image

December 19th, 1944.

Verdon, France.

The bunker is underground.

No windows.

Bare bulbs hang from the concrete ceiling, casting sick yellow light on 17 men seated around a scarred oak table.

They are generals.

They do not look at one another.

At the head of the table stands the supreme commander.

He is 54 years old.

His uniform is crisp, pressed 3 hours ago by someone else’s hands.

But his face is the color of wet newsprint.

Beneath his eyes, the flesh has settled into deep, bruised hollows.

His left temple pulses visibly.

He has not slept in 3 days.

3 days earlier on December 16th, 1944, eight Panza divisions emerged from the frozen Arden forest.

200,000 German soldiers, tanks painted white for snow, scorpion rockets, English-speaking commandos in American uniforms spreading chaos behind the lines.

The Allies were blind.

Within 48 hours, the German spearhead had driven a 50-mi gash through the American front.

12,000 American soldiers surrounded at Bastonia.

Entire regiments swallowed by snow and cold and the methodical, terrifying efficiency of an enemy everyone had assumed was already finished.

The Supreme Commander spent those 48 hours in his headquarters at Versailles.

He did not remove his uniform.

He did not eat.

His aids brought coffee.

The cups accumulated cold on the corner of his desk.

On the morning of December 18th, his chief medical officer stood in the doorway and watched him bend over a map with a magnifying glass.

The Supreme Commander’s hand trembled.

Not from fear, not from cold, from exhaustion so profound it had begun to mimic a neurological disorder.

The tremor was visible from 6 ft away.

The medical officer withdrew quietly and walked down the corridor to find the Supreme Commander’s personal aid.

He used her first name.

K, we need to talk.

Kathleen Summersby was 36 years old that December, Irish, born in County Cork.

She had driven an ambulance through the London Blitz, navigating streets with no lights, only the glow of burning buildings.

She had crossed the Atlantic in a troop ship that was torpedoed beneath her.

She had spent 6 hours in a lifeboat in the North Atlantic before rescue.

She had been assigned as General Eisenhower’s driver in May 1942.

By December 1944, she was his personal secretary, his aid, the person who knew which stack of papers to place on his desk first and which to bury.

She knew the exact temperature of coffee he preferred.

She knew he dictated best in the hour before dawn, when the world was quiet and the telephone did not ring.

She also knew, because she had been watching for 72 hours, that he was dying, not dramatically, not heroically.

He was simply burning through his own reserves at a rate the human body could not sustain.

The heart is a muscle.

Muscles fatigue.

Hearts fail.

The medical officer did not use euphemisms.

His blood pressure is spiking.

His pulse is irregular.

I can’t force him to rest.

He outranks me.

But if he continues like this for another 48 hours, I cannot guarantee his survival.

He paused.

I have an option.

I can give you a seditive.

Not strong enough to knock him unconscious.

He’d never accept that.

But enough to slow him down.

Enough to force 4 hours of sleep.

He placed a small glass vial on the table between them.

No label, clear liquid.

Put it in his whiskey or his coffee.

He won’t taste it.

Then he walked away.

The Supreme Commander’s headquarters that week occupied a former school in Versailles, requisitioned from the French government in 1943.

Classrooms had become operation centers.

The gymnasium housed the communications section where female auxiliaries in headsets transcribed Morse code from across the front.

Summersby had her own desk in a converted supply closet adjacent to the Supreme Commander’s office.

No window, a single lamp with a green glass shade, the kind found in a thousand American bureaucrats offices.

She sat beneath it at 11 p.

m.

on December 18th, the vial in her palm.

Outside her door, the Supreme Commander was on the telephone with General Omar Bradley.

Bradley’s headquarters in Spar, Belgium, was now 35 miles from the German spearhead.

His voice, distorted by static, was audible through the thin walls.

We’re pulling back.

I have no choice, Ike.

My communications are compromised.

I’ve lost contact with at least one core.

The Germans are wearing our uniforms.

shooting MPs at crossroads, redirecting convoys into ambushes.

The Supreme Commander’s voice, when he responded, was measured, controlled.

The voice of a man who had spent 30 years learning not to show fear.

You will hold, Bradley.

You will hold and you will counterattack.

With what, Ike? I’ve got divisions that don’t exist on paper anymore.

Kids who’ve been in combat for 48 hours without sleep.

Tanks freezing in place because nobody winterized the engines.

A pause.

Ike.

When was the last time you slept? The Supreme Commander did not answer.

Summersby closed her palm around the vial.

She had seen him sleep once, June 1944, the night before D-Day.

He had sat alone in his study at Telegraph Cottage, reading a western novel, not for pleasure.

He read to quiet his mind.

At midnight, his head dropped forward, the book sliding from his lap onto the floor.

She covered him with a blanket, and turned off the light.

She remembered his face in that moment, slack and vulnerable.

He looked, she thought, like the farm boy from Kansas he had been 40 years ago before West Point, before the Philippines, before the war, before the weight of 3 million men settled onto his shoulders.

She had never told anyone.

She watched him sleep.

She had never told anyone many things.

At midnight, she carried a cup of coffee into his office.

He stood at the map table, his back to her.

The magnifying glass in his hand trembled like a tuning fork that had been struck and would not stop vibrating.

“Sir, not now, K.

It’s coffee, sir.

You haven’t eaten.

I’m not hungry.

It’s not about hunger.

Silence.

Then he turned.

His face was gray.

His eyes, normally the pale blue of a winter sky, were bloodshot, shot through with fine red threads.

He took the coffee cup.

She watched his hand, watched the tremor, watched the liquid surface shiver.

