I had read them looking for weaknesses.

Now I read them looking for him.

And I found him on every page.

Not the historical figure, not the theological claim.

him, the presence I had met, speaking in the same voice.

I recognized it.

My husband noticed the change before I said anything.

He was a perceptive man, perceptive and worried.

He asked me twice in the second week of my recovery whether I was all right.

I said, “Yes.

” He said, “You seem different.

” I said, “I almost died.

That changes a person.

” He accepted this because it was true, even though it was not the whole truth.

I came home, I recovered, my children climbed on me, and I held them and wept quietly into the hair of the youngest one, who was five and did not understand why her mother was crying, but patted my cheek with a serious expression that undid me completely.

I spent three months in that in between space living my ordinary life performing its ordinary shapes while carrying this extraordinary thing inside me.

Going to the mosque with my family and praying the prayers and feeling the whole time as though I were speaking a language I was translating internally from another language that was more true.

I began to meet carefully, quietly other people who had followed the same path I was walking.

I will not describe how for their safety and mine, but they existed.

They existed in Iran in numbers larger than people assume.

Living in the specific, costly, courageous way of people whose faith cannot be expressed in public without danger.

They became my community, my church, though we did not call it that in any place that could be heard.

And all of that time, the question of my father grew larger.

I told my husband first.

I want to be honest, it did not go well.

He was not violent.

He was not cruel.

He was a man whose entire world had just tilted on its axis and who was responding with the controlled panic of someone trying to hold the shape of something while it changes underneath their hands.

He said, “This is from the illness, from what happened to you physically, the brain under that kind of stress.

” I said, “I know what it sounds like.

I know what you want it to be.

” He said, “Fatameé, your father.

” I said, “I know.

” We sat in silence for a long time.

He loved me.

I knew he loved me.

And his love was in that moment in direct collision with everything his love existed inside of.

His family, his position, his country, the name he had married into, which was also now the name his children carried.

He said, “You cannot tell him.

” I said, “I cannot not tell him.

” another silence.

He said, “You understand what this means?” I said, “Yes.

” He said, “You understand what he will do?” I said, “Yes.

” He looked at me for a long time with an expression I could not fully read.

Grief, anger, something that might have been underneath everything else, a sorrow that was almost tenderness.

Then he stood up and left the room, and we did not speak of it again for 2 weeks.

I told my father on a Thursday afternoon in late autumn.

I chose the afternoon because he was always at his most accessible in the afternoons.

The morning was for work, the evening for prayer and family routine, but the afternoon had a certain quality of openness of the guard being slightly lowered.

I chose Thursday because the weekend was coming and I did not want this to detonate in the middle of a work week and cause damage to his schedule that he would then associate permanently with what I was about to tell him.

These are the calculations of a daughter who has loved her father anxiously for 35 years.

We sat in his study.

It was a room I had loved as a child.

floor toseeiling bookshelves, the smell of old paper and tea, the particular quality of light through the single tall window that faced the garden.

He had received heads of state in rooms more impressive than this one, but this was the room where he was most himself, where the public figure thinned slightly, and the private man was faintly visible underneath.

I sat across from him and I
told him.

I told him everything from the beginning.

The illness, the night I died, the leaving of my body, the light, the presence, the voice, the question, and my answer.

I told him about the three months of secret faith, the secret community, the gospel I had read and recognized.

I told him about the prayers that had become conversations, about the specific, undeniable daily presence of someone who had promised he would be with me and had not left.

I told him all of it.

He listened.

My father had the gift, it was genuinely a gift, one I had observed in operation since childhood, of listening to things he found intolerable with an absolutely still face.

Diplomats from three continents had sat across from him and tried to read his response in his expression and found nothing.

He had perfected the stillness over decades of highstakes negotiation.

The stillness that said, “I am receiving this information.

It says nothing yet about what I will do with it.

” He listened and when I finished there was a silence that lasted.

I counted in the way you count things when you are very afraid.

11 seconds.

Then he said, >> “You were either mentally ill or you were a traitor.

” He said it quietly, not with rage.

That almost would have been easier.

He said it with the careful precision of a man stating a logical conclusion.

As if he had weighed the evidence and arrived at the only two possibilities the evidence permitted.

I said, “Baba,” he said, “there is no other explanation.

What you are describing is either a psychological break caused by your medical crisis or it is the result of outside influence, foreign Christian missionary influence that has found its way to you through channels I intend to identify.

I said it is neither.

He said, “Then you are telling me that the daughter of Ali Lariji, raised in this house, educated in this tradition, carrying the name of this family, has become a Christian.

” The word Christian in his mouth sounded the way a doctor says a diagnosis he considers catastrophic.

I said, “I am telling you that I met Jesus Christ.

That he is who he said he is.

That he is alive.

That he came for me when I was dying and he showed me the truth and I said yes to it and I am telling you because you are my father and I love you and I could not carry this and pretend to you that it didn’t happen.

