completely obvious is easy to dismiss afterward.

Easy to explain with one argument or another.

Easy to file under coincidence or exaggeration or the unreliable memory of a guilty man.

What happened that morning was the kind of thing that does not loudly announce itself as miraculous.

It simply sits there quiet and immovable in the middle of your explanation and refuses to be fully accounted for.

The fire burned the storage structures.

It damaged the rear wall significantly.

It sent smoke through gaps in the building structure into the interior where the congregation was gathered.

By every reasonable assessment of what we had done and how we had done it, that interior should have become untenable very quickly.

smoke in an enclosed space with a congregation of that size and with the fire behaving the way we had arranged for it to behave should have driven people out in minutes.

Should have made the air unbreathable.

Should have created the kind of desperate choking urgency that overrides everything else.

every prayer, every song, every impulse except survive.

That is not what happened.

The fire seemed to find a boundary, a point, a limit beyond which it did not progress at the speed it should have in the direction it should have with the total consumption it should have achieved.

I cannot give you a formula for this.

I cannot give you measurements.

I’m not a scientist.

And even if I were, I was standing at a distance, watching, not inside with instruments.

What I can give you is what I observed as carefully and honestly as I can render it.

Fire that burned but did not consume in the way I had been told it would.

and a congregation that remained inside that building far longer than any reasonable calculation of the situation should have allowed and came out of it more intact than they had any human right to be.

There were injuries.

I have said this before and I will keep saying it because I do not want this account to become something other than what it is.

the truth, including the painful parts of the truth.

People were hurt.

One man had an injury serious enough that he needed medical attention beyond what the village could provide.

The smoke alone left marks in people’s lungs that took weeks to heal.

I am not asking you to believe that nothing bad happened.

I’m asking you to believe that what happened was less than what should have happened and that the difference between those two things is the space where something I cannot explain with ordinary logic lives.

But more than the fire itself, it was the people.

Let me go deeper into the singing than I did before because it deserves more than I gave it and because it is one of the things I carry most clearly.

I had heard Christians sing before in passing at a distance through the walls of that church on mornings when I walked the longer road.

It had never meant anything to me.

It had been background noise at best.

The sound of people doing something in a building I was not interested in.

But that morning, hearing those voices rise from a building that was beginning to burn, the specific quality of it, the persistence of it, the refusal of it to become something else, something panicked or desperate or extinguished.

It reached a place in me
that nothing had reached in years.

It was not the beauty of it.

I’m not telling you it was musically extraordinary, though for all I know it was.

It was the fact of it.

The sheer impossible irrational fact that it was happening at all.

that in the middle of smoke and heat and danger, human beings were choosing to lift their voices in that specific vertical direction and choosing and choosing again and not stopping choosing even as the situation continued to be what it was.

You do not have to believe what I believe to understand why that is extraordinary.

You do not have to be a Christian or a Muslim or anything at all.

You just have to be an honest human being who understands that fear is one of the most powerful forces we carry.

That it overrides almost everything else when it is fully activated.

That it reduces us to our most basic wiring.

Run, hide, protect yourself, survive above all else.

And then you have to account for people responding to a situation that should have fully activated that most basic fear response by doing something entirely different.

By choosing to direct themselves upward rather than outward.

By choosing prayer over panic.

By choosing a posture of faith when every nerve in the body is screaming a different instruction.

I had been taught that Christians were weak, that their faith was a borrowed and corrupted thing, a diminished version of something that had once been true, emptied of its real content by human manipulation over centuries, that they had no real power behind them, that their prayers went nowhere because they were directed at nothing.

And yet what I was watching, what I was hearing was not weakness.

It was the furthest thing from weakness that I had ever observed in my life.

I did not have the vocabulary for what it was yet.

I had no framework that could hold it, but I knew, standing there with the sound of their sinking reaching me over the heat and the smoke, that the people inside the building had access to something I did not have, something I had never encountered before in any form, something that the ideology I had given years of my life to had never once provided.

for all its promises of
righteousness and power and divine approval.

Something that held the congregation came out and I want to tell you more carefully about what I saw as they emerged because I held back details before that I need to give you now.

They came out mostly together.

There was a deliberateness to how they moved.

Not the paralyzed deliberateness of shock.