He raised the cup to his lips.

The vial was in her pocket.

The seditive would take effect within 15 minutes.

He would become drowsy.

He would excuse himself, lie down on the cot in the corner.

He would sleep for 4 hours.

4 hours that might, the doctor had said, make the difference between life and death.

She thought if he dies the whole thing collapses.

The alliance, the offensive, the men at Bastonia, everything.

She thought if I do this, I am deciding for him.

I am taking his command, his control, his agency.

I am becoming a nurse instead of an aid.

I am reducing the supreme commander to a patient who needs to be managed.

She thought he will never forgive me.

She thought I don’t care if he forgives me.

I care if he lives.

His hand holding the cup was still shaking.

Sir.

He paused, looked at her.

You’re going to collapse.

He said nothing.

The doctor came to see me.

He said, “Your heart is showing strain.

” He said, “If you don’t rest, I know what he said.

” His voice was flat, drained of affect.

He told you to sedate me.

She did not answer.

He set the coffee cup down untouched.

K.

If I sleep now, I lose.

Not the battle.

I can’t lose the battle.

We don’t have enough men to lose.

But I lose this.

He gestured at the map, the telephone, the distant sound of Morse code bleeding through the walls.

This moment, this hour.

The Germans are moving faster than our intelligence can track.

Bradley is in a state of near panic.

pattern is 3 days away.

If I am not here, if I am unconscious, decisions will be made by men who do not have the full picture.

Good men, capable men, but not me.

He paused.

I am not indispensable, Kay, but I am the only one who has all the information.

The only one who knows what Montgomery is thinking and what Bradley is feeling and what Patton is capable of.

If I delegate that even for 4 hours, I risk a miscommunication that could cost 10,000 lives.

She said, “If you die, it will cost more than 10,000.

” He looked at her for a long moment.

Neither spoke.

Then he said very quietly, “I know.

” She did not put the seditive in his coffee.

She did not put it in his whiskey.

At 3:00 a.

m.

on December 19th, 1944, she carried the vial to the women’s latrine at the end of the corridor.

She opened the small glass container.

She poured the clear, odless liquid down the drain.

Then she stood at the sink for 3 minutes, watching the water run, and thought about what she had just done.

She had chosen to preserve his agency at the expense of his safety.

She had chosen to trust his judgment over the judgment of his physician.

She had chosen to allow him to remain in command, knowing that command might kill him.

If he died tonight, she would carry that choice for the rest of her life.

If he lived, she would never tell him what she had done.

At 11:00 a.

m.

on December 19th, the Supreme Commander walked into the underground bunker at Verda.

17 generals rose as he entered.

He nodded once and took his place at the head of the table.

His face was still gray.

His eyes were still bloodshot, but his hand, resting on the oak table, was perfectly steady.

He looked at the assembled commanders.

Omar Bradley, his face drawn with exhaustion and humiliation.

Arthur Tedar, the RAF marshall, chain smoking.

Jacob Devers, nursing cold coffee.

Walter Bedell Smith, Eisenhower’s chief of staff, awake for 72 hours and still immaculate.

He never spoke publicly about the nature of his relationship with his wartime secretary.

Kathleen Summersby remained in America.

She became a citizen.

She married twice, divorced twice.

She wrote a memoir in 1948, Eisenhower was my boss, which mentioned nothing of the intimacy that had grown between them.

It was, she wrote, better that way.

In 1975, she lay dying of cancer in a hospital in Southampton, New York.

Her second memoir, Past Forgetting, My Love Affair with Dwight D.

Eisenhower, was completed by a ghostriter and published postumously.

In it, she described Long Walks, Stolen Kisses, a note from the Supreme Commander that read, “How about lunch, tea, and dinner today? If yes, who else do you want? if any, at which time, how are you? She described a love that was, by her account, never physically consummated.

Eisenhower, she wrote, was impotent.

The war and its pressures had taken that from him, along with sleep, peace of mind, and the ordinary pleasures of middle age.

She did not describe the vial of seditive she had poured down the drain at 3:00 a.

m.

on December 19th, 1944.

She did not describe standing at the sink watching the water run and realizing that she had just chosen to let him command even if command killed him.

She did not describe the fear, the guilt, the knowledge that she had traded his life for his dignity and that he would never know.

Some choices are too heavy to share.

Some burdens can only be carried alone.

In 2003, 40 years after Eisenhower’s death and 28 years after Summersbiz, a group of aging veterans gathered in Charleston, South Carolina for a reunion of SHA headquarters staff.

They were in their 80s and 90s, former sergeants and left tenants and clerks who had served the Supreme Commander during the war.

A reporter asked them about K.

Summersby.

Sergeant Mickey Makio, Eisenhower’s personal orderly, was 92 years old.

He had put the general to bed every night and woken him every morning for 2 years.

He had never seen anything improper.

If you’re having an affair, he said, you can’t hide it that much.

Alan Reeves, a former SHA staff officer, was bluntter.

It was a mistake to have her there, he said, but he didn’t have a relationship with her.

Then he paused.

She was loyal, though.

God knows she was loyal.

He did not know about the vial.

None of them knew.

Summersby had taken that secret with her, buried it in the same Long Island grave where her ashes were later scattered over the Atlantic.

But loyalty is not measured in declarations.

Loyalty is measured in what you choose not to do.

At 3:00 a.m.

on December 19th, 1944, Kathleen Summersby chose not to sedate the Supreme Commander.

She chose to let him lead.

And the battle of the bulge was saved by a man who should have been asleep, propped up by coffee and will, and the faith of an Irish woman who refused to take his choice away.