” He said, “You will not speak of this again in this house, to your mother, to your brothers, to your husband, to anyone.

” I said, “I am already living this.

I have been for 3 months.

I cannot unliv and you will or he stopped.

I waited, he said.

Or you will leave this house and you will not return.

The room was very quiet.

The garden light came through the tall window.

The bookshelves stood around us, full of the accumulated learning of a man who had spent his life in the service of a truth he would not now allow his daughter to question.

I said, “I love you.

” He said nothing.

I stood up.

I said, “I will pray for you every day for the rest of my life.

That is not a threat.

It is the only gift I have left to give you.

” He did not look at me when I left the room.

What followed happened over several months, and I will not make it more dramatic than it was, because the reality was dramatic enough.

My husband, faced with the ultimatum my father had delivered to him separately and directly, a conversation I was not present for, but whose content I can reconstruct from its effects, chose the family.

I do not say this with bitterness.

I have worked very hard in the years since not to say it bitterly.

He was a man who had married into a world, and the world was telling him that his wife had become a danger to everything inside it.

He had children.

He had a position.

He had parents of his own and siblings and a life that existed within the gravitational field of the Lijani name.

He chose the field.

He asked me to recant multiple times with increasing desperation.

He asked me to simply say that I had been confused, that the illness had produced a psychological episode, that I had recovered and returned to my senses.

He would never ask about it again.

We would go on.

he would protect me from my father’s anger.

We would continue.

I could not.

Not because I was indifferent to what it would cost.

I want to be absolutely clear about this.

I knew exactly what the cost was, and the cost was devastating, and I paid it fully aware of what I was paying.

I could not because I had said yes in the light, and I had meant it.

And the yes I said there was not conditional on whether it was convenient.

It was not conditional on whether my father approved.

It was not conditional on whether the country I lived in permitted it or the family I was born into could accommodate it.

The yes was not mine to take back.

It was his.

My mother came to see me once secretly, I think, without my father knowing.

She arrived in the afternoon on a day when my husband was out and she sat with me and she cried and she held my hands and she said, “My daughter, my darling, why? Why this?” And I said, “Mama, because it is true.

” She said, “How can you know?” I said, “The same way you know anything you have experienced directly.

I was there.

I saw him.

I heard him.

He knew my name.

She said, “Your father will never.

” I said, “I know.

” And your children.

This was the hardest thing.

The children.

I will not describe the custody negotiations or the legal mechanisms or the specific ways in which the apparatus of a powerful family can be deployed against a woman who has stepped outside its protection.

I will tell you only that I held my children for the last time in Iran on a Tuesday morning in February and that my youngest, the one who had patted my cheek with the serious expression, asked me where I was going.

And I told her I was going on a trip because I could not tell her the truth because she was 5 years old and the truth would not be kind.

I held her for a long time and then I left.

I will not detail how I left Iran.

There are people who helped me who are still there and I will not endanger them.

What I will tell you is that I arrived in another country cold, late with one bag and the specific hollow exhaustion of a person who has lost so much that loss itself has become a kind of strange companion.

And I sat in a small room in a safe house and I prayed.

I prayed for my children.

I prayed for my mother.

I prayed for my husband who had made the only choice his world permitted him to make and who I believe suffered for it in ways he would never acknowledge.

I prayed for my brothers who had not contacted me and whose silence was its own kind of communication.

And I prayed for my father.

I prayed for Ali Lari Johnny the man who had told me I was either mentally ill or a traitor who had enforced that verdict with the same precision he brought to everything.

who had chosen, as I had always known he would choose, the fortress over the open field.

I prayed for him the way he had told me to, without agenda, without the prayer being secretly about bringing him to my side, just for him, for the man himself, for the question I had seen in his eyes, just for a moment before the stillness came down.

the question that said he had heard something in what I said that frightened him, not because it was false, but because it wasn’t.

I prayed for him every day.

He never contacted me.

I learned of my father’s death the way exiles learn most things from a distance through a screen in the middle of an ordinary day that then becomes permanently divided into before and after.

I was in a small apartment in a city I will not name.

It was morning.

I was making coffee.

My phone was on the counter and a news notification appeared and I read my father’s name and the word that followed it and I stood very still for a long moment.

And then I sat down on the kitchen floor because there was nowhere else to go.

He was gone.

Ali Lauri Johnny was gone and I had not spoken to him in I counted on the kitchen floor with the coffee cooling on the counter.

I had not spoken to him in 2 years, 1 month and 11 days.

I had sent letters early on, three letters each returned unopened, which is its own particular form of communication.

After the third one, I stopped sending letters and redirected the energy into prayer because at least the prayer was received by someone.

He was gone, and the last words he had spoken to me in his study with the tall window and the bookshelves were about traitors and mental illness.

And he was gone.

I sat on the kitchen floor and I did not perform my grief in any particular way.

I did not manage it.

I did not try to find the meaning in it immediately or locate the theological framework that would make it bearable.