Not the stumbling chaos of people in the grip of pure animal fear, but the deliberateness of people who are still in the middle of crisis, thinking about each other, conscious of each other.

I watched a young woman emerge and immediately turn back toward the door, not to go back in, but to hold it open and look for who was still coming.

I watched a teenage boy come out coughing badly, coughing so hard he was bent double and immediately be caught by two older men who held him and kept him upright.

I watched the careful, deliberate way in which those people organized themselves around each other’s need, even in the midst of their own distress.

I had spent years in a group of my own.

I knew what group solidarity looked like in the version I had lived.

It looked like shared anger, shared contempt, shared purpose directed at a target.

A kind of togetherness that required an outside enemy to sustain it that needed the other to hold itself together.

What I was watching in front of that church was togetherness of a different species entirely.

It was not unified by opposition.

It was unified by something else.

something interior and foundational, something that did not need an outside enemy to give its shape.

It simply was the way a strong building simply stands because of what it is made of rather than because of what it is set against.

I did not have words for this.

I only felt it as a contrast so stark it was almost physical.

Among the last people to come out of the church was a small boy.

I have described him briefly before.

I need to describe him more fully now because he is the specific human being who reached furthest into me that morning.

Not the most dramatic element of what I witnessed, not the most obviously extraordinary thing, but the thing that my heart, whatever small undeadened portion of my heart was still capable of receiving anything at all, could not construct an argument against.

He was perhaps seven or 8 years old, small for his age, with dark eyes and a narrow face.

He was holding the hand of a woman.

I took to be his mother who was coughing very badly.

The kind of deep wrenching cough that comes from smoke damaged airways.

The kind that shakes the whole body.

The adults around him immediately moved to help her.

And in that moment of adult attention shifting to adult crisis, this small boy found himself slightly alone in the open doorway.

He stood there in the doorway of the burning church with the smoke curling out around him and the morning light behind him and the orange glow from the burning sections casting its particular color across the white of the walls.

He stood there and he looked back inside the building.

I do not know what he saw.

I do not know what a seven-year-old boy sees when he looks back into a place he has just come from, a place that is burning.

I do not know what ran through him in that moment.

I only know what I saw from the outside of it.

” He stood there small and still with the chaos of the morning swirling around him, adults moving and coughing and calling to each other and the smoke going up and the sound of distant voices getting closer.

And he was in the middle of all of it completely still.

And then his lips moved barely, so slightly that from where I stood I would not have seen it.

If I had not been staring so hard, if I had not been unable to look away, just the smallest movement of his lips in the quiet private way that children speak when they are speaking to themselves or to someone only they can perceive.

I could not hear the words.

The distance was too great and the morning too full of other sound.

But I did not need to hear the words.

I knew standing there exactly what was happening.

I knew it with the certainty that bypasses reasoning and lands directly in the gut in the place where you know things before you can explain them.

That small boy standing in the doorway of a building that was burning because of people like me was praying.

He was praying.

A small boy in a burning doorway speaking quietly with a steadiness no 7-year-old should have been able to manufacture in that situation.

Speaking into the fire.

I do not have the capacity to tell you what that did to me.

I have tried many times to find the language for it and found that language always falls slightly short.

All I can tell you is that something about that image, not the dramatic things, not the most obviously miraculous things, but that one small specific human image of a child praying in a burning doorway slipped past every defense I had, past every year of hardening, past every layer of ideology and borrowed conviction and learned contempt.

It slipped past all of it and landed somewhere in me that had been sealed off and unused for so long I had forgotten it was there.

My eyes went hot.

I will tell you that plainly without embarrassment.

My eyes went hot and there was a pressure behind them that I had not felt since I was a very young child, since before I’d learned that softness was a vulnerability to be managed.

and I turned away, not because the scene was too terrible to look at, because it was too something else, too, too sincere, too much of a mirror that showed me something I was not remotely ready to see.

I ran and I sat against a wall and my hands shook and I tried to think and could not think and eventually I went home and I performed the surface of normaly and I lay on my mat and stared at the ceiling and I did not pray.

In the days that followed something happened that I need to describe carefully.

About 3 or 4 days after the fire, in the very early morning, before the sun was fully established in the sky, before the village was awake and the lanes were full, I went back, not to inspect what I had done, not out of pride or curiosity or the desire to see damage.

I went because something pulled me there, and I could not resist the pull.

I went the way a person sometimes goes back to the place where something significant happened to them.

Not to change it but to stand in the place again and see if the place can tell them something.

I stood in front of St.

Anony’s church in the gray pre-dawn light and I looked at it.

the blackened walls on the rear and side, the charred remnants of the wooden storage sections, the soot marks spread along the exterior like dark fingers reaching upward.

The damage I had been part of causing visible and real and permanent written on the building in a language I had put there and the iron cross on the roof unchanged in the gray morning light unchanged.

I stood there for a long time.

Nobody passed.

The birds were beginning.

The sky was moving from dark gray to the paler gray that comes before the first suggestion of color.

And something in that stillness, that absolute pre-dawn stillness, with nobody around me, and no group voice to drown out the quieter interior one, did something to the surface of what I had been managing to maintain.

The thing that broke through that morning standing alone in front of the building I had been part of burning was not insight.

It was not understanding.

It was simpler and more primitive than that.

It was feeling.

The feeling I had been holding back since that Sunday morning finally broke through the surface and was simply there unavoidable in my chest, in my throat, in the tightness of my jaw.

I had done this.

I specifically with my own hands had done this.

Not we, not the group, not the ideology, not the anger or the belonging or the borrowed righteousness.

me, Tariq, the second son of Gulam Hussein, the boy who had loved the tree in the courtyard.

I had done this to these people, to the old woman with the face and the eyes turned upward, to the small boy with the moving lips, to the man who had been half carried by others because he was in too much pain to walk alone, to all of them.

I stood in front of that building and for the first time since that Sunday morning, I asked a question that had no ideology in it, no framework, no borrowed answers standing ready to fill the space before the question had finished forming.

Just the raw honest question of a man who is alone and the defenses are down and there is nothing left to hide behind.

Is this true? What I have believed, what I have done, in the name of it, is it true? The question hung there in the gray morning air, enormous, patient, not attacking me, just there the way a large object is just there when you have walked into a room and found it waiting.

I did not get an answer that morning.

Not directly.

I got something else.

The knowledge that the question was there now and could not be put back.

A question like that once asked honestly does not unask itself.

It waits.

It grows.

It returns.

And every time it returns, it is a little harder to dismiss, a little more insistent, a little more completely the center of everything.

I went home in the early morning light and no one knew I had been there.

But I was different.

Some irreversible thing had happened in that pre-dawn stillness in front of the damaged church.

Not salvation, not transformation, not anything dramatic or complete, just the permanent widening of a crack, just the inexorable beginning of a process that once begun I would discover I could not stop even when I wanted to.

Something had found a way in.

Through the crack, through the question, through the boy in the doorway and the woman with the upturned face and the singing that had refused to stop, something was coming in, and it would not stop until it had reached everything.

If I had to point to the most painful period of my entire life, I would not point to the hardships I faced after I became a Christian.

And those hardships were real and I will tell you about them fully.

I would point to the months between that Sunday morning in spring and the night I finally surrendered.

Because that in between place, that long corridor between who I had been and who I was becoming, is one of the loneliest and most difficult places a human being can inhabit.

It is the place where the old self is losing its grip and the new self has not yet fully arrived and you are suspended between them like a man holding two ropes that are pulling in opposite directions and you cannot hold both much longer and letting go of either will be a kind of falling.

You are no longer fully the person you were, but you are not yet the person you are going to be.

And the suspension is agonizing because everything around you, your family, your friends, your community, the group, the mosque, the whole familiar world you have always known is still moving in the old direction.

And you are secretly, silently at enormous cost beginning to move in a different one.

And you cannot tell anyone and you do not even fully understand what you are moving toward.

You only know with the certainty of a man who has felt the ground shift beneath him that you can no longer move in the direction you were going.

That direction is finished.

something in front of a burning church made it finished.

That was my life in the months that followed.

The group continued to meet.

I continued to attend for a while because absence would have raised questions I was not prepared to answer and because the truth of what I was becoming would have put me in danger.

So I sat in those circles and I listened to the talk and I nodded at the right moments and I felt every single time as though I were wearing a skin that belonged to someone else.

The things that used to make me feel righteous and purposeful now produced a slow spreading nausea that I had to keep managing, keep pushing down, keep hidden behind the mask of a face that still looked like it belonged to a convinced and committed young man.