I just sat with it, the enormous, jagged, irregular fact of a father gone, a father I had loved anxiously and completely and at great cost, a father who had not said goodbye.

I cried for a long time.

And then from somewhere, from the place inside me that had been rebuilt in the light, the place that he had come to when I was dying, and that he had never, not once, in all the cost and loss and difficulty of the years since, actually left, something steadied.

Not comfort exactly, not the removal of the grief, something that held the grief the way two hands hold something fragile, not preventing the fragility, but not dropping it either.

He had said, “I will be with you in all of it.

” >> He was.

I sat on the floor and I wept.

He was there and the grief was real and his presence was real.

And both things were true simultaneously.

And I was somehow able to hold both of them.

I prayed for my father.

Then the prayer that is both the hardest and the only one that makes sense at the end.

I prayed for mercy.

Complete unearned extraordinary mercy of the kind he had shown me.

The mercy that does not wait for worthiness.

The love that goes to extraordinary lengths.

I prayed for Aliarajani to have encountered in whatever final moments were his.

the same light I had encountered to have been given the same question to have had the chance to answer differently.

I do not know what happened in those final moments.

I will not know in this life but I know who was there.

I know he was there because he told me he would never stop pursuing them.

and he has never in my experience of him said a thing he did not mean.

That is the only ground I have to stand on.

I stand on it.

I am telling you this from the other side of all of it.

From a place I will not name.

In a life that looks nothing like the life I was born into.

A life without the family home in Thyron.

Without the grandmother I cannot visit.

without the children I carried in my body and whose voices I hear only occasionally through the careful arrangements that have been made at great effort by people of great kindness.

From a life that is by every external measurement smaller than the one I left and from a life that is by every internal measurement incomparably larger.

I want to speak directly to some of you now because I know who is listening to this.

Some of you are Muslim and you are hearing the name of Issa said in a way that is new and uncomfortable and that activates in you the same trained resistance it activated in my father.

And I am not here to argue with you.

I am not here to tell you that your tradition is worthless or that everything you have been given is false.

I am here to tell you what I saw and to tell you that the issa I encountered is larger than the category your tradition assigned him and that the largess is not a threat.

It is an invitation.

Some of you are not Muslim.

Some of you are from religious backgrounds entirely different from mine or from no religious background at all.

And you are perhaps hearing this and thinking this woman gave up her family, her children, her country, her entire life for a vision she had when she was clinically dead.

You are perhaps thinking that this is a cautionary tale about the danger of extreme religious experience.

I hear that.

I want to ask you one question in return.

What else in the entire catalog of human experience would justify the cost? I did not make this decision lightly.

I did not make it in the first days of religious excitement before the cost was visible.

I made it after the cost was fully clear.

I made it with my eyes open to exactly what leaving would mean and exactly what staying would cost.

I made it not because I am brave.

I am not particularly brave, but because the alternative was to live the rest of my life having said yes to something true and then behaving as though I hadn’t, and that was not a life I could live.

He is real.

I am not an uneducated woman.

I am not someone prone to fantasy or easily manipulated by emotion.

I am the daughter of Ali Liani.

And whatever that meme means in the world of power and politics, in my own formation, it means rigorous, careful.

Unimpressed by the merely sentimental, trained to examine claims before accepting them, I examined this claim with everything I had from every angle.

And what I found was not what I expected to find.

What I found was not a western religion, not a colonial imposition, not the distorted text of councils and emperors.

What I found was a person, living, present, specific, personal, devastatingly real, a person who knew my name before I said it and loved what he found when he said it and came for me when I was dying in a Thyron hospital room.

Not because I had earned it.

Not because my theology was correct.

Not because my family was important.

Because love when it is real does not wait for permission.

My father is gone.

I carry this every day.

I carry the unanswered letters and the unopened doors and the last conversation in the study and the 11 counted seconds of silence.

I carry the face of my youngest child and the particular weight of a February morning and a bag and a border and all the distance between who I was and who I am.

I carry it and I carry something else too.

Something he gave me when he said I have not stopped pursuing them.

Something that functions in the darkness the way a compass functions, not removing the darkness but making it navigable.

I carry hope.

Not the optimistic kind, not the kind that requires good evidence and favorable circumstances.

The other kind, the kind that is not based on probability, but on the character of the one in whom it is placed.

The kind that says he said he would not stop and he does not say things he does not mean.

I do not know what happened in my father’s final moments, but I know who was there.

And that that is enough for me to keep walking.

I want to say one more thing before I am done.

If you are listening to this and you are Iranian, if you are a Muslim man or woman in Iran or in the diaspora living inside the same framework I grew up inside, carrying the same map I was given, feeling perhaps the same low hum of questions that I felt for years before I let myself admit they were questions.

I want to say this to you directly.

He is not your enemy.

He was never your enemy.

He is not a threat to your culture or your language or your people or your history or the memory of your parents.

Continue reading….
« Prev Next »