The performance of that conviction, when conviction was gone, was one of the most exhausting things I have ever done.

You do not appreciate the energy that genuine belief provides until the belief is gone.

And you discover how much it was running.

Without it, everything is effort.

Every meeting, every conversation, every nod and every expression of agreement is something you are manufacturing from nothing.

And manufacturing from nothing is incredibly expensive.

Sleep became difficult.

Eating became mechanical.

I moved through the days like a man walking underwater.

Everything slowed and resistant and requiring more effort than it should.

My mother noticed.

Of course she noticed.

Mothers notice when something is moving wrong inside their children.

Even when the surface is maintained.

Even when the child is doing everything correctly by every visible measure, she said nothing directly.

That was her way to know when to speak and when to let silence do its own slower work.

But she began leaving small things for me.

A cup of tea brought quietly to my room without announcement.

A portion of something she had made set on a cloth left by my door.

small tokens of attention that said without saying, “I see you.

I don’t know what I’m seeing, but I see you and I’m not going anywhere.

” I could not tell her.

The gulf between what she could receive and what I was carrying was too wide to bridge.

She was a deeply faithful Muslim woman who had poured herself into raising her sons in that faith who would have experienced what was happening in me not as a son’s salvation but as his destruction.

So I accepted the tea and I said I was tired.

And she looked at me with those eyes that had always seen more than I was comfortable with.

And she went back to her prayers.

And somewhere in those prayers, I now believe my name was spoken more urgently than ever before.

Somewhere in those prayers, a mother who did not know what she was asking for was asking for exactly the right thing.

I do not know exactly when the pull toward the Bible began.

It develop the way some of the most important things in a life develop gradually and then suddenly so that by the time you are fully conscious of it, it has already been present for a while growing in the quiet.

It was connected to the question.

I could not stop asking the question about the people in the church about what they had about what could produce what I had witnessed.

I kept being pulled back to it.

The way you are pulled back by a sound you cannot quite identify.

A sound that requires you to stop and listen more carefully until you can place it.

What did they believe specifically? What did this book say? Not what I had been told it said.

Not the summary of it that had been offered to me as definitive since childhood, but what it actually said in its own words on its own pages.

The hunger for that question became eventually impossible to ignore.

Finding a Bible in Kotadu in my situation was not simple.

This is not something available in the general market of a Pakistani village in my community.

You cannot ask around.

The risk of asking was enormous.

If anyone in my group had discovered I was looking for a Bible, the questions would have been immediate and the consequences potentially serious.

So, I did what I had to do.

I traveled to a larger city on the pretext of other business.

And in that city, in an area I had never visited, I found a small shop associated with a mission organization.

And I went in quickly with my heart hammering in my chest.

And I bought a pocket New Testament and a small Psalms, and I carried them home, hidden inside the cover of something else.

I kept them in a place in my room where no one would look.

a loose section at the back of an old storage space behind things that had not been moved in years.

I read only when I was absolutely certain I was alone, only for short periods, always with one ear on the sounds outside my door.

The physical act of reading that book in my situation was its own kind of risk and the risk was its own kind of clarification.

I was risking something for this.

The fact that I was willing to risk something for it told me how hungry I actually was.

I want to tell you what happened when I read it because it is important and because it was not what I expected.

I expected to find the errors I had been told about.

I expected to find something obviously wrong, something that confirmed the things I had always been taught.

I was not reading as a seeker, or not at first.

I was reading almost as a prosecutor, looking for the things that would allow me to put it down with the verdict I had been handed already written, corrupted, unreliable, beneath serious consideration.

I was looking for a reason not to be pulled further in the direction I was being pulled.

I did not find that reason.

I started with Matthew because it was the beginning and within a short time I came to the sermon on the mount and I want to tell you what happened when I read those words for the first time.

The words about loving your enemies, about praying for those who persecute you, about the meek inheriting the earth, about the pure in heart seeing God, about the peacemakers being called children of God.

I did not have a conversion experience.

I did not feel peace descend or light arrive or any of the things that I have since heard others describe in their first encounters with scripture.

What I felt was something more uncomfortable and more particular.

I felt accused.

I felt those words turn in my direction with a precision that was uncomfortable, almost painful, like a light turned into eyes that have been in the dark.

Because those words described with a specificity that felt almost personal exactly what I had witnessed in front of that church.

Loving your enemies.

I was the enemy praying for those who persecute you.

I was the persecutor.

And the people I had come to destroy had prayed, had sung, had walked out whole, had been in every observable way the living demonstration of the text I was now reading.

2 weeks after the fact, in a hidden corner of my own room, the book I had been told was corrupted and unreliable had just described with precision the event that had broken something open in me.

I came to the passage in Matthew about the house built on rock.

how the storm could come and the winds could blow and beat against that house and it would stand because its foundation was sure.

And I thought of the people who had come out of that burning building about what they were built on, what was underneath them that had allowed them to walk out singing.

I thought about the kind of foundation that makes that possible.

the kind of rock under the feet of people who can lose everything on the surface and not be swept away.

I had been part of the storm, and they had stood.

I read the Gospel of John over several nights in short, careful sections, hiding the book whenever a sound reached me from outside the room.

And there is one passage in John that I came to and that I have never fully left since.

Jesus says, “I am the light of the world.

He who follows me will not walk in darkness but will have the light of life.

” I read those words and then I sat with them in the actual darkness of my room with the book closed on my lap and my hands resting on the cover and I thought about what darkness was.

Not the metaphorical darkness of theological language, but the actual specific darkness I had been living inside.

The darkness of contempt.

The darkness of ideology.

The darkness of eyes that had stopped seeing human faces.

The darkness of a man who could hear people singing in a burning building and feel nothing.

That was darkness.

I recognized it sitting in the literal dark of my room as a thing I had been living in.

And the recognition itself was something.

The first tiny motion of light.

The moment when you become aware that you have been in the dark is itself a kind of light.

I came to acts.

I came to the account of Steven the first man killed for his faith in Jesus.

And the thing that held me was not his death because I had been in circles where that kind of violence was organized and celebrated.

And I had thought I understood the meaning of a man dying for something he believed.

What held me was what he did while he was dying.

He looked up.

He prayed.

He asked God not to hold it against the people who were killing him.

I had to put the book down.

I sat with that for a long time because what Steven did in the moment of his death was exactly what the congregation at St.

Anony’s had done in the moment of the crisis.

The same posture, the same direction, the same choice made freely against every physical instinct to direct the heart upward rather than outward toward God rather than toward the threat.

And Steven had seen something as he was dying.

He described seeing heaven opened and Jesus standing.

He had something to look toward.

He had a destination for his eyes.

when the earth below him was failing.

Did the people in that church see something I could not see? Did they have a destination for their eyes that I did not know existed? The psalms I read in a different way than the gospels and acts.

I came to them later when the process was further along.

When I was already somewhere in the middle of the journey, I could neither see the beginning nor the end of.

And the psalms met me where I was in a way that nothing else had.

There were psalms that sounded exactly like what was happening inside me.

The crying out of a man who is lost and knows he is lost, who is frightened of what he has become, who reaches towards something that might be God or might be nothing.

Because reaching is the only thing left to do.

There were psalms of desperate, searching, honest prayer.

The kind of prayer that does not dress itself up or use careful language.

The kind that simply says, “I am here and I am broken and I do not know how to fix what I have done.

” I did not expect a sacred text to sound like what was happening in the most private room inside me.

I did not expect to be found by words written thousands of years ago on the other side of the world in a language I was reading in translation.

But that is what happened.

And the experience of being found by something when you have been lost for as long as I had been lost.

When you have been sealed off from your own interior self for years by ideology and anger and the performance of conviction is something that is very difficult to stay composed about.

Somewhere in this period I began in the dark of my room to pray differently.

Not in the form I had always prayed, not the structured directional prayer I had performed all my life, which had been real once and had gradually become something holing, something raarer than that, something that had no form at all, only content.

At night in the dark, I would speak inward in the direction of whatever was out there and I would say essentially this.

I do not know what is true.

I have done terrible things.

I am broken in ways I do not fully understand.

If there is something real in what those people have, if the god they were praying to inside that fire is actually real and not a concept and not a borrowed idea but actually real and actually there then I need to know.

I’m asking to know.

I don’t have the words for what I’m asking but I’m asking.

This was not yet a prayer in Jesus’ name.

I was not yet there, but it was the most honest praying I had ever done in my life.

And honesty, I believe now is the only real beginning.

God is not impressed by formulas.

He is moved by honesty.

He meets you where you actually are, not where you are pretending to be.

The encounter with Pastor Emmanuel came about 3 months after the fire and it came through a man I will call Ysef.

Ysef was one of those particular people that communities sometimes produce.

People who do not fit neatly inside any of the categories that the community has established, who exist in the spaces between defined groups, who know everyone and are trusted by everyone and who have a gift cultivated or innate for seeing what is actually happening underneath the surface of what people present.

He had spoke one day in the
ordinary way of spoke one day in the ordinary way of village life.

Stopping briefly in the lane exchanging the pleasantries that are almost involuntary between people who have known each other their whole lives.

And in the middle of that ordinary conversation, Ysef said something that stopped the conversation entirely.

He said quietly and without accusation that he had heard I had been seen near the church in the early morning days after the fire.

I denied it.

Of course I denied it.

I felt the blood leave my face and I denied it and I walked away quickly.

But the conversation stayed with me.

The fact that he had said it so quietly.

The fact that he had not accused me of anything beyond being seen near a place.

The fact that what followed the observation was not threat or judgment but something else.

He said that if I was looking for something, there were people who could help.

A week later in the same lane, I came back to him.

The meeting with Pastor Emmanuel was arranged with more caution than I have ever organized anything.

It took place not at the church but at the home of Ysef in the early evening when the lane outside was quiet and the light was going.

I arrived feeling the kind of fear that is not physical danger but something more interior.

The fear of crossing a line, of saying something out loud that cannot be unsaid, of becoming visible to someone outside my own skull in the thing I was actually going through.

Pastor Emmanuel was a small man, shorter than I had imagined, thinner with wireframed glasses and the careful hands of someone who was accustomed to handling fragile things with deliberateness.

He was quiet in the way that the congregation at St.

Anony’s had been quiet.

Not the quietness of absence or passivity, but the quietness of someone who has chosen stillness as a mode of being rather than being unable to find words.

He had a presence that was difficult to describe and impossible to fabricate, a kind of groundedness, a quality of being fully in the room, fully attending that is rarer than people realize.

He did not open with interrogation.

He did not preach at me.

He did not perform spiritual authority or religious intensity.

He simply looked at me with those attentive eyes and waited.

And I found in the waiting that I was speaking before I had consciously decided to speak.

Not everything, not the full truth of everything, not yet, but enough.

enough of what was actually happening inside me.

Enough of the question that would not stop.

When I had said what I could say, he sat with it for a moment.

And then he said something simple.

He said that God had a way of finding the people nobody expected him to find.

Not as a formula, not as a performance of spiritual wisdom.

The way you say something you have watched be true over and over for many years until it has stop feeling like an insight and become simply a description of how things work as matter of fact as a man describing the weather the way my father had used to state facts.

That factual simplicity was what reached me, not the content so much as the delivery.

This was not a man trying to impress me or convert me or perform faith at me.

This was a man telling me something he knew to be true and trusting that the truth of it would be enough.

We met several more times over the following weeks, always carefully, always with the particular caution of two people engaged in something that would have consequences if discovered.

He gave me additional things to read.

He answered questions.

And there were many questions, sometimes difficult questions, sometimes questions I asked with something between genuine curiosity and the prosecutorial instinct I still had not fully set down.

He answered them without defensiveness.

When he did not have a complete answer, he said so clearly and without embarrassment and that honesty was itself a kind of answer.

He never pushed.

He never managed me toward a destination.

He simply stayed.

And I want to say something about that staying because I think it is one of the most important things one human being can offer another.

and it is one of the things that is least common in the world.

He knew what I had been by this point.

He knew specifically what I had been involved in, the fire, the violence before it, the years of activity in the group.

He knew I was one of the people who had brought that morning to his congregation.

And he stayed.

He came back to those meetings.

He brought the same quiet attentiveness each time.

He did not flinch when the worst of it was visible.

He did not perform forgiveness as a virtue to demonstrate.

He simply did not let what I had been be the reason to withdraw from what I was becoming.

That is one of the most profound things I have ever experienced.

Not because it was dramatic, because it was not.

Because it was the simple, consistent, costly choice of one person to keep showing up for another person who had given him every reason not to.

I have come to believe that this is one of the primary ways Jesus works in the world through the specific costly faithfulness of human beings who choose to stay when every reasonable calculation says leave.

The internal tension of my double life was building toward something it could not sustain.

I was not yet a Christian but I was meeting with a Christian pastor.

I was reading the Bible nightly.

I was praying in the dark in ways that had no precedent in my tradition.

And I was still on the surface, moving in the world I had always occupied, still seen as one of the group, still carrying the full weight of what I had participated in, and not yet repudiated, not yet publicly, not yet even to myself fully.

There was a night I remember it with the clarity that is different from the way I remember most things.

The clarity of a genuinely pivotal moment when I was reading the gospel of John.

I had come to the place where Jesus speaks about being the light of the world about how the one who follows him will not walk in darkness.

I put the book down and I looked at my hands.

these hands, the specific hands of this specific body, the hands I had used to carry the fuel, the hands I had used to pour it, the hands that had been part of hitting a man badly enough that he had to be taken to hospital in another town.

These hands resting on my thighs in the lamplight of my room, perfectly ordinary in their appearance, giving no indication of their history.

And I wept, not in the managed, controlled way of a man who was permitting himself a certain quantity of emotion, and no more.

I wept the way a person weeps when the dam that has been holding everything back finally gives way and there is nothing left to do but let the water go where it needs to go because fighting the water now would be more absurd than useful.

I wept for the things I had done.

I wept for the people I had not seen, the faces I had covered with concepts.

I wept for the small boy in the doorway and for the old woman’s face and for all the years of fear I had been part of creating in a community that had only been trying to live.

I wept for the child I had been the hungry boy who had wanted to matter, who had been given the wrong container for his hunger and had filled it with poison.

And in the middle of that weeping, I prayed for the first time in the name I had always been told was wrong to use, I prayed.

I said out loud quietly in the dark of my room that I was a sinner, that I had done terrible things that I could not undo, that I was not worthy of anything good and knew it, but that if Jesus was real, if the power I had seen in front of that church was his power, if the courage of those people came from him, if the steadiness of the small boy in the doorway came from him, Then I was
asking for what they had.

I was asking with everything left in me after all the weeping to be found.

I cannot tell you the ceiling opened.

I cannot tell you I saw a vision or heard a voice or felt a sudden complete transformation roll through me like something physical.

Those things may happen for others and I do not doubt them.

What happened for me was quieter and more interior and in some ways harder to explain, but not less real for that.

When the weeping stopped, the room was different.

Not visibly physically.

Everything was exactly as it had been, the same walls, the same lamp, the same dark corners.

But the room was different in the way a room is different after a storm has passed through it and the air has changed, after the pressure system that was pressing down has finally moved on, and the air is simply clean and still and itself again.

There was a quiet in
that room that I had not felt in years.

Not the heavy silence of avoidance and hiding.

Not the silence of a man who has stopped praying because he cannot find words.

A different quiet.

A quiet that felt for the first time in longer than I could clearly remember, like it might be safe to breathe in.

I stayed in that quiet for a long time.

And when I finally lay down to sleep, I slept without the nightmares for the first time since the spring.

The nightmares did not return.

I want you to know that they simply stopped.

That night in a small room in Cot Adu in the dark after a weeping that had been years in building something happened that I can only describe in the language of the book I had been reading.

I was found.

The shepherd had been looking for the lost sheep all along and the lost sheep had finally stopped running and been found.

The journey was not over.

It was in a sense just beginning.

The hardest things were still ahead.

The cost was still to come.

But the direction had changed.

The question had been answered.

The crack had become an opening.

And something had come through it that I now know by its right name.

Grace.

There is a question people ask me almost every time I share my story and I understand why they ask it because it is a natural question.

The question any honest person would ask.

They want to know what it cost not in a cruel way not out of a desire to watch me revisit pain or to use my suffering as proof of something.

They ask because they are human beings who understand that nothing real is free.

That every significant turning in a life carries a price.

And they want to know if what I found was worth what I paid.

They want to know if the thing on the other side of the sacrifice was real enough and solid enough and lasting enough to justify everything that came apart in the getting there.

Continue reading….
« Prev Next »